From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Waugh v. Casazza

Supreme Court of Nevada
Sep 8, 1969
85 Nev. 520 (Nev. 1969)

Summary

holding that district court has final appellate jurisdiction in cases arising in the justice's court

Summary of this case from Charles v. Discover Bank

Opinion

No. 5903

September 8, 1969

Appeal from judgment of the Second Judicial District Court, Washoe County; John F. Sexton, J.

Paul J. Williams, of Reno, for Appellant.

Streeter, Sala McAuliffe, of Reno, for Respondent.


OPINION


This action for unlawful detainer was commenced and tried in the justice's court, appealed and tried anew in the district court with the same result, and is now on appeal to this court. The respondent has moved to dismiss the appeal on the ground that this court lacks jurisdiction to consider it. We agree.

The appellant's contention that she enjoys a right to a double appeal rests mainly upon the 1876 case of Dickson v. Corbett, 10 Nev. 439. That case involved a suit to foreclose a mechanics lien for less than $300, was commenced in the justice's court, appealed and tried anew in the district court, and then appealed to the supreme court. There, as here, the respondent moved to dismiss the appeal. His motion was denied and the appeal entertained. The basic reason for doing so, however, was the existence of a statute [Vol. 1, Compiled Laws of Nev. § 1391, § 330] which specifically provided for appeals from the district court in cases brought into that court by appeal. The court wished to accommodate a co-ordinate branch of the government. Id. at 442. That statute was repealed long ago. Neither statute nor rule presently exists providing for an appeal to this court of a case brought to the district court by appeal. Whatever force Dickson v. Corbett, supra, once possessed has long since evaporated.

The district court has final appellate jurisdiction in cases arising in the justice's court. Nev. Const. art. 6, § 6; NRS 3.190(2), and NJRCP 72-75 specifies how civil appeals are to be perfected. This action for unlawful detainer was properly commenced in the justice's court [Nev. Const. art. 6, § 8; NRS 40.410; NRS 4.370(h)] since the relationship of landlord and tenant existed. Accordingly, there was no need to certify the matter to the district court for primary trial as an action involving title or possession to real estate. Fitchett v. Henley, 31 Nev. 326, 102 P. 865 (1909); NRS 66.070. The fact that the district court enjoys a concurrent jurisdiction over actions for unlawful detainer is irrelevant to the issue before us.

Appeal dismissed.

COLLINS, C.J., ZENOFF, BATJER, and MOWBRAY, JJ., concur.


Summaries of

Waugh v. Casazza

Supreme Court of Nevada
Sep 8, 1969
85 Nev. 520 (Nev. 1969)

holding that district court has final appellate jurisdiction in cases arising in the justice's court

Summary of this case from Charles v. Discover Bank

holding that district court has final appellate jurisdiction in cases arising in the justice's court

Summary of this case from Tagle v. State

holding that district court has final appellate jurisdiction in cases arising in the justice's court

Summary of this case from Trogdon v. State

holding that district court has final appellate jurisdiction in cases arising in the justice's court

Summary of this case from Gager v. State

holding that district court has final appellate jurisdiction in cases arising in the justice's court

Summary of this case from Volpicelli v. Nev. Dep't of Corr.

holding that district court has final appellate jurisdiction in cases arising in the justice's court

Summary of this case from Ruiz v. Nev. Dep't of Corr.

noting that "the district court has final appellate jurisdiction in cases arising in the justice's court"

Summary of this case from Gaule v. Cramer

noting that "[t]he district court has final appellate jurisdiction in cases arising in the justice's court"

Summary of this case from Goudy v. Reuter

noting that "[t]he district court has final appellate jurisdiction in cases arising in the justice's court"

Summary of this case from Morris v. State Gaming Control Bd.

noting that "[t]he district court has final appellate jurisdiction in cases arising in the justice's court"

Summary of this case from Leslie v. Zgo Trust

noting that "[t]he district court has final appellate jurisdiction in cases arising in the justice's court"

Summary of this case from Santos v. Neven

noting that "[t]he district court has final appellate jurisdiction in cases arising in the justice's court"

Summary of this case from Webb v. Nev. Dep't of Corr.

noting that "[t]he district court has final appellate jurisdiction in cases arising in the justice's court"

Summary of this case from Misiewicz v. Las Vegas Metro. Police Dep't

noting that "[t]he district court has final appellate jurisdiction in cases arising in the justice's court"

Summary of this case from Johnson v. Nev. Dep't of Prison

noting that "[t]he district court has final appellate jurisdiction in cases arising in the justice's court"

Summary of this case from Perez v. Cox

noting that "[t]he district court has final appellate jurisdiction in cases arising in the justice's court"

Summary of this case from Buyten v. Millard Realty & Constr.

noting that "[t]he district court has final appellate jurisdiction in cases arising in the justice's court"

Summary of this case from Brown v. Nev. Dep't of Corr.

noting that "[t]he district court has final appellate jurisdiction in cases arising in the justice's court"

Summary of this case from Alexander v. Gooss

noting appeal to Supreme Court from district court's review of justice court decision is improper, though there may be an exception if such an appeal is provided for by statute

Summary of this case from Stilwell v. City of N. Las Vegas

noting that "[t]he district court has final appellate jurisdiction in cases arising in the justice's court"

Summary of this case from Woodson v. Travis

noting appeal to Supreme Court from district court's review of justice court decision is improper, though there may be an exception if such an appeal is provided for by statute

Summary of this case from Stilwell v. City of N. Las Vegas

noting that "[t]he district court has final appellate jurisdiction in cases arising in the justice's court"

Summary of this case from Russell v. Pappas

noting that "[t]he district court has final appellate jurisdiction in cases arising in the justice's court"

Summary of this case from Kapetan v. Adamoli

noting that “[t]he district court has final appellate jurisdiction in cases arising in the justice's court”

Summary of this case from Hughes v. Sweringen

noting that “[t]he district court has final appellate jurisdiction in cases arising in the justice's court”

Summary of this case from Ray v. Deutsche Bank Nat'l Trust Co.
Case details for

Waugh v. Casazza

Case Details

Full title:ELEANOR WAUGH, APPELLANT, v. JOSEPH CASAZZA, RESPONDENT

Court:Supreme Court of Nevada

Date published: Sep 8, 1969

Citations

85 Nev. 520 (Nev. 1969)
458 P.2d 359

Citing Cases

Woodson v. Walmart, Inc.

The district courts have final appellate jurisdiction over cases arising in the justice courts. Nev, Const.…

Woodson v. Travis

Specifically, this appeal arises from the district court's appellate review of a justice court decision, and…