From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research


Court of Appeals of Alabama
Dec 19, 1916
15 Ala. App. 419 (Ala. Crim. App. 1916)


Decided December 19, 1916.

APPEAL from Montgomery City Court.

Heard before Hon. C.P. MCINTYRE.

W.R. BRASSELL, for appellant. WARREN S. REESE, for appellee.

Detinue by Cornelia Thomas against J.B. Posey and another. Judgment for defendants, and plaintiff appeals. Reversed and remanded.

Plaintiff claimed under a purchase, while defendant claimed under a mortgage executed by Ben Thomas, the husband of Cornelia Thomas, the plaintiff, and a taking of the wagon under the mortgage. It was admitted that Cornelia did not sign the mortgage. In his argument to the jury the attorney for defendant said that Mr. Posey was a reputable white man, a conductor on a railroad train, and that plaintiff was a negro woman, but in making up your verdict you must not let this interfere one way or the other.

(1, 2) The uncontroverted evidence shows that the wagon in controversy was the property of the plaintiff, that she did not sign the mortgage held by the defendant, and that he acquired no title or interest in the wagon through said mortgage. The mere fact that Ben Thomas, the husband of the plaintiff, used the wagon, would not impair plaintiff's title, or afford an inference that Ben owned the wagon. In such a case, the possession will be referred to the title. — Rollins v. State, 98 Ala. 79, 13 So. 2820.

The plaintiff's motion for new trial should have been granted; and for the error committed by the court in refusing a new trial, the judgment of the city court is reversed. — Cobb v. Malone, 92 Ala. 630, 9 So. 738.

(3) That portion of the argument of defendant's counsel excepted to was highly improper, and should have been excluded.

Reversed and remanded.

Summaries of


Court of Appeals of Alabama
Dec 19, 1916
15 Ala. App. 419 (Ala. Crim. App. 1916)
Case details for


Case Details

Full title:Thomas v. Posey, et al. Detinue

Court:Court of Appeals of Alabama

Date published: Dec 19, 1916


15 Ala. App. 419 (Ala. Crim. App. 1916)
73 So. 747

Citing Cases

Simon v. Still

Counsel discuss many of the issues presented by the assignments of error, with citation of authority, but in…

Life Casualty Ins. Co. v. Bell

f a written instrument made the basis of the suit is admissible in evidence, the original instrument itself…