Request Judicial NoticeCal. Super. - 6th Dist.April 24, 20181 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ,;:)" T""i 10 oCO QLl'l T""i O'I N 11 U LU ::i a.. !:; ~ I- ::::i 0 12 (/) (/) LI.. z <:J a tu< LU LUU 13 z ex: ~ '.:l I- 0 ~ (/) I- ~ffi 14 T""i::;:: 0~ co u < 15 (/) 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 Ian A. Rambarran, Bar No. 227366 Sunny S. Sarkis, Bar No. 258073 KLINEDINST PC 801 K Street, Suite 2100 Sacramento, California 9 5 814 (916) 444-7573/FAX (916) 444-7544 irambarran@klinedinstlaw.com ssarkis@klinedinstlaw.com Attorneys for Defendant BAYVIEW LOAN SERVICING, LLC SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA FOR THE COUNTY OF SANTA CLARA CASEY T AROKH, Plaintiff, V. BAYVIEW LOAN SERVICING, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company; CITIMORTGAGE INC., a New York corporation; and DOES 1-100, inclusive, Defendants. Case No. 18CV327044 REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE IN SUPPORT OF BAYVIEW LOAN SERVICING, LLC'S DEMURRER TO FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT Date: Time: Dept: Judge: Complaint Filed: Trial Date: April 11, 2019 9:00 a.m. D-02 Hon. Mark H. Pierce April 24, 2018 None set Defendant Bayview Loan Servicing, LLC ("Bayview" or "Defendant") hereby respectfully requests that this Court take judicial notice of the following documents pursuant to California Evidence Code §452, subdivisions (d) and (h) in Section I.(A) of this Request for Judicial Notice ("RJN") in supp01i of Defendant's Demurrer to Plaintiffs Initial Complaint. I. Legal standard for judicial notice Evidence Code §452, subdivision ( d), permits the trial court to take judicial notice of any federal and state court records. (Cal. Evid. Code, §452(d).) Evidence Code §452, subdivision (h) permits the trial court to take judicial notice of facts and propositions that are not reasonably subject to dispute and are capable of immediate and accurate determination by resort to sources of reasonably indisputable accuracy. (Evid. Code, §452(h); see also Columbia Cas. Co. v. Nw. 1 REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE IN SUPORRT OF BAYVIEW LOAN SERVICING, LLC'S DEMURRER TO FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT Electronically Filed by Superior Court of CA, County of Santa Clara, on 11/20/2018 12:20 PM Reviewed By: R. Tien Case #18CV327044 Envelope: 2190924 '¢ ,-I oco QL/) ,-I O'I N u UJ:::; 0.. t:; ~ I-:::, 0 (./J (/) u.. z <:l ci li:i <( UJ UJ u z ~ ~ ~ I- 0 :::.:: (/) I- :::.:: 15 ,-I :;: 0~ co u <( (/) 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 Nat'! Ins. Co. (1991) 231 Cal.App.3d 457, 468-469; Maryland Cas. Co. v. Reeder (1990) 221 Cal.App.3d 961, 977 (a court has authority to take judicial notice of documents that cannot reasonably be controverted).) Under this section, documents that are duly notarized and recorded at the county recorder's office are presumed to be reliable and beyond reasonable dispute. (See McElroy v. Chase Manhattan Mortg. Corp., for example, (2005) 134 Cal.App.4th 388,394 (court took judicial notice of the recordation of a notice of default under a deed of trust, the date of the notice's recording, and the amount stated as owing in the notice, for the purpose of demonstrating the plaintiffs had notice of the amount claimed to be owing and the opportunity to cure a defective tender); see also Poseidon Dev., Inc. v. Woodland Lane Estates, LLC (2005) 152 Cal.App.4th 1106, 1117-1118 ( affirming judicial notice, in sustaining a demurrer, of the parties, dates, and legal consequences of a series of recorded documents relating to a real estate transaction to find that a party gave up and no longer held any beneficial interest under the deed of trust pursuant to a recorded assignment).) Indeed, the "official act of recordation and the common use of a notary public in the execution of such documents assure their reliability, and the maintenance of the documents in the recorder's office makes their existence and text capable of ready confirmation, thereby placing such documents beyond reasonable dispute." (Fontenot v. Wells Fargo Bank, NA. (2011) 198 Cal.App.4th 256, 264-265 (finding fact that "MERS was the beneficiary under the deed of trust" was properly judicially noticed because, "as a legally operative document, the deed of trust designated MERS as the beneficiary"); Sciarratta v. US. Bank Nat'! Ass 'n (2016) 247 Cal.App.4th 552, 556, 563-564 (judicially noticing parties, dates, and legal consequences of recorded assignments to determine whether assignment was void/voidable; and only finding assignment was void where a single entity recorded multiple assignments purporting to assign same interest in the property twice to two different assignees).) Moreover, Evidence Code §452, subdivision (a) permits the trial court to take judicial notice of decisional law of any state. (Camara v. Comprehensive Care Corp. (1983) 140 Cal.App.3d 369, 373 (stating Cal. Evid. Code §452 provides that the decisional law of any state 2 REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE IN SUPPORRT OF BAYVIEW LOAN SERVICING, LLC'S DEMURRER TO FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 v ,-I 10 ooo ot..n ,-I Ci' N n . ~1ill Do you own, lease, or have legal or equitable interest in any vehicles, whether they are registered or not? Include any vehicles you own that someone else drives. If you lease a vehicle, also report it on Schedule G: Executory Contracts and Unexpired Leases. Official Form 106A/B Schedule A/B: Property Software Copyrght (c) 1996-2017 Best Case, LLC -www.bestcase.com Case: 17-51380 Doc# 1 Filed: 06/08/17 Entered: 06/08/17 12:49:16 page 1 Best Case Bankruptcy Page 11 of 47 Debtor 1 Casey Tarokh_, ___ _ Case number (if known) 8. Collectibles of value Examples: Antiques and figurines; paintings, prints. or other artwork; books, pictures, or other art objects; stamp, coin, or baseball card collections; other collections, memorabilia, collectibles ■ No D Yes. Describe ..... 9. Equipment for sports and hobbies Examples: Sports, photographic, exercise, and other hobby equipment; bicycles, pool tables, golf clubs, skis; canoes and kayaks; carpentry tools; musical instruments ■ No D Yes. Describe •..•. 10. Firearms Examples: Pistols, rifles, shotguns, ammunition, and related equipment ■ No 0 Yes. Describe ..... 11. Clothes Examples: Everyday clothes, furs, leather coats, designer wear, shoes, accessories □ No ■ Yes. Describe ..... ! Misc. clothing items · Location: 1381 Noreluis Court, San Jose CA 95120-3849 $100.00 12. Jewelry Examples: Everyday jewelry, costume jewelry, engagement rings, wedding rings, heirloom jewelry, watches, gems, gold, silver ■ No D Yes. Describe ••..• 13. Non-farm animals Examples: Dogs, cats, birds, horses ■ No D Yes. Describe ..... 14. Any other personal and household items you did not already list, including any health aids you did not list ■ No 0 Yes. Give specific information ..... 15. Add the dollar value of all of your entries from Part 3, including any entries for pages you have attached for Part 3. Write that number here ............................................................................. . ml Describe Your Financial Assets , ____________ _ Do you own or have any legal or equitable interest in any of the following? 16. Cash $800.00 Current value of the portion you own? Do not deduct secured claims or exemptions. Examples: Money you have in your wallet, in your home, in a safe deposit box, and on hand when you file your petition ■ No □ Yes ............................................................................................................... . 17. Deposits of money Examples: Checking, savings, or other financial accounts; certificates of deposit: shares in credit unions, brokerage houses, and other similar institutions. If you have multiple accounts with the same institution, list each. □ No ■ Yes ......•..•.....•....•... Institution name: Chase Account 17.1. Checking Account Number ending in 3389 Official Form 1 06A/8 Schedule A/8: Property Software Copyright (c) 1996-2017 Best Case, LLC - www.bestcase.com Case: 17-51380 Doc# 1 Filed: 06/08/17 Entered: 06/08/17 12:49:16 $3,230.89 page 3 Best Case Bankruptcy Page 13 of 47 Debtor 1 Casey Tarokh 28. Tax refunds owed to you II No Case number (if known) D Yes. Give specific information about them, including whether you already filed the returns and the tax years ...... . 29. Family support Examples: Past due or lump sum alimony, spousal support, child support, maintenance, divorce settlement, property settlement II No D Yes. Give specific information ..... . 30. Other amounts someone owes you Examples: Unpaid wages, disability insurance payments, disability benefits, sick pay, vacation pay, workers' compensation, Social Security benefits; unpaid loans you made to someone else II No D Yes. Give specific information .. 31. Interests in insurance policies Examples: Health, disability, or life insurance; health savings account (HSA); credit, homeowner's, or renter's insurance II No D Yes. Name the insurance company of each policy and list its value. Company name: 32. Any interest in property that is due you from someone who has died Beneficiary: Surrender or refund value: If you are the beneficiary of a living trust, expect proceeds from a life insurance policy, or are currently entitled to receive property because someone has died. II No D Yes. Give specific information .. 33. Claims against third parties, whether or not you have filed a lawsuit or made a demand for payment Examples: Accidents, employment disputes, insurance claims, or rights to sue II No D Yes. Describe each claim ........ . 34. Other contingent and unliquidated claims of every nature, including counterclaims of the debtor and rights to set off claims II No D Yes. Describe each claim ........ . 35. Any financial assets you did not already list II No D Yes. Give specific information .. 36. Add the dollar value of all of your entries from Part 4, including any entries for pages you have attached for Part 4. Write that number here .................................................................................................................... . Describe Any Business-Related Property You Own or Have an Interest In. List any real estate in Part 1. 37. Do you own or have any legal or equitable interest in any business-related property? II No. Go to Part 6. D Yes. Go to line 38. Describe Any Farm- and Commercial Fishing-Related Property You Own or Have an Interest In. If you own or have an Interest in farmland, list it in Part 1. 46. Do you own or have any legal or equitable interest in any farm- or commercial fishing-related property? II No. Go to Part 7. D Yes. Go to line 47. Describe All Property You Own or Have an Interest in That You Did Not List Above Official Form 1 06A/B Schedule A/B: Property Software Copyright (c) 1996-2017 Best Case, LLC -www.bestcase.com Case: 17-51380 Doc# 1 Filed: 06/08/17 Entered: 06/08/17 12:49:16 $19,232.42 page 5 Best Case Bankruptcy Page 15 of 47 Fill in this information to identify your case: ; Debtor 1 Debtor 2 (Spouse If, flflng) Casey Tarokh First Name Flrst Name Middle Name Last Name Middle Name Last Name i United States Bankruptcy Court for the: NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA I Case number '(ttknown) Official Form 106C Schedule C: The Property You Clalm as Exempt □ Check If this is an amended filing 4/16 Be as complete and accurate as possible. If two married people are filing together, both are equally responsible for supplying correct information, Using the property you listed on Schedule AIB: Property (Official Form 106A/B) as your source, list the property that you claim as exempt. If more space is needed, fill out and attach to this page as many copies of Part 2: Additional Page as necessary. On the top of any additional pages, write your name and case number (if known). For each Item of property you claim as exempt, you must specify the amount of the exemption you claim. One way of doing so is to state a specific dollar amount as exempt. Alternatively, you may claim the full fair market value of the property being exempted up to the amount of any applicable statutory limit. Some exemptions-such as those for health aids, rights to receive certain benefits, and tax-exempt retirement funds-may be unlimited In dollar amount. However, if you claim an exemption of 100% of fair market value under a law that limits the exemption to a particular dollar amount and the value of the property is determined to exceed that amount, your exemption would be limited to the applicable statutory amount. ■kffllM Identify the Property You Claim as Exempt 1. Which set of exemptions are you claiming? Check one only, even if your spouse is filing with you. ■ You are claiming state and federal nonbankruptcy exemptions. 11 U.S.C. § 522{b)(3) D You are claiming federal exemptions. 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)(2) 2. For any property you list on Schedule AIB that you claim as exempt, fill in the information below. Brief descrlptkln of the property and line on Schedule AIB that lists thii; property 1381 Noreluis court San Jose, CA 95120 Santa Clara County Line from Schedule AIB: 1.1 2008 Honda Odyssey 80000 miles line from Schedule AIB: 3.1 1996 Toyota Avalon 120000 miles Line from Schedule AIB: 3.2 Misc. Furniture Location: 1381 Noreluis Court, San Jose CA 95120-3849 Line from Schedule AIB: 6.1 Books and Pies Location: 1381 Noreluis Court, San Jose CA 95120-3849 Line from Schedule AIB: 6.2 Current value of the portion you own Copy the value from Schedule NB $1,338,133.00 $1,795.00 $623.00 $500.00 $200.00 Amount of the exemption you claim Check only one box far each exemption. ■ $75,000,00 □ 100% of fair market value, up to any applicable statutory limit ■ $1,795.00 □ 100% of fair market value, up to any applicable statutory limit ■ $623.00 □ 100% of fair market value, up to any applicable statutory llmlt • $500.00 □ 100% of fair market value, up to any applicable statutory limit • $200.00 □ 100% of fair market value, up to any applicable statutory limit Official Form 106C Schedule C: The Property You Claim as Exempt Software Copyright (c) 1996-2017 Best Case, LLC - www.bestcase.com Specific Jaws that allow exemption C.C.P. § 704.730 C.C.P. § 704.010 C.C.P. § 704.010 C.C.P. § 704.020 C.C.P. § 704.020 page 1 of 2 Best Case Bankruptcy Case: 17-51380 Doc# 1 Filed: 06/08/17 Entered: 06/08/17 12:49:16 Page 17 of 47 Fill in this information to identify your case: Debtor 1 Debtor2 (Spouse If, filing) Casey Tarokh First Name First Name Middle Name Last Name Middle Name Las! Name NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA I Ualt,d Sta1"s Baakrup~y Coe rt ro, lhe, Case number (If known) D Check if this is an amended filing Official Form 106D Schedule D: Creditors Who Have Clalms Secured by Property 12/15 Be as complete and accurate as possible. If two married people are filing together, both are equally responsible for supplying correct information. H more space is needed, copy the Additional Page, fill it out, number the entries, and attach It to this form. On the top of any addltional pages, write your name and case number (if known). 1. Do any creditors have claims secured by your property? D No, Check this box and submit this fonm to the court with your other schedules. You have nothing else to report on this form, ■ Yes. Fill in all of the information below. ■HIM List All Secured Claims 2. List all secured claims. If a creditor has more than one secured claim, list the creditor separately lbr each claim. If more than one creditor has a particular claim, list the other creditors in Part 2. As much as possible, list the claims In alphabetical order according to the creditor's name. [2.17 Bayview Financial Loan Creditor's Name Attn: Customer Service Dept 4425 Ponce De Leon Blvd, 5th Floor Miami, FL 33146 Number, Street, City, State & Zip Code Describe the property that secures the claim: 1381 Noreluis court San Jose, CA 95120 Santa Clara County As of the date you file, the claim Is: Check all that apply. D Contingent D Unliquldated D Disputed Nature of lien. Check all that apply, Column A Amount of claim Do not deduct the value of collateral. $1,094,506.56 Who owes the debt? Check one. ■ Debtor 1 only D An agreement you made (such as mortgage or secured D Debtor 2 only D Debtor 1 and Debtor 2 only D At least one of the debtors and another D Check If this claim relates to a community debt Opened 05/07 Last Active Date debt was incurred 7 /25/16 car loan) D Statutory lien (such as tax lien, mechanic's lien) D Judgment lien from a lawsuit D Other (including a right to offset) Last 4 digits of account number 7019 -------- ColumnB Value of collateral that supports this claim $1,338,133.00 !2.27Chase Describe the property that secures the claim: 1 1381 Noreluis court San Jose, CA $36,482.40 _$1,338, 133.00 Creditors Name P.O. Box 183166 Columbus, OH 43218-3166 Number, Street, City, State & Zip Coda Who owes the debt? Check one. ■ Debtor 1 only D Debtor 2 only D Debtor 1 and Debtor 2 only D At least one of the debtors and another Official Form 106D I 95120 Santa Clara County As of the date you file, the claim is: Check all that apply. D Contingent D Unliquidated D Disputed Nature of lien. Check all that apply. D An agreement you made (such as mortgage or secured car loan) D Statutory lien (such as tax lien, mechanic's lien) D Judgment lien from a lawsuit Schedule D: Creditors Who Have Claims Secured by Property Software Copyright (c) 1996·2017 Best Case, LLC-www.bestcase.com Column C Unsecured portion If any $0.00 $0.00 page 1 of 2 Best Case Bankruptcy Case: 17-51380 Doc# 1 Filed: 06/08/17 Entered: 06/08/17 12:49:16 Page 19 of 47 Fill in this information to identify your case: Debtor 1 Debtor2 (Spouse if. flilng) Casey Tarokh First Name First Name United States Bankruptcy Court for the: Case number (if known) Official Form 106E/F Middle Name Last Name Middle Name Last Name NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA Schedule E/F: Creditors Who Have Unsecured Claims D Check if this is an amended fillng 12/15 Be as complete and accurate as possible. Use Part 1 for creditors with PRIORITY claims and Part 2 for creditors with NON PRIORITY claims. List the other party to any executory contracts or unexpired leases that could result in a claim. Also 11st executory contracts on Schedule AJB: Property (Official Form 106AJB) and on Schedule G: Executory Contracts and Unexpired Leases (Official Form 106G). Do not Include any creditors with partially secured claims that are listed In Schedule D: Creditors Who Have Claims Secured by Property. If more space is needed, copy the Part you need, fill it out, number the entries In the boxes on the left. Attach the Continuation Page to this page. If you have no Information to report in a Part, do not file that Part. On the top of any additional pages, write your name and case number (if known). l@fM List All of Your PRIORITY Unsecured Claims 1. Do any creditors have priority unsecured claims against you? D No. Go to Part 2. ■ ves. 2. List all of your priority unsecured claims. If a creditor has more than one priority unsecured claim, list the creditor separately for each claim. For each claim listed, identify what type of claim~ is. If a claim has both priority and nonpriority amounts. list that claim here and show both priority and nonpriority amounts. As much as possible, fist the claims in alphabetical order according to the creditor's name. If you have more than two priority unsecured claims, fill out the Continuation Page of Part 1. If more than one creditor holds a particular claim, list the other creditors in Part 3. (For an explanation of each type of claim, see the instructions for this form in the instruction booklet.) Franchise Tax Board Pr1orlty Creditor's Name Personal Bankruptcy MSA340 P.O. Box 2952 Sacramento, CA 95812-0295 Number Street City State Zip Code Who Incurred the debt? Check one. ■ Debtor 1 only D Debtor 2 only D Debtor 1 and Debtor 2 only D Al least one of the debtors and another D Check if this claim is for a community debt Is the claim subject to offset? Total clalm Last 4 digits of account number ---- When was the debt Incurred? As of the date you file, the claim Is: Check all that apply D Contingent D Unliquldaled D Disputed Type of PRIORITY unsecured clalm: D Domestic support obligations ■ Taxes and certain other debts you owe the government $0.00 D Claims for death or personal Injury while you ware Intoxicated Priority amount $0.00 ■ No D Other. Specify _____________________ _ □ Yes Official Form 106 E/F Schedule E/F: Creditors Who Have Unsecured Claims Non priority amount $0.00 Page 1 of 3 Software Copynght (c) 1996-2017 Best Case. LLC • www.bestcase.com 467 41 Best Case Bankruptcy Case: 17-51380 Doc# 1 Filed: 06/08/17 Entered: 06/08/17 12:49:16 Page 21 of 47 Debtor 1 Casey Tarokh ~ Discover Financial Nonpriority Creditor's Name Po Box 3025 New Albany, OH 43054 Number Street City State Zip Code Who incurred the debt? Check one. ■ Debtor 1 only D Debtor 2 only D Debtor 1 and Debtor 2 only D At least one of the debtors and another D Check if this claim is for a community debt Is the claim subject to offset? ■ No □ Yes Case number (if know) Last 4 digits of account number 1451 When was the debt incurred? ------- Opened 08/93 Last Active 12/23/13 As of the date you file, the claim is: Check all that apply D Contingent D Unliquidated D Disputed Type of NONPRIORITY unsecured claim: D Student loans D Obligations arising out of a separation agreement or divorce that you did not report as priority claims D Debts to pension or profit-sharing plans, and other similar debts ■ Other. Specify Credit Card --------------------- Nil/ttfM List Others to Be Notified About a Debt That You Already Listed $4,420.00 5. Use this page only if you have others to be notified about your bankruptcy, for a debt that you already listed in Parts 1 or 2. For example, if a collection agency is trying to collect from you for a debt you owe to someone else, list the original creditor in Parts 1 or 2, then list the collection agency here. Similarly, if you have more than one creditor for any of the debts that you listed in Parts 1 or 2, list the additional creditors here. If you do not have additional persons to be notified for any debts in Parts 1 or 2, do not fill out or submit this page. Nil/ttliM Add the Amounts for Each Type of Unsecured Claim 6. Total the amounts of certain types of unsecured claims. This information is for statistical reporting purposes only. 28 U.S.C. §159. Add the amounts for each type of unsecured claim. Total claims from Part 1 Total claims from Part 2 6a. Domestic support obligations 6b. Taxes and certain other debts you owe the government 6c. Claims for death or personal injury while you were intoxicated 6d. Other. Add all other priority unsecured claims. Write that amount here. 6e. Total Priority. Add lines 6a through 6d. 6f. Student loans 6g. Obligations arising out of a separation agreement or divorce that you did not report as priority claims 6h. Debts to pension or profit-sharing plans, and other similar debts 6i. Other. Add all other nonpriority unsecured claims. Write that amount here. 6j. Total Nonpriority. Add lines 6f through 6i. 6a. 6b. 6c. 6d. 6e. 6f. 6g. 6h. 6i. 6j. Official Form 106 E/F Schedule E/F: Creditors Who Have Unsecured Claims Software Copyright (c) 1996-2017 Best Case, LLC • www.bestcase.com Total Claim $ 0.00 $ _____ 5~,9_9_5_.2_7 $ 0.00 ----------- $ 0.00 $ 5,995.27 Total Claim $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 $ 5,651.00 I $ 5,651.00 Page 3 of 3 Best Case Bankruptcy Case: 17-51380 Doc# 1 Filed: 06/08/17 Entered: 06/08/17 12:49:16 Page 23 of 47 Debtor2 (Spouse ff, filing) First Name Middle Name Last Name United States Bankruptcy Court for the: NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA Case number (If known) Official Form 106H Schedule H: Your Codebtors D Check if this is an amended filing 12/15 Codebtors are people or entities who are also liable for any debts you may have. Be as complete and accurate as possible. If two married people are filing together, both are equally responsible for supplying correct information. If more space is needed, copy the Additional Page, fill it out, and number the entries in the boxes on the left. Attach the Additional Page to this page. On the top of any Additional Pages, write your name and case number (if known). Answer every question. 1. Do you have any codebtors? (If you are filing a joint case, do not list either spouse as a codebtor. ■ No □ Yes 2. Within the last 8 years, have you lived in a community property state or territory? (Community property states and territories include Arizona, California, Idaho, Louisiana, Nevada, New Mexico, Puerto Rico, Texas, Washington, and Wisconsin.) ■ No. Go to line 3. D Yes. Did your spouse, former spouse, or legal equivalent live with you at the time? 3. In Column 1, list all of your codebtors. Do not include your spouse as a codebtor if your spouse is filing with you. List the person shown in line 2 again as a codebtor only if that person Is a guarantor or cosigner. Make sure you have listed the creditor on Schedule D (Official Form 106D), Schedule E/F (Official Form 106E/F), or Schedule G {Official Form 106G). Use Schedule D, Schedule E/F, or Schedule G to fill out Column 2. Column 1: Your codebtor Name, Number, Street, City, State and ZIP Code Name Number Street City Name Number City Official Form 106H Street State State Software Copyright (c) 1996-2017 Best Case, LLC -www.bestcase.com ZIP Code ZIP Code Column 2: The creditor to whom you owe the debt Check all schedules that apply: D Schedule D, line D Schedule E/F, line D Schedule G, line D Schedule D, line D Schedule E/F, line D Schedule G, line Schedule H: Your Codebtors Page 1 of 1 Best Case Bankruptcy Case: 17-51380 Doc# 1 Filed: 06/08/17 Entered: 06/08/17 12:49:16 Page 25 of 47 Debtor 1 CaseAy_T_a_r_o_k_h ____________________ _ Copy line 4 here 4. 5. List all payroll deductions: Case number (if known) for:Oebtor 1 $ __ 9~,3_6_1._00_ ForDebtor2.or non~filing spouse $ NIA 5a. Tax, Medicare, and Social Security deductions 5a. $ 1,355.72 $ _____ N_I_A_ 5b. Mandatory contributions for retirement plans Sb. $ 0.00 $ _____ N_I_A_ Sc. Voluntary contributions for retirement plans 5c. $ 707.84 $ ___ __ NNJ/AA 5d. Required repayments of retirement fund loans Sd. $ 0.00 $ 5e. Insurance Se. $ 694.71 $ _____ N_l.,..,A- 5f. Domestic support obligations 5f. $ 453.00 $ N/A 5g. Union dues 5g. $ 69.50 $ N/A 5h. Otherdeductions.Specify: _S_u_,_p_A_D_M_C_H_G _________ 5h.+ $ 1.50 + $ N/A ARAG Group $ ___ 10.19 $ NIA 6. Add the payroll deductions. Add lines 5a+5b+5c+5d+5e+5f+5g+5h. 6. $ 3,292.46 $ NIA 7. Calculate total monthly take-home pay. Subtract line 6 from line 4. 7. $ 6,068.54 $ N/A 8. List all other income regularly received: 8a. Net income from rental property and from operating a business, profession, or farm Attach a statement for each property and business showing gross receipts, ordinary and necessary business expenses, and the total monthly net income. 8b. Interest and dividends Be. Sd. Se. Sf. Family support payments that you, a non-filing spouse, or a dependent regularly receive Include alimony, spousal support, child support, maintenance, divorce settlement, and property settlement Unemployment compensation Social Security Other government assistance that you regularly receive Include cash assistance and the value (if known) of any non-cash assistance that you receive, such as food stamps (benefits under the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program) or housing subsidies. 8a. $ 8b. $ Be. $ Bd. $ Be. $ Specify: Sf. $ 8g. Sh. Pension or retirern_e_n_t_i-nc_o_m_e _______________ 8g. $ Other monthly income. Specify: Bh. + $ -120.00 $ NIA 0.00 $ N/A ------ 0.00 $ NIA 0.00 $----N-/A- 0.00 $ NIA 0.00 $ N/A 0.00 $----N-/A- 0.00 + $ NIA ------ 9. Add all other income. Add lines 8a+8b+Bc+Bd+8e+8f+Bg+Bh. 9. I$ -120.00 • l $ NIA I -------' c-------, 10. Calculate monthly income. Add line 7 + line 9. Add the entries in line 10 for Debtor 1 and Debtor 2 or non-filing spouse. 10. i $ 5,948.54 $ = $ -------; 11. State all other regular contributions to the expenses that you list in Schedule J. Include contributions from an unmarried partner, members of your household, your dependents, your roommates, and other friends or relatives. 5,948.54 Do not include any amounts already included in lines 2-10 or amounts that are not available to pay expenses listed In Schedule J. Specify: --------------------------------- 11. +$ ___ 0-'.~00-'- 12. Add the amount in the last column of line 10 to the amount in line 11. The result is the combined monthly income. Write that amount on the Summary of Schedules and Statistical Summary of Certain Liabilities and Related Data, if it applies 12. $ __ 5_,9_4_8_.5_4-' 13. Do you expect an increase or decrease within the year after you file this form? ■ No. D Yes. Explain: Officialf