From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Com. ex Rel. Derry v. Rundle

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
Sep 29, 1965
213 A.2d 349 (Pa. 1965)

Opinion

Submitted April 20, 1965.

September 29, 1965.

Criminal law — Constitutional law — 6th and 14th Amendments — Lack of counsel — Police interrogation — Failure to warn accused — Rule of Escobedo v. Illinois — Retroactive effect.

1. While the request for the assistance of counsel by a suspect during an accusatory investigation is not a conclusive factor in determining the admissibility of a confession under the rule stated in Escobedo v. Illinois, 378 U.S. 478, such rule should not be applied retrospectively to convictions finally sustained prior to the announcement of the rule on June 22, 1964.

2. Commonwealth v. Negri, 419 Pa. 117, followed. [147]

Mr. Justice COHEN dissented.

Before BELL, C. J., MUSMANNO, JONES, COHEN, EAGEN, O'BRIEN and ROBERTS, JJ.

Appeal, No. 108, Jan. T., 1965, from order of Court of Common Pleas No. 3 of Philadelphia County, June T., 1964, No. 5852, in case of Commonwealth ex rel. Carl T. Derry v. A. T. Rundle, Superintendent. Order affirmed.

Habeas corpus.

Petition dismissed, order by GRIFFITHS, J. Relator appealed.

Carl T. Derry, appellant, in propria persona.

Vincent C. Veldorale and Joseph M. Smith, Assistant District Attorneys, F. Emmett Fitzpatrick, Jr., First Assistant District Attorney, and James C. Crumlish, Jr., District Attorney, for appellee.


Petitioner challenges a 1948 conviction in reliance on the decision in Escobedo v. Illinois, 378 U.S. 478, 84 S. Ct. 1758 (1964). Having concluded today that the rule of that case is not to be given retrospective application, Commonwealth v. Negri, 419 Pa. 117, 213 A.2d 670 (1965), Negri is here controlling.

Order affirmed.

Mr. Justice COHEN dissents.


Summaries of

Com. ex Rel. Derry v. Rundle

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
Sep 29, 1965
213 A.2d 349 (Pa. 1965)
Case details for

Com. ex Rel. Derry v. Rundle

Case Details

Full title:Commonwealth ex rel. Derry, Appellant v. Rundle

Court:Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

Date published: Sep 29, 1965

Citations

213 A.2d 349 (Pa. 1965)
213 A.2d 349

Citing Cases

Commonwealth ex rel. McCormick v. Russell

Our Supreme Court has considered similar allegations in a number of recent cases. See Commonwealth v. Negri,…

Com. ex Rel. Wright v. Cavell

Assuming arguendo that relator's present allegation is true, Escobedo has been held by this Court not to be…