From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Brotherhood of Painters, Etc., of America v. Trimm

Supreme Court of Alabama
May 25, 1922
93 So. 533 (Ala. 1922)


6 Div. 622.

April 27, 1922. Rehearing Denied May 25, 1922.

Appeal from Circuit Court, Jefferson County; Dan A. Greene, Judge.

Black, Altman Harris, of Birmingham, for appellant.

It is highly prejudicial for counsel in argument to urge the jury to consider the fact that defendant is a nonresident.

104 Ala. 471, 16 So. 538; 58 Mich. 424, 25 N.W. 381; (Tex.Civ.App.) 99 S.W. 574; 175 Ala. 338 57 So. 876, Ann. Cas. 1914C, 1037; 62 Fla. 516, 56 So. 942; 15 Ala. App. 419, 73 So. 747; 203 Ala. 550, 84 So. 259; 74 Ala. 386.

Harsh, Harsh Harsh, of Birmingham, for appellee.

The argument complained of by counsel for appellant does not afford grounds for reversal. 68 Ala. 476; 173 Ala. 675, 55 So. 1001; 101 Ala. 35, 13 So. 130; 8 Ala. App. 405, 62 So. 990; 183 Ala. 273, 61 So. 80, Ann. Cas. 1916A, 543; 183 Ala. 237, 62 So. 889; 200 Ala. 258, 76 So. 24; 17 Ala. App. 154, 82 So. 644; 144 Ala. 35, 40 So. 269; 44 Tex. Cr. R. 663; 74 Ala. 374.

Mrs. Annie L. Trimm sues the Brotherhood of Painters, Decorators and Paperhangers of America, a corporation, for $300. Her husband, C. A. Trimm, was a member of that labor union in Birmingham; he is dead, and she claims the $300 due her, his widow, by reason of beneficial provisions of the corporation. There was judgment for the plaintiff, and the defendant appeals.

The defendant objected to, moved to exclude from the jury, and requested the court to instruct the jury as improper, the following part of the address of attorney for plaintiff to them:

"You know that any member of this local union here would gladly pay this man, if they had charge of the disbursement of the money. Gentlemen, you are not rendering a verdict against the local union here, but these people up in Indiana."

To this argument attorney for defendant objected, and stated to the court:

"I don't think it is fair for the gentlemen to argue to the jury that this judgment is not rendered against local people; that it is rendered against people up in Indiana; and I ask the court to instruct the jury that residence or locality has nothing to do with it."

The court thereupon stated: "That is a matter of argument." The defendant then requested the court to instruct the jury that it was improper argument; the court refused the motion, and defendant duly excepted.

This was illegitimate argument. The defendant was a nonresident corporation. It had the same rights in court in this case as if it had been a citizen of Alabama, or a corporation of this state. Whether it was a resident or nonresident should have no weight with a juror in rendering a verdict in the cause. It was calculated to prejudice the cause of the defendant with the jury. The court did not try to eradicate the attempted, intentional, or unintentional effort to inject prejudice against the cause of the defendant in the minds of the jury because it was a nonresident, but approved of it before the jury by stating "that is a matter of argument." This approved the argument as legitimate and proper to the jury. The argument was highly improper. Florence Cotton Iron Co. v. Field, 104 Ala. 471 (headnotes 8 and 9), 16 So. 538; B'ham R. L. P. Co. v. Drennen, 175 Ala. 338 (headnote 5), 57 So. 876, Ann. Cas. 1914C, 1037; Wolffe v. Minnis, 74 Ala. 386.

For this error the judgment is reversed.

Reversed and remanded.

ANDERSON, C. J., and SAYRE and GARDNER, JJ., concur.

Summaries of

Brotherhood of Painters, Etc., of America v. Trimm

Supreme Court of Alabama
May 25, 1922
93 So. 533 (Ala. 1922)
Case details for

Brotherhood of Painters, Etc., of America v. Trimm

Case Details


Court:Supreme Court of Alabama

Date published: May 25, 1922


93 So. 533 (Ala. 1922)
93 So. 533

Citing Cases

City of Birmingham v. Kircus

Montgomery v. Townsend, 80 Ala. 489, 2 So. 155, 60 Am. Rep. 112; Union Springs v. Jones, 58 Ala. 654; Evans…

Yarbrough v. State

The action of the court in reference to argument of the county attorney did not eradicate the error.…