Federal Knitting Mills Co.

National Labor Relations Board - Board Decisions

Aug 7, 1937

3 N.L.R.B. 257 (N.L.R.B. 1937)

In the Matters of FEDERAL KNITTING MILLS COMPANY and BAMBERGER
REINTHAL COMPANY and INTERNATIONAL LADIES' GARMENT WORKERS
UNION
In the Matter of STONE KNITTING MILLS COMPANY and AMERICAN
FEDERATION OF LABOR
Cases Nos. R-200, R-201, and K-202.-Decided August 7, 1937
. Ladies Knit Goods Industry-Investigation of Representatives: controversy
,concerning representation of employees: rival organizations; substantial doubt
as to majority status-Strikes : caused by attempt of employers to coerce em-
ployees into joining a particular organization-Unit Appropriate for Collective
Bargaining: eligibility for membership in both rival organizations-Election
Ordered: prior collective agreements no bar to holding-Certification of
Representatives.
Mr. Harry L. Lodish and Mr. Peter DiLeone for the Board.
Mr. Wells K. Stanley, Mr. Fred Frankel, and Mr. Phillip Frankel,
of Cleveland, Ohio, for the Companies.
11r. William J. Corrigan and Mr. Joseph B. Corrigan, of Cleve-
land, Ohio, for the Union.
Mr. John H. Orgill, of Cleveland, Ohio, for the Federation.
Mr. Julius Schlezinger, of counsel to the Board.
DECISION
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
On June 15, 1937, the International Ladies' Garment Workers
Union, herein called the Union, filed petitions with the Regional
Director for the Eighth Region (Cleveland, Ohio), alleging that
questions affecting commerce had arisen concerning the production
employees of the Bamberger Reinthal Company and the Federal
Knitting Mills Company, both of Cleveland, Ohio, and requesting
investigations and certifications of representatives pursuant to Sec-
tion 9 (c) of the National Labor Relations Act, 49 Stat. 449, herein
called the Act. On June 17, 1937, the American Federation of
Labor, herein called the Federation, filed a similar petition with re-
spect to the Stone Knitting Mills Company, also of Cleveland, Ohio.
On July 1, 1937, the National Labor Relations Board, herein called
the Board, issued an order consolidating the above cases for the pur-
pose of hearing and authorizing the Regional Director for the
257
258 NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD
Eighth Region to conduct an investigation and provide a hearing in
connection therewith . Notices of hearing were duly served on each
of the parties.
Pursuant to the notices , a hearing was conducted by Irving G.
McCann, the Trial Examiner duly designated by the Board, on July
15, 16, and 17 , 1937 , in Cleveland , Ohio, and testimony was taken.
Full opportunity to be heard , to examine and to cross -examine wit-
nesses, and to introduce evidence bearing upon the issues was afforded
all parties . The Board has reviewed the conduct of the hearing and
hereby affirms all rulings of the Trial Examiner.
At the hearing the Trial Examiner granted the parties a 10-day
extension of time in which to file their briefs and evidence concern-
ing the claims of the Union and the Federation to represent a
majority of the employees of the Bamberger Reinthal Company, the
Federal Knitting Mills Company , and the Stone Knitting Mills
Company, herein referred to collectively as the Companies . Pursuant
to this extension of time, briefs in behalf of all the parties and the
applications by employees of the Companies for membership in the
Union and the Federation were filed with the Board. Subsequently
a supplemental brief and exceptions to the ruling of the Trial Ex-
aminer refusing to grant a further extension of time were filed by
the Companies.
Upon the entire record in the cases the Board makes the following :
FINDINGS OF FACT
1. THE COMPANIES AND THEIR BUSINESSES
A. Bamberger Reinthal Company
The Bamberger Reinthal Company is an Ohio corporation with
its principal office and place of business in Cleveland , Ohio. It is
engaged in the manufacture of knitted outer wear. Its annual gross
sales amount to $1,033,294.66 and its purchases to $397,733.19.
The company purchases approximately 75 per cent of its raw mate-
rials from outside the State of Ohio. Eighty-five per cent of its
finished products are shipped to points without Ohio. About 80
per cent of these products are manufactured pursuant to special
order. The company possesses a registered trademark for use in
commerce among the several States.
B. Federal Knitting Mills Company
The Federal Knitting Mills Company is an Ohio corporation en-
gaged in the business of manufacturing knit goods at Cleveland,
Ohio. It also has a sales office in New York, New York. Its annual
purchases amount to $1,060,000 and its annual sales to $2,100,000.
DECISIONS AND ORDERS 259
A substantial portion of the raw materials used by the company
are received by it from points outside Ohio. Ninety per cent of its
finished products are shipped without the State. Practically all of
these products are made to special order. A trademark in the name
of the Federal Knitting Mills Company is registered in the United
States Patent Office for use in commerce among the several States.
C. Stone Knitting Mills Company
The Stone Knitting Mills Company, an Ohio corporation engaged
in the business of manufacturing knitted outer wear, has its principal
office and place of business in Cleveland, Ohio, and a branch office
in New York, New York. Its purchases amount to about $500,000
per year and its sales to about $1,000,000.
Ninety-five per cent of the raw materials used by the company
are purchased without the State of Ohio. Eighty-five per cent of
its finished products are shipped to points outside Ohio. All of these
products are manufactured pursuant to special order.
II. THE ORGANIZATIONS INVOLVED
A. The International Ladies' Garment Workers Union
The International Ladies' Garment Workers Union is a labor
organization affiliated with the Committee for Industrial Organiza-
tion. - It admits as members workers in the ladies knitted goods
industry. On June 16, 1937, it chartered Local No. 295 with juris-
diction over the employees in the knitted goods industry in Cleve-
land, Ohio.
B. The American Federation of Labor
The American Federation of Labor is a labor organization having
among its members workers from almost all branches of American
industry. On June 18, 1937, it chartered Federal Unions Nos. 20,865,
20,866, and 20,867 among the employees of the Stone Knitting Mills
Company, the Federal Knitting Mills Company, and the Bamberger
Reinthal Company, respectively.
III. THE APPROPRIATE BARGAINING UNITS
The Union and the Federation agreed at the hearing that the
appropriate bargaining unit in each plant consists of all production
and maintenance workers in such plant, excepting clerical and super-
visory employees. We find that in order to insure to employees the
full benefit of their right to self-organization and to collective bar-
gaining, and otherwise to effectuate the policies of the National Labor
Relations Act, all of the production and maintenance workers, ex-
260 NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD
cepting clerical and supervisory employees , of the Bamberger Rein-
thal Company, the Federal Knitting Mills Company, and the Stone
Knitting Mills Company , respectively , constitute units appropriate
for the purposes of collective bargaining.
IV. QUESTIONS CONCERNING REPRESENTATION
Late in March 1937, a group of workers at the Bamberger Reinthal
Company, dissatisfied with their pay and with working conditions
at the plant , requested the International Ladies' Garment Workers
Union to organize the employees of that company . The Union
thereupon commenced an organization drive at the factory of that
company. The following month similar drives were begun among
the employees of the Federal Knitting Mills Company and the Stone
Knitting Mills Company . On May 25, the Union wrote to the Fed-
eral Knitting Mills Company , and on June 3, to the other two com-
panies, requesting conferences for the purpose of negotiating with
respect to its members . No answer was received to any of these
letters. The evidence indicates that by June 7, the Union had made
considerable progress in organizing the employees of each of the
Companies.
Late in April or early in May, 1937, the American Federation of
Labor appointed a committee with Coleman Clarhaty as its chairman
to organize the knit goods workers in Cleveland for the Federation.
Clarhaty called upon Phillip Frankel, the secretary and attorney of
The Knitted Outer Wear Manufacturers of Cleveland , a trade asso-
ciation to which the Companies belong, and urged upon him the
advantages which a union contract with the Federation would bring
to the members of such association . Frankel arranged several meet-
ings between Clarhaty and officials of the Companies during the
month of May. At one of these meetings the Companies agreed to
throw open their plants to Federation organizers and to enter into a
contract with the Federation if it succeeded in obtaining a majority
of their employees as members. At the time of this agreement the
Federation did not as yet have any members in such plants.
On June 7, 1937, the Companies admitted several Federation
organizers into their factories . Telephone service at such factories
was cut off and their doors blocked to prevent anyone from leaving.
The workers in each plant were called together by their foremen
and foreladies and addressed by a Federation organizer who advised
them that it would be to their best interest to join the Federation.
Application cards were passed out to the employees and it appears
that a great many of them in each plant signed the cards and handed
them in. It is important to note that at each plant either officers of
DECISIONS AND ORDERS 261
the company or supervisory employees were present at the meeting
where the membership cards were distributed and filled out. At the
plant of the Stone Knitting Mills Company, the Federation organ-
izer was introduced by Mr. Woodworth, the secretary-treasurer of
the company.
Following the meetings, employees who had not already signed
cards were advised by their foremen and foreladies that the Com-
panies wished them to join the Federation. Supervisory employees
in each factory requested workers to sign Federation application
cards. At the plant of the Bamberger Reinthal Company several
workers who had not turned in cards at the meeting were called into
the company office and, in the presence of their foreman, requested
to join the Federation. At the plant of the Federal Knitting Mills
Company the workers were forced to attend a meeting of the com-
pany union that same afternoon where the president of the company
union stated that it was now against the law to have an inside union
and that they should join the Federation instead.' Several wit-
nesses testified that they had joined the Federation because they were
afraid that they would lose their jobs if they refused to do so. It
is clear that the Companies, in total disregard of the provisions of
the Act, interfered with and coerced their employees in the exercise
of their rights to self-organization, to Join or assist labor organiza-
tions, and to choose representatives for the purpose of collective
bargaining. This interference and coercion on the part of the Com-
panies cast doubt upon the question of whether a majority of their
employees had joined the Federation of their own free will.
In protest against these activities by the Companies the Union,
on June 8, 11, and 14, called strikes in the plants of the Bamberger
Reinthal Company, the Federal Knitting Mills Company, and the
Stone Knitting Mills Company, respectively. All three plants were
forced to close down. However, on June 30, the Stone Knitting mills
Company succeeded in reopening its factory.2 Subsequently, the
other two plants also reopened. The members of the Union remained
on strike, however, and at the hearing contended that very few em-
ployees had returned to work.
In the meantime the Federation and the Companies had contin-
ued their negotiations. On July 8, the members of the Federation
approved, at a mass meeting, the provisions of an agreement which
had been drawn up by Clarhaty and Frankel in May. These provi-
sions were then incorporated into a written contract and signed by
the Federation and the Companies on July 9. This contract pro-
1 A company union had been organized at each factory during the period of the National
Industrial Recovery Act
2 The reopening was marked by a riot at which several persons were injured.
49446-38-vol in-18
262 NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD
vided for recognition of the Federation as sole bargaining agent in
each plants
The Federation contends that the contract entered into with the
Companies on July 9 is a bar to an election. However, as pointed
out above, the interference and coercion on the part of the Companies
cast doubt upon the contention of the Federation that it had been
freely designated as their representative by a majority of the em-
ployees at the time of the contract.
The Federation also contends that since the International Ladies'
Garment Workers Union has only been suspended, and not expelled,
from the American Federation of Labor the dispute which has arisen
is an internal dispute within the body of the Federation, in which
the Board should not intervene. - We have already rejected a similar
contention, however, in view of the fact that it is a matter of common
knowledge that unions affiliated with the Committee for Industrial
Organization have ceased to obey the orders of the Federation 4
We conclude that questions concerning representation have arisen
which can best be settled by i secret ballot. Since the last day of
normal operations in each plant was the last working day before
the commencement of the present strike in such plant, those eligible
to vote should be the employees as of that date.
V. THE EFFECT OF THE QUESTIONS OF REPRESENTATION ON COMMERCE
We find ,that the questions concerning representation which have
arisen, occurring in connection with the operations of the Companies
described in Section I above, have a close, intimate, and substantial
relation to trade, traffic, and commerce among the several States, and
have led and tend to lead to labor disputes burdening and obstruct-
ing commerce and the free flow of commerce.
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Upon the basis of the above findings of fact, the Board makes
the following conclusions of law :
1. Questions affecting commerce have arisen concerning the repre-
sentation of the production and maintenance workers, excepting
clerical and supervisory employees, in the plants of the Bamberger
Reinthal Company, the Federal Knitting Mills Company, and the
Stone Knitting Mills Company, respectively, within the meaning of
Section 9 (c) and Section 2, subdivisions (6) and (7) of the National
Labor Relations Act. '
$ The contract is a single agreement covering seven knit goods manufacturers . It does
not contain any provision with respect to hours and wages but provides for the negotiation
of individual contracts between the Union and the Companies regarding such matters
4 Matter of the Interlake Iron Corp and Toledo Council , Committee for Inductriai.
Organization , Case No . R-149 , decided June 26, 1937 , 2 N. L R B. 1036
DECISIONS AND ORDERS 263
2. The production and maintenance workers, excepting clerical
and supervisory employees, in the plants of the Bamberger Reinthal
Company, the Federal Knitting Mills Company, and the Stone Knit-
ting Mills Company, respectively, constitute units appropriate for the
purposes of collective bargaining within the meaning of Section
9 (b) of the National Labor Relations Act.
DIRECTION OF ELECTIONS
By virtue of and pursuant to the power vested in the National
Labor Relations Board by Section 9 (c) of the National Labor Re-
lations Act, 49 Stat. 449, and pursuant to Article III, Section 8 of
National Labor Relations Board Rules and Regulations- Series 1, as
amended, it is
DIRECTED that, as part of the investigations authorized by the
Board to ascertain representatives for collective bargaining with the
Bamberger Reinthal Company, the Federal Knitting Mills Company,
and the Stone Knitting Mills Company, elections by secret ballot
shall be conducted within ten (10) days from the date of this Direc-
tion, under the direction and supervision of the Regional Director for
the Eighth Region, acting in this matter as agent for the National
Labor Relations Board and subject to Article III, Section 9 of said
Rules and Regulations, among all production and maintenance work-
ers, excepting clerical and supervisory employees, who were employed
in the Cleveland, Ohio, plants of the Bamberger Reinthal Company,
the Federal Knitting Mills Company, and the Stone Knitting Mills
Company, as of the last working day in such plants before June 8,
1937, June 11, 1937, and June 14, 1937, respectively, to determine
whether they desire to be represented by the International Ladies'
Garment Workers Union or the American Federation of Labor, for
the purposes of collective bargaining.
MR. DONALD WAKEFIELD SMrrhh took no part in the consideration
of the above Decision and Direction of Elections.
[SAME TITLES]
DECISION
AND
CERTIFICATION OF REPRESENTATIVES
September 3, 1937
On June 15, 1937, the International Ladies' Garment Workers
Union, herein called the Union, filed petitions with the Regional Di-
rector for the Eighth Region (Cleveland, Ohio ), alleging that ques-
tions affecting commerce had arisen concerning the production em-
264 NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD
ployees of the Bamberger Reinthal Company and the Federal
Knitting Mills Company, both of Cleveland, Ohio, and requesting
investigations and certifications of representatives pursuant to Sec-
tion 9 (c) of the National Labor Relations Act, 49 Stat. 449, herein
called the Act. On June 17, 1937, the American Federation of Labor,
herein called the Federation, filed a similar petition with respect to
the Stone Knitting Mills Company, also of Cleveland, Ohio. On
July 1, 1937, the National Labor Relations Board, herein called the
Board, issued an order consolidating the above cases for the purpose
of hearing and authorizing the Regional Director for the Eighth
Region to conduct an investigation and provide a hearing in con-
nection therewith. Pursuant to notice duly served on all the parties,
a hearing was held on July 15, 16, and 17, 1937, at Cleveland, Ohio,
before Irving G. McCann, the Trial Examiner duly designated by
the Board.
On August 7, 1937, the Board issued a Decision and Direction of
Elections in which it directed that elections be held among the
production and maintenance workers, excepting clerical and super-
visory employees, employed, respectively, by the Bamberger Rein-
thal Company, the Federal Knitting Mills Company, and the Stone
Knitting Mills Company, herein referred to collectively as the
Companies, to determine whether they wished to be represented by
the Union or the Federation for the purposes of collective bargaining.
On August 20, 1937, the Regional Director for the Eighth Region,
acting pursuant to Article III, Section 9 of National Labor Rela-
tions Board Rules and Regulations-Series 1, as amended, filed an
Intermediate Report with respect to the elections held pursuant to
the Direction of Elections. The Intermediate Report found the
results of the elections to be as follows :
BAMBERGER REINTHAL COMPANY
Total number eligible to vote______________________________ 299
Total number of ballots cast____________________________ 293
Total number of ballots cast for Federation______________ 132
Total number of ballots cast for Union__________________ 136
Total number of blank ballots___________________________ 0
Total number of void ballots ------------------------- .___ 0
Total number of challenged ballots (not counted) --------- 25
FEDERAL KNITTING MILLS COMPANY
Total number eligible to vote___________________________ 487
Total number of ballots counted__________________________ 479
Total number of ballots cast for Federation_______________ 149
Total number of ballots cast for Union__------------------ 290
Total number of void ballots_____________________________ 1
Total number of blank ballots ___________________________ 3
Total number of challenged ballots______________________ 36
DECISIONS AND ORDERS
STONE KNITTING MILLS COMPANY.
Total number of ballots counted__________________________ 486
Total number of ballots cast for Federation_____________ 298
Total number of ballots cast for Union____ ______________ 148
Total number of void ballots ____________________________ 6
Total number of blank ballots ____________________________ 0
Total number of challenged ballots________________________ 34
265
Objections to the ballot and the Intermediate Report were there-
after filed by the Federation with respect to the election among
the employees of the Bamberger Reinthal Company. No objections
have been filed by any of the parties with respect to the other two
Companies.
The Union, having been selected by a majority of the production
and maintenance employees, excepting clerical and supervisory em-
ployees, of the Federal Knitting Mills Company, as their repre-
sentative for the purposes of collective bargaining, is, by virtue of
Section 9 (a) of the Act, the exclusive representative for the pur-
poses of collective bargaining of all such employees, and we will so
certify it. Also, pursuant to Section 9 (a) of the Act, we will
certify the Federation as the exclusive representative for the pur-
poses of collective bargaining of all the production and mainte-
nance employees, excepting clerical and supervisory employees, of
the Stone Knitting Mills Company. No certification will be made
with respect to the employees of the Bamberger Reinthal Company
until a hearing is conducted on the objections to the ballot and the
Intermediate Report which have been filed concerning the election
among such employees.
CERTIFICATION OF REPRESENTATIVES
By virtue of and pursuant to the power vested in the National
Labor Relations Board by Section 9 (c) of the National Labor Rela-
tions Act, and pursuant to Article III, Section 8 of National Labor
Relations Board Rules and Regulations-Series 1, as amended,
IT IS HEREBY CERTIFIED that International Ladies' Garment Work-
ers Union has been selected by a majority of all the production and
maintenance employees, excepting clerical and supervisory employees,
of the Federal Knitting Mills Company as their representative for
the purposes of collective bargaining, and that, pursuant to Section
9 (a) of the National Labor Relations Act, International Ladies'
Garment Workers Union is the exclusive representative of all of such
employees of the Federal Knitting Mills Company for the purposes of
collective bargaining in respect to rates of pay, wages, hours of em-
ployment, and other conditions of employment.
266 NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD
AND IT IS FURTHER CERTIFIED that the American Federation of
Labor has been selected by a majority of all the production and
maintenance employees, excepting clerical and supervisory employees,
of the Stone Knitting Mills Company as their representative for
the purposes of collective bargaining, and that, pursuant to Section
9 (a) of the National Labor Relations Act, the American Federa-
tion of Labor is the exclusive representative of all of such employees
of the Stone Knitting Mills Company for the purposes of collective
bargaining in respect to rates of pay, wages, hours of employment,
and other conditions of employment.
MR. EDWIN S. SMITH took no part in the consideration of the above
Decision and Certification of Representatives.