From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

People v. Flint Municipal Judge

Supreme Court of Michigan
Apr 13, 1970
383 Mich. 429 (Mich. 1970)

Summary

In People v Flint Municipal Judge, 383 Mich. 429, 432; 175 N.W.2d 750 (1970), this Court recognized the power of the Court of Appeals to issue a writ of superintending control but held that a complaint seeking such a writ to review action of a municipal judge should be directed to the circuit court not to the Court of Appeals, and said of a proceeding seeking such a writ: "The process is not, properly speaking, an appeal. It is rather a whole new lawsuit, with different parties and different purposes."

Summary of this case from People v. Blachura

Opinion

Calendar No. 20, Docket No. 52,146.

Decided April 13, 1970.

Appeal from Court of Appeals, Division 1, Lesinski, C.J., and J.H. Gillis and Quinn, JJ., denying complaint for superintending control over Flint Municipal Court, Thomas C. Yeotis, J. Submitted November 6, 1969. (Calendar No. 20, Docket No. 52,146.) Decided April 13, 1970.

Complaint by the People of Michigan in the Court of Appeals for superintending control against Flint Municipal Judge Thomas C. Yeotis, to compel him to bind over a criminal defendant, Joseph Cusenza, for trial. Order denied. The People appeal. Joseph Cusenza intervened as a party defendant. Affirmed.

Frank J. Kelley, Attorney General, Robert A. Derengoski, Solicitor General, Robert F. Leonard, Prosecuting Attorney, and Paul G. Miller, Jr., Assistant Prosecuting Attorney, for the people.

Ivan E. Barris, for defendant Cusenza.


THE CASE

On November 6, 1967, a warrant was issued for the arrest of one Joseph Cusenza and six other persons for the crime of conspiracy to commit murder. Preliminary examination was had in the municipal court of Flint before Thomas C. Yeotis, municipal judge. On March 7, 1968, after a long and complicated examination, the magistrate filed a written opinion in which some of the defendants were bound over to circuit court for trial, and others, including Cusenza, were not.

The prosecuting attorney, purporting to act on behalf of the people, sought to obtain an original writ of superintending control in the Court of Appeals, directing the municipal judge to find probable cause as to Cusenza, and bind him over for trial in circuit court.

On July 26, 1968, the Court of Appeals denied the appellant's complaint for superintending control, for the reason that the complaint should be addressed to the circuit court.

We granted leave to appeal. Joseph P. Cusenza has intervened as a defendant-appellee, pursuant to our order of September 13, 1968.

SUPERINTENDING CONTROL

No argument is made here as to the proper office of superintending control as a means of reviewing the discretion of an examining magistrate. The order of superintending control embraces the functions of the former writ of mandamus. GCR 1963, 711.3 (2).

Superintending control, like mandamus, lies to require the magistrate to perform a function where the magistrate has a clear legal duty to act.

The superintending court does not substitute its judgment or discretion for that of the magistrate; neither does it act directly in the premises. Rather it examines the record made before the magistrate to determine whether there was such an abuse of discretion as would amount to a failure to perform a clear legal duty; and in such case, the superintending court orders the magistrate to perform his duty.

The process is not, properly speaking, an appeal. It is rather a whole new lawsuit, with different parties and different purposes. People v. Yeotis is not a criminal case, but is rather an original civil complaint designed to require the defendant municipal judge to perform a clear legal duty.

THE PROPER COURT

The Supreme Court, the Court of Appeals, and the circuit court all have jurisdiction to hear original complaints for superintending control, and to issue orders of superintending control directed to courts and judges of earlier jurisdiction. GCR 1963, 711.4 (1).

Reasons of policy dictate that such complaints be directed to the first tribunal within the structure of Michigan's one court of justice having competence to hear and act upon them.

Original complaints for superintending control against municipal judges, district judges, and probate judges should be directed to the circuit courts.

The Court of Appeals is affirmed. No costs, a public question being involved in this civil action.

DETHMERS, KELLY, BLACK, T.M. KAVANAGH, ADAMS, and T.G. KAVANAGH, JJ., concurred with T.E. BRENNAN, C.J.


Summaries of

People v. Flint Municipal Judge

Supreme Court of Michigan
Apr 13, 1970
383 Mich. 429 (Mich. 1970)

In People v Flint Municipal Judge, 383 Mich. 429, 432; 175 N.W.2d 750 (1970), this Court recognized the power of the Court of Appeals to issue a writ of superintending control but held that a complaint seeking such a writ to review action of a municipal judge should be directed to the circuit court not to the Court of Appeals, and said of a proceeding seeking such a writ: "The process is not, properly speaking, an appeal. It is rather a whole new lawsuit, with different parties and different purposes."

Summary of this case from People v. Blachura

In Flint Municipal Judge, supra, we noted that mandamus would lie to require the magistrate to perform a clear legal duty. Here it is contended that the judge acted without jurisdiction and therefore has a clear legal duty to vacate the guilty plea and reinstate the criminal proceedings as filed in the information.

Summary of this case from Genesee Prosecutor v. Circuit Judge
Case details for

People v. Flint Municipal Judge

Case Details

Full title:PEOPLE v. FLINT MUNICIPAL JUDGE

Court:Supreme Court of Michigan

Date published: Apr 13, 1970

Citations

383 Mich. 429 (Mich. 1970)
175 N.W.2d 750

Citing Cases

In re People v. Burton

Therefore, we must consider the statutory issues and policies which apply in a criminal prosecution. People v…

People v. McCoy

Defendant preserved this question by a motion to dismiss the prosecutor's appeal, which motion was denied by…