From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Brubaker Estate

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
Jan 29, 1943
30 A.2d 135 (Pa. 1943)

Opinion

January 18, 1943.

January 29, 1943.

Poor laws — Indigent and insane persons — Liability of parents — Maintenance by Commonwealth — Claim presented against parent's estate — Acts of June 1, 1915, P. L. 661 and July 11, 1923, P. L. 998.

1. Under the Act of June 1, 1915, P. L. 661, liability for the support of an indigent, insane child is imposed on the parent in the interest of the Commonwealth. [340-41]

2. The fact that no effort to enforce this liability was made during the lifetime of the parent does not bar the enforcement of such liability against the parent's estate. [340-41]

3. The Mental Health Act of July 11, 1923, P. L. 998, does not take away the right of the Commonwealth to present a claim for expenses incurred in the maintenance of an indigent, insane person against his parent's estate even though no effort to enforce such claim was made during the latter's lifetime. [341]

Argued January 18, 1943.

Before MAXEY, C. J.; DREW, LINN, STERN, PATTERSON, PARKER and STEARNE, JJ.

Appeal, No. 18, Jan. T., 1943, from order of O. C. Lycoming Co., Dec. T., 1940, No. 61, in matter of Estate of Herbert M. Brubaker, deceased. Order reversed.

Claim against decedent's estate. Before HUMES, J.

Report of auditor filed refusing claim of Commonwealth. Exceptions by Commonwealth to report dismissed and report affirmed. Commonwealth appealed.

J. B. Cupp, of Williamson Cupp, with him E. A. DeLaney, Deputy Attorney General, and Claude T. Reno, Attorney General, for appellant.

No brief was filed or argument made for appellee.


This appeal is from an order of the Orphans' Court of Lycoming County dismissing exceptions of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania to an auditor's report disallowing a claim of $3,170.20, presented by the Commonwealth against the Estate of Herbert M. Brubaker, deceased, for expenses incurred by it in the maintenance of decedent's insane and indigent son at the Danville State Hospital for the Insane from January 5, 1931, to January 7, 1941, the date of decedent's death. This son was committed to the Hospital upon an order made on January 5, 1931, by the Court of Quarter Sessions of Lycoming County, which placed the costs of maintenance on the county. The order was never revised or challenged and for that reason, the Orphans' Court upheld the auditor in disallowing the claim.

The Act of June 1, 1915, P. L. 661, imposes liability for the support of an indigent, insane child, in the interest of the Commonwealth, on, inter alia, its parent. The fact that there has been no effort to enforce this liability during the lifetime of the parent does not bar the enforcement of such liability by appropriate proceedings against the parent's estate: Harnish's Estate, 268 Pa. 128. The subsequent Act of July 11, 1923, P. L. 998, known as The Mental Health Act, does not take away this right of the Commonwealth to present claims for expenses incurred in the maintenance of indigent, insane persons against their parents' estate even though no effort to enforce such claims was made during the latters' lifetime. Had the attention of the court below been called to our decision in Harnish's Estate, supra, it would have undoubtedly so held in the instant case.

The order of the court below is reversed and the record is remitted with directions to make distribution in accordance with this opinion.


Summaries of

Brubaker Estate

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania
Jan 29, 1943
30 A.2d 135 (Pa. 1943)
Case details for

Brubaker Estate

Case Details

Full title:Brubaker Estate

Court:Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

Date published: Jan 29, 1943

Citations

30 A.2d 135 (Pa. 1943)
30 A.2d 135

Citing Cases

State v. Panzeri

The claim may first be made against the administrator or executor of the estate of the person legally liable.…

Stoner Estate

ate. Section 4 of the Support Law of 1937, as amended, cit. supra, provides that ". . . Any claim for the…