From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Pearson v. Creed

Supreme Court of California
May 20, 1886
69 Cal. 538 (Cal. 1886)


         Department One

         Appeal from a judgment of the Superior Court of Fresno County.


         Edward Lynch, and A. B. Hunt, for Appellant.

          Bennett, Wigginton & Creed, for Respondents.

         JUDGES: McKinstry, J. Ross, J., and Myrick, J., concurred.


          McKINSTRY, Judge

         The defendants claim title through a sale for taxes. Section 3628 of the Political Code, as amended in 1880, provides that a mistake in the name or supposed name of the owner of real property shall not render an assessment invalid. The assessment here in question was made in the year 1880, and the court below found that C. E. Graxiola (the name in which the land was assessed) died in March, 1879. Counsel for respondents admit that, except for the amendment, the assessment to "C. E. Graxiola" would be void, -- there being no such person then living. (Hearst v. Eggleston , 55 Cal. 366; Crawford v. Schmidt , 47 Cal. 617; Kelsey v. Abbott , 13 Cal. 617; People v. Sneath , 28 Cal. 615.)

         The amendment of section 3628 took effect March 22, 1880. The defendants alleged in their cross-complaint, and the court found that the assessment was made "between the first Mondays of the months of March and July" of that year. It was for the defendants to establish affirmatively that a valid assessment was made, and from the record it does not appear but that the assessment under which they claim was made prior to the amendment of section 3628 of the Political Code.

         Lake County v. Sulphur Bank Co ., 66 Cal. 17, was decided on facts occurring after the amendment became operative.

         Judgment reversed and cause remanded.

Summaries of

Pearson v. Creed

Supreme Court of California
May 20, 1886
69 Cal. 538 (Cal. 1886)
Case details for

Pearson v. Creed

Case Details

Full title:JOHN W. PEARSON, Appellant, v. W. H. CREED et al., Respondents

Court:Supreme Court of California

Date published: May 20, 1886


69 Cal. 538 (Cal. 1886)
11 P. 56

Citing Cases

Escondido High School District of San Diego County v. Escondido Seminary of University of Southern California

(Citing Lake County v.Sulphur etc. Min. Co., supra.) This latter case was referred to in Pearson v. Creed, 69…