Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York December 1960 casesPeople v. HowellZeglen v. AdamsonMatter of BaruchPeople v. TarverKaplan v. KaplanSubin v. U.S. Fidelity Guar. Co.Damiano v. DamianoPeople v. Rosenfeld, Buckles, KellyMatter of Kestenbaum v. Dunrite Painting Co.People ex Rel. Norwood v. CoffeyDurant v. Grange Silo CompanyMatter of VickPeople v. SweetMatter of Bluhdorn v. Greenwald IndustriesPeople v. GirardiWedtke Realty Corp. v. KaranasMatter of Puccio v. General Cable CorporationMatter of NathonsMatter of Noviscky v. HultsJones v. HuntGerchick v. MooreHarwood v. DoyleMatter of Grennell v. Driveway Paving Co.Edwards v. HunttingPeople v. SmithRicher v. GershPeople v. EspinosaMatter of Hallas v. AtlasWarner v. KenanSollish v. Hebrew Home Hosp for the ChronicPeople v. BowlerWeinstein v. Frizzie CorporationSiegel v. BayersGrimaldi v. Coca-Cola Bottling Co. of New YorkPeople ex Rel. Humphreys v. JohnstonMastrella v. MilesSzendy v. Bd. of Educ., Un. Free Sch. DistPeople ex Rel. Washington v. JohnstonClaim of La Barge v. Mercy General HospitalNorton v. MarshPeople v. CunninghamRadist v. ZidelPeople v. MooreLevitin v. State of New YorkPeople v. GriecoPeople v. RizziMatter of ScanlonJalco Products Inc. v. Tobra Knitting MillsMoss v. CarstairsPeritore v. Niagara Mohawk Power CorporationMunicipal Serv. Co v. Town of ColonieSpring v. Gedney Development Corp.People ex Rel. Tolbert v. MurphyPeople v. BarbosaCHEW v. DUFFYPeople v. BrownHotcaveg v. LightmanPeople ex Rel. Stevenson v. MurphyMatter of Northville Dock Corp. v. KennedyPeople v. WeiresPeople v. ScopasMatter of Kovary v. American Woolen CompanyMatter of Bd. of EducMatter of GilmartinRedmond v. SikoraMatter of DitchikShamrock Gas Oil Inc. v. Sterling StationsSchumm v. StateNicosia v. DraperPeople v. GosslingPeople v. HinesHartford v. HartfordRuggio v. BoigeolPeople v. ErcegMatter of Vreeland v. Auburn Board of EducPetzold v. Avis Rent-A-Car System, Inc.People v. BehahlterRubin v. MannPeople v. WilliamsKannaley v. WeissFaller v. DessarroPeople v. WegSedrish v. CoopersteinPeople v. JonesKenney v. KenneyKerr v. KerrBlack v. HuttmannBuchanan v. BuchananSmith v. VaughnBrechner v. Inc. Village of Lake SuccessMatter of Joe Fried, Inc.People v. PughStagg Tool Die Corp. v. WeismanMercer v. StatePeople v. RossN.Y. Water Serv. v. Palisades Interstate ParkLinden v. National City Bank of N.YPiliero v. Allstate Ins. Co.Allen v. HylandPeople ex Rel. Darling v. WilkinsPeople v. SmithPeople ex Rel. Passante v. JohnstonPeople v. BarberMatter of Brown v. New York City Hous. AuthRodriguez v. StatePeople v. MendezMatter of SomersMatter of City of New YorkPolite v. BurresGreen v. Long Island School of AeronauticsPeople v. NewmanBeausoleil v. ZaccaroPeople v. CallowayPeople ex Rel. Baum v. MurphyHarmen v. HarmenGerchick v. MooreBeisner v. KellyRadden v. City of New YorkScarpulla v. MogaveroPeople v. GastmanSlater v. MargolinPeople v. HoustonSchindo v. AntinozziPurdy v. Fifth Madison CorporationPeople v. CraskaLombard v. HastingsManard v. Hardware Mut. Cas. Co.People v. WestonKathleen Foley, Inc. v. Gulf Oil CorporationPeople v. DarlingHomchak v. FayBurchianti v. City of Long BeachMatter of Lippman v. Biennier Transp. Co.Schiff v. John Arborio, Inc.R.F. Erhardt Sons v. BuckoStern Juvenile Furniture Co., Inc. v. RochmanGoodyear Aluminum Products, Inc. v. StatePeople v. CostelloPeople v. StaigerPeople v. HallPeople v. WilsonMiller v. PennaEagle v. JanoffStar Constr. v. St. Paul Fire and Marine Ins. Co.Hume v. HumeMatias v. New York City Housing AuthorityBernstein v. BernsteinIn re the Arbitration between De Turris & Great American InsurancePeople v. BrigantiPeople v. JohnsonMatter of N.Y. Wat. Serv. v. Pub. Serv. CommPoliti v. Irvmar Realty Corp.People v. MarcusCrombie v. MillerPeople ex rel. De Falco v. La ValleeMatter of Bresnick v. Tax Comm., City of N.YMoss v. CarstairsPeople v. SumpterMatter of Lewis v. AllenPeople v. MeyerMason v. Allstate Ins. Co.Matter of Lawrence v. U.S. Seaboard TerminalBrowne v. AdamsMurphy v. KleinMatter of Pacemaker Constr. v. Heidi ConstrMatter of Travelers Indemnity CompanyHorowitz v. Alley Pond Park Apartments No. 1Matter of Roncey, FrenkelPeople v. HawaMatter of FarhartLenick v. LenickPioneer Building-Loan & Savings Ass'n v. FranzoniWeigel v. Church of St. Stephen of HungarySpringborn v. GottlerGibson v. McManus, Longe, Brockwehl, Inc.People v. DenzelSussman v. SussmanMatter of Wessels v. Fulton County Hwy. DeptMatter of Marks v. SchechterPeople v. TarpleyPeople v. CarrawayGurney, Becker Bourne v. Blasdell SteelDun & Bradstreet, Inc. v. Niagara Plastic Molds, Inc.Matter of Frederic WohlfeldMatter of Duchin v. PetersonMace v. StateNoah v. BergerSnyder v. General Mills, Inc.People ex Rel. Adams v. McNeillSabatino v. SabatinoKelly v. WassermanMcConnell v. Niagara Mohawk Power Corp.People v. CantieMatter of HirschPeople v. GriffinPerlman Wortmann, Inc. v. Yonkers ContrMatter of Morrow v. MorrisMatter of Whalen v. Allied Mess. ServPacelli v. CastanoCerasoli v. A. De Bevoise Co.People v. SmithCarlton Credit Corp. v. Atlantic Refining Co.Peritore v. Niagara Mohawk Power Corp.Matter of Zecca v. J. Levinsohn Co., Inc.People v. RamirezChaney v. N.Y.C. Transit AuthPeople ex Rel. Levine v. NobleNational Biscuit Company v. StateMazzella v. American Home Constr. Co., Inc.Abidin v. Psaty Fuhrman, Inc.Bell Television, Inc. v. Cal-New Yorker, Inc.People v. GuhrPeople ex Rel. Lyons v. WilkinsPeople v. BlasettiMcCabe v. Town of Oyster BayFiddlers Green v. Constr. Corp. of Long IslandMatter of Morris LevineColonial Sand & Stone Co. v. Local Union No. 282, International Brotherhood of Teamsters, Chauffeurs, Warehousemen & Helpers of AmericaFerrandino v. CartelliMATTER OF LA BELLE CREOLE v. ATTORNEY-GENERALMatter of Hofstra College v. WilmerdingPearson v. PearsonPeople v. LagodaPeople ex Rel. Wright v. MartinUsticano v. TraceyMatter of Stanton v. GerosaLagoe v. City of OswegoFAAS v. GENERAL ACC FIRE LIFE INS. CO. LTDMatter of Streger v. WeaverFoxluger v. StateSchwam v. SchwamFerrainolo v. Prudential InsuranceMatter of Kahan v. WeaverKaufman v. BakerPeerless Casualty Company v. BordiMatter of McCarty v. Dahlstrom Metallic DoorFreidberg v. FreidbergMatter of Union News CompanyFirst Federal Savings & Loan Ass'n v. United StatesEchevarria v. EchevarriaLa Torre v. Kentucky Leasing Corp.Sowells v. O'NeillFirst Federal Savings & Loan Ass'n v. United StatesAlbert Pearlman v. Bd. of Educ., City of N.YGutmann v. Hillside Farms Co., Inc.People v. ScottPeople ex Rel. Vasquez v. MurphyMatter of Destruction of Certain Papers FiledMatter of S. Klein on the Square v. S.CWiseman v. City of New YorkMatter of MeierJudson v. City of RochesterHernandez v. Mt. Sinai HospitalAdams v. Farrell Lines, Inc.Hawkins v. Dec-Art Co., Inc.W.S. Hayes, Inc. v. Pub. Serv. Mut. Ins. Co.Fellenbaum v. MillerMatter of County of NassauPeople v. KazmerskiMatter of LivingstonMatter of DavidsonMatter of Egitto v. McGinnisPlantier v. GouldMatter of FortePeople v. RobinsonPeople v. DaltoPeople v. WatsonPeople v. LubrienPeople v. WissenfeldMatter of EdelbaumGangloff v. BrownReynolds v. KohlmanMatter of HortonPeople v. ZacharczenkoPeople v. BryantPeople v. CorwinPeople v. TurnerMatter of Gilson v. Bickford's, Inc.Matter of Jacobs v. Ostow Jacobs, Inc.Kelvin Engineering Co. v. American Surety Co.Matter of Dawson v. N. Hudson Woodcraft Corp.Bauman v. FisherEvyan Perfumes, Inc. v. HamiltonMatter of Widrig v. J.M. Newhouse DistributorsPeople v. JonesBruno v. KosnacBurnash v. DunnMatter of Brooklyn Bar Association v. GreenLombard v. HastingsMatter of MoodyPeople v. BellachPeople v. NixonMatter of Brown v. WilsonUdell v. City Title Ins. Co.Rinaudo v. PalmeriMatter of RosinPeople v. MercadoPasciuti v. Town of Pound RidgePeople v. DevorePeople v. SaltersPeerless Insurance Co. v. Nationwide Ins. Co.Matter of Beiter v. HultsIndustrial Bank of Utica v. WolcottMatter of Amigone v. N.Y. State Liquor AuthSeide v. StateBrands v. City of New YorkBarnard v. PostleMatter of Chemical Corn Exchange BankGrace v. Real Property Owners, Inc.Baron v. Bobroy, Inc.Faas v. General Accident Fire & Life InsurancePeople v. LuchieZdanwic v. WinterKlein v. Capri Equities, Inc.Matter of Mojica v. Marlene Modes, Inc.Friedman v. Eastwood Stock Farms, Inc.Asiatic Petroleum Corp. v. Overseas InvestorsSpigner v. KupersmitMatter of Devine v. HultsGriffel v. BelferMatter of Buehler v. RoseMatter of FlastersteinPaliotto v. Brunswick-Balke-Collender CompanyHughes v. HughesLeckey v. McQuadePeople ex Rel. Valentino v. ConboyPeople v. DuncanTittler v. La BurtGREENWALD INDUS v. BK. OF AM. NATL. TR. SAVMatter of Kearney v. ShattuckPeople v. KouschPeople v. McGuinessNeely v. StateBRISKMAN v. OLDSKaufman v. GordonErie Cty. Bd. of Soc. Welfare v. WallaceCammarota v. CammarotaSelig v. StatePeople v. MitchellPeople v. CruzIn re the Probate of the Will of DixPeople ex Rel. Paul v. WilkinsGottler v. StaerkerLitwack v. RappaHunn v. NaplesGzanowicz v. City of Little FallsMay v. Simack Corp.Kavazanjian v. Brookhattan Trucking Co.Dickerson v. JohnsonMatter of Keegan v. MarkewichRodenbeck v. BekasinskiKletter v. KletterDowns v. StatePeople v. Nelson, BridgesMatter of Connolly v. Waldorf Astoria Corp.Hat Corp. of Am. v. Byer-Rolnick Hat Corp.Canter v. American Cyanamid CompanyMATTER OF ELIO v. GORDON BAKING COMPANYCosentino v. City of New YorkAndrews v. StatePeople v. AdamsonMatter of Ellis v. StateMatter of Johnson v. ZimmerPeople v. GoingsPeople ex Rel. Quinones v. O'NeillPeople v. BartolilloIsle of Wight Owner's v. Mo. Valley DredgingMatter of Associated Metals Minerals Corp.Ramsey v. DeckerBell Television, Inc. v. Cal-New Yorker, Inc.Cinelli v. SagerSeldowitz v. Manufacturers Trust CompanyDi Maria v. LittlePeople v. AngoraPeople v. WhiteCherhit v. General Lumber CorporationMatter of NudelmanPeople v. GavinRodriguez v. KologlouPeople v. HeineBrockbank v. Travelers Insurance CompanyMillwork Center, Inc. v. Lasker-Goldman Corp.Matter of Livermore v. Planet Corp.Matter of Sperling v. KissellPeople v. HillMatter of Simpson, Mr. John, Inc.Moon v. MoonPeople v. BrennanMatter of DmytreshinPeople v. WeeksPeople v. AlvarezMatter of Maslen v. Carrier CorporationBenneward v. Colonial Sand and Stone Co., Inc.Hill v. Hudson View Gardens, Inc.Century Lumber Corp. v. 513 E. 75th St. Corp.Matter of Harty v. MosesBW Dyer Co. v. Monitz, Wallack ColodneyKnauer v. City of RochesterPeople v. TerrellPurdy v. PurdySalkind v. SalkindPeople v. DavisPeople v. JacksonMcLaughlin v. 254 Holding CorporationPeople v. HairstonMatter of Young v. LeddenMatter of StaklinskiMatter of Walton v. Fred Fehlhaber Corp.PEOPLE v. LEISHandelman v. OlenMerchants Mutual Casualty Company v. WildmanPeople v. McKeithanSchoepfel v. SchoepfelCoons v. Massachusetts Bonding and Ins. Co.People v. GreenBrownell v. LadniukRattray v. HunttingMcAllister v. New York City Housing AuthorityMatter of DvorkinBlair v. Cent. Greyhound Lines, Inc. of N.YAlbert v. Isbrandtsen Company, Inc.Matter of PappasLa Pidus v. La PidusNeumann v. Poirier McLane Corp.Cimilluca v. GarraffaMatter of Berrios v. Park Sulgrave, Inc.Dinallo v. WeinerZANE v. GIACOVELLIPeople v. BranchPeople v. FlitmanPeople v. MoreliMatter of Mysiak v. Supreme Court, St. of N.YRose Manor Corp. v. Town of IslipPeople v. BrigantiMatter of GlasserMatter of PugachBreslow v. FingerGolditch v. FrancisPeople v. LondonMandel v. RekersMatter of Karol v. LiszkaPeople v. DoylePeople v. BrownGlazer v. GlazerMatter of Geoghan v. Francis Leggett PremierI. Burack, Inc. v. Metro. Plumbing Sup. Corp.Matter of Silver v. AssaelAlnwick v. Charles Kreisler Auto Rental Co.People v. RinaldoEngle v. Yankee Realty CorporationPeople v. StreckerMatter of Galuppi v. N.Y. State Liquor AuthClaim of Heck v. Hilton Hotels Corp.Madison 52nd Corporation v. Empire Trust Co.Miller v. Ford Motor Co.Grimm v. B. Gertz, Inc.Matter of ColwinHollins v. City of LackawannaPeople v. CadoganPeople v. Tangredi, DaughtonPeople v. BarbosaPeople ex Rel. Miller v. WilkinsMatter of MurrayPeople v. NickersonPEOPLE v. OREEImerson v. BenwayKeenan v. WaringClaim of Balsam v. Tip Top ShoePeople v. MarkowskiMorales v. RodellBregoff v. RubienBiskupick v. Van DykeMatter of Port of N.Y. AuthorityPeople v. AskewPeople v. LevinePeople v. FuentesBaran v. City of CohoesGIAN v. COUNTY OF WYOMINGPeople v. BennettPeople v. BarrPeople v. FleischmannKielb v. BoigeolKamen v. KamenWestern Foundation Corp. v. Five Boro Construction Corp.BEOL, INC. v. DORFStahl v. StahlSalzman Sign Co. v. BeckPeople v. Davis-ElMatter of Rosenblum v. KennedyStandard-Toch Industries v. Sun ChemicalFeeney v. AllenPeople v. SwearengenPeople v. FinkPeople v. BaumStone v. William Andacht, Inc.People v. EckertGuider v. GuiderSchlanger v. CowanMatter of Silver v. TurchinPeople v. Uran Mining Corp.Ferrandino v. CappelliPeople ex Rel. Mitchell v. MartinMatter of McGinty v. American Chimney Corp.Eveready Elec. Co., Inc. v. City of New YorkMatter of SzaboPeople v. HeadleyGalban v. Penn Shipping Co.Yellon v. KesslerSultan v. Lamport Co., Inc.Maddaus v. BowmanFreedman v. LloydFrancesco Realty Corp. v. WeinerBowley v. SchepensHandel v. HandelMatter of WainwrightPershan v. PershanMatter of VickMatter of SchneidermanTaller Cooper, Inc. v. Elec. Signal Co.People v. McGeeSpeedling v. PampinellaGover v. BoigeolThomas v. County of WyomingWest's Farm Agency, Inc. v. CoxsonCalucci v. OlninckPeople v. JonesMatter of Gem Credit v. Consol. Edison CompanyBernstein v. MorellPeople v. FlemmingMatter of Glen Operating v. Public Serv. CommMariani v. MaherPeople ex Rel. Staples v. WilkinsPeople v. WatermanCanton Savings and Loan Ass'n v. HarringtonPeople v. BarberPeople v. WilliamsPeople v. RodriguezPeople v. PetersonR.C. Gluck Co., Inc. v. TankelMatter of DankerlColonial Painting Co. v. Bobey CorporationDeak & Co. v. NunezPutvin v. Buffalo ElectricBenjamin v. BenjaminRobinson v. TreadwellPeople v. CiappettaEnsign v. KlekoskySharp v. City of HornellGoldner Trucking Corp. v. Stoll Packing Corp.Matter of BeachPardocchi v. National Casualty CompanyHut v. FraserCuzzacre v. Benco Togs, Inc.People v. WheelerLe Boyer v. MargolisMalavarco v. Village of Dobbs FerryPeople v. WeaverPeople v. TylerBaron's Cove Inn, Inc. v. MulvihillMatter of KraskaPeople v. RogersMatter of Johnston v. MannMorgan v. SpringerMatter of VynerKerper v. Royal Farms, Inc.People v. McGuireMatter of Rubino v. Empire Heating CorporationPeople v. HarrisMoore v. Hamilton Estates, Inc.People v. RossLippman v. New York Water Service CorporationBeaumont v. BeaumontSegrete v. Home Insurance Company of New YorkO'Leary v. Braile, Inc.People v. PooleChevere v. ChildsPringleton v. Bronx HospitalPeople ex Rel. Gencarelli v. MurphyPeople ex Rel. Berg v. WilkinsMatter of Kenler v. MurtaghMatter of Stallone v. BreweriesMatter of United States Trust Co. of New YorkKlein v. DieterPeople v. BryantTomkins v. WhitfieldPeople v. FenzaPeople v. GaynorPeople v. KnowlesRedino v. RedinoMatter of Inkpen v. Lehigh Constr. Co., Inc.People v. DasherAmerican Trust Company v. GlassmanLewis v. SabatoJamieson v. LamoreauxMatter of Roberts v. GalbreathRichards v. MorrowPeople v. AurigemmaPeople v. HernandezMatter of NuttallAmoruso v. N.Y. City Transit AuthPeople v. SmithMatter of Consolidated Avionics CorporationKirby v. ChasePeople v. DotyClaim of Murray v. Farmingdale Federal Savings & Loan Ass'nMatter of Jessup v. Jessup Stevens GaragePeople v. SteinLanvin Parfums, Inc. v. Le Dans, Ltd.People v. HuntMcNichols v. WeissPeople v. CarrawayTroy Operating Co., Inc. v. Vinciguerra220-2 East 85th Street, Inc. v. FastenbergMatter of Kindlick v. Nassau SmeltingPeople ex rel. Martinson v. FayO'Connor v. O'ConnorPeople v. CampbellHeaney v. County of ErieMatter of PasialisMatter of HillHines v. ChinnPeople v. JohnsonGramatan Natl. Bk. v. Greater Hope MissionaryClaim of Rothenberg v. Le Huray & Co.West v. L.J.F. Corp.Matter of Browne v. New York St. Bd. of ParoleDe Masco v. Cooper's Express, Inc.Ricke v. Westchester Surface Ways, Inc.Gardner v. CramerPeople v. BarnesMatter of Sheahan v. MurphyPeople v. TilkinsMatter of Hubbard v. Bd. of Educ, City of N.YMatter of ArcherCarducci v. GainesStabile v. StatePeople v. SuberMatter of Tiffany v. MurphyMatter of Pittston CompanyPeople v. NamerPeople v. DiblinPeople v. HinesDe Jesus v. Chase Manhattan BankMatter of Rizzo v. RizzoPeople v. JacksonColonial Painting Co. v. Davron CorporationMatter of WestonCastella v. Caristo Construction Corp.People ex Rel. Rose v. RosePeople v. De GroatMatter of Gannon v. JacobsBreasette v. BriscoePeople v. HendryFitzgerald v. Town of Oyster BayVitagliano v. Bd. of Educ. of the City of N.YGalati v. Roman Catholic Church of Our Lady Queen of AngelsLugo v. Stewart Kaufman, Inc.People v. KennyMcDavid v. SargentPeople v. MitchellMiller v. MillerPeople v. LewisKind v. BaronePeople v. EdwardsSchmid v. Niagara Mohawk Power Corp.PEOPLE v. ROSAPeople v. FishMount Hope Cemetery Association v. StateMartin v. PeckPeople v. LathanMatter of Bowman v. McGinnisMatter of Weinberg v. Weinberg Brothers Co.In re the Intermediate Accounting of CoyCastaldo v. OlkonMatter of HeigmanMatter of BernsteinMoore v. CarroadHolmes v. LiquoriPeople v. WilliamsPeople ex rel. Carroll v. FayTraversone v. MacFadden School for ChildrenMatter of Trebec v. BiaseRounds v. Charles R Blackstone Sons, Inc.Floyd v. United Hospital of Port ChesterMatter of Ryan v. State Liquor AuthorityMatter of Smokler v. HermanEdwards v. HunttingMatter of Grennell v. Driveway Paving Co.Nugent v. MolloyOtt v. HarringtonLittman v. GrossmanKehrig v. KoshneyGutierrez v. City of New YorkPeople v. GreenePeople v. CastellazzoRoesler v. SonneMatter of GoldblattLedet v. United Aircraft CorporationDillon v. BrownellPeople v. FaschinoMatter of PugachProvo v. MorehousePeople v. GravesPeople v. FessiaKarp v. HultsDi Maria v. PaddockLesron Junior, Inc. v. FeinbergSalganik v. U.S. Navigation Co., Inc.Matter of Trudeau v. Colonial Sand StoneMatter of Hilliker v. N. Am. Van Lines, Inc.Itkin v. RingerKarger v. NesiHowe Sound Company v. Greg-Gary CorporationOverseas Metal & Ore Corp. v. Mineracac Bomfim S/AMatter of Clemente Bros., Inc.People v. BattagliaBecker v. RieckMolinari v. Garden Party House, Inc.Matter of Harry W. Graff, Inc.People v. MasonEver-Betta Products v. Wallkill Machine WorksLenahan v. SiegalMiller v. WardHedges v. Warwick-Greenwood Lake & New York Stages, Inc.Matter of Kelsch v. N.Y. City Transit AuthKriger v. Holland Furnace Co.Levy v. ReillyNurnberg v. DworkJacobs v. LewickiPeople v. BarksdaleBack v. BergsteinMichel v. AmiPeople v. CampbellLane v. Epstein's Edco Process Dry Cleaners Co.Feinman v. Incorporated Village of Ocean BeachEidelberg v. NewmanMatter of Weiss v. HermanParlato v. C.P. Ward, Inc.Feature Sports, Inc. v. Telescript-CSP, Inc.Goodman v. GoodmanUlman v. DukeSposito v. MartinPeople ex Rel. Cohn v. County Ct., SchtdyMatter of Clingman v. CushmanKruger v. CiadellaPeople v. WarePeople v. MoserMatter of FlastersteinLicata v. MarraHartung v. BishopSherman v. Underwriters for Lloyd's LondonGuerin v. GuerinMatter of Phillips v. Ridgemont Golf ClubHarlem Savings Bank v. MarchantRabinowitz v. IndurskyMt. Zion Baptist Ch. of Port Chester v. BrownFiore v. AmorusoPolzin v. SavageMercantini v. InnamoratiMATTER OF WAHL v. TODS SHIPYARDSPeople v. RobertsPeople v. Gray
