From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Amer. United Life Ins. Co. v. Peffley

Court of Appeals of Indiana
Jan 24, 1974
306 N.E.2d 131 (Ind. Ct. App. 1974)


306 N.E.2d 131 (Ind.App. 2 Dist. 1974) 158 Ind.App. 29 AMERICAN UNITED LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY, Appellant (Defendant below), v. Becky A. PEFFLEY (Sanders), Appellee (Plaintiff below). No. 572A220. Court of Appeals of Indiana, Second District. January 24, 1974

        Ralph A. Cohen, Harry T. Ice, Ice, Miller, Donadios&sRyan, Indianapolis, for appellant.

       Daniel F. Cummings, Miless&sCummings, Indianapolis, for appellee.


       BUCHANAN, Judge.

       The central factual issue in this case was whether the deceased-insured changed the beneficiary of a certain American United Life group life insurance policy on his life from Plaintiff-Appellee (Becky) to Louise, his first wife. To do so the deceased-insured would have been required to execute a Change of Beneficiary card.

       Becky stipulated that a search had been made by the parties concerned for the original of a Change of Beneficiary card, 'if there was a card,' and maintains our opinion assumes Becky's acknowledgment of the existence of such card, a fact which Becky stoutly denies.

       We held that Exhibits C, D, and E, excluded by the trial court, should have been admitted in evidence as they tended to support the execution of a Change of Beneficiary card by decedent. Our opinion carefully uses the words 'diligent search' and in no way implies that Becky stipulated the existence of the Change card. The existence or non-existence of the Change card was for the jury to determine and Exhibits C, D, and E tended to support the existence and the contents of such a writing.

       The stipulation was recognized for just what it was and no more, i.e., a diligent search had been conducted for an instrument which may or may not have been in existence. No semantic sleight of hand here.

       Appellee's petition for rehearing is denied.

       SULLIVAN, P.J., and WHITE, J., concur.

Summaries of

Amer. United Life Ins. Co. v. Peffley

Court of Appeals of Indiana
Jan 24, 1974
306 N.E.2d 131 (Ind. Ct. App. 1974)
Case details for

Amer. United Life Ins. Co. v. Peffley

Case Details


Court:Court of Appeals of Indiana

Date published: Jan 24, 1974


306 N.E.2d 131 (Ind. Ct. App. 1974)
301 N.E.2d 651
158 Ind. App. 29

Citing Cases

Fendley v. Ford

Regardless of the objection registered at trial, if the trial court's exclusion of the evidence is…

Baker v. Wagers

See David F. Binder, Hearsay Handbook, pp. 142-144 (2d Ed., 1983). This court summarized the various Indiana…