Bell
v.
the State

Court of Criminal Appeals of TexasDec 7, 1921
90 Tex. Crim. 400 (Tex. Crim. App. 1921)
90 Tex. Crim. 400235 S.W. 887

Cases citing this case

How cited

  • Montez, Del Real, v. State

    276 S.W. 709 (Tex. Crim. App. 1925)

    …There are ten bills of exception in the record in which complaint is made at various rulings of the court,…

  • Jones v. State

    8 S.W.2d 169 (Tex. Crim. App. 1928)

    …Bills of exception in question and answer form are not entitled to consideration. Montez v. State, 276 S.W.…

lock 3 Citing caseskeyboard_arrow_right

No. 6528.

Decided December 7, 1921.

Perjury — Indictment — Materiality of Statement.

Where, upon trial of perjury, the motion to quash the indictment for the reason that there was a failure to aver that the alleged false statement. was material to the matter under investigation, the indictment revealed that the criticism was correct, the judgment must be reversed and the cause dismissed.

Appeal from the District Court of Comanche. Tried below before the Honorable J.R. McClellan.

Appeal from a conviction of perjury; penalty, two years imprisonment in the penitentiary.

The opinion states the case.

Hampton, Harris Hampton, for appellant. — Cited cases in opinion.

R.G. Storey, Assistant Attorney General, for the State.


Conviction is for perjury. Penalty two years imprisonment in penitentiary.

Motion to quash the indictment was made for the reason, among others, that there was a failure to aver that the alleged false statement was material to the matter under investigation. The indictment reveals the justness of the criticism, and the Assistant Attorney General confesses error under authority of Bell v. State, 75 Tex.Crim. Rep., 171 S.W. Rep., 239; Scott v. State, 75 Tex.Crim. Rep., 171 S.W. Rep., 243; Adamson v. State, 90 Texas Crim Rep., 221 (No. 6425, opinion delivered November 2, 1921, not yet reported); Highshaw v. State, 90 Tex.Crim. Rep. (opinion delivered October 26, 1921, not yet reported).

Judgment of the trial court is reversed, and prosecution ordered dismissed under the present indictment.

Reversed and dismissed.