From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Sanchez v. Village of Liberty, N.Y. St. Elec. Gas

Court of Appeals of the State of New York
Jun 9, 1977
42 N.Y.2d 876 (N.Y. 1977)

Summary

In Sanchez, the survivors of a fire in a multiple dwelling in the Village of Liberty brought wrongful death actions against a village and its building inspector, among others, in connection with the deaths of their spouses and children.

Summary of this case from O'Connor v. City of New York

Opinion

Argued May 4, 1977

Decided June 9, 1977

Appeal from the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court in the Third Judicial Department, DE FOREST C. PITT, J.

Gerald Orseck for appellants-respondents.

Jed B. Wolkenbreit and Robert P. Roche for respondents-appellants.

Lawrence E. Lagarenne for respondent.


MEMORANDUM.

Order modified, without costs, and the complaint as to defendants Village of Liberty and John Como dismissed.

Absent a special relationship creating a municipal duty to exercise care for the benefit of a particular class of individuals, no liability may be imposed upon a municipality for failure to enforce a statute or regulation (Motyka v City of Amsterdam, 15 N.Y.2d 134, 139; see Smullen v City of New York, 28 N.Y.2d 66, 72). Because the statutes and ordinances involved in the case at bar create no such special relationship, no liability may be imposed. Nor may liability be imposed on the "dangerous instrumentality" theory advanced in Runkel v City of New York with respect to an abandoned building attracting children from the abutting public thoroughfare ( 282 App. Div. 173, 176; see Runkel v Homelsky, 286 App. Div. 1101, affd 3 N.Y.2d 857; cf. Martinez v Kaufman-Kane Realty Co., 34 N.Y.2d 819, 821).

Chief Judge BREITEL and Judges JASEN, GABRIELLI, JONES, WACHTLER, FUCHSBERG and COOKE concur.

Order modified, without costs, in accordance with the memorandum herein and, as so modified, affirmed. Question certified answered in the affirmative.


Summaries of

Sanchez v. Village of Liberty, N.Y. St. Elec. Gas

Court of Appeals of the State of New York
Jun 9, 1977
42 N.Y.2d 876 (N.Y. 1977)

In Sanchez, the survivors of a fire in a multiple dwelling in the Village of Liberty brought wrongful death actions against a village and its building inspector, among others, in connection with the deaths of their spouses and children.

Summary of this case from O'Connor v. City of New York

In Sanchez v. Village of Liberty (42 N.Y.2d 876, 877-878, mod on other grounds 44 N.Y.2d 817), the Court of Appeals held that "[a]bsent a special relationship creating a municipal duty to exercise care for the benefit of a particular class of individuals, no liability may be imposed upon a municipality for failure to enforce a statute or regulation (Motyka v. City of Amsterdam, 15 N.Y.2d 134, 139; see Smullen v. City of New York, 28 N.Y.2d 66, 72)."

Summary of this case from Amadon v. State of New York
Case details for

Sanchez v. Village of Liberty, N.Y. St. Elec. Gas

Case Details

Full title:JOSE A. SANCHEZ, as Administrator of the Estate of LAURA SANCHEZ…

Court:Court of Appeals of the State of New York

Date published: Jun 9, 1977

Citations

42 N.Y.2d 876 (N.Y. 1977)
397 N.Y.S.2d 782
366 N.E.2d 870

Citing Cases

U.S. v. Hooker Chemicals Plastics

As indicated above, the duty allegedly breached must be more than simply a duty owed to the general public.…

Garrett v. Holiday Inns

We turn, then, to the instant case and the question whether the town owed any duty to appellants — the owners…