65- 407 C.M.R. ch. 660, § 13

Current through 2024-25, June 19, 2024
Section 407-660-13 - DISPUTE RESOLUTION Procedures
A.Employees Available

A utility shall have an adequate number of properly trained employees available during business hours to respond to questions from applicants and customers, resolve disputes, and address requests for service. Customers calling the utility must be provided the opportunity to talk to a live customer representative without spending an unreasonable amount of time on hold and without being forced to navigate through an unreasonable number of menu levels in an automated phone answer system. If a customer call is not automatically forwarded to a live person once a menu option is selected, the option to speak to a live representative must be provided as a menu choice. A utility with fewer than 5 full-time employees or fewer than 300 customers is not required to have an informed employee available at all times during business hours. If such a utility achieves contact with a customer before disconnection, the utility must not disconnect the customer until it has offered the customer the opportunity to resolve a dispute or to avoid disconnection by contact with the employee who is authorized to resolve disputes and enter into payment arrangements.

B.Disconnection of Service Prohibited

A utility may not threaten disconnection or disconnect the service of a customer if the customer has informed the utility that the customer disputes liability for the bill, a utility's deposit request, or the terms of a payment arrangement required by a utility to avoid disconnection, until the dispute is resolved pursuant to subsection C below. When a customer disputes only a portion of the bill, the utility may require payment of that portion not in dispute to prevent disconnection.

C.Dispute Resolution Process

When a utility becomes aware of a dispute by an applicant or customer, whether or not disconnection is pending, the utility shall:

1.Investigate Dispute

Investigate the dispute, preserving a record of the substance and results of the investigation;

2.Report Results

Report the results of its investigation to the applicant or customer based on the record; and

3.Attempt to Resolve Dispute

Attempt in good faith to resolve the dispute.

D.Dispute Record Maintenance

All utilities must preserve records of disputes for a period of 10 years from the date the dispute was resolved and those records must be available for examination by the Commission. The dispute records must include:

1. the name and address of the applicant or customer with the dispute;
2. the date and subject matter of the dispute;
3. the record of investigation required by this Section;
4. all communications to or from the customer regarding the dispute;
5. the adjustment or resolution offered to the customer; and
6. the final adjustment or resolution.
E.Notification of Right to File a Complaint With the CAD

If a utility cannot resolve a dispute with an applicant or customer after the procedures set forth above have been completed, the utility shall orally inform the applicant or customer of the right to file a complaint with the CAD and of the toll-free telephone number of the CAD. If the complaint concerns a pending disconnection of service, the utility shall orally inform the customer that the complaint must be filed before the disconnection date or within 2 business days of the oral notice, whichever is later. During that time, the utility may not disconnect the customer's service. If the 2-day extension exceeds the disconnection date of the notice, the effective period of the notice can be extended to accommodate the 2-day extension period.

F.Limitation of Disconnection During CAD Investigation
1.Limitation on Disconnection Pending Resolution

A utility may not threaten disconnection or disconnect service to a customer who disputes liability for the bill, a utility's deposit request, or the terms of a payment arrangement required by a utility to avoid disconnection and has filed a complaint with the CAD until the complaint is resolved pursuant to Section 13(G)(4) below.

2.Reconnection Pending Resolution

If a customer files a complaint after service has been disconnected, the customer is entitled to reconnection pending resolution of the complaint only if the Director of the CAD finds reasonable grounds to believe that the utility has failed to follow the disconnection provisions of this Rule (Section 10 ) or has failed to notify the customer of the right to file a complaint with the CAD as required by Section 13(F) above. If the CAD orders the utility to reconnect service on this basis, the utility shall reconnect the customer's service without reconnection charges or deposit.

G.CAD Complaint Process
1.CAD Acceptance of Complaint

The CAD will not accept a complaint from a customer if the customer has not first attempted to resolve the dispute with the utility, pursuant to Section 13(D) above. The CAD may also reject, without investigation, a complaint that is outside its jurisdiction or is without merit. A complaint may be considered to be "without merit" if, among other things, the CAD has previously issued a decision regarding the same issue that is the basis for the complaint. If the CAD accepts a complaint, the CAD shall investigate the complaint pursuant to paragraph 2 below.

2.CAD Investigation of a Complaint

The CAD will inform a utility that a complaint has been filed and the date of the filing by whatever means is acceptable to both the CAD and the utility, e.g., in writing, by telephone, by e-mail, or by fax. The CAD will conduct an informal investigation of the complaint that may include:

a. an informal meeting with the customer and/or the utility;
b. a review of the written record of the utility's investigation required by Section 13(D) above; and
c. an examination of other records, such as billing and payment information, notice of disconnection, or any other information that the CAD deems relevant to the complaint.
3.Provision of Information to the CAD by a Utility

A utility shall provide information requested by the CAD within 10 business days of its receipt of the request. This information may include, but is not limited to, billing and payment information, notice of disconnection information, the written record of the utility's investigation of the customer's dispute, or any other information in the utility's possession or that is readily available to the utility that the CAD deems necessary to investigate the customer's complaint. If the utility cannot provide the requested information within the 10-day time period, it may request an extension from the Director of the CAD or the Director's designee. The extension request may be made orally or in writing and it may be granted or denied orally or in writing.

4.Decision

The CAD will complete its investigation and issue a written decision within 30 days of its receipt of information from the utility that is deemed necessary by CAD staff to resolve the complaint. The decision by the CAD shall impose any just and reasonable requirements necessary to resolve the complaint, including, but not limited to:

a. reconnection of service, deposit requirements;
b. payment arrangement terms, which may include both water and sewer charges for utilities that have the ability to disconnect water service for the non-payment of sewer charges;
c. an adjustment of late fees accrued since the complaint was received;
d. a determination of whether a violation of this Rule has occurred; and
e. a determination that a utility may proceed with disconnection in appropriate circumstances.
5.Notice of Appeal Rights

When a decision is rendered, the CAD shall inform the customer and the utility of the right to appeal the decision to the Commission and of the rights of both parties while an appeal to the Commission is pending.

H.Appeal to the Commission
1.Appeal Process

The customer or the utility may appeal a CAD decision to the Commission by filing a notice of appeal with the Administrative Director of the Commission within 10 calendar days after the date of the decision. Notwithstanding Section 6(C) of the Maine Rules of Civil Procedure and Section 305 of the Commission's Rules of Practice and Procedure (Chapter 110), no additional time is allowed for mailing.

2.Disconnection Delayed

If an appeal is filed with the Commission, a utility may not disconnect or terminate the customer's service until the appeal is decided. This prohibition stands, even if the CAD's decision allows the disconnection.

3.Commission Review

The Commission shall review the decision to determine if it complies with applicable statutory and regulatory requirements, is based on sound facts, and does not represent an abuse of discretion by the CAD.

4.Order

The Commission shall issue an order affirming the CAD's decision or, if the decision is not affirmed, the Commission shall:

a. remand the complaint to the CAD for reconsideration with an explanation of the basis for the remand;
b. remand the complaint back to CAD to gather further facts;
c. issue an order reversing or altering the CAD's decision; or
d. issue an order opening an investigation pursuant to 35-A M.R.S.A. Section1303.

65- 407 C.M.R. ch. 660, § 13