Civil Action No. 08-561. March 22, 2010. Robert E. Paul, Paul Reich Myers, PC, Stephen R. Bolden, Fell Spalding, Philadelphia, PA, for Plaintiff. Bryan Michael Ferris, Bradley J. Vance, Edward John Kelbon, Reger Rizzo Kavulich Darnall LLP, Jonathan Walters, Markowitz Richman, Steven Schatz, Master, Weinstein PC, Philadelphia, PA, for Defendant. MEMORANDUM OPINION GOLDBERG, District Judge. This opinion addresses whether the national and local lodges of a union can be held liable for a physical altercation