Supreme Court of New York March 2023 casesRosen v. Zionist Org. of Am.Sheiffer v. FoxPeople v. LewisBaum v. SuzukiNicholls v. NGB Bay LLCMIC Gen. Ins. Corp. v. RashidAllco LLC v. Plumbing Today, Inc.Wilmington Sav. Fund Soc'y v. ZebrowskiAegis Smb Fund II, LP v. RosenfeldU.S. Bank v. Hilda JungSang Seok v. Malik & Assocs.Ankney v. Gjoni Law, P.C.Appel v. N.Y.C. Police Dep'tGopstein v. VadHaart v. ScagliaCampbell v. N.Y. Boiler, Inc.Cruz v. Komatsu Am. Corp.Max v. ALP, Inc.Green Improvement LLC v. HaiderFor a Judgment Under Article 78 of the Civil Practice Law & Rules v. N.Y. State Pub. Serv. Comm'n (In re Clean Air Coal. of W. N.Y.)Cardenas-Parra v. 540 Fulton Assocs.HSBC Bank U.S. v. PHH Mortg. Corp.Cunningham v. City of New YorkStier 109 LLC v. 109 S. 5 Prop.Arizaga v. Lex Gardens II TP4 Hous. Dev. Fund Co.Chiu-Yu v. ChinDoe v. Roman Catholic Archdiocese of N.Y.P.W. Developers, LLC v. R.C.People v. DavisHarlem 133 Owner, LLC v. JimenezPeople v. VergaraMorrow v. Criminal Records OfficerThe Lake George Assn. v. The NYS Adirondack Park AgencySafe Horizon, Inc. v. KalajD & D Bldg. Co. v. Allegro Pianos of Manhattan Corp.State v. Oren-PinesPerkins Eastman Architects D.P.C. v. White Plains Hosp. Med. Ctr.Koleosho v. CiporenSt. John's Capital Corp. v. 1365-1369 St. Johns Place LLCMic Gen. Ins. Corp. v. RashidGonzalez v. Victor's Coffee Shop, Deli & Rest.Chai foundation, Inc. v. N.Y. State Div. of Hous. & Cmty. RenewalElias v. N.Y.C. Hous. Auth.Amuze v. Better Bus. BureauZittman v. HSBC Bank U.S.Mack v. N.Y.C. Transit Auth.Gibbs v. 1429 Food Corp.Doe v. Diocese of BrooklynHall v. MiddletonIvry v. Elrac, LLCAm. Transit Ins. Co. v. A To Z Med. Care PCYeshiva Tiferes Shmuel LLC v. Weiss Advisory Servs.DS 17 W. 24th St. Note Purchaser v. LeeSklar v. Itria Ventures, LLCPeople v. LegareW. Mountain Assets LLC v. DobkowskiMazzone v. Alonso, Andalkar & Facher, P.C.Sanjines v. CruzHaut v. Consol. Edison Co. of N.Y.Deutsche Bank AG v. Bolta U.S. Ltd.Cruz v. Komatsu Am. Corp.Gross v. BrachCarter v. The City of New YorkCelia v. CeliaP.G. v. P.G.JF v. Archdiocese of New YorkEshaghpour v. The Promenade Condo.Great Am. Ins. Co. v. DeLeonMorrow v. Criminal Records OfficerTobia v. MeshechokLiving Real Estate Grp. v. Douglas Elliman, LLCSarmiento v. Hotel Carlyle Owners Corp.Morbieu v. KeayesU.S. Bank v. Hilda JungCheng Hao Zheng v. Jianjun Li QI Med.Rob Vel Trading Pty Ltd. v. ThomasNicholson v. JohnJDS Constr. Grp. v. Copper Servs.Gould v. Lex Shakos, LLCAgujlar v. Uncommon Grounds Enters.Acosta v. The City of New YorkN.Y. Gen. & Marine Ins. Co. v. Merchants Mut. Ins. Co.Yocum v. United States Tennis Assoc.Pizzarotti IBC, LLC v. A.L. One Constr.People v. DunkleyCosta v. 301 E. 80th Realty LLCE.L. v. M.S.Lahoz-Vargas v. Bop Ne LLCSeneca Lake Guardian v. N.Y. State Dep't of Envtl. ConservationDaddino v. Cosmo435 Cent. Park W. Tenant Ass'n v. Park Front Apartments, LLCKazoku, LLC v. The Bd. of Managers of the Museum Bldg.Reels v. Dynamics In Play, LLCByars v. Transp. Workers, Union of Am.People v. AndradeMurphy v. Metro. Transp.Broadstreet N.Y. Inc. v. L3 Capital Income Fund, LLCEsposito v. CasaleLliguin v. DDG Dev.Int'l Bus. Machs. Corp. v. GlobalFoundries U.S., Inc.Rossman v. SchwanzMr. Advance v. The Pore Co.Borboni, LLC v. RosaWhite Oak Commercial Fin. v. Rune N.Y.C., LLCU.S. Bank v. DiazHines v. DoeYakte Props. v. RattooMontalvo v. DouglasCruz v. Komatsu Am. Corp.Faina P. v. Alexander S.Star201, LLC v. MartinezAdvance Funding, LLC v. Martinez604 Willoughby LLC v. ClaytonBrach v. WydraJ.S. v. Church of the Blessed SacramentEscobar v. N.Y.C. Transit Auth.Schilling v. WalshMcCabe v. ABB, Inc.Ashkinazy v. Gary Pillersdorf P.C.1516 Roof LLC v. 469 Holdings, LLCSilla v. SillaState Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. v. Access Med. Diagnostic Sols.Ten W. Thirty Third Assocs. v. ABG Accessories, Inc.Sheiffer v. FoxG-Z/10 UNP Realty, LLC v. SLCE Architects, LLPSolomon v. 715-723 Sixth Ave. Owners Corp.Wynn v. TengKaycee Props. v. ColonBorek v. SeidmanFaina P. v. Alexander S.State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. v. Allied Care PT, P.C.Weber v. BarnettPeople v. J.S.Am. Transit Ins. Co. v. Marta Med. Supply, CorpKimball v. Bay Ridge United Methodist ChurchARK252 Doe v. Archdiocese of N.Y.Passanisi v. A.O. Smith Water Prods. Co.Bank of Am. v. DonohueCarpenter v. LAML, LLCMerriview Hill, LLC v. Prebenda16 W. 12 Holding, LLC v. 18 W. 12th St. Apt. Corp.People v. BanyaiFall v. Greyhound Lines, Inc.Marshalls of MA, Inc. v. CAC Atl., LLCChurchill 381 Broadway LLC v. PatelDoe J.G. v. The City of New YorkPetrikas v. Allstate Vehicle & Prop. Ins. Co.Wark v. Cameron Eng'g & Assocs.Roper v. Turner Constr. Co.Clover/Allen's Creek Neighborhood Ass'n, LLC v. M & F, LLCGov't Emps. Ins. Co. v. Altai Corp.Gov't Emps. Ins. Co. v. ALTAI Corp.Metro. Transp. Auth. v. Roth & Roth, LLPBellvue v. City of New YorkLettire v. S.D. Second Ave. Manager255 Butler Assocs. v. 255 Butler, LLCDeCock v. State of N.Y. Div. of Hous. & Cmty. RenewalHashkaot LLC v. Union Senior Citizens' Plaza, Inc.Tekiner v. Bremen House Inc.Alevy v. HerzMontagna v. All Good Elec. Corp.Marvinney v. Australian Spirit LLCQuagliata v. N.Y. City Police Dept.Galkowski-Coira v. The Price Chopper, Inc.For A Judgment Pursuant To Article 78 of the Civil Practice Law & Rules v. N.Y. State Div. of Hous. & Cmty. Renewal (In re Riverside Syndicate)Certain Underwriters At Lloyd's v. NL Indus.Arias v. Astoria-LIC Dev.Buhl v. KesnerMut. Redevelopment Houses v. Metro. Transp. Auth.Stanton v. Dragonetti Bros. Landscaping Nursery & FloristRobustelli v. Consol. Edison Co. of N.Y.Pirouz v. 1515 Broadway Owner LLCIKB Int'l S.A. in Liquidation v. StanleyIn re IlichAnonymous v. AnonymousAm. Transit Ins. Co. v. Marta Med. Supply Corp.Neira-Bernal v. The City of New YorkState Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. v. E. Coast Med. CareReliance First Capital LLC v. WagnerBankers Conseco Life Ins. Co. v. KPMG LLP16 Court St. Brooklyn, LLC v. N.Y.C. Water Bd.Seniorcare Emergency Med. Servs. v. Logisticare Sols. Indep. Practice Ass'nSuquitana v. Drmbre-85TM Fee LLCLiberty Ins. Underwriters v. The Plaza Condo.Hughes v. City of Mount VernonKrembs v. NYU Langone Hosps.Muoi T Luong v. Ha The LuongHarnaraine v. D. Lia Realty LLCSuber v. Churchill Owners Corp.Gonzalez v. ValenzuelaWells Fargo Bank v. ChrysostomEB v. VBFinkelstein v. FinkelsteinJ.T. Magen & Co. v. Starr Indem. & Liab. Co.Natixis v. 20 TSQ Lessee LLCMajestic Rayon Corp. v. Soho Office Suites, LLCTekiner v. Bremen House Inc.Worbes Corp. v. SebrowPeople v. TurnerLehman Bros. Int'l (Europe) (In Administration) v. AG Fin. Prods.Dragons 516 Ltd. v. Knights Genesis Inv.Postiguone v. Nat'l Gen. Ins. Co.Ali v. PastuizacaCooper v. Bldg 7<SUP>th</SUP> St.Mercer Square, LLC v. Namdor, Inc.HCC Ins. Holdings v. Athenium Analytics LLCG & Y Maint. Corp. v. 540 W. 48th St. Corp.Indus. Model Grp. v. Ferrante Law FirmHarlington Realty Co. v. Valdome, Inc.Tzfanya v. The N.Y. & Presbyterian Hosp.Landell v. Life Bridge Dental PLLCHarleysville Ins. Co. v. United Fire Prot., Inc.Ball v. Kpshah NY Inc.Eshaghpour v. Promenade Condo.Safe Horizon, Inc. v. KalajAntara Capital Master Fund LP v. Bombardier Inc.Defranco v. Napoli Bern Ripka Shkolnik LLPOrtiz v. Verizon N.Y. Inc.GFK U.S. MRI LLC v. LHK PartnersPeople v. McIverMurchinson-Hunt v. N.Y.C. Emps' Ret. Sys.Quinn v. The Hosp. for Special Surgery PHOMcGovern v. The St. Luke's-Roosevelt Hosp. Ctr.GNHC 1703-518, LLC v. Venari Partners, LLCSignature Fin. v. Endeavor Constr. Group- Corp.People v. ForteCivil Serv. Emps. Ass'n v. Cnty. of AlbanyClarke v. The N.Y.C. Transit Auth.J.C. v. A.J.S.People v. BerriosJ.C. v. A.J.S.Vargas v. 622 Third Ave. Co.Arnold v. BlitzFinitive LLC v. PattelliLis v. LancasterCanary Bus. Funding v. Tammy Tran Attorneys at Law, LLPMacMenamin v. 95th & Third LLCMartinez v. WHGA Renaissance Apartments Ltd. P'shipKovacevic v. MinoiaMarrero v. N.Y.C. Hous. Auth.3750 Broadway BCR, LLC v. Grand Express Deli & Grocery Corp.Doe v. Archdiocese of N.Y.People v. LunaR. C. v. The City of New YorkHolm v. Du City Tri Runs, Inc.721 Borrower LLC v. MohaPeople v. BanyaiLee v. BerkeleyProf-2013-S3 Legal Title Tr. v. JohnsonDesseaux v. Muse Mgmt.Savage v. BirchRodriguez v. Isabella Geriatric Ctr.In re JEState Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. v. Am. Empire Surplus Lines Ins. Co.McClean v. The Bd. of Trs. of the Fire Dept. of City of N.Y. Pension Fund43rd St. Deli, Inc. v. Paramount Leasehold, L.P.ATX Debt Fund 2, LLC v. PaulKhreshi v. Concierge Auctions, LLCFlores v. Dinosaur Rests.Shayne v. Star Nine Cab Corp.Mangasaryan v. Palomino260-261 Madison Ave. v. Wework 261 Madison LLCEshaghpour v. Zepsa Indus.9F Sec. Litig. v. [REDACTED]Hernandez v. Zoria Hous.Anonymous v. AnonymousAnkney v. Gjoni Law, P.CCarney v. Metro. Transp. Auth.Streetsblog-NYC v. City of New YorkPeople v. MorganARK247 Doe v. Archdiocese of N.Y.Al Int'l Holdings (BVI) v. Two Borrower 2016, LLCYes Lender, LLC v. High Prot. IntelligenceStanton Surf Club LLC v. Allstar Sec., & ConsultingKeys v. The City of New YorkFeng Li v. VillegasGibbs v. 1429 Food Corp.Morbieu v. KeayesLandmark Holdings N.Y.C., LLC v. BradshawDeans v. Nassau Cnty. Pub. Adm'rTurner Constr. Co. v. Nastasi & Assocs.People v. DavisColindres v. MohajerThe City of New York v. LacroixWilliams v. Genmill LLCCady v. VarmaThe Barrier Grp. v. BMF Advance LLCNewrez LLC v. KalinaMTGLQ Inv'rs v. GrossRoss v. No Parking Today, Inc.590 Myrtle LLC v. Silverman-Shaw Inc.Newrez LLC v. KalinaIn re Of Maria MarteState v. James G.BGC Partners v. Avison Young (Can.). Inc.Cnty. Wide Masonry Corp. v. Hudson Meridian Constr. Grp.435 Cent. Park W. Tenant Ass'n v. Park Front Apartments, LLCStancuna v. Cable News Network, Inc.G.B. v. Archdiocese of N.Y.Roulston v. The City of New YorkCimen v. HQ Capital Real Estate L.P.J.S. v. P.H.Bankers Conseco Life Ins. Co. v. KPMG LLPDuarte v. Adams1156 APF LLC v. Hotel Reservation Serv.Ferrari v. A.O. Smith Water Prods. Co.Noto v. Planck, LLCThrall v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co.In re Edgar V.L.601-609 W. 175th St. Corp. v. Disc. Linen & BeyondSaleh v. 418 River Rd. LLCState v. Oren-PinesEustache v. Bd. of Educ.B.R. v. E. at W. for Rehab. & Nursing, LLCSummerville v. Tradeweb Mkts.Smartmatic U.S. Corp. v. Fox Corp.Clover/Allen's Creek Neighborhood Ass'n v. M & F, LLCVoulgaris v. PhillipsMontagna v. All Good Electric Corp.Interasian Dig. Tech. Holdings v. Fid. Brokerage Servs.Hines & Assocs. Law Office v. Yan Ping LiuRaparthi v. ClarkAtanasio v. O'NeillSejour v. BekkaouiV.Z. v. Archdiocese of N.Y.Vivanco v. Znko Constr.Madan v. 57th & 6th Ground LLCTalmage v. Greenpoint Mfg. & Design Ctr.Stagen v. NeuSheiffer v. FoxZuckerbrot v. LandeCacani v. Sam Pucciarelli Co.Cacani v. Sam Pucciarelli Co.In re Parents for Educ. & Religious Liberty in Schs. v. Young558 Seventh Ave. Corp. v. E&B Barbers, Inc.Gordon v. N.Y. Presbyterian Healtcare Sys.Jackson v. Schindler Elevator Corp.Rudder v. Broome Co-Operative Ins. Co.J.S. v. P.H.Fall v. Greyhound Lines, Inc.Savage v. Birch15 W. 43rd St. LLC v. The Princeton Club of N.Y.KBL LLP v. Banana Kelly Cmty. Improvement Ass'n255 Butler Assocs. v. 255 Butler, LLCPV Holding Corp. v. Hyun Physical Therapy, P.C.Passanisi v. A O. Smith Water Prods. Co.Berkley Equity, Ltd. v. EtraWolf v. A.O. Smith Water Prods. Co.Fid. Nat'l Title Ins. Co. v. DaSilvaWells Fargo Bank v. ButlerSO & CO Watch LLC v. BT Supplies W.People v. AndradeCivil Serv. Emps. Ass'n, Inc. v. Cnty. of AlbanyAvatar Lenox Ave v. Jacqueline Allmond Cuisine, Inc.Yes Lender, LLC v. High Prot. Intelligence LLCGross v. BrachHarper Advance v. Chance Reynolds Trucking LLCSeen v. Kaiser Gypsum Co.Bank of N.Y. Mellon Tr. Co. v. HendricksonMJ v. N.Y. State Dep't. of HealthHicks v. SinclairBay Ridge Prince LLC v. The City of New YorkCamacho v. KatehisKing C Steel Works LLC v. Saga Mgmt. Grp.Ettienne v. ZhangBortugno v. Schindler Elevator Corp.Cohen v. Air & Liquid Sys. Corp.Hoggard v. Cheever Dev. Corp.Iacovacci v. Brevet Holdings, LLCRodriguez v. 344 McGuinness Holdings LLCE.L. 27 Realty, LLC v. GordonMonroe v. The City of New YorkTen W. Thirty Third Assocs. v. Abg Accessories, Inc.People v. QayyumFrey v. Mount Sinai Med. Ctr.SSC N.Y. Corp. v. ComputerShare Inc.Hughes v. City of Mount VernonAnsbro v. Brookfield Real Props.People v. LegareCapra v. PanzerK.G. v. Speonk Congregation of Jehovah's WitnessesBonesteel v. N.Y.C. Transit Auth.Townes v. TownesGordon v. N.Y.C. Transit Auth.Coleman v. The City of New YorkHernandez v. TanouyeKalamotousakis v. KarpSacklow v. N.Y.C. Transit Auth.Carr v. N.Y.C. Transit Auth.Strategic Funding Source, Inc. v. JohnsonMahne v. Cell Source, Inc.Tian Yun Chen v. 155 Ross St.Varbero v. CandelaReclaim N.Y. v. Vindex LLCARK647 Doe v. Archdiocese of N.Y.Johnson v. 767 Fifth Partners LLCJimenez v. Lordan Maspeth LLCPatterson Belknap Webb & Tyler LLP v. Marcus & Cinelli LLPEarthlink, LLC v. Charter Commc'ns Operating, LLCKunkel v. N.Y.C. Dep't of BuildingsLake George Ass'n v. N.Y.S. Adirondack Park AgencyPeople v. ArocaBayas v. Edison Mgmt.St. John's Capital Corp. v. 1365-1369 St. Johns Place LLCP.G. v. P.G.Pepen v. LascanoGonzalez v. Penn State Shoe Repair, Inc.Yunjie Frank Yang v. Knights Genesis Grp.D'Angelo v. City of New YorkRiley v. Purcell260-261 Madison Ave. v. WeWork 261 Madison LLCMP Indus. Venture v. Criterion Indus. HoldingsNW Media Holdings Corp. v. IBT Media Inc.Hayes v. Anderson & Sheppard LtdBrooks v. 662 Pac. St.Luong v. Ha the Luong, Luong's Mgmt. LLC.Johnson v. N.Y. Univ.Tenemaza v. PS 488 Grp.Hum v. TermurtoshovPeople v. ArocaPoretsky v. Bartleby & Sage, Inc.Kamel v. Pizzarotti, LLCLeeboo v. CohanEB v. VBRodriguez v. ManiPeople v. McIverCadigan v. Liberty Helicopters, Inc.JF v. Archdiocese of N.Y.Am. Transit Ins. Co. v. N. Shore Family Chiropractic PC260-261 Madison Ave. v. WeWork261 Madison LLCGonzalez v. AugelloDesiena v. Algoma Hardwoods, Inc.Fresh Funding Sols. v. Atlanta Audio & Automation Inc.Sanders v. ReddishStandlee Premium Prods. v. WGST, Inc.Winter v. Lab. Corp. of Am.Appel v. N.Y.C. Police Dep'tCastillo v. DominguezSchneebaum v. The City of New YorkMcClean v. The Bd. of Trs. of fire Dep't. of City of N.Y. Pension FundDangoor v. ChowaikiFargo v. ReismanAppel v. N.Y.C. Police Dep'tWells Fargo Bank, N.A. v. ChrysostomPeople v. SmithPierre v. Fire Dep't of the City of N.Y.NCR LLC v. CoriatCooper v. Bldg 7th St.Poynder v. IP Mortg. BorrowerInt'l Bus. Machs. Corp. v. GlobalFoundries U.S. Inc.Estwick v. SurahioSutton Apartments Corp. v. SeneSing for Serv. v. United Serv. Contract Grp.Walker v. Triborough Bridge & Tunnel Auth.Militana v. MilitanaOverton v. Egami Grp.Stanziale v. Danielle Unif. Maint.State of N.Y. Workers' Comp. Bd. v. 21st Century Constr. Corp.Antara Capital Master Fund LP v. Bombardier Inc.People v. BerriosDeutsche Bank v. WaltonAndes Petroleum Ecuador Ltd. v. Occidental Petroleum Corp.Pepen v. LascanoFFS Data Corp. v. The OLB Grp.Alvarez v. W. 205 Realty Co.Seaport Mgmt. Dev. Co. v. Shop Architects, P.C.NW Media Holdings Corp. v. IBT Media Inc.Sara Gilat, Rosh, Inc. v. SuttonBank v. SofiaState v. 21ST Century Constr. Corp.P.W. Developers, LLC v. R.C.Bankers Conseco Life Ins. Co. v. KPMG LLPIn re IlichJCF Assocs. v. Take Two Outdoor Media LLCE.L. v. M.S.McCaule v. Bd. of Educ.B.R. v. E. at W. for Rehab. & NursingAtalaya Asset Income Fund II LLP v. RingelSimmons v. The N.Y. & Presbyterian Hosp.Calvo v. 94th Ave. Jam.State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. v. Selective Ins. Co. of Am.Rhodes Assocs. Exec. Search of N.Y. v. IS Co.Borelli v. Town of ClarkstownSchmidt v. The Bd. of Dirs. of Duane OwnersMatte Projects, LLC v. ZalkinFabo v. Kushner Cos.Tsegai v. N.Y. State Div. of Hous. & Cmty. RenewalLinyard v. Long Island Coll. Hosp.Thrall v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co.Hunter v. Barnes & Noble, Inc.Dragons 516 Ltd. v. Knights Genesis Inv. Ltd.Outerlimits Techs. v. Elec. Sys. Prot.OceanhouseNYC, LLC v. 140 W. St. (N.Y.), LLCO'shea Partners LLP v. GladstonePrimo v. VarugheseMelody Bus. Fin. v. FalconeYes Lender, LLC v. High Prot. IntelligenceMontgomery v. 215 Chrystie LLCAm. Transit Ins. Co. v. N. Shore Family Chiropractic PCJain v. PruTech Solutions Inc.Ehresman v. Dragonetti Bros. LandscapingFrances v. KleinFerrari Fin. Servs. v. PaternoR.C. v. The City of New YorkFor the Dissolution of Hudson Valley NY in Support of Motion Holdings LLC v. Zablocki (In re Vashovsky)Wells Fargo Bank v. Daytowne GoodingAm. Transit Ins. Co. v. State Farm Gen. Ins. Co.Grissom v. The City of New YorkLandwehrle v. BianchiClute v. Town of LisleWynn v. TengStountenborough v. Vanderbuilt Glass Sys.Arizaga v. Lex Gardens II TP4 Hous. Dev. Fund Co.Perez v. The City of New YorkPinero v. SantiagoState Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. v. BeeharryDerosa v. NYU Langone Hosps.Atalaya Asset Income Fund II LLP v. RingelMrkulic v. PetersMetreveli v. Oceanview Manor Acquisition I, LLCJain v. PruTech Sols.Bankers Conseco Life Ins. Co. v. KPMG LLPJamie Zheng v. Ctrs. Urgent Care Mgmt.Doe v. Diocese of BrooklynPeople v. Theresa G.Harleysville Ins. Co. v. United Fire Prot.Jones v. RoweCampbell v. The City of New YorkCampbell v. The City of New York722-724 10th Ave. v. N.Y. State Div. of Hous. & Cmty. RenewalPycior v. New Line Structures, Inc.D. P. v. Riverside Church in the N.Y.Feliz v. Jims Realty Eec.Jones v. BSREP UA Parker LLCWynn v. Wynn-WrightL. A. v. City of New YorkZDG, LLC v. 174-176 1st Ave. OwnerKoblence v. Modern Pawn Brokers, Inc.Moss v. MumfordEshaghpour v. Zepsa Indus., Inc.Kaba v. Zara U.S., Inc.Shrestha v. MilkoPeople v. RosePope v. The City of New York
