From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

In re Town of Hallie

Supreme Court of Wisconsin
Jul 1, 1948
253 Wis. 35 (Wis. 1948)


May 25, 1948. —

July 1, 1948.

APPEAL from a judgment of the county court of Chippewa county: ORRIN H. LARRABEE, Judge. Affirmed.

For the appellants there was a brief by James A. McPhee and Stafford Stafford, all of Chippewa Falls, and oral argument by Mr. McPhee.

William H. Frawley of Eau Claire, for the respondents.

Proceedings in the circuit court branch of the county court of Chippewa county were instituted on the petition and application of certain freeholders and taxpayers of the town of Hallie, Chippewa county, for the incorporation of the said town into a village, under secs. 61.01 to 61.14, Stats. Pursuant to said application and proceedings in connection therewith, the court on January 3, 1947, ordered the incorporation of said village under said statutes. Within three months of said date Adolph Moe and Oscar W. Klatt, as residents, electors, and owners of real estate in the town of Hallie (which was then called village of Hallie) filed a petition in said court under sec. 61.64, Stats. 1945, for the purpose of determining the validity of the proceedings in the matter of said incorporation, and to have said order of incorporation, dated January 3, 1947, vacated and set aside as invalid. Answers to the petition of Moe and Klatt were filed on behalf of some of the signers of the original application for the incorporation of said village. Thereafter in the course of the proceedings, including the evidence taken under and in relation to matters alleged in said petitions and answers thereto, there were numerous assertions and objections, — some of which were highly technical, — by the respective parties, and at the conclusion of the proceedings the court, in connection with a written opinion in relation to many of said matters in controversy, made certain findings of fact and conclusions of law, including the following, —

"That the order of incorporation of the village of Hallie dated January 3, 1947, and recorded in the office of the register of deeds of Chippewa county, Wisconsin, on the 1st day of February, 1947, is null and void and is hereby vacated and set aside."

From a judgment entered by the court in accordance with that conclusion of law, an appeal was duly taken by petitioners for the incorporation of said village, and the officers thereof and also the officers of the town of Hallie.

On this appeal numerous grounds in respect to procedural and other highly technical matters are asserted on behalf of appellants as basis for reversing the judgment appealed from; and on the other hand there are asserted by respondents many other grounds as to similar matters of that kind as basis for affirming said judgment. Upon our review the record in the respects involved in view of appellants' contentions on this appeal, we consider it unnecessary to determine any of the matters in controversy excepting in so far as necessary to dispose of appellants' contentions in two respects.


Appellants contend the proceedings pursuant to the Moe and Klatt petition to have the order of incorporation in question adjudged invalid, and therefore vacated and set aside, were not commenced within the time prescribed by sec. 61.64, Stats. 1945. The facts material in this respect are as follows. In the proceedings instituted for the incorporation as a village of the entire town of Hallie, pursuant to a petition signed by eleven residents and freeholders, the court's order of incorporation was made on January 3, 1947. At the election which is required under ch. 61 of the statutes of the electors of the territory described in the order, and which .was held on January 28, 1947, two hundred thirty voted for incorporation and two hundred four against. The court's order of incorporation was duly recorded in the office of the register of deeds on February 1, 1947. On that date there then commenced to run the limitation period prescribed in sec 61.64, Stats., that, —

". . . any question of the validity of such incorporation and proceedings therefor may be tested by certiorari, or by any other proper action or proceedings brought directly for the purpose of vacating or setting aside the same, at any time within three months after such incorporation, but not thereafter."

Before the termination of that three months' period of limitation, Moe and Klatt, on March 31, 1947, duly filed in the court their petition under sec. 61.64, Stats. 1945, as basis for an order to show cause to have the court vacate and set aside the order of incorporation; and on that date due service of said petition and order was admitted by the attorney of record for the town board of the town of Hallie and also the village of Hallie and its officers. Thus, by so filing their petition on March 31, 1947, Moe and Klatt have proceeded in a manner and within the time authorized by sec. 61.64, Stats. 1945.


Appellants contend the trial court erred in holding, on the hearing pursuant to the Moe and Klatt petition, that the order, dated January 3, 1947, for the intended incorporation as a village of all the territory in question was invalid and must be held void because of the fact that said territory did not have the characteristics of a village, and therefore was not subject to incorporation as a village for the reason stated in Fenton v. Ryan, 140 Wis. 353, 354, 122 N.W. 756. As the court held in that case (syllabus), —

"The inclusion in a new village of territory, in excess of one half a square mile, consisting of sparsely settled rural or agricultural lands not having the distinctive characteristics of a village or any natural connection therewith, and not reasonably appurtenant and necessary for the future growth of the village, would be an invasion of the uniformity in town and county government required by sec. 23, art. IV, Const."

See also State ex rel. Holland v. Lammers, 113 Wis. 398, 86 N.W. 677, 89 N.W. 501; In re Incorporation of Village of St. Francis, 209 Wis. 645, 245 N.W. 840; In re Incorporation of Village of Twin Lakes, 226 Wis. 505, 277 N.W. 373; Incorporation of Village of Biron, 146 Wis. 444, 131 N.W. 829; In re Village of Chenequa, 197 Wis. 163, 221 N.W. 856. The conclusion and rule thus stated is clearly applicable in the case at bar in view of the following facts found and stated in the trial court's decision, —

"The agricultural land in the village is approximately 15, 180 acres; the residential area approximately 1,012 acres; the commercial area is approximately 27 acres; the industrial area is approximately 1,034 acres; the total population is less than 1,500 people [actually 1,313]. The residential, commercial, and industrial areas are found principally along .both sides of Highway 53 in a strip less than a mile wide and about nine miles long. The land lying both east and west of this strip is practically all agricultural except for the bank of the Chippewa river within a mile or so of the city of Eau Claire in the southwest corner of Hallie where some summer cottages and a few permanent homes are built overlooking the river."

In addition there are the following facts which were testified to by the assessor of the town of Hallie in 1946, and as to which there is apparently no dispute in any material respect, to wit: The area of said town consists of approximately 13,400 acres of farm land; 1,115 acres of swamp and cutover lands; 505 acres of mixed timber and woodlands; 27 acres of commercial property; 1,034 acres of industrial lands; and 1,012 acres of residential area. In 1946 there were 179 residences, 1,408 neat cattle, 209 swine, and 30 sheep. The farm population was estimated at 350 persons.

Thus it appears conclusively that the territory in question does not have the characteristics of a village; that therefore it was not subject to incorporation as a village and the court's order of incorporation, dated January 3, 1947, was invalid; and that the judgment vacating and setting aside that order must be affirmed.

By the Court. — Judgment affirmed.

MARTIN, J., took no part.

Summaries of

In re Town of Hallie

Supreme Court of Wisconsin
Jul 1, 1948
253 Wis. 35 (Wis. 1948)
Case details for

In re Town of Hallie

Case Details


Court:Supreme Court of Wisconsin

Date published: Jul 1, 1948


253 Wis. 35 (Wis. 1948)
33 N.W.2d 185

Citing Cases

Scharping v. Johnson

This decision accords with decisions by this court involving the earlier incorporation statutes, which held…

In re Village of Oconomowoc Lake

Furthermore, the court took up the matter of whether the area proposed to be incorporated would fit more…