Not overruled or negatively treated on appealinfoCoverage
Supreme Court of UtahMay 30, 1978
580 P.2d 606 (Utah 1978)

Cases citing this case

How cited

  • State v. Fontana

    …We have applied this rule to errors in jury instructions in criminal cases. State v. Brafford, Utah, 663 P.2d…

  • State v. Montague

    …A reasonable probability of a more favorable result for defendant in the absence of such error must exist.…

lock 3 Citing caseskeyboard_arrow_right

No. 15390.

May 30, 1978.

Appeal from the Third District Court, Salt Lake County, Peter F. Leary, J.

Stephen R. McCaughey, Salt Lake City, for defendants and appellant.

Robert B. Hansen, Atty. Gen., R. Paul Van Dam, Salt Lake County Atty., Earl F. Dorius, Asst. Atty. Gen., Salt Lake City, for plaintiff and respondent.

Appellant, with a co-defendant, Edward Lane Cornish, was charged with attempted criminal homicide in violation of 76-4-101, U.C.A. Defendants were tried jointly before a jury. On August 24, 1977, defendant Hutcheson was found guilty of attempted criminal homicide, and co-defendant Cornish was acquitted. We affirm.

In his review of the record counsel for appellant found no grounds for appeal. Our review of the record brings us to the same conclusion. Counsel did point out the only point which could be arguable, viz., the court's instruction on reasonable doubt, as it related to the defense of self-defense. The instruction told the jury they should find defendant not guilty, if they entertained a reasonable doubt — the proper phrase is must find defendant not guilty if a reasonable doubt is entertained.

We review such alleged error with 77-42-1, U.C.A. 1953, in view. Thus, a verdict is not disturbed, unless review of the record discloses error of sufficient gravity to indicate substantial prejudice to defendants' rights. A reasonable probability of a more favorable result, for defendant, in the absence of such error, must exist.

State v. Gaxiola, 550 P.2d 1298 (1976).

Here, the evidence adduced was of such force as to submerge the defense of self-defense, and render the error harmless.

Counsel having filed his Anders brief, and given notice to appellant; we grant his request to withdraw.