From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Lischin v. Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co.

Supreme Court of New Jersey
Jun 4, 1969
253 A.2d 803 (N.J. 1969)

Opinion

Argued May 20, 1969 —

Decided June 4, 1969.

Appeal from Superior Court, Appellate Division.

Mr. Isaac C. Ginsburg argued the cause for the appellant ( Messrs. Feinberg Ginsburg, attorneys).

Mr. Ronald I. Bloom argued the cause for the respondent ( Messrs. Finn and Rimm, attorneys).


We reverse, essentially for the reasons expressed by Judge Lewis in his dissenting opinion below. Lischin v. Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co., 104 N.J. Super. 525 , 527 ( App. Div. 1969).

All members of the Appellate Division agreed that the company's undertaking to pay for loss of use of the stolen automobile "until setlement for such theft is offered by the Company" was ambiguous in nature. The assured could reasonably expect that he would be paid for loss of use within the stated policy limitation of $10 per day (maximum of $300), until the company in good faith made a settlement offer in cash which he could use immediately to obtain alternate transportation. Surely a settlement offer in cash but payable at a later date would not have disentitled the assured to payment for loss of use in the interim period. That being so, and in the light of well settled principles of construction ( 104 N.J. Super., at 528), the obscure policy language may fairly be taken to have contemplated payment for loss of use during the interim period where, as here, the automobile was being repaired at the company's direction for ultimate return to the assured.

For reversal — Chief Justice WEINTRAUB and Justices JACOBS, FRANCIS, PROCTOR, HALL, SCHETTINO and HANEMAN — 7.

For affirmance — None.


Summaries of

Lischin v. Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co.

Supreme Court of New Jersey
Jun 4, 1969
253 A.2d 803 (N.J. 1969)
Case details for

Lischin v. Nationwide Mutual Insurance Co.

Case Details

Full title:RICHARD H. LISCHIN, PLAINTIFF-APPELLANT, v. NATIONWIDE MUTUAL INSURANCE…

Court:Supreme Court of New Jersey

Date published: Jun 4, 1969

Citations

253 A.2d 803 (N.J. 1969)
253 A.2d 803

Citing Cases

Stephan v. Allstate Insurance Company

Cases from other jurisdictions cited by Stephan do not support his position, involving either the application…

State Farm Mutual Automobile Ins. Co. v. Barrow

Shefrin v. Hawkeye Cas. Co., 85 F. Supp. 84 (U.S.Dist.Ct., Western Dist.Mo., 1949). A clause such as the one…