Supreme Court of New York December 2011 casesDeutsche Bank Natl. Trust Co. v. AlvaradoAssembly v. Village of Hempstead Bd. of Zoning AppealsIsland Props. LLC v. CalabrettaPeople v. RodriguezGjonbalaj v. 317 West 89™ Street LLCAugello v. New York City Sch. Constr. Auth.Dukes v. New York City Dep't of Hous. Pres. & Dev. & Veritas Prop. Mgmt. LLCFaath v. RothSpinella v. CostantinoNewmark & Co. Real Estate, Inc. v. 1523 Ave. M, LLCMahon v. Pfizer, Inc.Brown v. Manhattan Orthopaedics, P.C.Bd. of Managers of the Residence on Madison Condominium v. AryehRipka, Rotter & Ktng, LLP v. LemmoMatarazzo v. L.R. Royal Inc.Wilmington Trust, NA v. Vitro Automotriz, S.A.Scarola Ellis LLP v. PadehACP Master, Ltd. v. Vitro S.A.B. de C. V.Haywood v. LevyUnited Nimba Citizens Council v. DorliaePeople v. ChuynIn re Ella C.People v. BenitezMercury Ins. Grp. v. Brown-FortMyrtle v. Essex Cnty. Bd. of ElectionsWilmington Trust, Natl. Assn. v. Vitro AutomotrizFeld v. WillkieSouthampton Brick & Tile, LLC v. Suffolk Cnty. Nat'l BankBershtein v. SinghIn re New York City Asbestos Litig.Giambrone v. FarhaRSB Bedford Assocs. LLC v. Ricky's Williamsburg, Inc.Murphy v. 14 Sutton Tenants Corp.Bank of Am. N.A. v. GarciaRusso v. Time Moving & Storage, Inc.People v. BenitezGodley v. WambuaING Bank F.S.B. v. DiLuggioIn re G.V.S.Progressive Specialty Ins. Co. v. LubeckMorales v. New York City Health & Hosps. Corp.Navarro v. InslerBeck v. Studio Kenji, Ltd.AON Risk Servs. v. CusackEden Rock Fin. Fund, L.P. v. Gerova Fin. Grp. Ltd.Avellino v. City of N.Y.Rosenstack v. WongScarola Ellis LLP v. PadehWells Fargo Bank Northwest, N.A. v. US AirwaysRuisi v. ParrottFrederic v. City of N.Y.Mueller v. Mitchell Maxwell Jackson, Inc.Landau, P.C. v. Olivepj & Schwartz, P.C.Bellomo v. New York State Univ. Constr. FundBluefin Wear, Inc. v. Tuesday's Child Boutique, Inc.Deneny v. Van RossemNahar v. GulatiLucia v. WeberPeople v. GasperdAltman v. New York Transit Auth.Pierson v. New York City Dept. of EducationKeil v. LefkovitsSpector v. Cushman & Wakefield, Inc.Hochman v. MissirlianIrish v. 89 Murray St. Assocs. LLCMosticchio v. SinghWells Fargo Home Mortg. v. MoutopoulosDeneny v. Van RossemJPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. v. Goldpak, LLCNelson v. FischerAtrinsic, Inc. v. Mother Nature, Inc.Associated Mut. Ins. Coop. v. Dionne's Clip N Curl Collins v. KellyGrubin v. Gotham Condo.Orosz v. OroszIn re ZornowShapiro v. Nat'l Arbitration & Mediation, Inc.Orosz v. OroszWells Fargo Bank Northwest, N.A. v. US Airways, Inc.Legion of Christ v. Town of Mount PleasantU.S. Bank, N.A. v. RamjitManglaviti v. KozakiewiczBenes v. American Gen. Annuity Serv. Corp.Thwaites v. New York State Bd. of ParoleHSBC Bank USA, NA v. HagermanPlatten v. BezioMcGarrity v. PicoSerer v. Gorbrook Assocs. Inc.Stark v. NussbaumGarcia v. GarciaMinelli v. Watkins Aircraft Support Prods. Inc.Estrategia Corp. v. CondoFulton Commons Care Ctr. v. MantellEstrategia Corp. v. Lafayette Commercial CondoCanzona v. AtanasioState Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. v. PerrucNahar v. GulatiBarouh v. BarouhGrix v. RCPI Landmark Props. LLCPappas v. City of New YorkNassau Cnty. v. New York State Urban Dev. Corp.1150 Fifth Ave. Owners Corp. v. DolgerBrentwood Union Free Sch. Dist. v. Local 237James v. Nat'l Arts ClubFalcon v. Rhaisa Auto Corp.Lee v. SS. CosmasMui v. New York City Bd./Dep't of Educ.Pomerance v. McGrathPeople v. RodriguezDeutsche Bank Trust Co. Americas v. DayLa Jolla Bank, FSB v. Whitestone Jewels, LLCCuillo v. Fairfield Prop. Servs. L.P.Roshodesh v. PlotchEifu v. WirtzPeople v. LabarberaDutchess Truck Repair Inc. v. BoyceStanton v. DBD Servs. Inc.Stuart's LLC v. EdelmanScelzo v. Acklinis Realty Holding LLCTower Ins. Co. of New York v. T&S Food Mkt. Corp.GDH Capital Corp. v. LisMistofsky v. A.C. & S. Inc.Lam v. 39 CAM, LLCLopez v. MontalbanoU.S. Bank, N.A. v. RamjitBayerische Hypo-Und Vereinsbank AG v. HSBC Bank USA, N.A.Fox v. City of New YorkZuckerbrod v. 355 Co.Zatulovskaya v. FNRSchwing Elec. Supply Corp. v. Hunter Roberts Constr. Grp. LLCMackey v. Consol. Edison Co. of New York, Inc.Manouel v. Bd. of AssessorsPeople v. GasperdWashington v. Marrano Dev. Affiliates, L.P.In re J.G. Wentworth Originations, LLCDubinsky v. City of New YorkPeople v. CardenasD'Alia v. BaroneWill v. Golf N.Y.C.Damis v. BarrellaWatkins v. Hosp. For Special Surgery PHO, Inc.Krackeler Scientific, Inc. v. Ordway Research Inst. Inc.BLUEFIN WEAR, INC. v. TUESDAY'S CHI. BOUTIQU., INC.Finamore v. Hardesty & Hanover, LLPParis Suites Hotel, Inc. v. Seneca Ins. Co., Inc.CIT GROUP/CONSUMER FIN., INC. v. PLATTAgile Opportunity Fund, LLC v. VectorMax Corp.Pryor Cashman Sherman & Flynn LLP v. BrodyACC Concrete Corp. v. Core Cont'l Constr. LLCLebedowicz v. Meserole Factory LLCKarakas v. RinaldiAon Risk Servs. v. CusackHoly Church of the Virgin Mary Home for Aged in Icaria, Greece v. Pan-Icarian Found.Weir v. Holland & Knight, LLPAlistair Records, LLC v. AdamsPeople v. Norstrand Chibcha Rest., Inc. v. David A. Kaminsky & Assocs., P.C.Mountain Creek Acquisition LLC v. Intrawest U.S. Holdings, Inc.S & I Elecs. PLC v. Pursco Grp. Ltd.Helmar Constr. Inc. v. Basic Structure Eng'gClark v. ClarkBlock v. McCaffreeIn re Matter of Myrtle v. Essex County Bd. of Elect.Herbst v. City of New YorkUnited States Bank Nat'l Ass'n v. MurilloSolomons v. Douglas Elliman LLCAugust v. New York City Dep't of Educ.Stark v. NussbaumNorguard Ins. Co. v. Apex Design & Constr. Corp.Fatato v. ReaganIn re New York City Asbestos Litig.Meron v. SchepsmanBencivenga v. CondonIngenito v. City of New YorkPeople v. CardenasKurzweil v. FerraroCovington v. KellyN.C. v. M.C.Inspector Gen. of N.Y. v. Indian Cultural & Cmty. Ctr., Inc.People v. LaBarberaLee v. SS. Cosmas & Damian Human Servs. Ctr. Inc.Pagan v. WardEden Rock Fin. Fund, L.P. v. Gerova Fin. Grp. Ltd.Comprehensive Care Mgmt. Corp. v. Utica Mut. Ins. Co.Merola v. Catholic Med. Ctr. of Brooklyn & Queens, Inc.Countrywide Home Loans Servicing v. BurroughsAmbassador Constr. Co., Inc. v. Dejil Sys., Inc.Vincent v. Metro. Suburban Bus Auth.Augeri v. Fid. Nat'l Title Ins. Co.Mintz & Gold LLP v. ZimmermanTawil v. TawilBaldeo v. MajeedSanchez v. MarticorenaWarshaw v. MendelowPeople v. YenPeople v. DiazLane v. Glaves House, L.P.JD Reinforcing Supply Inc. v. RCS Constr. LLCZweifach v. City of New York609 Corp. v. Park Towers South Co.Keil v. LefkovitsComm. To Save St. Brigid v. EganGoldman Sachs Lending Partners, LLC v. High River Ltd. P'shipHammami v. K&T Realty Assocs., LLCContra. Comp. Tru. v. Jack of Hearts Carpet Mill Out.Lieberman v. GuerraComplete Mgmt. Inc. v. SubinCooke-Zwiebach v. OzielHSBC Bank USA, N.A. v. CayoLally v. VillellaIn re White v. New York City Hous. Auth.Ass'n for a Better Long Island, Inc. v. New York State Dep't of Envtl. ConservationBorden v. Port Auth. of New York & New JerseyPierson v. New York City Dep't of Educ.Vykhodets v. Old Republic Nat'l Title Ins. Co.Godley v. WambuaFusco v. Direct Access Mgmt.Mahon v. Pfizer, Inc.Ass'n for a Better Long Island, Inc. v. New York State Dep't of Envtl. ConservationIn Matter of Bookman v. FischerThe Cit Group/Consumer Fin. Inc. v. PlattKirton v. DickersonAvellino v. City of New YorkWestbury Realty Assocs. LLC v. Relide Realty Co.Sierra-Cabrera v. City of New YorkPrince v. Dep't of Motor VehiclesAlbano v. DersovitzAnonymous v. LaSalaShafranov v. Planning Bd. of the Town of RiverheadTomlinson v. DegannesWhalen v. Donna Karan Int'l, Inc.Pavia & Harcourt LLP v. Squire Sanders & Dempsey LLPHernandez v. City of New YorkEllison v. KorfhageManouel v. Bd. of AssessorsGalligan v. Columbia Univ. Coll. of PhysiciansTomlinson v. DegannesPersico v. New York City Dep't of BuildingsMae v. Shiraz Assocs. Corp.Ward v. NYC Human Res. Admin.S&I Elecs. PLC v. Pursco Grp. Ltd.White v. New York City Hous. Auth.Belik v. New York City Hous. Auth.Quintas v. Pace Univ.Treyman v. NalbandianLofaro v. NgPlumitallo v. Cnty. of NassauAdvance Grp. Inc. v. New York City Campaign Fin. Bd.Warschauer v. SchneidermanMaiolini v. G&S Mount Vernon, LLCE.C.-P. v. P.P.S.A. v. D.A.Comfort Supply, Inc. v. GEICO Gen. Ins. Co.Kemcy Int'l v. Regus Mgmt. Grp., LLCPeople ex rel. Taylor v. WardenTitone v. Lufthansa Cargo AGWenzel v. 16302 Jamaica Ave. LLCIn re HoodCity of New York v. New York City Civil Service Comm'nCardona-Torres v. City of New YorkSanchez v. PierreBelik v. New York City Hous. Auth.Estate of Maltese v. Diagnostic Medical Imaging of L.I.New York Cmty. Bank v. ArichitrikSilverman v. City of New YorkMolina v. VollmersParis Suites Hotel, Inc. v. Seneca Ins. Co.Good Karma Props., LLC v. GromisVillon v Town Sports Int'l LLCKrolick v. Natixis Sec. North America Inc.American Transit Ins. Co. v. Hanover Ins. Co.Wai Mui v. N.Y.C. Board/Department of Educ.CitiMortgage, Inc. v. OrichelloVishnick v. BotesazanThomas v. PrackJ.G. Wentworth Originations, LLC v. RahmanLegnetti v. Camp Am.City of New York v. Red River Partners, LLCCollins v. KellySowich v. Cnty. of OneidaMalcolm v. Rite Aid of N.Y., Inc.Countrywide Home Loans Servicing LP v. BurroughsMoncrieffe v. City of White PlainsZweifach v. City of New YorkSRN Realty, LLC v. Scarano Architect, PLLCContractors Comp. Trust v. Jack of Hearts Carpet Mill Outlets, Inc.Ling v. TsungLee v. CosmasWinston v. DavidSpector v. Cushman & Wakefield, Inc.Habib v. Best Yet Mkt. of Hicksville Inc.Bookman v. FischerU.S. Bank Nat'l Ass'n v. BresslerKoeningsberger v. 200 Fifth Ave. Owner, LLCMosticchio v. SinghTogut v. Riverbay Corp.Halladay v. CiceroTelamerica Media, LLC v. Sound Commc'ns, Inc.Alexander v. WeinerHoffman v. Westchester Cnty.AXA Winterthur Ins. Co. v. Transvalue, Inc.Bank of America, N.A. v. OhebshalomErickson v. Cross Ready Mix, Inc.Legion of Christ, Inc. v. Town of Mount PleasantSanchez v. 1710 Broadway, Inc.Kekovic v. 13 TH St. Entm't. EECScarola Ellis LLP v. PadehDangerville v. MejiaBaldeo v. MajeedNew England Sec. Corp. v. StoneAlyssa H. v. Robinson's Ambulance & Oxygen Servs. Inc.ASSO. FOR A LONG ISLAND v. DECBaldeo v. MajeedCalderon v. American Transit Ins. Co.Hidalgo v. City of New YorkPerez v. Zumbach Sports Cars, Ltd.In re New York City Asbestos Litig.Mackey v. Consol. Edison Co. of New York, Inc.Country Pointe at Kings Park Homeowners Ass'n, Inc. v. Beech Wood Kings Park Bldg. Corp.Morales v. New York City Health & Hosps. Corp.Sondik v. KimmelGalligan v. Columbia Univ. Coll. of Physicians & SurgeonsSanatass v. Consol. Investing Co. Inc.Holy Church of the Virgin Mary Home for the Aged in Icaria v. Pan-Icarian Found.Nahar v. GulatiFassler v. FasslerGold v. KanterHSBC Bank USA, N.A. v. Taher1047 Old Northern Assoc. LLC v. KornAlbano v. DersovitzKekovic v. 13th St. Entertainment, LLCBregman v. Challenger III, LLCBoutsouris v. ENP Gen. Constr. Corp.Chiriguaya v. Arthur Ransome Houses, LPCruz v. City of New YorkQ-Plus USA, Inc. v. E. Original Inc.Andre Romanelli, Inc. v. Citibank, N.A.Payen v. W. Beef SupermarketFitzgerald v. CzubekAniqa Halal Live Poultry Corp. v. Montague-Lee Ltd. P'shipVishnick v. BotesazanSantana v. New York City Transit Auth.Avellino v. City of New YorkCastor v. PulaskiIn Matter of New South Ins. Co. v. HymanS.A. v. D.A.Sanchez v. 1710 Broadway, Inc.Rotondo v. RankellApplication of Pro Player Funding LLC v. GoodmanBluefin Wear, Inc. v. Tuesday's Child Boutique, Inc.Norton v. 360 Riverside Owners Corp.Islamaj v. Quaker Hill Venture, LLCAs. for a Better Long Is. v. State Dept. of Env. Con.Mueller v. Mitchell Maxwell & Jackson, Inc.8812 Caffe Inc. v. New York State Liquor Auth.Friedman v. Clearview Gardens Second Corp.Rapid Demolition Container Servs. Inc. v. MaldonadoGallant Funding, L.P. v. TocciGen. Electric Capital Corp. v. Ocean Marine Inc.Gershwin Partners, Inc. v. New Latham Hotel Corp.Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. v. BanksSass v. NAT VariscoISS Action Sec. v. New York City Comm'n on Human RightsMason v. Brecher, Fishman, Pasternack, Walsh, Tilker & Ziegler P.C.Klimowicz v. Powell Cove Assocs. LLCIsrael Cancer Research Fund, Inc. v. Harvey & Gloria Kaylie Foundation, Inc.Spector v. Cushman & Wakefield, Inc.Henry v. Staten Island Univ. Hosp.Holy Church of the Virgin Mary Home for the Aged in Icaria v. Pan–Icarian Found.As v. Heritage Mar. SATower Ins. Co. of N.Y. v. T S Food Mkt. Corp.Broadway Triangle Cmty. Coal. v. BloombergDurando v. City of New YorkIn Matter of Palleschi v. CassanoFlushing Sav. Bank, FSB v. RagunandanKrasnow v. VarrialeFlushing Sav. Bank FSB v. RagunandanCooke-Zwiebach v. OzielAlvarez v. New York City Hous. Auth./Riis HousesAbarca v. FournierPeople v. ChuynWatson v. New York State Div. of Hous. & Cmty. RenewalDeutsche Bank Natl. Trust Co. v. AlvaradoNew South Insurance Co. v. HymanIn re LaFave, Wein & Frament, PLLCMartin v. BuckleyIsgro v. LEV Mgmt. Corp.Rose v. Tee-Bird Golf Club, Inc.Anonymous #1 v. LaSalaEssex Ins. Co. v. Rowan Constr. Co.Oparaji v. City of New YorkBocoum v. RuhmanBd. of Managers of the Schaefer Landing North Condo. v. Cont'l Cas. Co.Norton v. 360 Riverside Owners Corp.Gallant Funding, L.P. v. TocciPatino v. DelacruzWeir v. Holland & Knight, LLPMontas v. JaipersaudRivera v. JothianandanGeorgy Mamdouh & Norama, Inc. v. LegerBudd-Morgan Cent. Station Alarm Co. v. Jekyll & Hyde, Inc.Zatulovskaya v. Four Seasons Nursing & Rehab. Ctr.C McCormack Inc. v. 6 St Nicholas LLCE.C.-P. v. P.P.Montanez v. Dep't of Educ. of the City of New YorkPeople v. AsantenaRusso v. WilloughbyDyson v. TewariEast End Cement & Stone, Inc. v. DestinoCitimortgage, Inc. v. OrichelloNew York City Health & Hosp. Corp. v. Wellcare of New York, Inc.Fireman's Fund Ins. Co. v. Laruccia Constr. Inc.WARD v. NYC HUMAN RESOURCES ADMIN.Florez-Bossio v. RodriguezUnited Nimba Citizens Council v. DorliaeHSBC Bank USA, N.A. v. CAYONahar v. GulatiFlushing Sav. Bank, FSB v. RagunandanDimapja v. JJM Pizza Corp.Kirton v. DickersonGarcia v. First Fid. Mortg. Grp. LLCVailes v. Sukhraj380 Kings Highway v. Fidelity Natl. Tit. Ins. Co.Persico v. N.Y.C. Dep't of Bldgs.Guapjno v. Land Rover North America, Inc.Zatulovskaya v. Four Seasons Nursing & Rehab. Ctr.Liberty Mutual Grp. v. KrollIn re Application of the the Vill. of HaverstrawMacKey v. Consol. Edison Co. of N.Y., Inc.SRN Realty, LLC v. Scarano Architect, PLLCSpinella v. CostantinoEssex Ins. Co. v. MondoneGrubin v. Gotham Condo.Alyssa H. v. Robinson's Ambulance & Oxygen Servs., Inc.People v. LaBarberaLim v. JilaniOlynec v. StanwickBeizer v. HirschU.S. Bank, N.A. v. RamjitLancaster Dev. Inc. v. McDonaldDeneny v. RossemDollar v. Republic Emp't Agency, Inc.Fulton v. Hankin & Mazel, PLLCMurphy v. City of N.Y.Spector v. Cushman & Wakefield, Inc.Travelers Prop. Cas. Co. of America v. Nassau Cnty. Traffic & Parking Violations AgencyPeople ex rel. Taylor v. ViernoSelective Ins. Co. of Am. v. Cnty. of RensselaerPeople v. ChuynAmalgamated Bank, v. Fort Tryon Tower SPE LLCSantana v. Cnty. of SuffolkMiller v. Sinai Van Serv. Inc.Sherman v. MulermanIngrassia v. Retail Prop. TrustChauvert v. Anitei11 Essex St. Corp. v. Tower Ins. Co. of N.Y.U.S. Bank Natl. Assn. v. BresslerVBH Luxury, Inc. v. 940 Madison Assocs. LLCLopez v. MTA/N.Y. City Tr. Auth.American Home Assurance Co. v. Highrise Constr. Co.Analisa Salon Ltd. v. Elide Props., LLCLopez v. FennHightower v. MTA Bus Co.Chiriguaya v. Arthur Ransome Houses, LPEDA Logistics Corp. v. B & B Int'l Connections, Inc.D'Agostino v. FaigelmanBrio Capital, L.P. v. Sanswire Corp.Rose v. Tee-Bird Golf Club, Inc.Citigroup Global Markets Realty Corp. v. SmithLuden v. NierodaKarakas v. RinaldiTeixeira v. City of New YorkGuglielmo v. City of New YorkAmbassador Constr. Co. v. De Jil Sys. Inc.Global Delivery Sys. LLC v. Bruce P. Benvenuti & Laser Delivery, Inc.White Mountains Specialty Underwriting, Inc. v. Gera Danbury, LLCHIGHTOWER v. MTA BUS CO.Brown v. City of New YorkLitman v. LipkinMoore v. BenowitzPalleschi v. CassanoFed. Nat'l Mortg. Ass'n v. CampbellTown Bd. v. GarveySchneiderman v. City of New York380 Kings Highway, LLC v. Fid. Nat'l Title Ins. Co.Goren v. TomasinoNorton v. 360 Riverside Owners Corp.Durando v. City of New YorkTreyman v. NalbandianGEICO Gen. Ins. Co. v. A. Cent. Ins. Co.Gibson v. FischerBrio Capital, L.P. v. Sanswire Corp.Schemitsch v. Valley Enters. Parks & Realty LLCRosenthal v. Quadriga Art, Inc.Federal National Mortgage Assn. v. CampbellCerda v. City of New YorkJames v. New York State Bd. of ParoleGoodwin v. PretoriusAAA Electricians, Inc. v. Vill. of Haverstraw (In re Vill. of Haverstraw)In Matter of Village of HaverstrawKim v. KimSchiller v. GuthriePersico v. New York City Dep't of Buildings Summit Constr. Servs. Grp., Inc. v. Act Abatement, LLCNahar v. GulatiCooke-Zwiebach v. OzielSpinella v. CostantinoDoe v. SamiishaqNat'l Fire Ins. Co. v. WrynnBickel v. Air & Liquid Sys. Corp.Giambrone v. FarhaWashington v. Albany Hous. Auth.11 Essex St. Corp. v. Tower Ins. Co. of New YorkMiller v. RossEastern Capital Grp. LLC v. 2480 Richmond Terrace Real Estate Corp.380 Kings Highway, LLC v. Fid. Nat'l Title Ins. Co.RSB Bedford Assocs. LLC v. Ricky's Williamsburg, Inc.Malaney v. AC. & S. Inc.Kivat v. KershisToner v. BasakPeople v. Delacruz