14-002 Code Vt. R. 14-010-002-X

Current through August, 2024
Section 14 010 002 - GENERAL RULES APPLICABLE TO ALL PROCEEDINGS BEFORE THE BOARD
Part 1 GENERAL RULES APPLICABLE TO ALL PROCEEDINGS BEFORE THE BOARD
Section 1.0 Description of Transportation Board Organization

The Transportation Board, hereafter called "Board", exercises functions of a policy making, regulatory and quasi-judicial nature related to transportation under Title 19, Title 5, and Chapter 5 and 31-49 of Title 30, all of which relate to highway, air, rail and water transportation in Vermont. The Board has seven members appointed by the Governor with the advice and consent of the Senate. The Chairman of the Board is designated by the Governor. The Board's policies are executed by the Agency of Transportation. General charge of the Board's Office and affairs is vested in its Executive Secretary, from whom the public may obtain information, or to whom the public may make submissions or requests. The Executive Secretary's address is 133 State Street, Montpelier, Vermont, and the telephone number is 802-828-2669. Office hours are 7:45 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. Monday through Friday, except legal holidays.

Section 1.1 Incorporation of Vermont Rules of Civil Procedure

The Vermont Transportation Board (hereinafter referred to as the "Board") hereby adopts so much of the following Vermont Rules of Civil Procedure to govern its proceedings in contested cases as they are not inconsistent with the laws of the State of Vermont or other specific rule of this Board in accordance therewith substituting the Board where reference is made to "court(s)" or to "judge(s)":

Rule 5 - Service & Filing of Pleadings
Rule 26 - General Provisions governing discovery
Rule 28 - Persons before whom depositions may be taken
Rule 29 - Stipulations regarding discovery procedure
Rule 30 - Depositions upon oral examination
Rule 31 - Depositions upon written examination
Rule 32 - Use of depositions in court proceedings
Rule 33 - Interrogatories to parties
Rule 34 - Production of documents and things and entry upon land for inspection and other purposes
Rule 36 - Requests for admission
Rule 37 - Failure to make discovery: sanctions
Rule 42 - Consolidation; separate trials
Rule 43 - Evidence
Rule 44 - Proof of official record
Rule 44. 1-Determination of foreign law
Rule 45 - Subpoena
Rule 46 - Exceptions unnecessary

Rule b 52(b) Findings by the court - amendment

Rule 59 - New trial; amendment of judgments
Rule 60 - Relief from judgment or order
Rule 61 - Harmless error
Section 1.2 Pleadings; where filed and number

All papers including the original process and any other papers requesting relief or action from the Board shall be filed with the Clerk of the Board and shall include the original and three copies.

Section 1.3 Intervention

A person desiring to intervene in any proceedings shall file with the Board and serve on all parties a verified written application setting forth the facts upon which such person claims an interest in the proceeding. Applications must be filed with the Board with proof of service at least two days before the hearing. Failure to serve or file such application shall be deemed sufficient cause for the denial unless good and sufficient reason exists why is was not served or filed.

Section 1.4 Subpoenas, Application for

An attorney representing a party, may issue subpoenas for board proceedings in contested cases by following the procedures of VRCP 45. A party may apply to the Board for the issuance of subpoenas or subpoenas duces tecum. Such application shall be timely. It shall specify the name of the witness or the documents or things the production of which is desired, with such particularity as will enable such documents to be identified for purposes of production, the return date desired, and the general nature of the facts to be proved by the witness or the documents or things sought to be produced. Such application shall be filed with the Board and shall be served on all other parties. The Board may grant or deny such application in whole or in part and may make such subpoena returnable at any time. The Board may issue subpoenas at any time requiring persons, parties or witnesses to attend and be examined or give testimony, and to produce any document or thing that relates to any matter under investigation or any question before the Board.

Section 1.5 Officer and Witness fees

Officers who serve subpoenas issued by the Board and witnesses attending hearings shall receive fees and compensation at the same rates as officers and witnesses in causes before a district court. Such fees and compensation are to be paid to persons entitled by the party requesting the subpoena.

Section 1.6 Prehearing Conference

Upon order of the Board setting a pre-hearing conference, upon its own initiative or the motion of a party, the Board or Board's agent shall hold a pre-hearing conference for the purpose of clarifying issues and stipulating to facts and applicable law. At the pre-hearing conference, the Board's agent will, unless otherwise directed by the Board, have the authority to make binding orders.

Section 1.7 Exhibits, Evidence, Prefiled testimony

Any party intending to submit documentary exhibits in contested cases, shall provide the opposing party with a copy of the proposed exhibit and file the original with the Board not less than five days before the hearing. The filing of documentary exhibits shall not constitute acceptance into evidence by the Board or any admission by the other party of relevance, accuracy or materiality and the opposing party may object to their admission into evidence when offered. Documentary evidence which has not been pre-filed as required herein shall not be admitted into evidence by the Board except upon good cause shown. Impeachment exhibits need not be pre-filed. The Board may require pre-filed testimony at its discretion.

Section 1.8 Board's Report

After the close of a hearing in a contested case, the Board shall prepare its decision which shall contain, but not be limited to:

(a) Findings of Fact;
(b) Opinion; and
(c) Order.
Section 1.9 Appeals, Completion of Record

The transcript of a hearing shall be ordered within the time provided in V.R.A.P. 10. One-half the estimated cost of the transcript shall be as determined by the Board. That sum shall be forwarded with Appellant's order for the transcript.

Section 1.21 Separability

If any provision of these rules shall be held invalid by a decision of the Vermont Supreme Court or made invalid by a statutory change, such decision or statutory change shall not affect the validity of the remainder of these rules.

DESIGN HEARINGS -- NECESSITY PETITIONS AND COMPENSATION HEARINGS

1. The time and place of design hearings will be entered on the agenda for regular meetings of the Board.
2. The proposed design for the project will be available for review by the Board at a Board meeting and the Board will be supplied with a brief description of the project.
3. One or more members of the Board will be designated to attend the hearings.
4. Following the hearing, the Board representatives will report in writing to the Board and the Agency.
5. Following Agency review of the project, the Board will be advised of the results of the Agency review.
6. Approval of the project will be noted by the adoption of a formal motion. In the event the project is not approved, the project shall be tabled pending action by the Board and/or Agency.
7. Following approval of the project by the Board, the Agency will prepare a necessity petition for signature by the Chairman or Executive Secretary.
8. Upon receipt of the judgement order, time and place for the compensation hearing shall be established by the Agency with Board approval and the notice of the compensation hearing will be prepared by the Agency and signed by the Chairman or Executive Secretary.
9. Following the compensation hearing, the Executive Secretary will supply the Agency with a list of the recommanded awards, identification of Attorneys in attendance and comments.
10. Within 45 days after the compensation hearing the Board will execute it's condemnation, under which will be filed and recorded is required by law.

14-002 Code Vt. R. 14-010-002-X

Effective Date: October 1, 1985 (SOS Rule Log #85-57)