Or. Admin. R. 137-003-0568

Current through Register Vol. 63, No. 6, June 1, 2024

Section 137-003-0568 - Discovery in Contested Case Hearing - Procedure

(1) Before filing a motion for an order requiring discovery, a party or the agency must make a good faith effort to obtain the information from the party, agency or person who has the information, unless the effort would pose a risk to any person or would be futile.

(2) A motion for an order requiring discovery should be filed with and decided by the agency or the administrative law judge, as required by OAR 137-003-0520(2) and 137-003-0630.

(3) Any party seeking an order from the administrative law judge requiring discovery shall send a copy of the motion to the agency, unless the agency has waived notice, and to all other parties. If the agency seeks an order requiring discovery, the agency shall send a copy of the motion to all parties. A request for an order requiring discovery must include a description of the attempts to obtain the requested discovery informally, or an explanation why no such attempt was made, and an explanation of how the discovery is likely to produce information that is generally relevant and necessary to the case.

(4) The agency or the administrative law judge may authorize the requested discovery if the agency or the administrative law judge determines that the requested discovery is reasonably likely to produce information that is generally relevant to the case and necessary or likely to facilitate resolution of the case. Upon request of a party, a witness, or the agency, the agency or the administrative law judge may deny, limit, or condition discovery to protect any party, any witness, or the agency from annoyance, embarrassment, oppression, undue burden or expense, or to limit the public disclosure of information that is confidential or privileged by statute or rule. In making a decision, the agency or administrative law judge shall consider any objections by the party, the witness or the agency from whom the discovery is sought.

(5) If the agency or the administrative law judge authorizes discovery, the agency or the administrative law judge shall control the methods, timing and extent of discovery. Upon request of a party or the agency, the administrative law judge or the agency may issue a protective order limiting the public disclosure of information that is confidential or privileged by law.

(6) Only the agency may issue subpoenas in support of a discovery order. The agency or the party requesting the discovery may apply to the circuit court to compel obedience to a subpoena. (Subpoenas for attendance of witnesses or production of documents at the hearing are controlled by OAR 137-003-0585.)

(7) A party or agency dissatisfied with an administrative law judge's discovery order may ask the Chief Administrative Law Judge for immediate review of the order. A request for review by the Chief Administrative Law Judge must be made in writing within 10 days of the date of the discovery order. The Chief Administrative Law Judge shall review the order and independently apply the criteria set out in OAR 137-003-0567. The Chief Administrative Law Judge's order shall be in writing and shall explain any significant changes to the discovery order.

(8) The Chief Administrative Law Judge or the agency may designate in writing a person to exercise their respective responsibilities under this rule.

(9) In addition to or in lieu of any other discovery method, a party may ask an agency for records under the Public Records Law. The party making a public records request of the agency before which the contested case is pending should serve a copy of the public records request upon the agency representative or the attorney representing the agency.

Or. Admin. R. 137-003-0568

DOJ 10-1999, f. 12-23-99, cert. ef. 1-1-00; DOJ 7-2003, f. 7-11-03, cert. ef. 7-21-03; DOJ 19-2003, f. 12-12-03, cert. ef. 1-1-04; DOJ 11-2005, f. 10-31-05, cert. ef. 1-1-06; Renumbered from 137-003-0570 by DOJ 1-2012, f. 1-11-12, cert. ef. 1-31-12

Stat. Auth.: ORS 183.341

Stats. Implemented: ORS 183.341 & 183.630