Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York December 1909 casesPeople v. BaileyMatter of FlowerRichmond v. International Railway CompanyBennett v. G. W. Manufacturing Co.OLDS v. OOTHOUDTShapiro v. KlarCity of New York v. Dowd Lumber Co.Gartland v. New York Zoological SocietyClement v. MooreNew York and Pennsylvania Company v. DezegoUvalde Asphalt Paving Co. v. National Trading Co.People ex Rel. Canton Bridge Co. v. Town AuditorsMATTER OF DE GROOTLawrence v. Sun Printing and Publishing Ass'nSwenson v. Norcross Brothers CompanyBaker v. DuffDaigneault v. Hudson Valley Railway CompanyFilippone v. ReisenburgerBushby v. BerkeleyMitcheltree v. StairSchaaf v. HaberDexter v. Jetter Brewing CompanyCommonwealth Mortgage Co. v. De WaltoffMulligan v. McDonaldCharles v. NickersonBoyer v. International Railway CompanyPeople v. Long Island Railroad CompanyMontant v. MooreCiccarelli v. Naughton Co. McMullenDevlin v. Brooklyn Heights Railroad CompanyFlatow v. Jefferson BankMatter of FallonSchlicht v. Jewett CompanyGuerrier v. ColemanWheeler v. Phenix Insurance CompanyPratt, Hurst Co., Limited v. TailerWheelright v. StrausChurch v. N.Y. Central Hudson River R.R. CZwecker v. LevineNicholls v. NichollsHathaway v. Clendening Co.Darrow v. LeeMcCahill v. New York Transportation Co.Heidgerd v. ReisPeople v. DeckerTwin State Gas Elec. Co. v. Knickerbocker T. Co.Eder v. Post & McCordMatter of McCall CompanyFraker v. Hyde SonsPeople ex Rel. Gordon v. ButlerKozak v. Erie Railroad Co.Leyer v. PoloPeople ex Rel. McCarthy v. BinghamMeyer v. CrimminsBadger v. Hamilton Fire Insurance CompanyMakoski v. Union Bag Paper Co.People ex rel. Fifth Avenue Building Co. v. GausMatter of Title Guarantee Trust Co. v. BrownMcKee v. City of New YorkMitchell v. MurrayDeitsch v. Martin Bowne CompanyPeople ex Rel. New York Edison Co. v. Wells. No. 3Kahn v. TierneyReusens v. ArkenburghPress Publishing Co. v. EhrichMatter of GartlandBadger v. Springfield Underwriters Mut. F. Ins. Co.Kelley Lumber Co. v. Otselic Valley Railroad Co.Kelly v. DoubledayMatter of WalbridgeMatter of GeyerPacker v. Van WagenenCunningham v. Sheltering ArmsGibbs v. LeslieKohly v. FernandezMcCargo v. JergensO'Mara, Jr. v. MorganCollins v. Ferguson Contracting CompanyArnold v. National Starch CompanyMcGovern v. JolineMatter of JosephParis v. Little Giant Realty CompanyPeople v. RiceSeaman v. McLauryMcKinley v. HessenBenvegna v. United Surety CompanyKlinck v. KeppyChurch of Transfiguration v. St. Stephen's ChurchWeil v. Corn Exchange BankBaumfeld v. BlitzKennedy v. FlynnLake v. LakeTrustees, Columbia College v. N.Y. Elev. R.RHoffman v. Metropolitan Life Insurance Co.Seymour v. Evening Herald CompanyColeman v. ClarkHoffman v. HauptnerHoffman v. WulsteinPeople v. DunnMATTER OF DE GROOTJones v. SabinPeople v. HlavacekRanken v. ProbeyCarey Printing Co. v. Toilettes Fashion Co.Charniack v. RavitchMurphy v. Prudential Insurance CompanyMatter of ChildsAllegro v. John Peirce CompanyLanglois v. BelmoreErie Basin Improvement Co. v. SmithPeople ex Rel. New York Edison Co. v. Wells. No. 6Matter of RobinsonRoper v. Ulster County Agricultural SocietyPeople ex Rel. Rottenberg v. Utah Gold Copper MWilson v. Central Insurance Co., LimitedHarris v. Lehigh Valley Railroad CompanyMatter of HardenbrookOakes v. SloaneMcElraevy Hauck Company v. KronengoldSchwartz v. State BankFiesel v. White Sewing Machine CompanyStafford v. Canavan Brothers Co.Lewis v. GehlenKellogg v. Church Charity FoundationPeople ex rel. Rota v. BakerBecker v. McCreaRosenberg v. GitelsonIvers v. Continental Casualty CompanyDuffy v. ShirdenMatter of RieserKnickerbocker Trust Company v. SabineMetcalfe v. Board, Edu., Union Free S. DistSlattery v. BartolicusMatter of O'ReillyMatter of GoodmanLEFI v. KNAUTHSchwerdtle v. W.E. Pruden Hardware CompanySpencer v. Binghamton Railway CompanySeaward v. DavisDenny v. Lake Ontario Bay, Quinte S.B. Co.Weissberger v. WallachPaolicchi v. PaolicchiPeople v. MorgensternSeely v. FletcherBENEVOLENT PROT. v. IMPROVED BENEVOLENT PROTHamell v. SpottswoodKiendl v. DubroffPeople ex Rel. Zotti v. FlynnSussman v. EdelmanContinental Insurance Co. v. ReeveBarnes v. Southfield Beach Railroad CompanyPeople v. PersceRothenberg v. Brooklyn Heights Railroad Co.Clement v. MayDecora v. American Carbide Co.People ex Rel. Third Avenue R.R. Co. v. Tax ComrsWerner v. HerbstMatter of Phillips v. HoganO'Reilly v. MeyerParham v. BurnsTeitler v. EganFisher v. Wakefield Park Realty Co.Matter of City of New YorkMatter of FlanneryStrammer v. MendelsonSizer v. Kline Bros. CompanyDoherty v. Catskill Cement CompanyMatter of CurtissMatter of EllwangerClement v. StrattonKilmurry v. BulkleySchuss v. BruggemannDayton v. ElixmanNew York Cement Company v. National Fire Ins. Co.Jacobs v. FowlerBarber v. Ellingwood. No. 1Cuba v. DruskinGore v. New York Central Hudson River R.R. CGoldberg v. Eastern Brewing CompanyMoses v. SouleGreen v. DunlopTanners National Bank of Catskill v. LacsRead v. Lehigh and New York Railroad CompanyTanenbaum v. BoehmGreen v. DickinsonRice v. MacArthur Brothers CompanyMatter of Grade Damage CommissionCommonwealth Mortgage Co. v. CarruthMatter of HollinsIngalls Stone Co. v. NunnMatter of SmithMatter of SimmonsMatter of BarkerLehman-Charley v. BartlettMatter of Grade Crossing Comm., City of BuffaloMiles v. Casualty CompanyWalsh v. CaulfieldMatter of Mayhew v. BoldmanRutherfurd v. CarpenterHarrison v. ScottMatter of IckelheimerSlobodin v. Sun Printing and Publishing Ass'nCousins v. SchlichterChalmers v. LaubackMannion v. SteffensGrimmer v. Tenement House DepartmentPeople ex Rel. Scott v. ReidCity Equity Company v. JonesRoss v. EpsteinMaloney v. KatzensteinNew York Central H.R.R.R. Co. v. City of N.YBackman v. TophamMcCoy v. Gas Engine Power Co.DOTY v. NORTONN.Y. Produce Exchange Bank v. Twelfth Ward BankPerrin v. WhippleHedden Construction Co. v. Procter Gamble Co.Kinkaid v. Chapter General of AmericaPeople ex Rel. Stern v. McGowanPEOPLE EX REL. DE GROOT v. BD., CTY. CANVASSERSWallach v. R. Hudnut's PharmacyHamilton v. HamiltonHahn v. Conried Metropolitan Opera CompanySilverman v. Silverman-Jones Construction CompanyOstermann v. WareMatter of StevensonBlumquist v. Snare Triest Co.Croft v. Rockville Centre CompanyComora v. PearlbergCondon v. New Rochelle Water CompanyHoward v. City Club of New YorkPeople v. BromwichSchieffelin v. McClellanPeople v. CarloDambmann v. Metropolitan Street Railway CompanySchultz v. United States Fidelity GuarantyMatter of ChadseyMatter of SchlosserDensmore v. DensmoreSeredinski v. BalabanStreat v. WolfCourtney v. McArdleButnors v. National Sugar Refining CompanyHebert v. Hudson River Electric Co.Boyd v. Improved Property Holding Co.National Bank of Glens Falls v. W.F. Burns CompanyMedbury v. WrightSchaffhauser v. Liebmann's Sons Brewing CompanyMatter of MajotWeyand v. Park Terrace CompanyStringer v. BarkerPeck v. FriderichLIND v. LONG ISLAND RAILROAD COMPANYCampbell v. Frontier Telephone CompanyIn re BeckHack v. DadyYudicki v. Hodgman Rubber CompanyLong Island Railroad Company v. City of New YorkWebster Realty Co. v. DelanoPeople ex Rel. N.Y.C. H.R.R.R. Co. v. GourleyDuckworth v. McSorleyPeople v. Paul Smith's Elec. L. Power R.RMatter of Del GenoveseRaymond v. TiffanyKlein v. LidvallCarlin v. New York, New Haven Hartford R.R. Co.Brant v. SiegerPeople v. MarenoMatter of Mayhew v. BoldmanScully v. ScullyDavids v. DavidsMatter of CunnionTaylor v. HiggsWinkler v. H. Clausen SonPeople ex Rel. Drake v. AndrewsLinder v. JolineBean v. Trust Company of AmericaBartholoma v. Town of FlorenceCommercial Trust Co. v. PeckSiemann v. New York Transportation CompanyMatter of City of New YorkRosen v. Philipsborn Co.Kascsak v. Central Railroad of New JerseyMann v. Press Publishing Co.Cohen v. Fisher Co.National Park Bank v. RandoBermingham v. G.H. Gerard Son CompanyBloom v. MintzTredwell v. SmithOsterhoudt v. Prudential Insurance Co.John D. Park Sons Company v. HubbardFeatherstone Fdry. Mach. v. N.Y. Breweries CMatter of ClementWolf v. RudinskyHavana Central R.R. Co. v. Knickerbocker Trust Co.Philip Realty Construction Co. v. ChubinWebster Realty Company v. GeratyWeinstock v. Clarendon Improvement CompanyGadlowski v. West Virginia Pulp and Paper CompanyPeople v. WeissParcell v. New York Central Hudson River R.ROnorato v. McLarnonMcClure v. Union Railway CompanyGotthelf v. ShapiroFunger v. Brooklyn Bottle Stopper CompanyDwyer v. New York Central H.R.R.R. Co.United States of America v. BreenRosenbluth v. SurutAlbany, Schoharie v. Whitehead Bro. CompanyZimmermann v. WeberMatter of WilliamsCobb v. United Engineering and Contracting CompanyMatthews v. EliasBreeze v. BayneWright v. DayGraham v. ReisSchleissner v. GoldstickerPeople v. WaltmanPeople v. O'BrienDavidge v. Guardian Trust Co.People ex Rel. New York Edison Co. v. Wells. No. 4Northrup v. WheelerSchneittacher v. Illustrated Postal CardThompson v. AldenBrody v. Hudson CompaniesGoodyear Raincoat Company v. KrigerLawlor v. Densmore-Compton Building CompanyBush v. New York Life Insurance Co.Gouverneur Village v. Gouverneur Cemetery AssnKemp v. New York Central H.R.R.R. Co.Cohen v. Hancock Mutual Life Ins. Co.MATTER OF HOTZMatter of BackusFlynn v. JolineStonehill v. HastingsFox v. LennonKreshover v. BergerAinsworth v. Dutchess Hat WorksFerry v. DunhamSedalia Trust C. v. Development Co., AmericaRoosen v. DenikeLifer v. Alsen's American Portland Cement WorksJoseph v. HerzigTeschmacher v. ClementO'Reilly v. GallagherSwartz v. BrownSchulze v. FarrellClarke v. KoeppelStanbridge v. Nassau Electric Railroad Co.Swift Co. v. New York Queens County Railway Co.Shaw v. Jordan Co.WOODING v. THOMSchuller v. TodaroBlair v. New York Transportation CompanyCollins v. BeckerLyons v. N.Y. Central Hudson River R.R. Co.Morat v. NewtonFairbanks v. NicholsCleminshaw v. CoonMatter of LeavittBokor v. H. Koehler CompanySavage v. New York Press Company, LimitedPeople ex Rel. Lindemann v. BinghamRosenblum v. WoodPeople v. ReynoldsRyan v. Prudential Insurance CompanyWood v. BoeseMatter of MoeserConey Island Associates v. TealeJenkins v. BishopNicholls v. WallaceNordstrom v. Sun Printing and Publishing AssocLawlor v. New York and New England Realty CompanyDuffy v. MeyerBrady v. Hudson River and Eastern Traction CompanyMatter of City of New YorkChurch v. N.Y. Central Hudson River R.R. Co.Matter of TailerBarney v. HoytChurch v. Tribune AssociationMcCaffrey v. Baltimore and Ohio Railroad CompanyOutcault v. LamarHerrmann Grace v. City of New YorkCity of New York v. New York Mutual Gas Light Co.Havana Central R.R. v. Knickerbocker Trust Co.Rice v. RiceKliewer v. Hudson and Manhattan Railroad CompanyPutman v. GrahamAnthony v. Moore Munger Co.Hedges v. KeiserClough v. Lackawanna Steel CompanyWitkov v. DruckerPeople ex Rel. McLaughlin v. AumenwerthSachse v. WohlPratt v. McKeePeople ex Rel. Metro. Life Ins. Co. v. HotchkissCasey v. ClarkePeople ex Rel. White v. CraneLehman-Charley v. BartlettLevin v. HessbergBarnett v. Vaughan InstituteCohn v. WahnPeople ex Rel. Holtzmann v. City of SchenectadyHynes v. WhitridgeThayer v. BurrDeutsch v. HaabMATTER OF PAPEArmstrong v. Quayle SonPaine v. LanrowitzPechette v. New York and Queens County RailwayPeople v. Star Co.Lee v. Western Electric Co.Krippendorf v. MarkO'Conor v. McElroyHoffman v. HoffmanWeyand v. Park Terrace Co.Friedland v. Commonwealth Fire Insurance Co.Kiernan v. Gutta Percha Rubber Mfg. Co.DOTY v. NORTONSecord v. BroadheadSmith v. ReedFritz v. MouakadEgelston v. New York, Chicago St. Louis R.RMatter of Change of Grade CommissionInternational Cheese Company v. Phenix CheeseLubbee v. HilgertMcGovern v. Commercial Union Telephone CompanyMatter of German Legal Aid AssociationBadger v. Helvetia Swiss Fire Insurance Co.Matter of Sheehan Co.DE RENSIS v. D'AMICOPEOPLE v. DE BARBERIFerguson Contracting Co. v. Helderberg Cement Co.Morgenthaler v. HullGahan v. Westchester Electric Railroad CompanyInternational Paper Co. v. PurdyDelany v. CarpenterPeople ex Rel. Patrick v. FrostPeople ex Rel. MacFayden v. MetzThompson v. ThompsonRobins v. BertramShane v. City of New YorkHunter v. BaconMattson v. Phœnix Construction Co.Caleo v. GoldsteinZagarino v. KurzrokLeverich v. GorinFISCHEL v. LESEStone v. Cleveland, Cincinnati, ChicagoKelly Asphalt Block Co. v. Barber Asphalt PavingRaymond v. TiffanyCooper v. JordanKerns v. DavenportMeadows v. MichelBancroft v. Interborough EstatesJoseph v. Schwarzschild Sulzberger CompanyBall v. ShepardLandsberg & Co. v. Hein Construction Co.Gest v. City and County Contract Co.Kelly v. New York Central Hudson River R.RCarey v. American Ice CompanyHarrison v. UlrichsLake v. SwensonGibson v. City of ElmiraGoodman v. CaseyAnderson Price Company v. City of New YorkPeople v. GreenMatter of CurtisMatter of City of New YorkBecker v. JungO'Brien v. Naughton CompanyStewart v. GarfordEnright v. Murtha Schmohl CompanyPeople ex Rel. Post v. MetzCurtis v. GoldbergSchaefer v. HutchinsonPeople v. HarrisPeople v. KenneyKohler v. RosenthalFlynn v. New York Taxicab CompanyPowell v. Cohoes Railway Co.Fitzgerald v. Union Laundry CompanyStrelitzer v. SchnaierPorges v. United States Mortgage Trust Co.People v. Erie Railroad Co.People ex rel. Goff v. KirkRamsay v. MillerDaily v. Press Publishing CompanyKolb v. MortimerFletcher v. Bankers Life Insurance Co.Cole v. TozerYoung v. LoshenBaumfeld v. German Theatre, Inc.People ex Rel. McLaughlin v. AmmenwerthRappaport v. OttenMatter of HiscoxMatter of GriffinBell v. N.Y. Central and Hudson River RailroadMatter of WebbBingham v. GaynorMatter of AmidonPeople ex Rel. Scharff v. FrostEly v. RussellN.Y. Central Hudson River R.R. C. v. WilliamsBitterman v. WeinsteinBaldwin v. FederConsolidated Rubber Tire v. Firestone Tire RPitman v. SmithHagadone v. Normoyle Quailey, IncorporatedGuggenheim v. GuggenheimMatter of Mayor, Aldermen Commonalty, N.YMushaw v. City of AmsterdamMulvany v. Chapter General of AmericaLageza v. Chelsea Fibre MillsDean v. HornbostelMalfino v. Eastern Tablet CompanyDe Long v. ZetoVan Wicklen v. Van WicklenMatter of Commissioner of Public WorksPendleton v. FriedmanRyan v. HalliganBuckley v. City of New YorkMatter of Liquid Carbonic Company v. MatthewsBarsantee v. Clyde Steamship CompanyNorton Gorman Contr. v. Uvalde Asphalt PavingLoughran v. Jordan L. Mott Iron WorksPeople v. VietersonIsaacs v. Illinois Surety CompanyKlein v. VogelGoodman v. RothFlynn v. New York, Westchester Boston R. Co.Hammond v. Union Bag Paper Co.PEOPLE v. THOMPeople v. HoughtonPeople ex Rel. Nichols v. Board of Town AuditorsVan Veghten v. Whitehead Brothers CompanyMatter of TibbittsMatthews v. Title Guaranty and Surety CompanyPeople ex Rel. White v. MaddoxRenwick v. WeedenConklin v. N.Y., Ontario Western Railway CMitchell v. Dunmore Realty Co.St. John's College v. Ætna Indemnity Co.Mills v. KampfeTyndall v. CemeteryHurley v. OlcottCohen v. Williamsburgh Savings BankO'Hare v. O'Rourke Engineering Construction Co.Hoagland v. BrownStiebel v. GrosbergVail v. R.G. Peters Salt and Lumber CompanyMatter of ValletteErie Railroad Company v. WilliamsSalvation Army in U.S. v. American Salvation ArmyMatter of HotchkissInnis, Speiden Company v. NevinsHayes v. Brooklyn Heights Railroad CompanyVan Etten v. SchmahlFlynn v. New York Taxicab CompanyKorn v. LoewPlunkett v. Lehigh Valley Railroad CompanyRead v. Lehigh Valley Railroad CompanyPerrin v. SmithMcFarland v. Elmira Water, Light R.R. Co.Bail v. New York, New Haven Hartford R.R. CQuinn Nolan Beverwyck Brewing Company v. BossHackett v. H. Koehler CompanyCohn v. Catskill Mountain Railway CompanyMatter of LadewWoodbury v. BuggelnMcCall Co. v. WrightDehn v. ShermanMatter of KingMutchnick v. FriedmanNew Hartford Cotton Mfg. Company v. LowensteinAmerican Exchange National Bank v. GoubertCity Equity Co. v. Elm Park Realty Co.Gavin v. New York Contracting CompanyMatter of SloaneCallanan v. PowersNat. Conduit Cable Co. v. Commercial Un. AssurBoyer v. BoyerMatter of SmithCarcione v. McDonaldBrown v. National Fire Insurance CompanyThompson Co. v. BoudinMatter of City of New YorkDraffen v. WalkerWyckoff, Church Partridge v. Riverside BankFallert v. FallertDisken v. ToplitzLapier v. GonyoMatter of BlochRosenberg v. HalpertMoore v. Rochester Railway CompanyMott v. IngalsbeMasterson v. Crosstown Street Railway CompanyCandee, Smith Howland Company v. CityBuckley v. HasellMatter of IckelheimerGallagher v. GallagherWertheim v. Maintenance Co.Van Haaren v. Long Island Railroad Co.Hollins v. BourneSiff v. ForbesTrumbley v. N.Y. Central Hudson River R.RBosca v. Brooklyn, Queens Cty. Suburban R.RHickok v. Auburn Light, Heat and Power CompanyMatter of Co Operative Law CompanyDraper v. Interborough Rapid Transit CompanyKAZMAN v. LYONS BEET SUGAR REFINING COMPANYAldrich v. Borden's Condensed Milk CompanyLynch v. PeirceReider v. Michigan Central Railroad CompanyManko v. Girard Fire and Marine Insurance CompanyBogert v. TurnerTyndall v. CemeteryBrooklyn Dock Terminal Co. v. BahrenburgMatter of ChapmanEitingon v. GoldsmithBecker v. HartCzibilisky v. Solvay Process CompanyPeople ex Rel. Vineing v. HayesMilliken Brothers, Inc. v. City of New YorkPeople v. American Ice Co.Treadwell v. United Verde Copper CompanyThedford v. HerbertBrady v. New York Central and Hudson River R.RMatter of MaverickMcDuffie v. Financier Co.Creatore v. CreatoreKina v. Machwirth Brothers CompanyO'Connor v. City of New YorkMiller v. CampbellHeiter v. JolineSperry Hutchinson Co. v. O'Neill-Adams Co.Dell v. FletcherJones v. DennehyHyland v. Baker and Shevlin CompanyAndrews v. AndrewsCohen v. AbrahamTonkonogy v. FuchsLa Duke v. Hudson River Telephone Co.SZAG v. PENNSYLVANIA RAILROAD COMPANYPeople v. O'BrienWynn v. CarlinPeople v. FisherShalet v. StoloffPaladino v. Brooklyn Heights Railroad CompanyBrangaccio v. Weber Piano CompanySteele v. Leopold