From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Huntley v. State of New York

Court of Appeals of the State of New York
May 15, 1984
62 N.Y.2d 134 (N.Y. 1984)

Summary

affirming liability of defendant psychiatric hospital for patient's suicide where the patient, with a history of instability who had communicated specific suicide plan at an off-site location to member of hospital staff, left the hospital unsupervised and jumped from the roof of a nearby parking garage

Summary of this case from Christophel v. N.Y.-Presbyterian/Weil Med. Coll.

Opinion

Argued March 29, 1984

Decided May 15, 1984

Appeal from the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court in the Fourth Judicial Department, Thomas J. Lowery, J.

Robert Abrams, Attorney-General ( Michael S. Buskus and Peter H. Schiff of counsel), for appellant.

Richard K. Hughes and Frederick F. Shantz for respondent.


Where a psychiatric hospital patient with a history of instability communicated her specific suicide plan involving an off-premises location to a hospital staff member, failure to transmit such information to the staff psychiatrist (who controlled the patient's privileges to leave hospital premises) constituted a breach of duty and rendered the hospital liable for negligence. CPLR 4010, which limits the application of the collateral source rule in medical malpractice actions, has no application to the hospital's liability for negligence.

At issue on this appeal is the liability of appellant, the State of New York, for injuries sustained by respondent, Helen C. Huntley, a patient at the State's Hutchings Psychiatric Center, when she left the hospital premises, unsupervised, and jumped from the roof of a nearby parking garage. The Court of Claims determination in respondent's favor, finding the evidence sufficient to establish appellant's negligence, was unanimously affirmed by the Appellate Division.

Given the correct application of legal standards and affirmed findings of fact, our scope of review is limited. Where such findings are supported by evidence in the record, they are conclusive in this court. ( Humphrey v State of New York, 60 N.Y.2d 742.) Here, there was ample evidence to support the finding that appellant on the day of the accident failed in its duty to supervise its patient adequately, leading to her injury (see Martindale v State of New York, 269 N.Y. 554; Horton v Niagara Falls Mem. Med. Center, 51 A.D.2d 152 [Simons, J.]). Apart from respondent's history of mental instability and her depression, deterioration and unusual behavior shortly before the accident, there was evidence that, one day prior to her jump from the garage roof, respondent had communicated this specific suicide plan to a hospital staff member, and that this information was not transmitted to the staff psychiatrist so that he could consider what impact — if any — it should have on respondent's privileges to leave hospital premises unsupervised. While a medical judgment might have been reached to continue respondent's privileges, and an error in such judgment would not have given rise to liability for malpractice ( Fiederlein v New York City Health Hosps. Corp., 56 N.Y.2d 573; Topel v Long Is. Jewish Med. Center, 55 N.Y.2d 682), here, any opportunity to form a medical judgment was foreclosed by a failure to transmit the information, and no measures were taken to secure respondent's physical safety.

Nor did the Appellate Division err in refusing to reduce the judgment, in accordance with CPLR 4010, by amounts respondent received from collateral sources. CPLR 4010 is limited to actions for medical malpractice, and is thus inapplicable to reduce this common-law negligence award.

Accordingly, the order of the Appellate Division should be affirmed, with costs.

Chief Judge COOKE and Judges JASEN, JONES, WACHTLER, MEYER, SIMONS and KAYE concur in Per Curiam opinion.

Order affirmed, with costs.


Summaries of

Huntley v. State of New York

Court of Appeals of the State of New York
May 15, 1984
62 N.Y.2d 134 (N.Y. 1984)

affirming liability of defendant psychiatric hospital for patient's suicide where the patient, with a history of instability who had communicated specific suicide plan at an off-site location to member of hospital staff, left the hospital unsupervised and jumped from the roof of a nearby parking garage

Summary of this case from Christophel v. N.Y.-Presbyterian/Weil Med. Coll.

In Huntley v. New York, 62 N.Y. 2d 134 (1984), the Court of Appeals held a psychiatric hospital negligent when a patient left the grounds unsupervised and jumped from a nearby roof.

Summary of this case from Stelman v. United States

In Huntley, a psychiatric hospital employee failed to satisfy her duty of taking adequate measures to ensure the safety of a patient who had told her of a plan to commit suicide (cf. Zophy v State of New York, 27 A.D.2d 414, 416, affd 22 N.Y.2d 921; Callahan v State of New York, 179 Misc. 781, 784-785, affd 266 App. Div. 1054).

Summary of this case from Bleiler v. Bodnar
Case details for

Huntley v. State of New York

Case Details

Full title:HELEN HUNTLEY, Respondent, v. STATE OF NEW YORK, Appellant

Court:Court of Appeals of the State of New York

Date published: May 15, 1984

Citations

62 N.Y.2d 134 (N.Y. 1984)
476 N.Y.S.2d 99
464 N.E.2d 467

Citing Cases

Laura v. Hillside Children's

The abuse for which plaintiffs seek recovery occurred during the home visits Reznikov made in the course of…

Borrillo v. Beekman Hosp

This question was eliminated in 1978 by the express inclusion of hospitals in the statute requiring panel…