Court of Appeals of Ohio December 2003 casesState v. ScalmatoCantale v. Nationwide Ins. Co.Kathrens v. BerryCastrataro v. UrbanNorwest Bank Minnesota v. Alex-SaundersERB v. FLYING Z LAND TRUST CO.Barlay v. Yoga's Drive-ThruPierson v. Norfolk Southern Corp.State v. Industrial Commission of OhioState v. TaylorState v. LinkState v. BarnesState v. ShinaberryErie Ins. Exchange v. Colony Dev. Corp.Biviano v. Edward C. Mahan TrustTobias v. TobiasCollins v. Ohio State Racing CommissionState v. StallingsStavick v. Coyne, Unpublished DecisionState v. ChilcuttPorter v. KeefeState v. RussoIn re HarperIn re Adoption of HarrisState ex Rel. Aliane v. ShewardNeier v. SimsIn re Estate of LewisFraysure v. A-Best Products Co.State v. PierceRoberson v. Dept. of Rehab. CorrectionJones v. Federal Insurance CompanyState v. BrumleyState v. ByrdSTATE v. NAGYState v. FlemingWeltman v. Artic Freeze Arena, LLCState v. AcostaState v. TaylorCaston v. DamrauerState v. CaldwellMays v. DunawayMason v. Royal Insurance Co. of AmericaState v. GordonIn re Protest of BrooksState v. Industrial Commission of OhioRobinson v. Central Reserve Life Ins.State v. SealeyState v. ValesState v. HessIn re Kelley v. Amchem Products, Inc.Short v. Central Ins. Cos.Reynoldsburg v. Fraternal Order, PoliceState v. MillerPoptic v. PopticCrofut v. CrofutSullivan v. Hamilton County Board of HealthState v. McDuffeySpeedway Super America v. Granville V.Graybeal v. Cincinnati Ins. Co.State v. LoweAPPS v. APPSState v. CostelloIn re C.H.State v. RodriguezGusman v. Strongville Bd. of Edn.Child Care Provider v. HarrisTripp v. Beverly Enterprises-Ohio, Inc.STATE v. HYREState v. GirardState v. LambertState v. PerryState v. AllenState v. LowryState v. ColdironState v. MondryState v. BylandCominsky v. Madison Health CareBurke v. MeltonState v. StrongState v. McClentonState v. CochranState v. LattimoreState ex Rel. Biars v. Indus. Comm.In re MaloneTisdale v. RathboneSEFF v. DAVISPowers v. Ohio Dept. of Rehab CorrectionValleaire Golf Club, Inc. v. ConradHalliwill v. State Farm Insurance CompanyJackson v. City of ClevelandState v. HornbeckCity v. EllenbergerState v. KimbroughSOTOS v. EDELWhitman v. Travellers Insurance Co.Harris v. ReiffState v. WeiserState v. MorningstarTzarnas v. TalatiState v. JohnsonClancy v. Erie Insurance GroupKing v. E.A. Berg Sons, Inc.SABO v. SABOAddair v. MitchellWitfoth v. KieferRANK v. RANKSTATE v. MONKPerkins v. Land Rover of AkronState v. ColemanShafer v. Westfield Insurance Co.State v. ThomasState v. HowardWarren v. DavisState v. AdamsPrudential Prop. v. Unitary Prod. GroupState v. MartinGeauga County Board of Health v. PauerState v. CampbellStuller v. PriceState v. WardRizvi v. St. Elizabeth Hosp. Med. Ctr.Hickin v. American Guarantee Liab.Jurczak v. JR Schugel Trucking Co.State v. ChandlerState v. VanekMoffett v. Salem City School Dist. Bd.State v. TaylorState v. SteigerwaldZinsmeister v. Wayne Twp. Bd. of Tru.State v. Industrial Commission of OhioState v. RiedelCity of Cleveland Heights v. JacksonFerguson v. Lear Corp.State v. WootenIn re Application of KellerCity of Garfield Heights v. McElroyState v. TannerState v. BlalockWestfield Co. v. O.K.L. Can LineBevins v. ArledgeLedford v. Board of Zoning AppealsNicholas v. DealPetitti v. Plain Twp. Bd. of Zoning App.State v. RiceState v. WoodruffBouffard v. Robinson Memorial HospitalRACH v. DEPASQUALEBowman v. HudakKeybank National Association v. AdamsLake v. LakeState v. SpeesState v. ButlerLOOM LODGE v. OHIO LIQUOR CONTROL COMM.Jackson v. JacksonState v. ShineIn re R.C.State v. MaloneyState v. WintersState v. AlexanderWynn v. Taylor-Dunn ManufacturingPfile v. City of CirclevilleYovanno v. Ryder System, Inc.State v. CavinState v. MaysState v. WilliamsAdkins v. DossBrothers v. Morone-O'Keefe Dev. Co.Peck v. SerioIn the Matter of NashKEEN v. HARDIN MEM. HOSP.State v. BhattHottensmith v. CorvoState v. VandergriffState v. WerfelTracy v. TinnermanParis v. Dairy Mart-Lawson Co.State v. PerryMadden v. Fidelity Guaranty Ins. Under.Lindsey v. Sinclair Broadcast GroupThornton v. HagginsState v. CrosbyState v. JacocksSummit Sound Security, Ltd. v. SheelerRetina Associates of Cleveland v. SmithPurdy v. PurdyMcCollam v. American Foreign Ins. Co.Kauble v. PfeifferMcGrath v. SaretBYG v. LYNCHState v. McAdorySTATE v. BETZState v. AdkinsI-70 310 Auto Care v. ShupeCarpenter v. Wellman Products GroupState v. PavlickChesney v. JowersState v. Industrial CommissionState v. CereghinSchwartz v. Realtispec, Inc.Mills v. MillsState v. FrederickCity of Cleveland v. CarpenterState v. WalkerMarcum v. MarcumDiemert v. DiemertState v. BakerSTATE v. MOYEState v. HolcombArkley v. ArkleyMcPherson v. Goodyear Tire Rubber Co.Springfield Fireworks v. OhioDavis v. DavisIn re Estate of LoweBridge v. Park National BankState v. EllisonState v. RatliffState v. MauldinBARR v. HERNANDEZState v. KingState v. HardyState v. CarterState v. WaltonState v. CvijetinovicState v. WantzUTT v. UTTWinfield v. WinfieldKonstand v. BarbertonMoss v. MarraState v. HicksState v. ReamesState v. ShafferJordan v. JordanIn re I.M.State v. KimbroughGeorgenson v. GeorgensonState v. MaloneyMason v. Royal Ins. Co. of AmericaIn re Guardianship of FraserPoole v. SamsonState v. BrownDayton v. HuberState v. SteeleTate v. Adena Regional Medical CenterState v. PeacockState v. AbuzahriehSaponari v. Century Limousine ServiceState v. HensleyState v. MillerTaylor v. CirclevilleCriado v. TruesdellSteffy v. BlevinsState v. SarverKuhnle v. ZanderIn re HustonBuschard v. StateBaltz v. C.M.H.A.State v. PearsonState v. StarcherState ex Rel. Active USA, Inc. v. ConradState v. BoggsSagenich v. Erie Insurance GroupValerian v. Ohio Liquor Control Comm.Ruark v. SmithRyncarz v. AuroraYarder v. SchererState v. DurandState v. BaileyState v. WileyState v. EscorttState v. WestState v. RennerState v. VercellinoState v. DouglasState ex Rel. Williams v. O'DonnellSarmiento v. Grange Mutual Insurance Co.Tharp v. BerdanierState v. TannerState v. MickeyIn re BarkerIn re HibbardState v. MillerState v. ReeseAnderson v. Interface Electric, Inc.Deadwyler v. Akron Public SchoolsIn re Estate of CampbellState v. DanielsBrookman v. Estate of GrayHAMPTON v. SWADState v. ZaffinoState v. VerdreamJones v. A-Best Products CompanyState v. RicciIn re La. B.McElrath v. Travel Safe.com Vacation Ins.COX v. INDEMNITY INSURANCE CO.Sovak v. SpiveyState v. SnyderCoates v. AsmarState v. BuchananMaggard v. ZervosMoore v. HartSTATE v. PYLEState ex Rel. Holdren v. Indus. Comm.State v. FowlerHerip v. City of ClevelandState v. HudsonState v. DaddarioImage Inc. v. WestfallState v. Martin, Unpublished DecisionJACKSON AE v. PUBLIC EMP. RETIREMENTState v. MuhammadState v. MooreSandusky Dock Corporation v. JonesLoretz v. StewartCasterline v. KhouryWilliams v. City of AkronState v. CopleyState v. VactorSykes v. General Motors CorporationState v. ElersicState v. PoughPowell v. State Farm Fire Casualty Co.ATWATER TWP. TRUSTEES v. KEENIn re D.H.Parrish v. State Farm Mutual Auto. Ins.Brock v. Lucas Co. Bd. of ElectionsState v. SaundersBlythe v. BlytheVanatta v. AkersState v. DiluccaBiddle v. Maguire Schneider, LLPState v. PaytonDickerson v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins.State v. ScarburyState v. UngerState v. EldridgeState v. KellwoodIn re M.H.State v. ShahanState v. StumboGuardianship of Vasko v. BrownStohlmann v. Koski-HallState v. CarterState ex Rel. Angell Mfg. Co. v. LongState v. DavisLogan v. LoganMeece v. American and Foreign InsuranceGrieshop v. Oh. Dept of Job Family ServThomas v. U.S. Fidelity Guarantee Ins.Sendejaz v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.State v. GlavicState v. BarnesScarabino v. E. Liverpool City HospPorter v. FerrallUTT v. UTTDeCarlo v. SchillaCincinnati Insurance Co. v. BlazeticBay West Electric v. GMS ConstructionSchwaller v. MaguireWeitzel v. WayAsmis v. Marc Glassman, Inc.ROBB v. DIRECTOR, OHIO DEPT. OF JOBState v. FreemanSherrick v. McCoyJUDD v. JACKSONCity v. American Fed. of StateHilton v. Mill Road Construction IIState v. QuinonesSTATE v. GISTHollar v. Pleasant TownshipShell v. Ohio Vet. M. Licensing Bd.Bates Amusement v. Ohio Dept. of Agric.Jones v. Federal Insurance Co.State v. HintonState v. HardinMason v. Royal Insurance Co. of AmericaLinden Medical v. State Bd. PharmacyState v. PriceAEY v. BARGAINER-RAGLANDWinkler Bldg. v. Fairview Sh. CenterCollins v. National City BankFaulkner v. Integrated Services NetworkHall v. Kreider Manufacturing, Inc.Braithwaite v. Department of CommerceState v. ByerlyGaspar, Inc. v. Scott Process Sys., Inc.Aponte v. CastorHHA SERVICES v. SO. OHIO MED. CTR.Stevens v. MaloneWilson v. Natl. Union Fire Ins. Co.Whittington v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.Lepole v. Long John Silver'sState v. PerdueBaldwin v. VogelsongCross v. Horace Mann-Teachers Ins.State v. HeflinSowers v. HeidlerState v. ThomasNational City Bank v. KesslerBright v. Family Medicine FoundationDoran v. Northmont Board of Ed.National City Bank v. Slink TaylorState v. NormanIn re Estate of CarrierState v. Groce-HopsonState v. McMillinState v. AlvarezBowman v. StottState v. ByersState v. HallState v. SzerlipLautermilch v. Findlay City SchoolsFee v. FeeState v. BeverlyWood v. KiptonState v. VaughnState v. DanielsClark v. ClarkBeaston v. SlingwineState v. DesmanIn re Guardianship of BorlandState v. ToddJones v. Federal Insurance CompanyState v. LawsonHaslam v. RussellCollias v. Troy Radiologists, Inc.Erie Ins. Co. v. CortrightShimko v. BrickmanState v. SiengState v. BickelState v. GeorgeState v. HanshawChase Manhattan Mtg. Corp. v. LockerState v. TaylorState v. PenceWelsh-Pojman v. PojmanState v. RatkovichGrant v. GraeningCochran v. CochranNigro v. City of ParmaState v. PishokState v. TaftTOTO v. ST. PAUL FIRE MARINE INS. CO.State v. CrumptonSeouds Enter. v. Ohio Liquor ControlMahoning Ct. v. Int'l BHD of TeamstersNevergall v. Indemnity Insurance CompanyScott v. Falcon Transport Co.State v. BonnerIn re T.W.State v. BrumfieldState v. HouserState v. GilcreastDeer Lake Mobile Park v. WendelKeefer v. Ohio Dept. of Job Family Serv.State v. JohnsonState v. BeachMcComb-Houghton v. HoughtonSTATE v. WYERClifton v. CliftonCHO v. CHOState v. ConethanState v. YorkState v. RiceState v. JordanIn re Protest of BrooksHoeck v. VarnerLeffler v. State Farm Insurance Co.Information Leasing Corp. v. USA FormsPaynter v. PaynterIn re Guardianship of KoenigState v. SummerourBombardier Capital, Inc. v. W.W. CyclesZiegler v. Pacific Employers Ins. CompanyWinkler v. WinklerBuck v. Auto Shop M.D., Inc.Baker v. DorionState v. C K Industrial Services, Inc.Chatman v. Progressive Casualty Ins. Co.State v. LetscheState v. ShineEasterwood v. EnglishIN RE GOFFHoward v. Contech Construction ProductsNationwide Mutual Ins. Co. v. LayfieldPravitskyy v. HalczysakState v. BrooksEisele v. Polyone Inc.City of Lima v. Frat. Order of PoliceIn re DarlingMiller v. MillerState v. BanksHartley v. Allstate Insurance Co.State v. MasekGreen v. GreenLinam v. LinamColburn v. Baier Realty AuctioneersState v. ArnoldState v. ReynoldsState v. WattsState ex Rel. Wooten v. Indus. Comm.Kershner v. KershnerWarner v. BowersoxIn re BurtonState v. PiertState v. KirkwoodMadden v. Fidelity Guaranty Ins. Under.Shaffer-Goggin v. StateContinenza v. TablackARP-HALL v. LINDSpringfield Fireworks, v. Ohio CommerceMiller v. McMichaelDater v. Dater FoundationBengala v. DoeState v. AbuzahriehHarrod v. Travelers Prop. Cas.City of Willoughby Hills v. SheridanState v. StanishiaState v. MooreMaloney v. ConradGroob v. KeyBankState v. BerryWyatt v. Autozone, Inc.Myers v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins.State v. FraleyState v. BrownShirley v. Republic-Franklin Ins. Co.In re Forfeiture of Property of KusnerIn re Blanka H.M.GEVEDON v. IVEYBrown v. Pacific Employers Insurance Co.Kogler v. Daniel Bros. Fuel Co.McDonald v. WilliamsonState v. WalkerQualchoice, Inc. v. NiecieckiState ex Rel. Wrenn v. Kroger CompanyBrowne v. WalgreensIn re N.K.Peroz v. NagelPauley v. Royal Insurance CompanyPreston v. PrestonMuirhead v. BoydTrumbull Cty. Sheriff's Off. v. O.P.B.A.State v. WilburnCalhoun-Brannon v. BrannonState v. LaFeverState v. GainesState v. SchofieldJohnson v. JohnsonState v. GraySpringer v. CaltriderIn re Joshua C.Wilds v. Ohio Deptartment of CommerceState v. GarriesState v. LewisSchirmer v. Mt. Auburn Obstetrics & Gynecologic Associates, Inc.State v. Ohio Housing Finance AgencyJohnson v. HundleyState v. TaylorRudloff v. EfstathiadisBank One v. JohnsonDAVIS v. REMYIn re Estate of SvetichanESKE PROPERTIES, INC. v. SUCHERDunigan v. State Farm Mutual Auto. Ins.McDaniel v. Westfield CompaniesAce Ventures v. Ohio Dept., of Trans.State v. VannState v. VincerState ex Rel. Nifco v. WoodsIn re DoeColeman v. Akron Board of EducationState v. OhlemacherCarper v. SnodgrassCargotec v. Westchester Fire Ins. Co.Wallace v. Ohio Department of CommerceHaven House Manor, Ltd. v. GabelUllom v. UllomState v. BaucomSmyers v. BennettTHOMAS v. ARM FOOD, INC.State v. ScharfState v. GriffithState v. TarverState v. HoldrenDosier v. Travelers Property CasualtySCHUSTER v. CITY OF AVON LAKEAites v. American Motorists Ins.Pengov v. PengovState v. WilliamsState v. NjoguPoland Township Bd. of Tr. v. SweseySansom v. GriffinGeauga Cty. Bd. v. Geauga Cty. SheriffShannon v. SchillerBeaston v. SlingwineState v. McElroyCity of Akron v. NiepsujGonzalez v. Travelers Insurance CompanyState v. ArmstrongLee v. Upper ArlingtonDiebold Credit Corporation v. ColemanZuzan v. ShutrumpState v. LivingstonClark v. RiskoFlynn v. Gen. Motors Corp.Planck v. Cinergy Power GenerationState v. GrantMcManus v. EicherTraxler v. TraxlerBYRD v. MIDLAND ROSS/GRIMES AEROSPACEState v. GraysMoore v. MooreErwin v. Best Buy Auto Sales, Inc.WACO SCAFFOLDING v. SCHAFFER SONSState v. SmithHawkins v. Crestwood Local School Dist.Burns v. Zuck-SpriggsIn the Matter of KnightState v. TownsendState v. PillarState v. WayneOliver-Pavkovich v. PavkovichState v. SchislerMayor v. WeddingSmart Pages v. Ohio MortgagePotts v. Cinemark USAMason v. American and Foreign Ins. Co.King v. State Farm Insurance Co.In re Protest of BrooksBarber v. McFaulStroud v. LyonsAllen v. McBrideDadosky v. DadoskyState v. KnodeSullivan v. WilkinsonState v. PamerPerkins v. MayerState v. RandlettState v. KnodeNickel v. CarterState v. NewsomeGriffin v. Twin Valley Psychiatric Sys.Stanton v. City of ClevelandSTATE v. PROMState v. LambJustice v. LernerState v. HendersonYost v. BermudezIn re Petition of DoeState ex Rel. Donald v. RussoFlatinger v. FlatingerState v. ClarkState v. EskridgeLinquist v. SutekState v. RichardsonSherrick v. McCoyMiller v. MillerJohnson v. Microsoft Corp.State v. MilesState v. DonaldsonState v. JohnsonIn re VanceState v. MayState v. AlveyState v. RothLinden Medical v. State Bd. of PharmacyIn re PayneState v. HarrisState v. TateState v. PfeiferTurckes v. TurckesState v. SeabrookSzakal v. Akron Rubber DevelopmentXenia v. DiazState v. ThompsonCity of Strongsville v. StoskopfAl-Sadeq Islamic Ed. v. Lucas CountyBarnby v. Natl. Union Fire Insurance Co.Yusko v. SubichinState v. Ohio Adult Parole AuthorityKay v. SchifferShterenberg v. American States Ins.State v. SullivanState v. BoergertState v. RichterState v. ColeState v. SpragginsHottensmith v. CorvoMcGinnis v. Lawrence Economic Dev. Corp.State v. MarableJones v. Kemper Insurance CompanyKennedy v. StriebelWarren v. DavisWiesman v. WiesmanLumbermens Mutual Casualty Co. v. BebszBowling Green v. BaileyPlastech Engineered v. Cooper-StandardState v. JohnsonState v. HicksBonacorsi v. Wheeling Lake Erie RailwayState v. ColemanHawk v. KettererState v. DunlapTriplett v. American Family Ins. GroupState v. MatiaPoling v. Nationwide Mutual Ins. Co.State v. MetcalfVILLAGE/CHAGRIN PARTNERS v. BD. OF ED.Ross v. SmithState v. RiversWells v. Progressive Ins. Co.Francis v. Showcase Cinema EastgateState v. Hutzler