From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Akao v. Shimoda

United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit
Jun 19, 1987
832 F.2d 119 (9th Cir. 1987)

Summary

reversing district court's dismissal of claim that overcrowding caused increased stress, tension and communicable disease among inmate population

Summary of this case from Rounds v. Woodford

Opinion

No. 84-1538.

Argued and Submitted April 13, 1987.

Decided June 19, 1987.

William H. Orrick III, and Tom Eicher, San Francisco, Cal., for plaintiff-appellants.

Glenn S. Grayson and James H. Danneberg, Honolulu, Hawaii, for defendants-appellees.

Appeal from the United States District Court for the District of Hawaii.

Before WALLACE, KENNEDY and WIGGINS, Circuit Judges.


Akao, Tripp, and Umiamaka (prisoners) brought a pro se action pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 1983 alleging a violation of their eighth amendment right to be free from cruel and unusual punishment. The defendants in this action, the Director of Corrections and Administrator of the Oahu Community Correction Center, moved to dismiss. The district court dismissed their action, holding that it "is clear that [the prisoners] can claim no eighth amendment violations." Order, p. 3. The prisoners appealed and we appointed pro bono representation. The district court had jurisdiction pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1331. We have jurisdiction pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1291. We reverse.

The district court properly held that an allegation of overcrowding without more does not state a claim under the eighth amendment. Hoptowit v. Ray, 682 F.2d 1237, 1249 (9th Cir. 1982). But more was alleged here: "Due to population increase in Module-1, there is an increase in stress, tension, communicable diseases, and a high increase in confrontations between inmates." Complaint, ¶ 12. Subsequent to the decision of the district court, we decided Toussaint v. Yockey, 722 F.2d 1490 (9th Cir. 1984), in which we affirmed a determination of an eighth amendment violation due to overcrowding when it "engenders violence, tension, and psychiatric problems." Id. at 1492.

Pro se complaints are held to a less strict standard than those drafted by a lawyer. Estelle v. Gamble, 429 U.S. 97, 106, 97 S.Ct. 285, 292, 50 L.Ed.2d 251 (1976). It is appropriate to dismiss a prose's action only if it is "beyond doubt that the plaintiff can prove no set of facts in support of his claim which would entitle him to relief." Id., quoting Conley v. Gibson, 355 U.S. 41, 45-46, 78 S.Ct. 99, 101-02, 2 L.Ed.2d 80 (1957). Given the intervening Toussaint opinion, we cannot say now that this test has been met.

It is true that the prisoners' allegations are not sufficiently specific and do not allege that they personally have suffered cruel or inhuman punishment, but we cannot hold that it is "beyond doubt" that they could not do so. Therefore, we reverse and remand for the district court to allow the prisoners to file an amendment.

Upon issuance of our mandate, pro bono counsel is relieved from his appointment. He may move for attorney's fees and costs pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 1988. Leeds v. Watson, 630 F.2d 674, 677 (9th Cir. 1980).

REVERSED AND REMANDED.


Summaries of

Akao v. Shimoda

United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit
Jun 19, 1987
832 F.2d 119 (9th Cir. 1987)

reversing district court's dismissal of claim that overcrowding caused increased stress, tension and communicable disease among inmate population

Summary of this case from Rounds v. Woodford

reversing district court's dismissal of claim that overcrowding caused increased stress, tension and communicable disease among inmate population

Summary of this case from Shirley Bishop v. Reyes

reversing district court's dismissal of claim that overcrowding caused increased stress, tension and communicable disease among inmate population

Summary of this case from Bakke v. Clark Cnty. Jail

reversing district court's dismissal of claim that overcrowding caused increased stress, tension and communicable disease among inmate population

Summary of this case from Leon-Lara v. Arpaio

reversing district court's dismissal of claim that overcrowding caused increased stress, tension, and communicable diseases, and confrontations between inmates

Summary of this case from Vice v. Arpaio

reversing district court's dismissal of claim that overcrowding caused increased stress, tension, and communicable diseases, and confrontations between inmates

Summary of this case from Rivera v. Arpaio

reversing district court's dismissal of claim that overcrowding caused increased stress, tension and communicable disease among inmate population

Summary of this case from Appell v. Maricopa Cnty.

reversing district court's dismissal of claim that overcrowding caused increased stress, tension and communicable disease among inmate population

Summary of this case from Ostler v. Arpaio

reversing district court's dismissal of claim that overcrowding caused increased stress, tension and communicable disease among inmate population

Summary of this case from Sanchez v. Durango Jail

reversing district court's dismissal of claim that overcrowding caused increased stress, tension and communicable disease among inmate population

Summary of this case from Perez v. Arpaio

reversing district court's dismissal of claim that overcrowding caused increased stress, tension and communicable disease among inmate population

Summary of this case from Leon-Lara v. Arpaio

reversing district court's dismissal of claim that overcrowding caused increased stress, tension, and communicable diseases, and confrontations between inmates

Summary of this case from Nava-Nuñ v. Durango Jail

reversing district court's dismissal of claim that overcrowding caused increased stress, tension and communicable disease among inmate population

Summary of this case from Morris v. Arpaio

reversing district court's dismissal of claim that overcrowding caused increased stress, tension and communicable disease among inmate population

Summary of this case from Folsom v. Arpaio

reversing district court's dismissal of claim that overcrowding caused increased stress, tension and communicable disease among inmate population

Summary of this case from Ostler v. Maricopa Cnty. Durango Jail

reversing district court's dismissal of claim that overcrowding caused increased stress, tension and communicable disease among inmate population

Summary of this case from Groch v. Arpaio

reversing district court's dismissal of claim that overcrowding caused increased stress, tension and communicable disease among inmate population

Summary of this case from Appell v. Maricopa Cnty. Sheriff's Office

reversing district court's dismissal of claim that overcrowding caused increased stress, tension and communicable disease among inmate population

Summary of this case from Miel v. Maricopa Cnty. Sheriff

reversing district court's dismissal of claim that overcrowding caused increased stress, tension and communicable disease among inmate population

Summary of this case from Arias v. Arpaio

reversing district court's dismissal of claim that overcrowding caused increased stress, tension and communicable disease among inmate population

Summary of this case from Alford v. Arpaio

reversing district court's dismissal of claim that overcrowding caused increased stress, tension, and communicable diseases, and confrontations between inmates

Summary of this case from Coomes v. Arpaio

reversing district court's dismissal of claim that overcrowding caused increased stress, tension, and communicable diseases, and confrontations between inmates

Summary of this case from Aguilar v. Arpaio

reversing district court's dismissal of claim that overcrowding caused increased stress, tension and communicable disease among inmate population

Summary of this case from Davids v. Maricopa Cnty. Sheriffs Office

reversing district court's dismissal of claim that overcrowding caused increased stress, tension, communicable disease, and confrontation between inmates

Summary of this case from Valdespino v. Brewer

reversing district court's dismissal of claim that overcrowding caused increased stress, tension and communicable disease among inmate population

Summary of this case from Lopez-Cortes v. Maricopa Cnty. Sheriff Joseph M. Arpaio
Case details for

Akao v. Shimoda

Case Details

Full title:EMMET AKAO, ALLEN V. TRIPP AND GARRICK UMIAMAKA, PLAINTIFFS-APPELLANTS, v…

Court:United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit

Date published: Jun 19, 1987

Citations

832 F.2d 119 (9th Cir. 1987)
832 F.2d 119

Citing Cases

Meyers v. Arpaio

But overcrowding may result in circumstances that do rise to the level of Eighth Amendment violations. The…

Belanus v. Dutton

Allegations of overcrowding, alone, are insufficient to state a claim under the Eighth Amendment. Rhodes v.…