7 Colo. Code Regs. § 1105-1-9.413

Current through Register Vol. 47, No. 23, December 10, 2024
Section 7 CCR 1105-1-9.413 - RIGHTS OF APPEAL AND FORMAL APPEAL PROCESS [Rev. eff. 7/1/08]

Trainees and Certified Blind Operators may seek council of a Colorado Elected Committee member for a grievance in accordance with these Rules, §9.403.2 and shall refer to the DVR Policy Manual for any mediation, informal appeal, or formal appeal of a State Licensing Agency decision.

Licensed Blind Operators whose license is in any status, who wish to pursue a grievance or appeal, shall act in accordance with the following.

9.413.1Right of Appeal [Rev. eff. 7/1/08]
A. A Licensed Blind Operator who is dissatisfied with any determination made by the Business Enterprise Program staff and/or Division of Vocational Rehabilitation agency representative, which concerns the provision of Business Enterprise Program services, may request a:
1. Grievance in accordance with these Rules, § 9.403.2(b) and/or;
2. An informal review in accordance with this § 9.413 et seq. and/or;
3. A formal appeal in accordance with this § 9.413 et seq.
B. A Licensed Blind Operator is responsible for costs associated with their appeal.
C. NOTIFICATION OF RIGHTS TO REVIEW AND REQUEST MEDIATION

All Blind Operators through the Business Enterprise Program training, shall be notified of Licensed Blind Operator appeal rights.

D. PROVISION OF BUSINESS ENTERPRISE PROGRAM SERVICE(S) DURING REVIEWS AND MEDIATION

When a review request is made, all Business Enterprise Program services being provided under a current plan shall continue as specified until the review and/or appeal is completed, unless an Licensed Blind Operator or, as appropriate, the individual's representative requests a suspension, reduction, or termination of services, or if there is a risk to public safety or stability of The Business Enterprise Program. If the disputed service(s) and/or good(s) was obtained through proven misrepresentation, fraud, collusion, or criminal conduct by the individual or the individual's representative, the good or service shall be terminated immediately.

E. ADDITIONAL SERVICES DURING APPEALS

When an informal review or formal appeal request concerns an issue which may impact determination of ineligibility for Business Enterprise Program services and/or Transfer and Promotion, new or additional service(s) or good(s) shall not be provided.

F. DOCUMENTATION OF REVIEWS AND MEDIATION

The Blind Operator record shall contain documentation concerning actions and decisions relating to requests by Blind Operators for an informal review or formal appeal of Business Enterprise Program staff determinations.

G. INFORMAL REVIEW

The Licensed Blind Operator may request an informal review by the Program Manager in order to resolve the issue(s) under dispute with or without the conduct of a formal appeal. Informal review begins with a request for the Program Manager to review a decision concerning the provision of Business Enterprise Program services. If the individual is not satisfied with the decision made by the Program Manager, the individual may then submit a written request for review to the Blind and Low Vision Services Manager to review the decision. Informal review shall be conducted in a timely manner that shall not delay a formal appeal and within thirty (30) days of the initial request unless both parties agree that additional time is necessary. If the informal review does not resolve the issue(s), and the formal appeal process has not been requested, the individual may request a formal appeal.

When a formal appeal has been requested and the informal review does not resolve the dispute within the time established through mutual agreement, the formal appeal shall be conducted within the time frames outlined for the formal appeal process. An individual is not required to go through an informal review prior to or instead of a formal appeal.

H. FORMAL APPEAL: FULL EVIDENTIARY HEARING
1. This is written pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 107d-1 and 34 CFR Part 395.13.
2. An individual, or, as appropriate, his or her authorized representative, may initiate a formal appeal regarding Business Enterprise Program staff determinations by requesting an impartial due process hearing with an administrative law judge (ALJ).
3. The request shall be submitted, in writing, to the Colorado Department of Personnel and Administration, Office of Administrative Courts within ninety (90) calendar days of the decision that affects provision of a Business Enterprise Program service. The written request shall be a statement identifying the basis of the appeal, including a description of the determination made by the Business Enterprise Program staff that the individual is appealing. The statement should include a description of what the individual wants from the appeal.
4. Hearing Timelines

A hearing shall be held within sixty (60) calendar days of the informal pre-hearing conference, unless both parties agree additional time is necessary for good cause. There may be situations when a time extension is necessary to allow either party or the administrative law judge sufficient time to prepare for the hearing following an informal review. Even at those times, all parties must agree to the extension.

5. Additional Evidence and Witnesses

The individual, or, as appropriate, his or her authorized representative may present additional evidence, information, and witnesses to support the individual's position during the hearing.

6. Findings and Decision

The administrative law judge shall render a decision and provide a written report of the findings and the grounds for this decision to the individual, or, as appropriate, his or her authorized representative, and the Business Enterprise Program within thirty (30) calendar days of completion of the hearing.

7. Federal Arbitration

The State Licensing Agency or the Licensed Blind Operator who wishes to challenge the final decision made by the administrative law judge may submit a request for review of such decision to the Secretary of Education pursuant to and 20 U.S.C. § 107d-2 and 34 CFR Part 395.13 . The final decision of the administrative law judge shall be implemented pending the results of the review of the Secretary of Education.

7 CCR 1105-1-9.413

40 CR 04, February 25, 2017, effective 3/17/2017
41 CR 05, March 10, 2018, effective 3/30/2018
42 CR 03, February 10, 2019, effective 3/2/2019
42 CR 17, September 10, 2019, effective 9/30/2019
43 CR 02, January 25, 2020, effective 3/1/2020
45 CR 21, November 10, 2022, effective 11/30/2022