From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Anderson v. State

Supreme Court of Nevada
Jul 29, 1980
96 Nev. 633 (Nev. 1980)


No. 11025

July 29, 1980

Appeal from judgment, Eighth Judicial District Court, Clark County; J. Charles Thompson, Judge.

Morgan D. Harris, Public Defender, and H. Leon Simon, Deputy Public Defender, Clark County, for Appellant.

Richard H. Bryan, Attorney General, Carson City; Robert J. Miller, District Attorney, and Ira H. Hecht, Deputy District Attorney, Clark County, for Respondent.


Appellant was convicted of robbery with use of a deadly weapon. See NRS 200.380, 193.165. The sole contention on appeal is that the evidence was insufficient to support the weapons enhancement.

At trial appellant admitted using a blank gun in the commission of the robbery. In Allen v. State, 96 Nev. 334, 609 P.2d 321 (1980), we held that use of an inoperable firearm in the commission of a crime would support the enhanced penalty. In so deciding, we stated: "A firearm is dangerous, not only because it can inflict deadly harm, but because its use may provoke a deadly reaction from the victim or from bystanders." Id. at 336, 609 P.2d at 322. We perceive no substantial distinction between the inoperable firearm in Allen and the blank gun used in the instant case.


MOWBRAY, C.J., and THOMPSON and BATJER, JJ., concur.

Any dicta in Allen v. State, 96 Nev. 334, 609 P.2d 321 (1980) notwithstanding, I respectfully submit that the term "deadly weapon" should be applied only to objects having that essential nature. In Allen v. State, a robber's pistol misfired when he attempted to shoot his victim. This court decided not to burden enhancement cases with debate over whether something clearly a "weapon," and clearly "deadly" in its essential nature, is actually operable or inoperable at the moment of the crime. I submit that such a holding does not support the view that an object which is neither a weapon nor deadly, such as a cap pistol or a rubber knife, should be deemed a "deadly weapon" in law.

Summaries of

Anderson v. State

Supreme Court of Nevada
Jul 29, 1980
96 Nev. 633 (Nev. 1980)
Case details for

Anderson v. State

Case Details


Court:Supreme Court of Nevada

Date published: Jul 29, 1980


96 Nev. 633 (Nev. 1980)
614 P.2d 540

Citing Cases

Berry v. State, 125 Nev. Adv. Op. No. 26, 49709 (2009)

Thus, whether the weapon was unloaded or inoperable at the time of the crime is irrelevant. In reaching this…

People v. Cotarelo

Thus, the mere fact that a firearm brandished by an assailant is known by him to be unloaded, or to be loaded…