Id. at 13. The Fifth Circuit disagreed with this position too.The court noted, as did Rodríguez, that the Board’s precedential decision in Matter of Ortega-Cabrera, 23 I&N Dec. 793, 798 (BIA 2005), clearly states that an applicant must show GMC during the ten years immediately preceding the final decision by the immigration judge or BIA. Id. at 13.