From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Malley v. New York City Board of Education

United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit
Apr 23, 1997
112 F.3d 69 (2d Cir. 1997)

Summary

holding that a filing injunction may issue if numerous complaints filed are based on the same events

Summary of this case from McTerrell v. Koenigsmann

Opinion

No. 96-9013.

Argued: April 14, 1997.

Decided: April 23, 1997.

Peter J. Malley, pro se, Clifton, New Jersey, for Plaintiff-Appellant.

Stuart D. Smith, Assistant Corporation Counsel, City of New York, New York City, for Defendants-Appellees.

Appeal from an order denying relief under Rule 60(b), Fed. R. Civ. P., from a judgment in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York (John F. Keenan, Judge) enjoining appellant from filing future complaints in the Southern District of New York without first obtaining permission from a judge of that court. We affirm the injunction concerning complaints filed in the Southern District of New York. Malley appears now to have begun to pursue his repetitious and frivolous actions against the same defendants in other districts, and we remand for consideration of an order extending the injunction to all federal courts.

Before: FEINBERG, WINTER and PARKER, Circuit Judges.


Peter Malley appeals from Judge Keenan's order denying relief under Rule 60(b), Fed. R. Civ. P., from an injunction prohibiting appellant from filing future complaints in the Southern District of New York without first obtaining permission from a judge of that court. Malley has filed repetitive actions concerning his discharge as a New York City school teacher and revocation of his teaching license. These actions have just as repetitively been dismissed on statute of limitations and res judicata grounds. Malley was warned after the third such action that further such complaints might result in sanctions like the injunction now under review. Undeterred, Malley filed a fourth such complaint that was dismissed with yet another warning. Malley then filed the instant matter, dismissed again for the usual reasons, but this time the district court imposed the injunction from which Malley now appeals.

Malley has amply demonstrated that neither the lack of success of his actions nor the warnings of the district court will cause him to cease his abuse of the judicial process. We therefore affirm the injunction as granted. See In Re Martin-Trigona, 737 F.2d 1254, 1261 (2d Cir. 1984) (injunction is appropriate where plaintiff "abuse[s] the process of the Courts to harass and annoy others with meritless, frivolous, vexatious or repetitive . . . proceedings" (internal quotation and citation marks omitted)).

Appellees advise us that Malley has filed two other actions of the same nature in the District of New Jersey, although they were subsequently withdrawn. They also inform us that Malley, faced with the injunction issued in the instant case, has now filed yet another repetitious action, but this time in the Eastern District of New York. They ask us to broaden the injunction beyond the Southern District to all federal courts. We see no barrier to a broader injunction in light of the warnings previously issued to Malley and of his persistence in pursuing the same meritless claims wherever his papers are accepted by a clerk of court. See id. at 1262 (approving injunction restricting new actions in all federal courts). However, we believe that such an order should be considered and fashioned in the first instance by the district court. We therefore remand the request to broaden the injunction.

Affirmed in part and remanded in part.


Summaries of

Malley v. New York City Board of Education

United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit
Apr 23, 1997
112 F.3d 69 (2d Cir. 1997)

holding that a filing injunction may issue if numerous complaints filed are based on the same events

Summary of this case from McTerrell v. Koenigsmann

finding an injunction appropriate where the plaintiff persisted in spite of adverse judgments in frivolous and repetitive litigation

Summary of this case from Pentagen Technologies Int'l. Ltd. v. U.S.

upholding an injunction where Plaintiff had been previously warned that he could face such a sanction

Summary of this case from 100,000 Victim Families v. Schulte Roth Zable

granting injunctive relief because plaintiff persisted in repeatedly filing the same claim that had been dismissed on statute of limitations and res judicata grounds

Summary of this case from Robert v. Department of Justice

affirming district court's issuance of injunction where plaintiff had repeatedly filed repetitive actions, including in the face of court warnings, in different jurisdictions and forums, and finding as dispositive the fact that plaintiff "has amply demonstrated that neither the lack of success of his actions nor the warnings of the district court will cause him to cease his abuse of the judicial process"

Summary of this case from Executor of the N.Y. Estate of Kates v. Pressley & Pressley, P.A.

affirming district court's issuance of injunction barring repetitive proceedings

Summary of this case from Jones v. US Dep't of Hous. & Urban Dev.

affirming the imposition of a filing injunction after the plaintiff filed numerous complaints based upon the same events which were repetitively dismissed

Summary of this case from DePaoli v. Bivona

affirming an injunction where the plaintiff had filed repeated lawsuits concerning the same nucleus of operative facts

Summary of this case from Valle v. YMCA of Greater New York

affirming injunction where the plaintiff had filed repeated lawsuits concerning the same nucleus of operative facts.

Summary of this case from Neshewat v. Salem

affirming injunction where the plaintiff had filed repeated lawsuits concerning the same nucleus of operative facts

Summary of this case from Lacy v. Principi

affirming injunction where plaintiff exhibited such behavior

Summary of this case from Hoffenberg v. Hoffman Pollok

affirming imposition of injunction against future filings in light of litigant's "persistence in pursuing the same meritless claims wherever his papers are accepted by a clerk of court"

Summary of this case from Murray v. Deer Park Union Free School Dist

filing injunction may issue if numerous complaints filed are based on the same events

Summary of this case from Lau v. Meddaugh

filing injunction may issue if numerous complaints filed are based on the same events

Summary of this case from Tomczyk v. N.Y. Unified Court Sys.

filing injunction may issue if numerous complaints filed are based on the same events

Summary of this case from Vallen v. Newson

filing injunction may issue if numerous complaints filed are based on the same events

Summary of this case from Tooker v. Grossman

filing injunction may issue if numerous complaints filed are based on the same events

Summary of this case from Falco v. Anthony Santoro, Spectrum Psychology Servs., PCLLC, Laura Bowery, Sea Aire Inc.

filing injunction may issue if numerous complaints filed are based on the same events

Summary of this case from Comm'r of Soc. Servs. ex rel. Boertlein v. Clarke

filing injunction may issue if numerous complaints filed are based on the same events

Summary of this case from Wang v. New York

filing injunction may issue if numerous complaints filed are based on the same events

Summary of this case from Comm'r of Soc. Servs. ex rel. Boertlein v. Clarke

filing injunction may issue if numerous complaints filed are based on the same events

Summary of this case from Keyes v. Nassau Cnty. Police Dep't

filing injunction may issue if numerous complaints filed are based on the same events

Summary of this case from Ajamian v. Nimeh

filing injunction may issue if numerous complaints filed are based on the same events

Summary of this case from Lamb v. Cuomo

filing injunction may issue if numerous complaints filed are based on the same events

Summary of this case from George v. Kings Cnty. Hosp. Ctr.

filing injunction may issue if numerous frivolous complaints are filed

Summary of this case from Kenny v. King
Case details for

Malley v. New York City Board of Education

Case Details

Full title:PETER J. MALLEY, PLAINTIFF-APPELLANT, v. NEW YORK CITY BOARD OF…

Court:United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit

Date published: Apr 23, 1997

Citations

112 F.3d 69 (2d Cir. 1997)

Citing Cases

Hoffenberg v. Hoffman Pollok

Courts have recognized the need to impose severe limitations on the opportunity of litigious individuals to…

Vallen v. Newson

The repetitive and duplicative nature of Plaintiff's actions--and his lack of success--demonstrates that…