Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York October 2007 casesState v. MartinezManhattan Total v. Oxford HealthIn re MeyersonState v. GreenIn re RichichiReg-Tru Equities v. ValleyMarro v. StateKendall v. KendallState v. MarciaRochelle v. RochelleBarakov v. Israel MedicalState v. CaroselliChkhartishvili v. VolovoySoto-Lopez v. Board of ManagersIn re CurtisState v. WilkinsonState v. JacksonState v. PinheiroEwers v. GormanState v. CameraIn re JewleLu v. SpinelliNew York v. Countrywide Ins. Co.Williams v. McDonoughClover v. N.Y. CityState v. KelemenSchorr v. Guardian Life Ins. Co.Cespuglio v. SA Bros. Taxi Corp.Tamarkin v. New York CityQuattrocchi v. F.J. SciameLanger v. DadabhoyRosenberg v. ElliottState Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance v. JumaStarr RogersRichmond v. PerezElizabeth v. DoundleyAvenue I Corp. v. 515 AvenueMustello v. BergKilmartin v. KilmartinHull v. SpagnoliDaniels v. Millar ElevatorWanda v. EliteDiBlanda v. ADC Pinebrook, LLCState v. BellState v. CovingtonNeal v. WhiteWashington v. DelossantosTolpygina v. TeperGriesbeck v. County of SuffolkTerrence v. YokesAlpert v. OmincomIn re the Claim of YottFriedman v. AlbertMunoz v. MunozUniversity Studio v. Nyctl 1997-1State v. WalkerState v. BurtonState v. DeansIn re SanfordSean v. KilkennyState v. VasquezMcCrae v. City of N.YState v. SmithThomas v. N.Y. StateAbreu v. Birch ServState v. TuckerAnderson v. New YorkGibson v. TordoyaZoref v. GlassmanState v. McGregor245 Realty Assoc. v. 73rd OwnersKlepp v. KleppState v. HollandAdvanced Global v. Sirius SatelliteKeybank, USA, NA v. Government Employees InsuranceState v. DancyState v. ScottState v. BritoIn re RyansAce Fire Underwriters Insurance v. ITT Industries, Inc.State v. CortesState v. StrawderIn re SidneySastow v. Plainview-Old BethpageState v. BellingerState v. BurgosIn re LeonardState v. BrownState v. GillespieBROWMLEY v. DOARMonica v. CalvinState v. TruesdaleState v. EckhoffMartinez v. MartinezOrlic v. GatlingDenicola v. CostelloPerez v. Travco Ins. Co.State v. WilliamsNeuhaus v. Staten IslandRalin v. City of N.YD'Esposito v. GusraeEiseman Levine v. Torino JewelersAbalola v. Flower HospitalRoberson v. Moveway TransLawrence v. PrattState v. EspinosaJRP Old Riverhead Ltd. v. Town of SouthamptonState v. FluddIntriago v. City of New YorkState v. WrayHersh v. City of New YorkState v. Warden of RikersState v. HaithFerris v. QuinonesState v. MorganBreidbart v. MelvinDiruzzo v. Dept. of EducationMingo v. ErcoleMareno v. ShorensteinKane v. AusubelState v. WilliamsMason v. Main Plaza RealtyTower Ins. v. T G ConstSpierer v. Bloomingdale'sGjelaj v. State Farm MutualGawez v. Inter-Connection ElecTheatre Row Phase II Associates v. H & I, Inc.Blank Rome LLP v. ParrishAsh v. Bd. of ManagersMarrale v. MarraleIn re Arverne Second AmendedCamoia v. Custom ComputerOsorio v. City of New YorkEstate of Waterman v. JonesMarshall v. Tower Ins. Co.Smith v. SmithMelendez-Natal v. Maren Eng. Corp.State v. LambertLounsbury v. RobertRON v. TONYAPeople v. MoraIn re SaharaState v. GiggeyLau v. SuarezState v. GradyState v. George SnowdenState v. CortesIn re BritneyJames v. SandraParnes v. Mitzy TransState v. SaccoIn re Jose A.Brooks v. Maintenance ServFox v. FoxMartinez v. Ashley Apts. Co.State v. HayesHealth v. Deerbrook Ins. Co.Porkave v. Ramapo RadiologyHarold Galper v. Jeffrey BurkesEvangelista v. MattoneOwen v. Lindsay HamiltonJaffe v. JaffeRyba v. AlmeidaTelfer v. TelferJames v. SluzarMalkhan v. City of New YorkCameron v. EngelhartInter Metal Fabricator, Inc. v. HRH Construction LLCState v. JacksonTimeless Realty v. Con. DiversifiedState v. FordIn re SheegerState v. SeeleyGoldman v. ChapmanAllocca v. KellyBaker v. City of New YorkRao-Boyle v. AlpersteinLorenz Diversified v. FalkMunoz v. Pavel KoyfmanAcademy St. v. SpitzerFox v. FoxMcCarae v. City of New YorkBrooks v. Maintenance ServJuric v. BergstraesserEckerd Corp. v. SemonIn re LafvorneSimpson v. New YorkAbony v. TLC Laser Eye Center, Inc.Moran v. GrilloAra Plumbing & Heating Corp. v. Abcon Associates, Inc.Madison Hudson v. NeumannIn re AndrewRosenberg v. RosenbergJoint Diseases v. N.Y. Cent. Mut. FireMaor v. Town of Ramapo Planning BoardState v. GonzalezState v. ArroyoIn re OswaldState v. BrucelState v. GuerreroStruble v. StrubleState v. GrahamIn re VivianSawchuk v. 335 Realty 58 AssocIn re NigelState v. O'NealState v. PurdieState v. WalshCzaban v. CzabanMingo v. GoordAqeel v. CasaleMisek-Falkoff v. Metro. TransitMiller v. GedolaPeople v. BeyGovori v. Agate Corp.Reyz v. KhelemskyRuiz v. N.Y. CityState v. SmithState v. LawlessDairo v. Rockaway Boulevard Properties, LLCLugauer v. Forest City RatnerAames Funding Corp. v. HoustonIn re SeviroliFelton v. KellyWhite v. Chrysler Corp.State v. TownsendState v. PerezState v. NicholasState v. HernandezArmstrong v. PhillipsIn re OscarMoney Garden Corp. v. CMC Markets (US) LLCState v. BrownZeldin v. Interboro Mut. Ins. Co.Corp. v. Steven RosenfeldFollender v. MaximBrooks v. Maintenance ServTishman v. MurrayCheng v. Prime DesignSavino v. ABC Corp.Henning v. RitzCertain Underwriters at Lloyds, London v. Millennium Holdings, LLCVentures v. JenkensBucknor v. N.Y. City HealthJoseph v. Pitkin CarpetState v. BrownIn re AnjanneState v. GrullonRivera v. FiretogState v. PeoplesState v. PerezState v. HendersonState v. SawyerState v. LawrenceState v. Warden of RikersNicole v. KaiserState v. SpinnerState v. CatalaState v. BoldenState v. PerezState v. GortspujulsChong Min Mun v. Soung Eun HongErrico v. WeinsteinState v. JamelState v. EduardoDeleon v. 650 WestMcGarty v. City of New YorkWald v. WaldAdams v. Lemberg EnterprisesImamkhodjaev v. KartvelshviliDeltoro v. AryaVitale v. LevineState v. PalinState v. MarshallIn Matter of Oswald [3d Dept 10-4-2007State v. AliceaIn re Commissioner of LaborIn re VictorState v. LiceaState v. HaiglerState v. MilesState v. MonteroState v. LassiterBroome County v. CoreyLewis v. ConnollyState v. RiosState v. LebronState v. RockState v. DavidState v. CarterSinensky v. WeinerMorales v. Beacon CityJohnson v. Marriott ManagSciacca v. HoblockKuri v. BhattacharyaState v. AlvarezIn Denzel FKnoll v. Chemung CountyEdwards v. N.Y. State PoliceRibaudo v. Delaney ConstPorcelli v. Key Food StoresIn re LeeState v. HernandezJefferson v. NetusilPeri v. City of New YorkState v. HowellIn re CunninghamVelasquez v. GomezState v. LewisIn re LeeNationwide Inc. v. HarrisState v. AlvarezState v. DasqueTenants Assoc. v. CalogeroPlass v. WattersAbramowitz v. City of New YorkKim v. Broome CountyState v. GibbsIn re TaniseaIn re East HamptonYoung v. RichardsStecher v. M T BankState v. Sweet-RoySbriglio v. NovelloHongach v. HongachErcegovic v. P ManagementMechanical v. Royal SunalliancePeople v. VelasquezState v. WilliamsTownhouse Co. v. PetersBarnard v. LawrencePeople v. Jean-BaptisteBrewster v. FTM Servo, Corp.People v. VereIn re NearyShands v. EscalonaRodriguez v. KillerlaneCheng v. Prime DesignTarhan v. KabashiDaddio v. ShapiroRendely v. Town of HuntingtonKatz Park Ave. v. JaggerLangston v. Triboro ContractingRhodes-Evans v. 111 ChelseaLitvinskiy v. May Entert. GroupBroadway Realty v. LevitesPeople v. De La CruzMcKinley v. GoordState v. WalkerFreimor v. City of New YorkState v. WantonState v. ZayasState v. FuentesState v. Warden of RikersState v. DemarcoState v. ReillyFriedler v. Nasti and Co.Moore v. N.Y. MedicalIn re Attorneys in ViolationIn re AdoniseNorth Fork Bank v. KrassnerFladell v. American Red MagenState v. LacewellState v. GrahamState v. TerryIn re PhillipGonzalez v. GoordAlkaifi v. Celestial ChurchState v. BriggsState v. WrightIn re Attorneys in ViolationPenner v. HoffbergRush v. County of NassauRobinson v. RobinsonSchoenlank v. Yonkers YMCATransitional Serv. v. N.Y. StateDavey v. DaveyCarrano v. CastroDjelina Lekutanovic v. City of New YorkFugazy v. FugazyCornely v. DynamicPreferred Mutual Insurance v. Sav Carpentry, Inc.Pendleton v. City of N.YIn re CarolynCarnahan v. WardState v. SudbrinkSedita v. N.Y. City TransitGoldston v. T.J. Maxx, Inc.State v. HussainState v. SuphalIn re JasmineIn re MoniqueState v. WestIn re EmanuelState v. BollackIn re Carol-AnnState v. BrinkhuisAlatorre v. ChunPriel v. LinarelloCounty of Nassau v. VelasquezCounty of Orange v. Kiryas JoelIn re NavijaState v. HowellPeople v. ArguetaIn re DerekRubino v. City of New YorkGranite Broadway Development LLC v. 1711 LLCState v. WilliamsIn re JoseRankoth v. SloanIn re AngelIn re BaileeRichthofen v. FoundationState v. LunaIn re Deajah Shabri T.State v. BiggioState v. HernandezInternational v. North RiverMonkhouse v. Maven Limo, Inc.Hynes v. HoldmanIn re TerrancePeach Parking v. 346 West 40th St.Smith v. CherubiniState v. VelasquezIn re TiffanyKim v. City of New YorkDeem v. New York State & Local Retirement SystemCoburn v. SamuelFin. Pacific v. D D WireSanon v. MoskowitzProgressive Ins. v. TorahMontes v. CityState v. HernandezState v. FrancisIn re DavaunState v. DillonBarbara v. JohnKaur v. SinghState v. VillanuevaSpinale v. Tag's Pride Produce Corp.Cialino v. O'NeillLong Island Railroad v. MadisonPreferred Mut. v. PineMetropolitan Property v. Croton-On-HudsonState v. JordanAnaya v. Town Sports InterState v. HamptonState v. GaryState v. BurgessFabish v. Garden BayIn re AmandaMatias v. Rebecca'sMercado v. Iannelli ConstIn re PatriciaPerry v. City of N.YState v. FordState v. MartinezBhatt v. N.Y. StateState v. AdamsMichael v. CalliopeRoss v. BravermanEsteves v. City of New YorkRovenia v. SpitzBarila v. Comprehensive PainState v. BrowningViera v. Riverbay Corp.State v. FordVanessa v. CatanzanoKarwowski v. N.Y. CitySusan v. GaryTechnologly Multi v. Stack GlobalEdcia Corp. v. McCormackHochhauser v. Electric Ins. Co.Eckerd Corp. v. GilchristState v. MendezMitchell v. New York CityPearson v. WalkerWall Street v. Lancer Ins. Co.Czaban v. CzabanHerbstein v. HerbsteinState v. KingState v. SndhumState v. BowmanState v. DombroffGamiel v. CurtisCostantini v. CostantiniAbraham v. CastillantIn re DywonIn re Casey NPutnam County Department of Social Services v. Eda G.State v. MartinIgneri v. KellyIn re HedigerTompkins-Seneca-Tioga v. Candor CentralState v. RecchiaAvrashkova v. PaulState v. CruzAnesthesia v. North. WestchesterNew York v. Bd. of AssessorsIn re ChristianBreidbart v. MelvinBarchella v. BarchellaKelly v. HickmanCervone v. CervonePosokhov v. OselkinPeople v. MoralesState v. MontalvoNew Stadium v. Greenpoint-GoldmanWoods v. JohnsonFrank v. DonnaDavidson v. Metropolitan TransitIn re GentileMcDonald v. StrohDavid Ogando v. Equities Corp.State v. RushState v. ToribioState v. DozierDoundley v. ElizabethState v. MarteMargaret v. AlbaneseAtlantic Mutual v. RichardDilorenzo v. Estate MotorsState v. GlahnFord Motor Credit v. LouieState v. VegaState v. RamosEisenberger v. SeptimusCharles v. MitziKelly v. North-Port Yacht ClubRoddy v. NederlanderWonder Works Const. Corp. v. RcdolnerYoungquist v. YoungquistBinder v. O'SheaManko v. Lenox Hill HospSienna Capital v. RosenNyctl 199-1 Trust v. 114 TenthVarney v. McKeeState v. CharlottenRockwood v. Vicarious VisionsGroves v. N.Y. City TransitCoastal Commun. v. N.Y. CityJohnnie v. SchillKally v. Mount Sinai HospScott v. N.Y. StateErica Ruiz v. Hart Elm Corp.Millennium Const. v. LoupoloverN.Y. City v. Merchants MutualMcDonald v. StrohLopez v. GonzalezState v. MarajCarter v. Suburban Heating OilIn re AndreaniIn re TarasekIn re LefrakState v. Generali InsurJackson v. TorresIn re LopezIn re RaskindWilson v. Sirius America Ins. Co.State v. BilusState v. EddieElefantis v. P.O.P. DisplaysEisner v. EisnerSelinger v. SelingerState v. LopezState v. JenkinsState v. BrownGonzalez v. Curt Realty LLPPulgram v. ReisnerOlko v. Citibank, N.A.Stewart v. Schulte RothState v. TaylorIn re Rachel212 Investment v. KaplanJoseph v. GMAC Leasing Corp.Cathedral Prop. v. BlinbaumMarino v. CunninghamWatanabe v. SherpaState v. ElianoLPP Mortgage Ltd. v. GoldPadovani v. MillerLouis v. MTA Long Island Bus Co.Hunt v. Odd Job TradingAbayev v. Jaypson JewelryDean v. CampagnaSergei v. SofiaHawthorne v. City of New YorkMoises v. StateAlexa v. ScruggsBoskin v. N.Y. CityDepasquale v. DepasqualeState v. StevensState v. MontefuscoSOUNDVIEW OWNERS, LLC v. VILLANOVABridgewater v. JohnsonCandreva v. Ultra Kote Applied Technology, Ltd.Ferguson v. I.H.B. RealtyMaster v. PohankaIn re GlennMentesana v. JanowitzState v. CabreraState v. SantanaDickinson v. WoodleyIn re PamelaState v. McGuireYagi v. CorbinIn re RobertDanish v. Tax and LimousineState v. SpencerLavandier v. Landmark Ins. Co.Murray v. StabileDorcean v. LongueiraIn re HarrounVasquez v. HernandezHohenforst v. DemagistrisJessica v. EliseJodoin v. BillingsIn re JoeCheck Cashing Corp v. Fifth OwnerBlue Water v. Incorporated VilliagdIn re MauriceKefalas v. KontogiannisBrooks v. Maintenance Serv Resources, Inc.State v. DejesusTeamsters Local v. DolanAccess Medical v. Straus FamilyCerami v. CeramiO'Brien v. BarrettaGorman v. HuntingtonCooke v. AlaimoVerette v. Zia21 West 58th St. v. FosterImtanios v. SachsSomma v. DanskerRosmarin v. BelcastroState v. SeverinoIn re Attorneys in Violation of Judiciary v. Heveran [3d Dept 10-4-2007Norasteh v. StateState v. MunizKopec v. Dormitory AuthorityPark v. State of N.YProspect v. DoylePeople v. VannoyState v. AllenState v. RamirezBrimberg v. New YorkCzach v. O'NeillIn re BernsKramer v. Real EstateIn re DavonteState v. GardnerLouchheim v. Zoning BoardIn re CastroState v. WalkerIn re DwayneBlomberg v. GarisSiino v. Dept. of EducationState v. PerezState v. MaldonadoPeople v. FolkGurgenidze v. VitaleState v. WhaleyState v. MalaussenaSSL International, PLC v. ZookCone v. DanielIntl. Flavors v. Royal Ins. Co.Yellow Book of N.Y. v. WeissHarari v. GiundiPeople v. BussApple Bank for Savings v. Fort Tryon Apartments Corp.State v. CampbellLease v. Royal LinesFresh Del Monte v. Eastbrook CaribeOwen v. HamiltonOrtiz v. JaberSS Constantine & Helen's Romanian Orthodox Church of America v. Z. Zindel, Inc.Snitovsky v. Forest HillsState Farm Ins. v. ColangeloIn re SchwartzIn re PearlAlbany Manor, Inc. v. New York State Liquor AuthorityCity of New York v. Jamaica Arms Hotel, Inc.Segrell v. New YorkColwell v. ParksState v. BoyeaMargarita Morales v. Shelter ExpressState v. LipscombePeople v. VannoyDonohue v. DonohueRoberts v. Manzanet-DanielsState v. HarrisAbraham v. WoodPeterson v. SoloffCarrera v. RoachPeople v. LipscombeHinck v. HinckStokes v. Valeo Electrical SystemsBurgos v. AlamoAIU INS. v. ROBERT PLAN CORPSimon v. NortraxGrigoropoulos v. MoshopoulosRealty Corp. v. StateHall v. HallSimonetti v. LarsonFox v. FoxPerson v. EinhornBoyle v. BoyleJason v. NovelloNickell v. Gould Long IslandState v. CrowderState v. RuizRodriguez v. LeclaireCohen v. Columbia UniversityAbu-Aqlein v. El-JamalGriggs v. GriggsIn re HydeVelasquez v. GallelliBRONX RADIOLOGY v. NY CENTRALJames v. City of New YorkState v. OrtizState v. LinenState v. WatsonState v. JamisonPeople v. LaraIn re ClementeIn re BenjaminRamirez v. JIB II ExpressState v. RamirezKholasechi v. IsraelianGeisco v. GreaterAnn P. v. Nicholas C.P.Daley v. M/S Capital NY LLCState v. WhitfieldAlexandre v. DweckGouvis v. GouvisState v. JohnsonJCH Delta Contracting, Inc. v. City of New YorkBenfeld v. GalkinState v. AmusoState v. LanierNigro v. NigroHunter v. R.J.L. DeptIn re SchumerReal Estate v. Bd. of AssessorsHalycon Ins Co v. FoxSoto v. Nyrac Inc.Ross Realty v. V a Fabricators, Inc.Keating v. Bd. of EducationGebaide v. GebaideBank of America v. FriedmanAmeriquest Mortgage v. RobertState v. CharpentierPeople v. HurdAbraham v. WoodState v. VidalTait v. TaitState v. MonkoBaruch v. 587 Fifth AvenueState v. GerardState v. DominSanchez v. North Shore UnivState v. GriffinHaines v. HainesIn re DillionState v. WilliamsShawn v. HernandezIn re AntoineState New York v. SableIn re SilvaState v. BurksPearson v. Parkside Limited Liability Co.State v. FerranteState v. WashingtonState v. GonzalezBryant v. KellyState v. BerlerHouston v. WalshGerteis v. GerteisSumba v. SampaioDeleon v. RossAuljta v. ChangState v. FranciscoNegro v. St. Charles HospitalAmbroise v. City of N.YState v. WilliamsGriffin v. DaVinci Development, LLCTreider v. LamoraElmo Manufacturing Corp. v. American Innovations, Inc.Spears v. Town of Cortlandt PlanningPeople v. AlasState v. WrightEck v. EckSoundview Own. v. VillanovaBronx Radiology v. N.Y. CentState v. CastaldiConfetti v. N.Y. StateNyctl 2004-A Trust v. Fulton St.State v. MaskowAgurto v. DelaCannon v. CityState New York v. RiversGonzalez v. RamosState v. AshleyBrennan v. CenterFrangione v. DanielsOrtega v. Paul TrefzWBP Central Associates, LLC v. Deco Construction Corp.In re GladstoneForman v. McFaddenFleury v. BenitezAirtran v. MidwestHosten v. OladapoIn re Keira O