From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

State v. Raulie

Supreme Court of New Mexico
Jun 23, 1936
40 N.M. 318 (N.M. 1936)


No. 4177.

June 23, 1936.

Appeal from District Court, Curry County; Taylor, Judge.

J.C. Gilbert, of Roswell, for appellant.

Frank H. Patton, Atty. Gen., and Edward P. Chase, Asst. Atty. Gen., for the State.

An information was filed in the district court of Curry county charging the appellant with the crime of mayhem. Comp.St. 1929, § 35-401. Upon trial and verdict of guilty, appellant was sentenced to a term in the penitentiary of not less than one nor more than two years. From the verdict and sentence the case is here on appeal.

We have carefully reviewed the evidence. It is needless to set forth the same here at length. All that the prosecution proved was a fist fight and brawl. We can find no evidence in the record wherein a conviction of the appellant upon the charge of mayhem can be sustained. True the appellant punched the prosecuting witness in the mouth, which punch cut his lip and required some stitches put in; yet no permanent injury to the lip has been shown. No evidence is in the record showing that the prosecuting witness has been maimed or disfigured. Without such showing the offense is not complete. 8 R.C.L. 305.

"Where the evidence in a criminal case not only fails to support the verdict, but shows conclusively that the defendant did not commit the crime charged, this court, of its own motion, will take notice of the fact, and reverse the judgment, notwithstanding the defendant is precluded from insisting on the error by reason of failure to take and preserve proper exceptions in the court below." State v. Garcia, 19 N.M. 414, 143 P. 1012.

We would be derelict in our duty to permit a man to be sent to the penitentiary charged with mayhem, when all the evidence merely proves an assault and battery.

For the reasons given, the case will be reversed, with directions to discharge the appellant.

It is so ordered.

SADLER, C.J., and HUDSPETH, BICKLEY, and BRICE, JJ., concur.

Summaries of

State v. Raulie

Supreme Court of New Mexico
Jun 23, 1936
40 N.M. 318 (N.M. 1936)
Case details for

State v. Raulie

Case Details

Full title:STATE v. RAULIE

Court:Supreme Court of New Mexico

Date published: Jun 23, 1936


40 N.M. 318 (N.M. 1936)
59 P.2d 359

Citing Cases

United States v. Cook

But what is important now is not the victim's capacity for attack or defense, but the integrity of his…

People v. Turner

It is true the Goodman court cited a New Mexico Supreme Court opinion and said mayhem would not include the…