From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Wiggins v. Brown

Court of Civil Appeals of Alabama
Dec 10, 1980
391 So. 2d 128 (Ala. Civ. App. 1980)


Civ. 2459.

December 10, 1980.

Appeal from the Circuit Court, Monroe County, Robert E.L. Key, J.

V. Wylynn Gilmore of Gilmore Keahey, Grove Hill, for appellant.

Windell C. Owens, Monroeville, for appellee.

The plaintiff filed his negligence action for damages occasioned by an automobile accident. The nonjury trial resulted in a judgment in favor of the defendant, from which the plaintiff appeals. We affirm.

The plaintiff, a sister, a brother and a cousin each testified as to facts indicating that the defendant was liable for the rear end collision. On the other hand, a state trooper disagreed in part with some of such evidence as to terrain features at the place of the accident and as to what had been said to him by the plaintiff and his sister. The defendant's son's evidence cast some doubt upon the ability of one or two of the plaintiff's witnesses to have observed the accident. Without objection, the defendant swore that he was driving from thirty-five to forty feet behind the plaintiff's automobile when it suddenly stopped "and I locked the wheels and slid on into them. I couldn't miss it."

The plaintiff contends that the judgment was contrary to the great weight of the evidence. We have summarized only so much of the evidence as to demonstrate that the trial evidence was in substantial disagreement. Under the contradictory testimony, it was within the special province of the trial court to determine both the weight and the credibility to be accorded to the testimony of each witness:

It is well settled that where the record shows that a case is tried by the court, sitting without a jury, upon disputed facts heard orally, the conclusion of the trial judge will be affirmed if it is fairly supported by credible evidence under any reasonable aspect, and is not palpably wrong or manifestly unjust. [Citations omitted.]

Whitt v. McConnell, Ala., 360 So.2d 336 (1978).

We have reviewed and examined the entire transcript in detail. The evidence credibly supported the trial court's judgment, which is neither wrong nor unjust.

The foregoing opinion was prepared by retired circuit judge EDWARD N. SCRUGGS while serving on active duty status as a judge of this court under the provisions of § 12-18-10 (e) of the Code of Alabama of 1975. His opinion is hereby adopted as that of the court.


All the Judges concur.

Summaries of

Wiggins v. Brown

Court of Civil Appeals of Alabama
Dec 10, 1980
391 So. 2d 128 (Ala. Civ. App. 1980)
Case details for

Wiggins v. Brown

Case Details

Full title:Thomas WIGGINS v. Joe BROWN, Sr

Court:Court of Civil Appeals of Alabama

Date published: Dec 10, 1980


391 So. 2d 128 (Ala. Civ. App. 1980)

Citing Cases

Surginer v. Roberts

" ' " Kennedy, 53 So.3d at 68 (quoting Reed v. Board of Trs. for Alabama State Univ., 778 So.2d 791, 795…

Shackleford v. Brumley

The conclusions of the circuit court will be affirmed on appeal if they were supported by credible evidence…