From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

State v. Deshotel

Supreme Court of Louisiana
May 31, 1996
674 So. 2d 260 (La. 1996)


No. 96-KK-0778

May 31, 1996

IN RE: Deshotel, James Earl; — Defendant(s); Applying for Supervisory and/or Remedial Writs; to the Court of Appeal, Third Circuit, Number CW95 1701; Parish of St. Landry 27th Judicial District Court Div. "C" Number 94-2968.

Writ granted; case remanded. See per curiam.








BLEICH, J. not on panel.

Writ granted; case remanded. Louisiana sanctions the use of deadly force to prevent commission of a violent or forcible felony carrying the risk of death or of great bodily harm directed against the person. La.Rev.Stat. 14:20 (2); State v. Plumlee, 177 La. 687, 698-699, 149 So. 425 (1933); Carmouche v. Bouis, 6 La. Ann. 95, 97 (1851); State v. Chandler, 5 La. Ann. 489, 490-491 (1850). Other jurisdictions share this approach. See Warren LaFave and Austin Scott, Substantive Criminal Law, § 5.7 (West 1986); Wharton's Criminal Law, §§ 127-130 (Torcia ed. 1979). The circumstances must be such that a reasonable person would conclude "that there would be serious danger to his own life or person . . . ." La.Rev.Stat. 14:20 (2). If supported by the evidence presented at trial, the defendant is entitled to an instruction, which may be delivered by the trial court under its general duty to charge jurors "[a]s to the law applicable to the case," La. Code Crim.Proc. art. 802 (1), that an individual is entitled to act in self-defense upon a reasonable belief that he would thereby prevent the intentional infliction of serious bodily injury to his person. The reasonableness of the accused's perception of the impending harm, as well as the reasonableness of his response, are matters exclusively for the jury. Consideration of the disputed jury charges is pretermitted. The case is remanded to the district court for further proceedings consistent with the views expressed here.

___________________________ Associate Justice

Bleich, J. not on panel.

Summaries of

State v. Deshotel

Supreme Court of Louisiana
May 31, 1996
674 So. 2d 260 (La. 1996)
Case details for

State v. Deshotel

Case Details


Court:Supreme Court of Louisiana

Date published: May 31, 1996


674 So. 2d 260 (La. 1996)

Citing Cases

State v. Hurst

If supported by the evidence at trial, the defendant is entitled to an instruction, that may be delivered by…

State v. Curley

And, though BWS expert testimony may be relevant to the defendant's credibility, seeHumphrey , supra , 56…