Endo Pharmaceuticals Inc. v. Roxane Laboratories, Inc.

MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support re: 116 MOTION in Limine Notice of Defendants' Motion in Limine to Exclude Unqualified Testimony of Reza Fassihi, Ph.D.. Memorandum in Support of Defendants' Motion in Limine to Exclude Unqualified Testimony of Reza Fassihi, Ph.D.. Document

S.D.N.Y.March 9, 2015

! (439&.38!-.,-1?!(43+.)*39.&1!.3+472&9.43!X!! 8;'/*(9!94!5749*(9.<*!47)*7! .3!9-*!;3.9*)!89&9*8!).897.(9!(4;79!! +47!9-*!84;9-*73!).897.(9!4+!3*=!?470! ! ! ! 5;'1.(1?!+.1*)! 7*)&(9*)!<*78.43! ! ! ! ! 9(7(!Eb(!+-'Vi'*2/31'JG>! ! 2*247&3);2!.3!8;55479!4+!)*+*3)&398W! 249.43!#&!$#%#&"!94!*>(1;)*!;36;&1.+.*)!! 9*89.243?!4+!7*@&!+&88.-.$!5-%)! ! ! ! Case 1:13-cv-03288-TPG Document 124 Filed 03/09/15 Page 1 of 11 ! (439&.38!-.,-1?!(43+.)*39.&1!.3+472&9.43!X!! 8;'/*(9!94!5749*(9.<*!47)*7! 7_Ta!8(!9_X`Xag! GTh_!IhWXagTf! CF9BbbW\a! 7`TaWT!B(!BX__l! MTf\ !̀B(!8_X\UX_! CF9BeXZbel!A(!=_XXf_Xe! I[Te\!7(!7_XkTaWXe! DFI68!I?8;$! 7aWeXT!C(!9[XX^!#DEC!>68!I?8;$! BEF8868!I?8;$! BEF886EA68;HG?86@F!,B8# Case 1:13-cv-03288-TPG Document 124 Filed 03/09/15 Page 2 of 11 \! (439&.38!-.,-1?!(43+.)*39.&1!.3+472&9.43!X!! 8;'/*(9!94!5749*(9.<*!47)*7! 9&'1*!4+!(439*398! GHKD!4+!&;9-47.9.*8! ! 5AGE"Q#! (&8*8! $9I6B8;9!3;8>#!,B8H76GCE"!,B8#!I#!2>6ED!&CED(&! Eb(!/4*3'9@L'**+-/';='88&!,*+*!MC!++1*+.2!#<(;(!JXk(!DTeV[!,,&!,*+*$!((((((((((((((((((((!,! ,B!E;!%6L8C@!0EC9F#!-?G?=#&! /-,!=(!Ihcc(!,W!+*,3!#;(!D\aa(!,**1$!((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((!,! &6@?F?!I#!$77CGG!-67F#&!! Eb(!9@L(7(!++'+*01+';A9&!,*+-!MC!/..+-//!#;(!DTff(!IXcg(!,1&!,*+-$!(((((((((((((((((!,! '6H7;EG!I#!.;EE;@@!'CJ!0>6EA6#"!,B8#&! /*3!K(I(!/13!#+33-$!(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((!+! +?=>@6B9!&6D?G6@!.=AG#"!-#0#!I#!28>B;?9;E&! //+!=(!Ihcc(!,W!+1-!#I(;(E(O(!,**2$!(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((!,! 1#)#.#$#2#"!,B8#!I#!2C&! 1.2!=(!Ihcc(!,W!,..!#I(;(E(O(!,*+*$!(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((!+! 2#(#&#!I#!3CHEE;&! 3/*!=(!Ihcc(!,W!000!#I(;(E(O(!,*+-$!((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((!+',! 3E6I;@;EF!,B9;A#!&C#!I#!/CEG>ECD!*EHAA6B!&CED#&! Eb(!+,!9@L(!-*.*!B8=&!,*+.!MC!.0.103!#I(;(E(O(!ATa(!,2&!,*+.$!((((((((((((((((((((((((((!,! 4B?G;9!2G6G;F!I#!+C@A;F&! ..!=(-W!++/*!#,W!9\e(!+33/$!(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((!,! KB?G;9!2G6G;F!I#!.6>6<$&!,**1!MC!+,+-1-2!#<(;(E(O(!7ce(!,.&!,**1$((((((((((((((((((!,'-! 49-*7!&;9-47.9.*8! =XWXeT_!Hh_X!bY!6EA6#"!,B8#&!/*3!K(I(!/13&!/3,'3-!#+33-$(!!J[X! 9bheg![Tf!g[X!Thg[be\gl!gb!fVeXXa!XkcXeg!gXfg\`bal!Ybe!eX_XiTaVX!TaW!eX_\TU\_\gl(!!,9#!Tg!/23(!!Hh_X! 1*,!`TaWTgXf!g[Tg!XkcXeg!gXfg\`bal!\f!abg!eX_\TU_X!j[XeX!Ta!XkcXeg!\f!hadhT_\Y\XW!gb!bc\aX!ba!Ta! \ffhX(!!2;;!1#)#.#$#2#&!1.2!=(!Ihcc(!Tg!,.25!,02'03#!!=heg[Xe`beX&!\g!\f!cebVXWheT__l!cebcXe!gb! Case 1:13-cv-03288-TPG Document 124 Filed 03/09/15 Page 5 of 11 ,! ! (439&.38!-.,-1?!(43+.)*39.&1!.3+472&9.43!X!! 8;'/*(9!94!5749*(9.<*!47)*7!! TWWeXff!g[X!dhT_\Y\VTg\baf!bY!Ta!XkcXeg!\a!Ta!?B!@?A?B;!fXgg\aZ(!!2;;!2#(#&#!I#!3CHEE;&!3/*!=(!Ihcc(! ,W!000&!01.'1/!#I(;(E(O(!,*+-$(!!! ECD!*EHAA6B!&CED#&!+,!9@L!-*.*!B8=&!,*+.!MC!.0.103&!%,!#I(;(E(O(! ATa(!,2&!,*+.$!#8?G?B=!4B?G;9!2G6G;F!I#!3?B!56G!&>?B&!-1+!=(-W!-+&!.*!#,W!9\e(!,**.$!#\a! WXgXe`\a\aZ!j[Xg[Xe!T!j\gaXff!\f!dhT_\Y\XW!gb!eXaWXe!Ta!XkcXeg!bc\a\ba&!Vbhegf!Vb`cTeX!g[X! XkcXegnf!TeXT!bY!XkcXeg\fX!j\g[!g[X!cTeg\Vh_Te!fhU]XVg!`TggXe!bY!g[X!cebYYXeXW!gXfg\`bal($!!2;;"!;#=#"! &6@?F?!I#!$77CGG!-67F#&!++'+*01+';A9&!,*+-!MC!/..+-//&!%%2'+*!#;(!DTff(!IXcg(!,1&!,*+-$! #Y\aW\aZ!g[Tg!T!c[Te`TVb_bZ\fg!jTf!abg!\a!g[X!cbf\g\ba!gb!bc\aX!TUbhg![bj!T!ceXfVe\U\aZ!`XW\VT_! WbVgbe!jbh_W![TiX!\agXeceXgXW!T!ceXfVe\cg\ba!_TUX_($!!M[XeX!Ta!XkcXeg!TW`\gf![X!be!f[X!\f!abg! f^\__XW!\a!g[X!Teg!bY!T!cTeg\Vh_Te!Y\X_W&!Vbhegf![TiX!YbhaW!g[X!XkcXeg!gb!UX!hadhT_\Y\XW!gb!Z\iX!Ta! bc\a\ba!cXegT\a\aZ!gb!g[Tg!Y\X_W(!!2;;"!;#=#"!$9I6B8;9!3;8>#!,B8H76GCE"!,B8#!I#!2>6ED!&CED(&!Eb(! /4*3'9@L'**+-/';='88&!,*+*!MC!++1*+.2&!Tg!%/!#<(;(!JXk(!DTeV[!,,&!,*+*$!#8?G?B=! 2HB96B8;"!,B8#!I#!';ACBG;!)67E?86G?B=!-G9(&!//*!=(-W!+-/0&!+-0-!#=XW(!9\e(!,**2$$5!,B!E;!%6L8C@! 0EC9F#!-?G?=#&!/-,!=(!Ihcc(!,W!+*,3&!+*.1!#;(!D\aa(!,**1$(!!! @a!TWW\g\ba&!=XWXeT_!Hh_X!bY!@6B9!&6D?G6@! .=AG#"!-#0#!I#!28>B;?9;E&!//+!=(!Ihcc(!,W!+1-&!+10'11!#I(;(E(O(!,**2$!#Y\aW\aZ!\g!haaXVXffTel! TaW!T!jTfgX!bY!g\`X!Ybe!`h_g\c_X!XkcXegf!gb!bc\aX!ba!g[X!fT`X!fhU]XVgf$(!!oQ7R!ge\T_!]hWZX!eXgT\af!T! j\WX!_Tg\ghWX!gb!XkV_hWX!\eeX_XiTag&!eXcXg\g\iX&!be!Vh`h_Tg\iX!Xi\WXaVX(p!!4B?G;9!2G6G;F!I#!+C@A;F&! ..!=(-W!++/*&!++/1!#,W!9\e(!+33/$(!!J[X!9bheg![Tf!W\fVeXg\ba!gb!XkV_hWX!Vh`h_Tg\iX!gXfg\`bal! UXVThfX&!Ul!i\eghX!bY!\gf!eXcXg\g\iXaXff&!g[X!gXfg\`bal!j\__!abg![X_c!g[X!YTVg'Y\aWXe!Tf!eXdh\eXW! Case 1:13-cv-03288-TPG Document 124 Filed 03/09/15 Page 6 of 11 -! ! (439&.38!-.,-1?!(43+.)*39.&1!.3+472&9.43!X!! 8;'/*(9!94!5749*(9.<*!47)*7!! haWXe!Hh_X!1*,(!!2;;!4B?G;9!2G6G;F!I#!.6>6<$&!,**1!MC!+,+-1-2&!%-! #<(;(E(O(!7ce(!,.&!,**1$(! +AQQIHI$!A!FMPKSJARIML!QCIELRIQR$!QHMSJD!BE!NEPKIRRED!RM!REQRIFV!MLJV!AQ!RM!NHAPKACESRICAJ! FMPKSJARIMLQ!ALD!QHMSJD!LMR!BE!NEPKIRRED!RM!NPMFFEP!MNILIMLQ!RHAR!FAJJ!QOSAPEJV!TIRHIL! ! %! ! =Tff\[\!\f!T!cebYXffbe!bY!U\bc[Te`TVXhg\VT_!TaW!\aWhfge\T_!c[Te`TVl!TaW!Ta!T__XZXW!XkcXeg! \a!g[X!Y\X_W!bY!U\bc[Te`TVXhg\Vf!TaW!c[Te`TVXhg\VT_!Ybe`h_Tg\baf(!!#