04 Civ. 10067 (TPG). March 23, 2009 OPINION THOMAS GRIESA, Senior District Judge This interpleader action was brought by Sotheby's against Rod Shene, the German State of Baden-Württemberg, the Baden-Württemberg Ministry of Science, Research, and the Arts ("the Ministry"), and a German museum known as the Staatsgalerie Stuttgart, for a determination of which of the defendants has title to a 16th-century German book known as the Augsburger Geschlechterbuch. Sotheby's, the Staatsgalerie, and the Ministry