From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

People v. Zimmerman

Court of Appeals of the State of New York
Jan 11, 1962
10 N.Y.2d 430 (N.Y. 1962)

Opinion

Argued October 16, 1961 Reargued December 6, 1961.

Decided January 11, 1962

Appeal from the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court in the First Judicial Department, JOHN A. MULLEN, J.

Maurice Edelbaum for appellant. Frank S. Hogan, District Attorney ( Harold Roland Shapiro of counsel), for respondent.


When the defendant was on trial in 1938 under an indictment charging murder in the first degree, the witness Rose called on behalf of the People falsely denied upon cross-examination that he had made any statements in the presence of a District Attorney's stenographer more than a week before the trial when, in fact, he had previously made such statements, containing material inconsistencies, on May 25, 1937, on June 4, 1937, and on March 5, 1938.

The failure of the prosecutor to make any effort to correct this falsehood and to afford the court or defense counsel an opportunity to examine those statements, which were in his possession, in effect amounted to a suppression of such material and prejudiced the defendant in his right to a fair trial ( People v. Mangi, 10 N.Y.2d 86; People v. Savvides, 1 N.Y.2d 554; White v. Ragen, 324 U.S. 760; Pyle v. Kansas, 317 U.S. 213; Mooney v. Holohan, 294 U.S. 103). We decide no other question. The order appealed from should be reversed, the writ of error coram nobis sustained and the appellant remanded for a new trial.

Chief Judge DESMOND and Judges DYE, FROESSEL, VAN VOORHIS, BURKE and FOSTER concur; Judge FULD taking no part.

Order of Appellate Division (affirming denial of coram nobis after a murder first degree conviction commuted to life imprisonment) reversed and matter remitted to the Court of General Sessions for further proceedings in accordance with the opinion herein.


Summaries of

People v. Zimmerman

Court of Appeals of the State of New York
Jan 11, 1962
10 N.Y.2d 430 (N.Y. 1962)
Case details for

People v. Zimmerman

Case Details

Full title:THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK, Respondent, v. ISIDORE ZIMMERMAN…

Court:Court of Appeals of the State of New York

Date published: Jan 11, 1962

Citations

10 N.Y.2d 430 (N.Y. 1962)
224 N.Y.S.2d 2
179 N.E.2d 849

Citing Cases

People v. Romeo

It is idle to say that the jury was not misled by these statements of the prosecutor because even the trial…

Zimmerman v. State of New York

The claimant, convicted of the crime of murder, first degree, was sentenced on April 22, 1938. In 1962, after…