Argued April 2, 1879
Decided May 20, 1879
Nelson Smith, for appellant.
Benjamin Estes, for respondent.
Per Curiam opinion for reversal of judgment of General Term of New York Common Pleas, and for affirmance of order of General Term of the Marine Court, which reversed a judgment in favor of plaintiff, and for judgment absolute on stipulation.
FOLGER, RAPALLO, ANDREWS and EARL, JJ., concur; CHURCH, Ch. J., MILLER and DANFORTH, JJ., dissent.