In re SSA Bonds Antitrust Litigation

REPLY MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support re: 520 MOTION to Dismiss the Second Consolidated Amended Class Action Complaint. . Document

S.D.N.Y.March 13, 2019

!"#$%&'()*+,$-*./,*#$ &$0.$0',"&+# 1123453678113 9: ;<== =< ;; < >== < =< =;< < < = Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 1 of 46 3?3 @< ;ABC D9E9FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF1 9FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG F DHHIJFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG FKLMMNO?P?NQINQR?STOKUPDVU?QP?ROHU?VNDVLUWQP?PSXOPQYXSZFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG FKLMMNO?P?NQINQR?STOPKUPDVU?QP?RROSLNPR?4?LQPQRNS4LSOFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF18 F[IDIEEDHH9DFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG6 FDVU?QP?RRO\INQOM?SU4ZKLNSZ?ONQOLQO?4UVFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG1 FDVU?QP?RROHU?VPNVL]L?SL4P5?WLQ4LNRPKLVL]LWINQOM?SU4ZNPPNINTMLPLFFFFFG2 IFDVU?QP?RROHU?VPNVL]LI?S4XTOPUQP?UV5?WLQ4LXR?4?LQPPNXMMNSPUDVUXO?̂VL QRLSLQ4LNRINQOM?SU4ZFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF76 F DHH9DDDDFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF72 IIFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF78_ ` Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 2 of 46 3?3 @< ; abc AdCd e$fg$he,!$i,g$-*/.,j$k&g$lg$k","mn&(op$q+'gr G61st1u1vG6wxFFFEF9USFG6rG61syFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF1s 0mz/$k&nog$lg${&.|)/+$i/'!#${nogp$q+'gr G612t866w671xFFFEFN5F76rG612yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFw 0./#}/$~.*'g$*+#"&+$€(+|$lg/+}$&z$0)g$k&nogr 18vHFXMMF7WuuxFFFEFG612yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF12rG6r77 q+$n*$0.()"+()$f/n*!&(#"+m$0+,",n(#,$‚","mgr s77HF7W1v1xGWI?SFG612yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF2r8 0)*n"'/+$k&.()+$ƒ$‚()„*n$k&g$lg$…+",*|$i,/,*#r Gv8FF788x1wG1yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFGs 0o*†$‡".$k&g$lg$%"ˆ/(n&r sGGHFGWGu2xGWI?SF1ws8yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFGs 0##&'g${*+g$k&+,n/',&n#$lg$k/.g$i,/,*$k&(+'".$&z$k/no*+,*n#r uvwFFv1wx1ws7yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF1sr1wrG6 /,"o/m."/lg‰*Š$‹&n}$i,/,*$‚"Œ(&n$0(,!gr 8uvHFGW122xGWI?SF1wsuyFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFurGw *.$0,.g$k&nog$lg$ Š&)„.jr vv6FFvuuxG668yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF16 "m*.&Š$lg$-‡$-/|"&$"',(n*#r 7G8FFGv1x1wu2yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG6 k!/n.*#$i'!Š/„k&nog$lg$/+}$&z$0)g$k&nogr ss7HF7W2sxGWI?SFG61syFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF72 k",j$&z$n&'},&+$-*,g$ij#g$lg$i!/Š${nog$q+'gr vu6HFXMMFGWu2uxFFFEFG66syFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF16 q+$n*$k&))&|",j$~†'!gp$q+'gr G17HFXMMF7W271r2uvxFFFEFG612yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF12r77 q+$n*$k&))&|",j$~†'!gp$q+'g$i".l*n$€(,(n*#$ƒ$‡o,"&+#$ n/|"+m$‚","mgr G617t1166886xFFFEF9USF1srG617yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF12 Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 3 of 46 3??3 q+$n*$kn*|",$%*z/(.,$iŠ/o#$0+,",n(#,$‚","mgr G61utu78w11GxFFFEFLMFurG61uyFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF1s q+$n*$%%0Ž$%"n*',$(n'!/#*n$0+,",n(#,$‚","mgr vsvHF7W288xGWI?SFG66wyFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG6 q+$n*$%"m",/.$ˆ(#"'$0+,",n(#,$‚","mgr s1GHFXMMFGW7w6xFFFEFG611yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF78 q+$n*$~.*'g$&&}#$0+,",n(#,$‚","mFr svwHFXMMFGW281xFFFEFG61GyFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFGu €"l*$i)",!#p$q+'g$lg$‰/,"&+/.$€&&,„/.$‚*/m(*$./j*n#$0##&'"/,"&+r 8ssHFXMMF16uGxF9?QQF1wwGyFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFGs q+$n*$€./,${./##$0+,",n(#,$‚","mgr 7svHF7W7v6x7WI?SFG66uyFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFs q+$n*$€&n*"m+$~†'!g$*+'!)/n}$-/,*#$0+,",n(#,$‚","mgr G612tv16s171xFFFEFLMPFG6rG612yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG6rG7rGu q+$n*$€&n*"m+$~†'!g$*+'!)/n}$-/,*#$0+,",n(#,$‚","mFr 8uHFXMMF7Wvs1xFFFEFG61vyFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG7 €n&+,&"+,$0#"/+$~l*+,$%n"l*+$€(+|p$‚gg$lg$k","„/+}p$‰g0Fr G61stus766s8xFFFEF4PFurG61syFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF72 {/,$k&))'+#p$q+'Flg$ˆk$0##&'#gp$‚g‚gkgr 811HF7W2sxGWI?SFG617yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFGr1w {*.„&")$lg$/+}$&z$0)*n"'/$k&noFr sG7HF7W8vwxGWI?SFG612yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG6 /nnj$lg$ &,/.${/#$ƒ$&Š*n$‰g$0)gp$q+'gr GuuHFXMMF7Wu6GxFFFEFG618yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF8r1s q+$n*$"m!$€n(',&#*$k&n+$ijn(o$0+,",n(#,$‚","mgr GwvHF7W2v1x8PKI?SFG66GyFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFGu q+$n*$"m!‘ *'!$~)o.&j**$0+,",n(#,$‚","m/,"&+r sv2HFXMMFGW1167xFFIUVFG61GyFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFGu "+|#$k&(+,jp$ˆ"##"##"oo"$lg$f/'!&l"/$/+}$‰g0gr 866HFXMMFGW78sxFFFEFG616yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG8 q."+&"#$n"'}$k&g$lg$q."+&"#r u71FF8G6x1w88yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF1w Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 4 of 46 3?53 q+$n*$q+#g$n&}*n/m*$0+,",n(#,$‚","mgr 21sHF7W766x7WI?SFG616yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF7G q+$n*$q+,*n*#,$-/,*$iŠ/o#$0+,",n(#,$‚","mgr G21HFXMMF7Wu76xFFFEFG618yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF1s ’g$ n(*,$/j+*$k&gp$q+'g$lg$k!nj#.*n$ˆ&,&n#$k&nogr uv1FFvv8x1ws1yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG6 ‚/()/++$lg$‰/,"&+/.$&'}*j$‚*/m(*r w68HFXMMFGWu2vxFFFEFG61GyFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF1w ‚/j|&+$lg$ˆ"“(!&$/+}p$‚,|gr G61ut1Gs6u2uxFFFEF9USFGsrG61uyFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF1sr1w ‚*†)/n}$q+,.p$q+'glg$i,/,"'$k&+,n&.$k&)o&+*+,#p$q+'gr 17uFIPF1788xG61uyFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG6 q+$n*$‚&+|&+$i".l*n$€"†"+mp$‚,|gp$0+,",n(#,$‚","mgr G61st7vsvG88xFFFEF”XVZGvrG61syFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG7rG2r77 ˆ/†")${nog$‚‚klg‚"z*$/n,+*n#$&.|"+m#p$q+'gr 2w6HFXMMFGWGw7xFFFEFG616yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF16 ˆ/j&n$ƒ$k",j$k&(+'".$&z$/.,")&n*p$ˆ|g$lg$k","mn&(op$q+'gr 86wHF7W1GwxGWI?SFG617yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF7G q+$n*$ˆ*nn".$‚j+'!$ j'&$-*#*/n'!$i*'g$‚","mgr G66ut76vs6wxFFFEFHL̂F1srG66uyFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF7v q+$n*$‰0i%0•$ˆ/n}*,‘ˆ/}*n#$0+,",n(#,$‚","m/,"&+r 12wHFFFuw7xFFFEF1ww2yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFGu ‰jo.$lg$’ˆ&nm/+$k!/#*$ƒ$k&gr G618t1177uu2xFFFEF9USFGurG618yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF1w &)o/+&‘f"+|j$k",j$/n,+*n#p$‚,|g$lg$*/n$i,*/n+#$ƒ$k&gp$q+'gr 8wuHFXMMF1G2vxFFFEF1wwGyFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF7u n*'"#"&+$0##&'"/,*#p$q+'g$lg$/+/.o"+/$f&n.|$ n/+#o&n,$–&.|"+m—$‚,|gr G611t86v7s68xFFFEF”UQFurG611yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFwr1wr78 n")*$*/.,!'/n*$i*nl#gp$q+'g$lg$i*nlg$~)o#g$q+,.$…+"&+r G617t7s8768uxFFIUVF”XVZGvrG617yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF76 -&,!lgk","ˆ&n,m/m*$q+'gr 8v2HF7W18sxGWI?SFG61uyFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFv Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 5 of 46 353 q+$n*$i‚ˆ$k&nog$~-qi0$‚","mgr G616t7w16v22xFFFEFLMPFGurG616yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF1u i&+,*nn/$k/o",/.$ˆ/#,*n$€(+|$‚,|g$lg$kn*|",$i("##*${nog$0{r G88HFXMMF7WvG1xFFFEFG618yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFwr71 i,/*!n$lg$/n,z&n|$€"+g$i*nl#g${nogp$q+'gr vu8HF7Wu62xGWI?SFG66syFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF7v i,/nn$lg$i&+j$ˆ{$ˆ(#"'$~+,*n,/"+)*+,r vwGHF7W71uxGWI?SFG616yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF7u i(."l/+$lg$/n'./j#$‚kr G618t2svv86xFFFEFHL̂FG1rG618yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFGu q+$n*$ € ‘‚k%$–€./,$/+*.—$0+,",n(#,$‚","m/,"&+r G28HFFFvs7xFFIUVFG616yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFGu &||$lg$~††&+$k&nogr G8vHF7W1w1xGWI?SFG661yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFu …+",*|$i,/,*#lgk&+,/"+*n$k&nogr 7w7FF777x1w2wyFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFursrGsrGw …+",*|$i,/,*#$lg$…gig${jo#()$k&gr u7sFFuGGx1w8syFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF76 …+"l*n#/.${n/|"+m$i*nlg$lg$*/jp$q+'Fr G61Gt862uuxFFIUVF”UQFwrG61GyFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF71 q+$n*$˜"+'$0+,",n(#,$‚","mgr 1vvHFXMMF7W778xFFFEFG612yFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG1r72 Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 6 of 46 1 LUVLSLRLQWUQPO1SLOML4PRXVZOX̂T?PPK?OYN?QPSLMVZTLTNSUQWXTNRVU™?QRXSPKLS OXMMNSPNRPKL?STNP?NQPNW?OT?OOPKLL4NQWINQONV?WUPLWTLQWLWIVUOO4P?NQINTMVU?QP xšPFv62yxPKL›INTMVU?QPœNS›IœyRNSRU?VXSLPNOPUPLU4VU?TMXSOXUQPPNXVL1Gx̂yx2yNR PKLHLWLSUVXVLONRI?5?VDSN4LWXSLF ; <= = DVU?QP?RRO\NMMNO?P?NQ̂S?LRxPKL›MMNO?P?NQœNS›9LS?POMMFœy4NQR?STOPKUPDVU?QP?RO\ 4VU?TOOKNXVŴLW?OT?OOLWRNSPKLSLUONQOOLPRNSPK?QLUVLSLRLQWUQPO\NMLQ?Q]̂S?LRF €"n#,rDVU?QP?RRO\4VU?TOOKNXVŴLW?OT?OOLWRNSVU4šNRUQP?PSXOPOPUQW?Q]̂L4UXOLrURPLS PKSLLUPLTMPOrDVU?QP?RROOP?VKU5LQNPUVL]LWPKUPPKLZOXRLSLWUQP?PSXOP?QYXSZNSUSLLR?4?LQP LQRNS4LSONRPKLUQP?PSXOPVU™OFDVU?QP?RORU?VPNLMVU?QKN™PKL?SMU]LONR›UQUVZOLOrœ MXSMNSPLWVZNR›TUSšLP3™?WLOXTTUSZWUPUrœLOPÛV?OKPKUPPKLZPKLTOLV5LOKU5L̂LLQKUSTLWF KLZUVONRU?VPNLMVU?QUWLžXUPLVZKN™PKL?SUVL]UP?NQONR›TUSšLP3™?WLœKUSTUSLMVUXO?̂VL?Q V?]KPNRPKLUVL]LWO?ŸLr̂SLUWPKrUQWW?5LSO?PZNRPKLMXSMNSPLW›TUSšLPœRNŜNQWOFP N̂PNTrDVU?QP?RORU?VPNUVL]LPKUPUQZNRPKL?SPSUQOU4P?NQO™LSLMS?4L3R?LWFQWL5LQ?R DVU?QP?RRO4NXVWTUšLOX4KUVL]UP?NQONR?QYXSZ MLSONQUVNS›TUSšLP3™?WLœ PKL?SMMNO?P?NQ RU?VOPNLMVU?QKN™PKLZUSLLR?4?LQPLQRNS4LSONRPKLUQP?PSXOPVU™OF i*'&+|rPKLIOKNXVŴLW?OT?OOLWNQPKLOLMUSUPLUQW?QWLMLQWLQP]SNXQWPKUP?PRU?VO PNMVUXO?̂VZUVL]LU4NQOM?SU4ZFDVU?QP?RROUS]XLPKUPx1yPKL̂SNUW4NQOM?SU4ZPKLZUVL]L4NXVW KU5LNMLSUPLWONVLVZPKSNX]K/|$!&'4NTTXQ?4UP?NQOUTNQ]OX̂OLPONRLRLQWUQPO¡xGyPKLNXP3 NR34NQPLPrTNOPVẐ?VUPLSUV4KUPOPKLZUVL]L?QPKLI4NQOP?PXPLW?SL4PL5?WLQ4LNRU 4NQOM?SU4ZUTNQ]UVLRLQWUQPO¡UQWx7yL5LQ?RPKLZUSLQNPrPKLZUSLUOXR?4?LQP̂UO?OPN?QRLS U4NQOM?SU4ZUTNQ]UVLRLQWUQPOFXPQNQLNRPKNOLUS]XTLQPOKUOTLS?PFDVU?QP?RROKU5LQN TLUQ?Q]RXVSLOMNQOLPNLUVLSLRLQWUQPO\US]XTLQPPKUPPKL5LSZ4KUPOPKUPDVU?QP?ROK?]KV?]KP 1LR?QLWPLSTOKU5LPKLOUTLTLUQ?Q]UO4S?̂LWPNPKLT?QLUVLSLRLQWUQPO\NMLQ?Q]TLS?PÔS?LRx›9LS?POSFœyF Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 7 of 46 G ?QPKL?SMMNO?P?NQUO›4NQ4SLPLrœW?SL4PL5?WLQ4LNRU4NQOM?SU4Z UVNR™K?4KUSL̂?VUPLSUVUQW XQ4NQQL4PLW TLSLVZXQWLSO4NSLPKLRSU]TLQPLWQUPXSLNRPKLUVL]UP?NQO?QPKLIUQWPKL XPLSVU4šNRUQZMVUXO?̂VLUVL]UP?NQOOX]]LOP?Q]UQẐSNUWUQWLQWXS?Q]U]SLLTLQPrVLPUVNQL OX4KUQU]SLLTLQP̂LP™LLQUVNRPKLLUVLSLRLQWUQPOF HNSPKLOLUQWNPKLSSLUONQOrDVU?QP?RRO\4VU?TOOKNXVŴLW?OT?OOLWF a= ¢ ;< < a¢ DVU?QP?RROWL4VUSL?QPKL?SMMNO?P?NQPKUPPKLI›4XSL£O¤PKLNQVZWLR?4?LQ4ZPKLINXSP ?WLQP?R?LWœ?QW?OT?OO?Q]PKL?SMS?NS4NTMVU?QPx9LS?POMMFUP7yr̂XPPKLZWNQNPK?Q]PNOKN™ PKUPPKLI\OUWW?P?NQUVUVL]UP?NQONR?SSLVL5UQPPSUQOU4P?NQOUQWMU]LONRTLUQ?Q]VLOO ›UQUVZOLOœNR›TUSšLP3™?WLOXTTUSZWUPUœx"|FUPu8yLOPÛV?OK›PKUP,!*j,!*)#*.l*#KU5L̂LLQ KUSTLŴZ£W¤LRLQWUQPO\U4P?5?P?LOœx9L4?O?NQUP1uyFOPK?OINXSPKUOSL4N]Q?ŸLWr DVU?QP?RRO\RU?VXSL?ORUPUVFq|FQWL5LQ?RDVU?QP?RRO4NXVWMVUXO?̂VZUVL]LONTLUPLQXUPLW ?QYXSZx™K?4KPKLZWNQNPyrPKL?S4VU?TO™NXVWOP?VRU?V̂L4UXOLDVU?QP?RROUSLQNPLR?4?LQP LQRNS4LSONRPKLUQP?PSXOPVU™OFDVU?QP?ROrPKLSLRNSLrVU4šUQP?PSXOPOPUQW?Q]UQWPKL?S4VU?TO OKNXVŴLW?OT?OOLWF ¢¥ ¦C§§̈d©ª©̈«̈«¬©®d¦Aª;̄A©«ª©¬¬dA©̄̈;̄CA° «ª©ª±dª«²±³¢ NUOOLOO™KLPKLSUMVU?QP?RRMVLUWOUQP?PSXOP?QYXSZr4NXSPOTXOP›?WLQP?RZPKLU4PXUV ?QYXSZPKLMVU?QP?RRUVL]LOœUQW›PKL™UZO?Q™K?4KPKLMVU?QP?RR4VU?TO?P?O?QU™NSOLMNO?P?NQUO U4NQOLžXLQ4LNRPKLWLRLQWUQP\O4NQWX4PFœ{/,$k&))'+#p$q+'Flg$ˆk$0##&'#gp$‚g‚gkgr811 HF7W2sr82xGWI?SFG617yx?QPLSQUVžXNPUP?NQOUQW4?PUP?NQNT?PLWyFKLMMNO?P?NQ4NQR?STO PKUPDVU?QP?RO\4VU?TO4UQQNPOXS5?5LOX4KO4SXP?QZF Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 8 of 46 7 1F́ DVU?QP?RROHU?VPNDVLUWQYXSZ3Q3HU4PL4UXOLKLZNNPVL]LKUP QZNRKL?SSUQOU4P?NQOtLSLDS?4L3H?LWF DVU?QP?RROUWT?PPKUP›PKLIWNLOµ¶·UVL]LPKUPLRLQWUQPOR?LWPKLMS?4LNRL5LSZ O?Q]VL̂NQWPSUQOU4P?NQFœ9LS?POMMFUPuxLTMKUO?O?QNS?]?QUVyFQPKL4NQPSUSZr DVU?QP?RROUVL]LPKUPUKUQWRXVNRPSUWLSOVN4UPLWÛSNUW›W?SL4PVZR?£LW¤PKLMS?4LOœNRUV?T?PLW QXT̂ LSNRPSUQOU4P?NQO?QMUSP?4XVUŜNQWO™?PKOML4?R?44NXQPLSMUSP?LOFi**p$*gmgr$ FXPYXOPV?šLDVU?QP?RRO\MS?NSMVLUW?Q]OrPKLIWNLOQNPMVUXO?̂VZUVL]LPKUP./"+,"z#$ ™LSLMUSPZPNUQZMS?4L3R?LWPSUQOU4P?NQOF UF́ VL]UP?NQOKUPDVU?QP?RROSUWLWNQWOQPKLUTLUZO DXSMNSPLWVZINVXO?5LIKUPSLQOXR?4?LQPPNKN™QYXSZF LOM?PLDVU?QP?RRO\4NQPLQP?NQOPNPKL4NQPSUSZrTLSLVZUVL]?Q] WNLOQNPK?Q]PN 9LS?POMMFUPu8FDVU?QP?RRO4NQ4LWLPKUPQL?PKLSDHIQNSSNQtNSšLSO™UOMUSPZPN x'&)o/n*9LS?POSFUPs311rŠ",! 9LS?POMMFUPuv3u8yUQWUOOLSPTLSLVZPKUPPKLZPSUQOU4PLW›?QPKLOUTLGuKNXSMLS?NWUO PSUWLSOœOXMMNOLWVZ›W?O4XOOLWTUQ?MXVUP?NQFœ9L4?O?NQUP12xžXNP?Q]q+$n*$‚&+|&+$ i".l*n$€"†"+mp$‚,|gp$0+,",n(#,$‚","mgrG61st7vsvG88rUP̧G8QF72xFFFEF”XVZGvrG61syy¡ #**p$*gmgr ¡#**$/.#& FK?OINXSPKUO UVSLUWZKLVWPKUPOX4KUVL]UP?NQOUSL›O?TMVZPNNPK?QÛUO?ORNSPKLINXSPPN?QRLSPKUP?P?O MVUXO?̂VLPKUPPKLPSUWLSO\LTMVNZLSO4UXOLWPKLDVU?QP?R£O¤U4PXUVWUTU]LOFœ9L4?O?NQUP 12x?QPLSQUVžXNPUP?NQNT?PLWyFGDVU?QP?RTUšLOO?T?VUSVZWLR?4?LQPUVL]UP?NQOx GDVU?QP?RORU?VPNUWLžXUPLVZLMVU?Q™KZ4LSPU?Q4KUPOrUVL]LWVZN44XSS?Q]NQPKLOUTLWUZPKUPDVU?QP?ROPSUWLWr ™LSL?TMSNMLSFi**9LS?POSFUPw316FL]USWVLOOrPKLZWNQNPK?Q]PNOKN™KN™UQZQUTLWDVU?QP?R™UOKUSTLWF DVU?QP?RO4NQ4LWLPKUP Fi**$9LS?POMMFUPuv3u2FQOPLUWrDVU?QP?ROOPSU?QPN US]XLPKUP x"|gyr™K?4K?OQNPr?POLVRrUo*n$#*$5?NVUP?NQNR PKLUQP?PSXOPVU™O™?PKUMSLOXTLW?TMU4PNQMS?4LOPKUP4NXVWLOPÛV?OKUQP?PSXOP?QYXSZx#**$9LS?POSFUPsQFvru13 u7¡#**$/.#&$"+zn/UPG83GwyrUQWUVL]LQNRU4POUOPNKN™ F Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 9 of 46 u yrUVNR™K?4KRU?VRNSPKLOUTLSLUONQF7 F̂́ DVU?QP?RRHU?VOPNVL]LQZQP?PSXOPQYXSZQPO F UVONOML4XVUPLOPKUP?P™UOMUSPZPNUPSUQOU4P?NQW?O4XOOLW?Q FI¹¹18738sFtK?VLDVU?QP?ROWL5NPLMU]L URPLSMU]LNRPKL?SMMNO?P?NQPNPK?O4KUPx9LS?POMMFUP137ruG3uvyr?PUWWOQNPK?Q]PNPKL?S US]XTLQPF UVL]LOPKUPr FXPUOLRLQWUQPO\NMLQ?Q]̂S?LRTUWL4VLUSx9LS?POSF UP11yrL5LQ?R PKXORU?VOPNMVUXO?̂VZUVL]LPKUP?P™UO U4PXUVZ?QYXSLŴZUQZMXSMNSPLWUQP?4NTMLP?P?5L4NQWX4PNQ Fi**$9LS?POSF UP11FDVU?QP?RRO\MMNO?P?NQRU?VOPNUWWSLOOPK?ORXQWUTLQPUVWLRL4P?QPKLIFu 7QURNNPQNPLrDVU?QP?ROT?OVLUW?Q]VZ4NQPLQWPKUPLRLQWUQPO›WNQNP4KUVLQ]LPKLKUSTPN KUP?O™SNQ]FLRLQWUQPO\NMLQ?Q]̂S?LRTUWL4VLUSPKUP/.4VU?TÔUOLW NQ›UVL]UP?NQONRPSUWLOUPXQOML4?R?LWP?TLONQPKLOUTLWUZUOOXMMNOLWVZ4NVXO?5L4KUPOœRU?VXQWLSPK?OINXSP\O MS?NSSXV?Q]F9LS?POSFUPwFQUQZL5LQPrPKLIWNLOQNPL5LQUPLTMPPNUVL]LPKUP uDVU?QP?ROUS]XLPKUPPKLMXSMNSPLW›OKUS?Q]NRMS?4?Q]?QRNSTUP?NQUTNQ]KNS?ŸNQPUV4NTMLP?PNSO?OPKLPZMLNR ?QYXSZ4NQPLTMVUPLŴZPKLUQP?PSXOPVU™OœUQWXQVU™RXV›MLSOLœx9LS?POMMFUP81QFv8yr̂XPPKL?SNQVZOXMMNSP?Q PKL4UOLVU™?OUR?RPZ3ZLUSNVWXMSLTLINXSPWL4?O?NQr…+",*|$i,/,*#lgk&+,/"+*n$k&nogr7w7FF777x1w2wyr ™K?4KPKLL4NQWI?S4X?PKUOOX̂OLžXLQPVZW?OP?Q]X?OKLWUO›RU4P̂NXQWœUQWSLVL5UQPNQVZPNUSXVLNRSLUONQ4UOLF i**$/,"o/m."/lg‰*Š$‹&n}$i,/,*$‚"Œ(&n$0(,!gr8uvHFGW122r18vxGWI?SF1wsuy¡#**$/.#&$ &||$lg$~††&+$k&nogr G8vHF7W1w1r1wwxGWI?SFG661yxNPNTUZNSr”FyxLMVU?Q?Q]PKUPPKLXMSLTLINXSPKUWSLONV5LWMS?NS4NQRXO?NQ UTNQ]4NXSPÔZ›4VUS?RZ?Q]PKUPºPKLW?OOLT?QUP?NQNRMS?4L?QRNSTUP?NQ?OQNP?POLVRUMLSOL5?NVUP?NQNRPKL Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 10 of 46 v QOPLUWrDVU?QP?RO4SLUPLUSLWKLSS?Q]̂ZPUš?Q]?OOXLx9LS?POMMFUPu73uuy™?PK F9LS?POSFUP11»QF11F44NSW?Q]PNDVU?QP?ROr 9LS?POMMF UPuuFK?O4VU?T?OÛOXSWFLRLQWUQPOW?WQNPUOšPKLINXSPPN›PUš£L¤YXW?4?UVQNP?4LNR LPS?QO?4TUPLS?UVœNS›OL4NQW3]XLOOœDVU?QP?RRO\UVL]UP?NQÔUOLWNQ›OL4NQWUSZONXS4LOFœ 9LS?POMMFUPuuQF7vFUPKLSrLRLQWUQPOTUWLUQN̂OLS5UP?NQPKUPPKLl*nj$#/)*VNNT̂LS] WUPUXOLW?QUVNRDVU?QP?RRO\MXSMNSPLWLMLSPUQUVZOLO?QPKLIWLTNQOPSUPLPKL?TMVUXO?̂?V?PZ NRDVU?QP?RRO\UVL]UP?NQOFi**I¹¹v6s3v1FL4UXOLDVU?QP?RO›KUWšQN™VLW]LUQWSLV?LWNQ £PK?OWUPU¤?Q̂S?Q]?Q]OX?PrœPKLWUPUKUÔLLQ›?Q4NSMNSUPLW£¤̂ZSLRLSLQ4Lœ?QPNPKLIrUQW PKLINXSPTUZ4NQO?WLS?PNQLRLQWUQPO\TNP?NQF-&,!lgk","ˆ&n,m/m*$q+'gr8v2HF7W18sr1s6 xGWI?SFG61uyFv 4F́ DVU?QP?RRIUQQNPKN™QP?PSXOPQYXSẐZDN?QP?Q]PN QPLSWLUVLSSUW?Q]F UPLTMPOPN̂NVOPLS?POUVL]UP?NQOSLVUP?Q]PN 9LS?POMMFUPu7FXPUOLRLQWUQPO\NMLQ?Q]̂S?LRLMVU?QLWx9LS?PO KLSTUQ4PF\œyx4?P?Q]…+",*|$i,/,*#lg$k","“*+#$ƒ$ig$‰/,.$/+}ruGGFFs2r117x1w8vyyFDVU?QP?ROrNR4NXSOLr KU5LQNPMVLWUSXVLNRSLUONQ4UOLFi**$"+zn/$QF7wFQWPKLZ4UQQNPPSUQORNSTUVL]LW?QRNSTUP?NQOKUS?Q] ™K?4K ™NXVWQLLWPN̂LUQUVZŸLWXQWLSUSXVLNRSLUONQUQUVZO?O ?QPNo*n$#*?VL]UVMS?4LR??Q]™?PKUMSLOXTLWMS?4L ?TMU4PPKSNX]K"o#*$|"†",$UQW?QUMMNO?PL4UOLVU™F vDVU?QP?RO\MNO?P?NQUMMLUSOPN̂LPKUPx1yPKLINXSPOKNXVWU44LMPVNNT̂ LS]WUPURNSMXSMNOLONRDVU?QP?RO\ L4NQNT?4UQUVZOLO¡̂XPxGyPKLINXSPOKNXVWW?OSL]USWPKUP5LSZOUTLWUPU™KLQ?PMVU?QVZOKN™OPKUP 9LS?POMMFUPuuFNOPUPLDVU?QP?RO\MNO?P?NQ?OPNSLRXPL?PF KLSL?OO?TMVZQNPK?Q]›?TMSNMLSœÛNXPLRLQWUQPO\XO?Q]›VNNT̂ LS]WUPUœPNOKN™PKUPU›OML4?R?4DVU?QP?R SL4L?5LWÛUS]U?QNQUOML4?R?4?QPSU3WUZPSUWLPKUPU4PXUVZN44XSSLWUPUOML4?R?4P?TLrœ™KLQDVU?QP?ROPKLTOLV5LO UPLTMPPNXOLPKUP5LSZOUTLWUPUPNOKN™PKUPDVU?QP?RO™LSL!/n)*|NQ›OML4?R?4?QPSU3WUZPSUWL£O¤Fœq|g Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 11 of 46 2 SFUPw316yrPK?OUVL]UP?NQRU?VOPNOKN™UQP?PSXOP?QYXSZUOUTUPLSNRVU™̂L4UXOL FL4UXOLUMVU?QP?RR TXOP̂LU›MUSP?4?MUQP?QPKL5LSZTUSšLPW?SL4PVZW?OPNSPLŴZPKLUQP?PSXOP5?NVUP?NQrœ 4UQQNP4VU?TUQZUQP?PSXOP?QYXSẐUOLWNQ4NQWX4PPKUPN44XSSLW?QUQ?QPLSWLUVLSPSUW?Q] LQ5?SNQTLQP?Q™K?4KW?WQNPMUSP?4?MUPLFq+$n*$0.()"+()$f/n*!&(#"+m$0+,",n(#,$‚","mgr s77HF7W1v1r126321r27xGWI?SFG612yF DVU?QP?RROUOOLSPPKUP 9LS?POMMFUPuuQF7ur8638GFK?O?O™SNQ]FN̂L]?Q™?PKrDVU?QP?RRO\ US]XTLQP?ORVUPVZ4NQPSUW?4PLŴZDVU?QP?RRO\MS?NŜS?LR?Q]̂LRNSLPK?OINXSPr?Q™K?4KDVU?QP?RO UOOLSPLWUW?OP?Q4P?NQ̂LP™LLQPKL?QPLSWLUVLSUQWWLUVLS3PN34XOPNTLS›TUSšLPOœUQWUR?STUP?5LVZ SLMSLOLQPLWPKUPPKL4NTMVU?QP›WNLO+&,UVL]LPKUPDVU?QP?RO™LSLW?SL4PVZ?QYXSLŴZ PSUQOU4P?NQÔLP™LLQWLUVLSO?QPKL?QPLSWLUVLSTUSšLPFœi**$DVOF\INQONVFMM\QPNLROF\9NPF N?OT?OOxIHNFuGuyUPvGQFG2F$DVU?QP?RROUVON?]QNSLPKLI\OWLPU?VLWUVL]UP?NQONR KN™̂NQWO™LSLPSUWLWUQWMS?4LWr™K?4K4VLUSVZW?OP?Q]X?OK̂LP™LLQ?QPLSWLUVLSUQW WLUVLS3PN34XOPNTLSPSUQOU4P?NQOUQW?QRNSTUP?NQRVN™F2 9NSLRXQWUTLQPUVZrDVU?QP?RO4UQQNPOUP?ORZ0.()"+()\OPLOPRNSUQP?PSXOP?QYXSZTLSLVZ ẐUOOLSP?Q]RNSPKLR?SOPP?TL?QPKL?SMMNO?P?NQPKUPLRLQWUQPO x9LS?POMMFUP8Gyr̂L4UXOL PKLI?POLVR4NQPU?QOQNUVL]LWRU4POPNOXMMNSPPKUPPKLNSZFKLIWNLOQNPL5LQUPLTMP 2i**p$*gmgrI¹¹172378xWLO4S?̂?Q]W?RLSLQ4LÔLP™LLQLRLQWUQPO\›U4P?5?P£?LO¤UOTUSšLPTUšLSOœUQW ›PSUW£?Q]¤̂NQWO™?PKNPKLSWLUVLSOœy¡#**$/.#&$"|g¹¹176377r17w3uGxWLO4S?̂?Q]KN™MS?4LO™LSLžXNPLW?Q WLUVLS3PN34XOPNTLSPSUW?Q]yF Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 12 of 46 8 PNLMVU?Q r8NSKN™OXMMNOLWVZ x9LS?POMMFUPu7y i**p$*gmgrI¹177xUVL]?Q]žXNPLÔL4UTLOPUVLžX?4šVZyFNSWNDVU?QP?ROUPLTMPPN MVLUWKN™4XOPNTLSOV?šL™NXVWKU5LVLUSQLWPKUP 44NSW?Q]VZrDVU?QP?RRO4UQQNPLOPÛV?OKPKUPPKLZOXRLSLW UQP?PSXOP?QYXSZUOUSLOXVPNRUVL]LW?QPLSWLUVLSPSUW?Q]NSUQZMXSMNSPLW›4NVUPLSUVœLRL4PO PKLSLRSNTFs GF́ KLIHU?VOPNVL]LQZ›9USšLP3t?WLœ[USTPNDVU?QP?RROF UF́ KLPSX4PXSLNRPKLVL]LWNQW›9USšLPœLQWLSO DVU?QP?RRO\IVU?TONR›9USšLP3t?WLœ[USTTMVUXO?̂VLF LRLQWUQPO\NMLQ?Q]̂S?LRWLTNQOPSUPLW™KZDVU?QP?RO\UVL]UP?NQONR›TUSšLP3™?WLœ KUST™LSLRXQWUTLQPUVZ?TMVUXO?̂VL?QV?]KPNRPKLUVL]LWO?ŸLr̂SLUWPKrUQWW?5LSO?PZNR MSNWX4PO™?PK?QPKLMXSMNSPLW›TUSšLPœRNŜNQWOF9LS?POSFUP1G31uFUPKLSPKUQ SLOMNQWPNPKLOLUS]XTLQPOrDVU?QP?ROUOOLSPPKLZOXRLSLWUQP?PSXOP?QYXSẐL4UXOLPKLZ ›MXS4KUOL£W¤/$on&|(',OX̂YL4PPNUQP?4NTMLP?P?5L4NVXO?NQ|"n*',.j$RSNTœLRLQWUQPOF9LS?PO MMFUP2wxLTMKUO?OUWWLWyFOUPKSLOKNVWTUPLSr̂NQWOUSLQNPUO?Q]XVUS ›MSNWX4PrœUODVU?QP?RRO\N™QUVL]UP?NQOTUšL4VLUSFi**p$*gmgrI¹¹11v31s¡9LS?POMMFUP 8tK?VLDVU?QP?RO5U]XLVZUVL]LPKUP xI¹172yrDVU?QP?RORU?VPNUVL]LUQZRU4POLOPÛV?OK?Q]KN™PK?O?QRNSTUP?NQ™UOXOLWr?RUPUVrPN 4NTMXPLžXNPLORNSWLUVLS3PN34XOPNTLSPSUQOU4P?NQOrNSOML4?R?4UVZRNSPKL?SN™QPSUQOU4P?NQOF si**$0.()"+()rs77HF7WUP126327¡#**$/.#&$/nnj$lg$ &,/.${/#$ƒ$&Š*n$‰g$0)gp$q+'grGuuHFXMMF7Wu6GruG7 xFFFEFG618yxMVU?QP?RPKUPMXS4KUOLWQUPXSUV]UOUPNQLKX̂W?WQNPOXRLSUQP?PSXOP?QYXSZUOUSLOXVPNRUVL]LW TUQ?MXVUP?NQNRQUPXSUV]UOUPUW?RLSLQPKX̂̂L4UXOLUQZ?QYXSZMVU?QP?ROOXRRLSLW™UOQNP?QPKL5LSZTUSšLPPKUP ™UOUVL]LWVZ›W?SL4PVZSLOPSU?QLWœ̂ZPKLT?O4NQWX4PyF Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 13 of 46 s 86¡9LS?POSFUP1G317rG1FNNQLMSNWX4P™UOUVL]LWVZPKLOX̂YL4PNRLRLQWUQPO\UVL]LW N5LSUS4K?Q]U]SLLTLQP›QNPPN4NTMLPLFœ9LS?POSFUPu3vr16»QFwr1G317FQV?šLTNOP UQP?PSXOP4UOLO ?Q4VXW?Q]4UOLO4?PLW?QPKLMMNO?P?NQw PK?O?OQNPU4UOLÛNXPUKNTN]LQNXO ?QWXOPS?UVMSNWX4PNSRXQ]?̂VL4NTTNW?PZFDVU?QP?RROXOLPKLPLST›̂NQWOœPNSLRLSPN KXQWSLWONR̂?V?NQONRWNVUSO\™NSPKNR|"z*n*+,̂NQWO?OOXLŴZUTXVP?PXWLNR|"z*n*+, ?QOP?PXP?NQOU4SNOOPKL]VN̂LrNR|"z*n*+,TUPXS?P?LOUQW|"z*n*+,?OOXUQ4LWUPLOr™K?4KUSLPSUWLW UQWMS?4LW"+|*o*+|*+,.j$NRNQLUQNPKLSUQWUP|"z*n*+,P?TLOUQW?Q|"z*n*+,$5NVXTLOF9LS?PO SFUPu3vFKLMMNO?P?NQWNLOQNP L̂4UXOL?P4UQQNP 4KUVLQ]LLRLQWUQPO\N̂OLS5UP?NQPKUP ›PKLSL?OQNUSP?4XVUPLW4NTTNQUV?PẐLP™LLQPKL5US?NXOW?RLSLQPš?QWONR̂NQWOPKUPDVU?QP?RO MXSMNSPPN]SNXMXQWLSUO?Q]VLXT̂SLVUœUQW4UV›̂NQWOFœq|gUP1GF NSWNLOPKLMMNO?P?NQUWWSLOOPKLÛOLQ4LNRUVL]UP?NQO?QPKLILMVU?Q?Q]KN™ PKLMS?4LNRU]?5LQPSUQOU4P?NQ?QNQL̂NQWKUOUQZ?TMU4PNQPKLMS?4LNRUQZNPKLS N̂QWPSUQOU4P?NQFQWLLWrDVU?QP?RO4NQ4LWLPKUPPK?O›?OQNPUº̂LQ4KTUSš?Q]\4UOLrœ?Q™K?4KU MVU?QP?RRUVL]LO›TUQ?MXVUP?NQNRUMX̂V?OKLWR?]XSL™NXVW?QOPUQPVZUVPLS4UOKRVN™ORNS L5LSZNQL\O?QOPSXTLQPOPKUP™LSL4NQPSU4PXUVZP?LWPNPKUP̂LQ4KTUSšFœ9LS?POMMFUP7v¡#**$ /.#&$D”MMFUPGxºQUTLWDVU?QP?RRO™LSL5?4P?T?ŸLWFFFQNP̂L4UXOLPKL4KUPOžXNPLW?QPKL INTMVU?QP£KU5L¤UºS?MMVLLRL4P\NQOLMUSUPLrNPKLS™?OL3?QQN4LQPWLUVOrQNP̂L4UXOLPKLHNSL?]Q LUVLSLRLQWUQPOOLPMNV?4?LO?QPKLÛOPSU4PœyFDVU?QP?ROUVONU4šQN™VLW]LPKL?SUVL]UP?NQO PKUPPKL›TUSšLPœRNŜNQWO›?ONMUžXL̂L4UXOL?PSLV?LONQN5LS3PKL34NXQPLSPSUW?Q]œ™KLSL ›PKLSL?ONRPLQQNPSUQOMUSLQ4Z?QPNPSUW?Q]5NVXTLOrMS?4LOrNSNPKLSXOLRXV4NTTLS4?UV ?QRNSTUP?NQFœ9LS?POMMFUP72F?5LQPKLOLRU4PNSOUQWPKLÛOLQ4LNRUQZUVL]LWMS?4?Q] 4NTTNQUV?PẐLP™LLQW?RRLSLQP̂NQWOrDVU?QP?RO\US]XTLQPPKUPPKLZMXS4KUOLW›/$on&|(', wi**p$*gmgr…+",*|$i,/,*#lgk&+,/"+*n$k&nog$&z$0)gr7w7FF777x1w2wyx4?PLW?Q9LS?POMMFUP12r81QFv8y¡q+$n*$ €./,${./##$0+,",n(#,$‚","mgr7svHF7W7v6x7WI?SFG66uyx4?PLW?Q9LS?POMMFUPG1r1GsyF Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 14 of 46 w OX̂YL4PPNUQP?4NTMLP?P?5L4NVXO?NQœx"|gUP2wxLTMKUO?OUWWLWyy?OXQOXMMNSPLWUQW ?TMVUXO?̂VLF16 9NSLN5LSrDVU?QP?RROWNQNPUXPNTUP?4UVZKU5LUQP?PSXOPOPUQW?Q]̂L4UXOLPKLZUSL UVL]LWVZ›LRLQWUQPO\W?SL4P4XOPNTLSOFœ9LS?POMMFUP2wF9NOPNRDVU?QP?RO\UVL]UP?NQO MXSMNSP?Q]PNOKN™W?SL4PPSUQOU4P?NQO™?PKLRLQWUQPOUSL4NQ4VXONSZUQWLQP?PVLWPNQN™L?]KPF i**$9LS?POSFUPFF1FL]USWVLOOr4NXSPOSL]XVUSVZW?OT?OOUQP?PSXOP4VU?TOWLOM?PLUVL]UP?NQO NR›W?SL4PœPSUQOU4P?NQO™?PKUVL]LW4NQOM?S?Q]WLRLQWUQPOr™KLSLPKLSL?OQNMVUXO?̂VLUVL]UP?NQ PKUPU›W?SL4PœPSUQOU4P?NQ™UOTUQ?MXVUPLWFHNSLUTMVLr?Qn*'"#"&+$0##&'"/,*#p$q+'g$lg$ /+/.o"+/$f&n.|$ n/+#o&n,$–&.|"+m—$‚,|grG611t86v7s68xFFFEF”UQFurG611yr™K?4K DVU?QP?RRO4?PLrPKL4NXSP$UWWSLOOLW4VU?TÔZ›W?SL4PMXS4KUOLSOrœ™KNUVON4VU?TLWPNKU5L PSUQOU4PLW™?PKWLRLQWUQPO?QÛSNUWVZWLR?QLWTUSšLPPKLOXMMNOLWTUSšLPRNS›HSL?]KP HNS™USW?Q]LS5?4LOœNQ5US?NXOSNXPLOFG611t86v7s68rUP̧11FKL4NXSPW?OT?OOLWPKL MVU?QP?RRO\4VU?TÔL4UXOLrUVPKNX]KPKLZMXS4KUOLWRSL?]KPOLS5?4LOW?SL4PVZRSNTWLRLQWUQPOr MVU?QP?RROW?WQNPUWLžXUPLVZUVL]LPKUPPKLZMXS4KUOLWOLS5?4LONQSNXPLOPKUPU4PXUVZN̂V?]UPLW PKLTPNMUZUQZ›R?LWOXS4KUS]LOFœq|gUP̧w31GF11DVU?QP?RO\4VU?TOKLSLOKNXVŴLW?OT?OOLW RNSO?T?VUSSLUONQOL5LQ?RDVU?QP?RROPSUWLW4LSPU?Q̂NQWO›W?SL4PVZœ™?PKLRLQWUQPOrDVU?QP?RRO WNQNPMVUXO?̂VZUVL]LPKUPPKLZPSUWLWUQẐNQWOPKUP™LSLMS?4LR?LWFi**$9LS?POSFUPs31GF1G 16i**p$*gmgpi&+,*nn/$k/o",/.$ˆ/#,*n$€(+|$‚,|g$lg$kn*|",$i("##*${nog$0{rG88HFXMMF7WvG1rvuvQF16xFFFEF G618yx›k€$‚q‡-œyx›KL4NQ4VXONSZOX]]LOP?NQFFFPKUPPKL5US?NXOWLS?5UP?5LO4NQOP?PXPLºNQL?QPL]SUPLWFFF TUSšLP\UOPN̂?W3UOšOMSLUWO MSLOXTÛVZPN?TMVZPKUPTUQ?MXVUP?NQNRPKLOMSLUWRNSNQLWLS?5UP?5L™?VURL4PPKL OMSLUWNRPKLNPKLSO ?ORUSRSNTL5?WLQPFFFFKLOLWLS?5UP?5LOUSLUVL]LWPN̂LW?OP?Q4PMSNWX4POPKUPUSLONVW OLMUSUPLVZrUQWPKLINTMVU?QPWNLOQNPLMVU?Q™KZTUQ?MXVUP?Q]PKLOMSLUWRNSNQLNRPKLOLMSNWX4POQL4LOOUS?VZNS L5LQMVUXO?̂VZTUQ?MXVUPLOPKLOMSLUWUOPNNPKLSOLMUSUPLVZONVWPZMLOFœyF 11i**$/.#&0mz/$k&nog$lg${&.|)/+$i/'!#${nogp$q+'grG612t866w671rUP̧vxFFFEFN5F76rG612yxW?OT?OO?Q] UQP?PSXOP4VU?TOUVL]?Q]TUQ?MXVUP?NQNRPKLUVXT?QXT™USLKNXOLOLS5?4LOUQW™USSUQPPSUW?Q]TUSšLPOrL5LQ PKNX]KMVU?QP?ROUVL]LWVZMXS4KUOLWMKZO?4UVUVXT?QXT|"n*',.jRSNTWLRLQWUQPOUP?QRVUPLWMS?4LOyF 1Gk€$‚q‡-?OUVON?QOPSX4P?5LFKLSLrPKLMVU?QP?ROUVL]LWTUQ?MXVUP?NQNR̂?W3UOšOMSLUWOrUQWUOX̂OLPNRPKL MVU?QP?RO4VU?TLWPKLZPSUQOU4PLWW?SL4PVZ™?PK4LSPU?QNRPKLWLRLQWUQPOFG88HFXMMF7WUPvuv3u8F”XW]LPL?Q RNXQWPKUPPKLMSNMNOLWWLR?Q?P?NQNRPKLTUQ?MXVUPLW›MSNWX4Pœ™UO?TMVUXO?̂VZN5LS3?Q4VXO?5LrUQWSLYL4PLWPKL MVU?QP?RO\UPLTMPPN›VXTM£TXVP?MVL¤WLS?5UP?5LOPN]LPKLSXQWLSPKLXT̂ SLVUWLR?Q?P?NQNRº™?OORSUQ43 Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 15 of 46 16 F̂́ DVU?QP?RRO\›4NQNT?4QUVZOLOœHU?VPNLTNQOPSUPLKUP DVU?QP?RROXRLSLWQYXSZUOLWQQZ›9USšLP3t?WLœ[USTF LRLQWUQPO\NMLQ?Q]̂S?LRx9LS?POSFUP1u3GGyOKN™LWPKUPLU4KNRDVU?QP?RO\UQUVZOLO NR›TUSšLP3™?WLOXTTUSZWUPUœ?ORUPUVZRVU™LWFUPKLSPKUQOML4?R?4UVZUWWSLOOPKNOL OKN™?Q]OrDVU?QP?RROMVUZUOKLV]UTLPNU5N?WPKLTFNW?OPSU4PRSNTPKL?SUQUVZOLO\N̂5?NXO WLR?4?LQ4?LOrDVU?QP?RRO?QOPLUWLTMKUO?ŸLPKLZKU5LUVL]LW12W?RLSLQPUQUVZOLOUQWUPLTMPPN US]XLPKUPQNPUVPKLUQUVZOLOOKUSLUVNRPKLOUTLRVU™OFi**p$*gmgr9LS?POMMFUPv2r22r2wF17 XPžXUQP?PZ?OQNOX̂OP?PXPLRNSžXUV?PZrUQWUVL]?Q]12W?RLSLQPRUPUVZ3RVU™LWUQUVZOLO?OQN L̂PLSPKUQUVL]?Q]UO?Q]VLNQLFi**k",j$&z$n&'},&+$-*,g$ij#g$lg$i!/Š${nog$q+'grvu6HFXMMF GWu2uru8vxFFFEFG66syxMVU?QP?RRO4UQQNPOPUPLU4VU?T̂ZUS]X?Q]PKUP›ŸLSNMVXOŸLSNMVXO ŸLSNMVXOŸLSNUWWOXMPNONTLPK?Q]œyF~/'!$&+*NRDVU?QP?RRO\UQUVZOLO ™K?4KSLVZNQWUPUPKUP DVU?QP?RRO4NQ4LWLUSL›QNPLRLQWUQP3OML4?R?4œUQWWN›QNPUVN™RNSPKL?WLQP?R?4UP?NQNR ?QW?5?WXUV̂?WOrNRLSOrNSMS?4LOœx9LS?POMMFUPG2rusy OXRLSORSNTSLUW?VZUMMUSLQPWLRL4PO PKUPSLQWLSDVU?QP?RO\UVL]UP?NQONR›TUSšLP3™?WLœKUST?TMVUXO?̂VLF ÛOLWWLS?5UP?5LO\œUQWPKLQ›UVL]L£¤PKUPWLRLQWUQPOTUQ?MXVUPLWPKLº̂?W3UOšOMSLUW\RNSº™?OORSUQ4¼ ÛOLWWLS?5UP?5LO\]LQLSUVZ™?PKNXPL5LSUVL]?Q]TUQ?MXVUP?NQRNS™?OORSUQ4H½RNS™USWOUQW™?OORSUQ4 4XSSLQ4ZRXPXSLO4NQPSU4PO£PKL?QOPSXTLQPOMVU?QP?ROPSUQOU4PLW¤OML4?R?4UVZFœq|gUPvuv3u2FDVU?QP?ROKLSL O?T?VUSVZOLLšPNVXTMPKL5US?NXOPZMLONR̂NQWO?QPNNQL›TUSšLPœ™?PKNXPUQZ?QW?4UP?NQNRKN™PKLMS?4LNR NQL̂NQW™NXVWURL4PPKLMS?4LNRUQNPKLSFL4UXOLDVU?QP?ROTUšLQN›4VLUSUVL]UP?NQPKUPPKL£MS?4L¤RNS £D¤VU?QP?RO\£̂NQWO¤™LSLURL4PLŴZ£¤LRLQWUQPO\TUQ?MXVUP?NQrœPKLZKU5LQNPMVUXO?̂VZUVL]LWUQ?QYXSZ3?Q3RU4PF q|gUPvuvF 17DVU?QP?ROUVON?TMSNMLSVZUPLTMPPN̂NVOPLSPKL?SWLR?4?LQPUQUVZOLO™?PKQL™rXQMVLWUOOLSP?NQOFHNSLUTMVLr DVU?QP?RORU?VLWPNUVL]LUQZRU4POPKUP™NXVWOKN™PKUPPKLUQUVZOLO?QMUSU]SUMKOvG73GvrvGs3Gwrv77378rUQW vu63v1NRPKLI™LSLOPUP?OP?4UVZO?]Q?R?4UQPFi**$9LS?POSFUPG1QF77FDVU?QP?ROQN™NRRLSPKL̂UVW4VU?TrRNS PKLR?SOPP?TL?QPKL?SMMNO?P?NQ̂S?LRrPKUPLU4KNRPKLOLSLOXVPO?OOPUP?OP?4UVZO?]Q?R?4UQPFi**$9LS?POMMFUP28F ?T?VUSVZr?QUMMUSLQPSL4N]Q?P?NQNRPKL?SRU?VXSLPNUVL]LRU4POPKUP™NXVWWLTNQOPSUPLPKLXOLNRMSNMLS4NQPSNVO RNSPKL?SR?SOPOPUP?OP?4UVUQUVZO?OrDVU?QP?ROQN™U5LSPKUPPKLUQUVZO?O4NQPSNVORNS›TN5LTLQPO?QSLVUPLW ?QOPSXTLQPOœx9LS?POMMFusyr™?PKNXPLMVU?Q?Q]KN™NS™KUP?QOPSXTLQPODVU?QP?RO\LMLSPÔLV?L5LPN̂L ›SLVUPLWFœODVU?QP?RO™LVšQN™rOX4KUPLTMPOPNSL4SURPUVL]UP?NQOPKSNX]K̂S?LR?Q]USLLQP?SLVZ?TMSNMLSr L̂4UXOLUMVU?QP?R›4UQQNPUTLQW?POMVLUW?Q]PKSNX]K?PONMMNO?P?NQ̂S?LRFœˆ/†")${nog$‚‚klg‚"z*$/n,+*n#$ &.|"+m#p$q+'gr2w6HFXMMFGWGw7r76sxFFFEFG616yFQWL5LQ?RPKLZ™LSLQNP?TMLST?OO?̂VZVUPL3̂SLUš?Q]r DVU?QP?RO\QL™UWW?P?NQOUSLQNPK?Q]TNSLPKUQ›VÛLVOUQW4NQ4VXO?NQOrœQNP™LV3MVLUWLWRU4POF*.$0,.g$k&nog$lg$ Š&)„.jrvv6FFvuurvvvxG668yF Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 16 of 46 11 ¾¿ÀÁµ·ÁÂÃÄÅÆ¿ÀÇÈÉÅÊÀ·ÀÅËÀµµ¶·ÅÌÈÅÍÃÈÉÅ·¶ÅÎÏ¶ÇÅÐÏÀ·ÅÑµÒÅ¾¿ÀÁµ·ÁÂÅÓÀÃÅÔµÕÖ×ÈÉÅØÒÅ ·ÏÈÅÑ¿ÈÙÈÉÅË¶µÃÚÁ×ÀÛÒÜÅKLMMNO?P?NQ4NQR?STOPKUPDVU?QP?RRO\MXSMNSPLWUQUVZOLONR ›TUSšLP3™?WLœ›OXTTUSZœWUPUx9LS?POMMFUPu8y4UQQNP̂LXOLWPNOKN™PKUPUQZQUTLW DVU?QP?RROXRLSLW?QYXSZNQUQZU4PXUVPSUQOU4P?NQrVLPUVNQLUQ?QYXSZ4UXOLŴZLRLQWUQPO\ UVL]LWVZ4NVXO?5L4NQWX4PFi**$9LS?POMMFUPu83v7¡9LS?POSFUP1u3GGF €"n#,rDVU?QP?RRO4NQ4LWLPKUPPKLVNNT̂LS]WUPUOLPONQ™K?4KPKLZSLVZ›4NQPU?Q£¤QN OML4?R?4PSUWLOUPUVœ̂XPSUPKLSUSLNQVZ›OXTTUSZrœ›WU?VZœ̂?WUQWUOšžXNPLOPKUPWN›QNP UVN™RNSPKL?WLQP?R?4UP?NQNR?QW?5?WXUV̂?WOrNRLSOrNSMS?4LOœx9LS?POMMFUPusrvvrv8QFu7yr VLPUVNQLU4PXUVPSUQOU4P?NQOFQNPKLS™NSWOrDVU?QP?RO\WUPUWNQNPSLRVL4P?QRNSTUP?NQNQPKL /',(/.$on"'*#UP™K?4K̂NQWPSUQOU4P?NQO™LSLLL4XPLW¡UP̂LOPPKLZ4NQO?OPNRU›WU?VZœ U]]SL]UP?NQNRŒ(&,*#PN̂XZNSPNOLVFKLOLžXNPLOTUZQNPKU5LVLWPNUQZU4PXUVPSUQOU4P?NQOF 5LQ?RPKLZW?WrPKLSL?OQNSLUONQPNPK?QšPKUPPKLžXNPLOVLWPNPSUQOU4P?NQOUPPKNOLMUSP?4XVUS MS?4LOF1uDVU?QP?RRO\WUPUUSLPKXOXQR?PRNSPKL?S?QPLQWLWMXSMNOL¡WUPUOLS?LOPKUPWNQNPSLRVL4P U4PXUV̂NQWPSUQOU4P?NQOWNQNP4SLUPLUQZ?QRLSLQ4LNR?QYXSZ?QU4PXUV̂NQW PSUQOU4P?NQOFi**$9LS?POSFUP1v312F i*'&+|rDVU?QP?ROUWT?PPKUPPKLWUPUPKLZXOLW?O›TUSšLP3™?WLrSUPKLSPKUQLRLQWUQP3 OML4?R?4Fœ9LS?POMMFUPvsFOUPKSLOKNVWTUPLSrOX4KU]]SL]UPLWUPU4UQQNPOKN™PKUPUQZ ?QW?5?WXUVDVU?QP?RR\OPSUQOU4P?NQ™UOURL4PLWF9LS?POSFUPGGQF7vF1vHXSPKLSr̂L4UXOL 1uQWLLWrPKLPSUWLNQ™K?4KDVU?QP?ROTNOPKLU5?VZSLVZx#**$9LS?POMMFUP137yWLTNQOPSUPLOPK?OMLSRL4PVZFKL MS?4LPKUPDVU?QP?ROUVL]L i**9LS?POSFUP11»QF11F TUšLO4VLUSPKUPPKNOLOLS?LOWNQNPMVUXO?̂VZSLRVL4PUQZU4PXUVPSUQOU4P?NQ MS?4LOF 1vDVU?QP?RO\NQVZSLOMNQOL?OPN4VU?TPKUPPKLWUPUOLS?LOUSLXOLW?QXQOML4?R?LW›R?QUQ4?UVSLOLUS4KV?PLSUPXSLœ?Q NSWLS›PNOPXWZV?žX?W?PZUQWPKLSNVLNRWLUVLSO?Q̂NQWTUSšLPOFœI¹v17QF2wx4?PLWUP9LS?POMMFUPvvyFXP ™KLPKLSPKLWUPU?OXOLWPNÛOPSU4PVZOPXWZ›V?žX?W?PZUQWPKLSNVLNRWLUVLSOœUPPKL›TUSšLP3™?WLœVL5LVx9LS?PO MMFUPvvyKUOQNSLVL5UQ4LPN™KLPKLS?P4UQMVUXO?̂VZWLTNQOPSUPLPKUPDVU?QP?ROOXRRLSLW?QYXS?LO™KLQLQ]U]?Q] ?QOML4?R?4SLUV™NSVWPSUQOU4P?NQOF Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 17 of 46 1G DVU?QP?RROTUWLQN›UPLTMP£¤PN4NQPSNVRNS4KUQ]LO?QPKL̂LKU5?NSNRNPKLSTUSšLPMUSP?4?MUQPOrœ PKLZ›4UQQNPWLTNQOPSUPLPKUPUVL]LW4KUQ]LO?Q̂?W3UOšOMSLUWOrZ?LVWONS5NVUP?V?PZ™LSLPKL SLOXVPNRLRLQWUQPO\U4P?NQOrœUONMMNOLWPNU4P?NQÔZPK?SWMUSP?LOF9LS?POSFUPG63G1F12 DVU?QP?RROWNQNPW?OMXPLPK?ÔXP?QOPLUWUS]XL ™?PKNXPUQZRU4PXUVOXMMNSP PKUP›?RUQZPK?Q]r XO?Q]TUSšLP3™?WLrSUPKLSPKUQLRLQWUQP3OML4?R?4rOMSLUW?QRNSTUP?NQ™NXVŴLLML4PLWPN (+|*n#,/,*PKL?TMU4PNRPKL4NQOM?SU4ZFœ9LS?POMMFUPvsFK?OUS]XTLQPSLV?LONQPKL ?TMVUXO?̂VL UQWXQMVLW UOOXTMP?NQPKUPrWXS?Q]UIVUOODLS?NWOMUQQ?Q]TXVP?MVL TU4SNL4NQNT?44S?OLOrQNQLNRPKLQNQ3LRLQWUQPWLUVLSO4KUQ]LWKN™PKLZMS?4LWPKL?S PSUQOU4P?NQO?QSLOMNQOLPNL4NQNT?4RNS4LOF !"n|rDVU?QP?RROUWT?PPKUPPKLZR?VPLSLWPKLWUPÛLRNSLSXQQ?Q]PKL?SUQUVZOLOx#**9LS?PO MMFUPvvyrUQWPKUPPKLWUPUOLPOPKLZXOLWW?W+&,?Q4VXWLONTLNRPKL̂NQWOPKUPDVU?QP?RRO UVL]LWVZPSUWLWFi**$"|gUPv8x4VU?T?Q]PKLWUPU›4N5LS£O¤+*/n.j$/.PKL̂NQWODVU?QP?RROPSUWLWœ xLTMKUO?OUWWLWyyFDVU?QP?ROUVONWNQNPW?OMXPLPKUPPKL?SWUPUOLP|"|?Q4VXWL4NTMVLPLVZ ?SSLVL5UQPWUPUMN?QPOUQŴ?WOÝNRLSOSLVUP?Q]ONVLVZPN?QPLSWLUVLSPSUW?Q]Fi**$"|gUPv8QFu7F DVU?QP?RROrTNSLN5LSrRU?VPNUVL]L™KLPKLŜ?WUQWUOšžXNPLORNSPKLMUSP?4XVUŜNQWOPKUP DVU?QP?RROOXMMNOLWVZPSUWLW™?PK%*z*+|/+,#™LSL?Q4VXWLW?QPKLWUPUOLPFKL*†'.(#"&+$NR MVU?QVZSLVL5UQPWUPUSLVUP?Q]PNDVU?QP?RR3UQWLRLQWUQP3OML4?R?4PSUWLOrUQWPKL"+'.(#"&+NR MVU?QVZ?SSLVL5UQPWUPURSNT?QPLSWLUVLSPSUW?Q]?QDVU?QP?RRO\UQUVZOLOrSLQWLSDVU?QP?RRO\OPUP?OP?4UV SLOXVPOTLUQ?Q]VLOOF ¾¿ÀÁµ·ÁÂÃÅÆÀÁ¿Å·¶ÅÞßÚ¿ÀÁµÅÐÏÈÁ×ÅàÈ¿ÁÀµÛÈÅ¶µÅÔµÛ¶µÃÁÃ·Èµ·ÅÐÁáÈâ¾È×Á¶ÉÅË¶µ·×¶¿Ã¢ DVU?QP?RRO\MXSMNSPLWLMVUQUP?NQORNS™KZPKL?SUQUVZOLOSLVZNQ?Q4NQO?OPLQPMSL3UQWMNOP3 12DVU?QP?RO\XQOXMMNSPLW4VU?TPKUPLRLQWUQPOUSL›LOP?TUPLWPNKU5L̂LLQSLOMNQO?̂VLRNSUOTX4KUO26ãNRPKL XQWLS™S?P?Q]RNSon")/nj$"##(/+'*#NR̂NQWOœxI¹v6vxLTMKUO?OUWWLWyyr4UQQNPSLTLWZPK?ORU?VXSL L̂4UXOLPK?OUVL]UP?NQNQVZMLSPU?QOPNMS?TUSZrNS?Q?P?UVr̂NQW?OOXUQ4LO ?Q™K?4K4LSPU?QWLUVLSOMXS4KUOL N̂QWORSNTPKLOXMSU3QUP?NQUVrON5LSL?]QrOX̂3ON5LSL?]QNSU]LQ4ẐNSSN™LS?OOX?Q]PKLTx#**$I¹1Gvy SUPKLS PKUQOL4NQWUSZPSUW?Q]r™K?4KN44XSOURPLS?OOXUQ4LUQW?OU5U?VÛVLPN̂NPKWLUVLSOUQW4XOPNTLSOx"|g¹1GwyF Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 18 of 46 17 UVL]LW4NQOM?SU4ZP?TLMLS?NWONQVZ4NQR?STPKUPDVU?QP?RROKU5L4KLSSZ3M?4šLWMLS?NWOPN TUQXRU4PXSLSLOXVPOTNOPRU5NSÛVLPNPKLTFOLMVU?QLW?QLRLQWUQPO\NMLQ?Q]̂S?LRx9LS?PO SFUP18yrDVU?QP?RRO?QLMV?4ÛVZXOLz&(nW?RRLSLQPOPUSPWUPLORNSPKL?SUQUVZOLOFi**$I¹¹ v72x9USF1GrG66Gyrv77xHL̂FwrG662yrv76x”UQF1rG66wyrv12QF8ux9USF1rG616yFDVU?QP?RRO\ NQVZLMVUQUP?NQ PKUPPKL?SOPUSPWUPLO™LSL›WS?5LQ̂ZPKLU5U?VÛ?V?PZNRWUPUœx9LS?POMMFUP 26x4?P?Q]I¹¹v6w316rv12QF8uyy ?O4NQPSUW?4PLŴZPKL5LSZUVL]UP?NQO?QPKLIPKUP DVU?QP?RRO4?PLPNOXMMNSPPKUP4VU?TFKLIUVL]LOPKUPP™NWUPUOLS?LOOPUSPLWNQ”UQXUSZ1r G66uUQWPKUPPKLNPKLSOLS?LOKUWWUPU›U5U?VÛVL™?PKOXR?4?LQPRSLžXLQ4ZœOPUSP?Q]NQ9US4K1r G616FI¹v12QF8uFXPPK?O4UQQNPLMVU?Q™KZ4LSPU?QNRDVU?QP?RRO\UQUVZOLOOPUSPLWNQ HL̂SXUSZwrG662NS”UQXUSZ1rG66wSUPKLSPKUQ”UQXUSZ1rG66uFQW?P4LSPU?QVZ4UQQNPLMVU?Q ™KZNQLNRDVU?QP?RO\UQUVZOLOXOLOUOPUSPMLS?NŴL]?QQ?Q]NQ9US4K1GrG66GFi**I¹v72F HXSPKLSrDVU?QP?RROKU5LQNTLUQ?Q]RXVLMVUQUP?NQRNS™KZPKLL4NQNT?4UQUVZOLO?QPKL IPSLUP5US?NXOW?RLSLQPMNSP?NQONRPKLRNXS3ZLUSMLS?NŴLP™LLQ”UQXUSZ1rG66vUQW”UQXUSZ 1rG66wUO'&+,n&.$o*n"&|#xI¹¹v12rvGu3v1yr™KLQDVU?QP?RROMSL5?NXOVZOPUPLWr?QPKL?SMS?NS 4NTMVU?QPrPKUPPKLUVL]LW4NQOM?SU4Z›™UO?QMVU4LUOLUSVZUOG66vx?RQNPLUSV?LSyFœi**II ¹¹1Gwru6u¡9LS?POSFUP12318FDVU?QP?RRO4NQPLQWPKUPPKLSL?OQN?TMLST?OO?̂VL ›4NQPSUW?4P?NQœKLSL̂L4UXOL›PKLWUPUUSL™KUPPKLZUSLrœUQWDVU?QP?RO\MS?NS4NTMVU?QP›TUWL QNUVL]UP?NQOÛNXPPKLWUPUFœ9LS?POMMFUP21FXPDVU?QP?RROT?OUMMSLKLQWPKL?OOXLF LRLQWUQPOUSL$+&,US]X?Q]PKUPDVU?QP?RROOKNXVWQNP̂LMLST?PLWPNUTLQWPKL?SMVLUW?Q]OUQW US]XLPKUPPKLUVL]LW4NQOM?SU4ZOPUSPLWUPUW?RRLSLQPP?TLF18UPKLSrDVU?QP?RROOKNXVWQNP̂L MLST?PLWPNU5N?WW?OT?OOUV̂ZTUš?Q]UOLVR3OLS5?Q]UTLQWTLQPPNOKNSPLQPKLUVL]LW ›4NQOM?SU4ZœMLS?NW?QRU5NSNRUVNQ]LSMSL34NQOM?SU4Z›4NQPSNVœMLS?NWO?TMVZPNPLLXMPKL?S 18HNSPK?OSLUONQrDVU?QP?RO\4?PUP?NQOPN4UOLOOPUQW?Q]RNSPKLXQSLTUSšÛVLMS?Q4?MVLPKUPUQUTLQWLWMVLUW?Q] ›NSW?QUS?VZOXMLSOLWLOPKLNS?]?QUVœx9LS?POMMFUP21»QFu8yUSL?SSLVL5UQPF Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 19 of 46 1u SLOXVPO3NS?LQPLWOPUP?OP?4UVUQUVZOLOFi**$9LS?POSFUP1231s¡#**$/.#&$q+$n*$i‚ˆ$k&nog$~-qi0$ ‚","mgrG616t7w16v22rUP̧sxFFFEFLMPFGurG616yxR?QW?Q]MVU?QP?RR\OUŜ?PSUSZSL5?O?NQ PNPKLUVL]LW4VUOOMLS?NWr™?PKNXPUQZUWW?P?NQUV›OX̂OPUQP?5LUVL]UP?NQOœUOPNPKL4KUQ]L UO?WLRSNTPKLÛ?V?PZPNMVLUWU]SLUPLSOKUSLMS?4LWL4V?QLr›OX]]LOPONMMNSPXQ?OP?4 SXTTU]?Q]œyr/z|$#(„$+&)p$i./j)&+$lg$i‚ˆ$k&nogrv62HFMM\21xGWI?SFG61GyF DVU?QP?RROUVON4UQQNPLMVU?Q™KZPKLZRU?VLWPNUV?]QPKL?S›MNOP34NQOM?SU4Z4NQPSNV MLS?NWœ ™K?4KWNLOQNP̂L]?QXQP?VT?W3L4LT̂ LSG61vUQWSXQOPKSNX]KG61s ™?PKPKL I\ONPKLSUVL]UP?NQOOKN™?Q]PKUPr›#,/n,"+m$"+$./,*$äåæçrœ̂UQšO›̂L]UQPN?TMNOL?Q4SLUOLW SLOPS?4P?NQONQPSUWLSOXO?Q]4KUPSNNTOrœUQWPKUP̂ZG61urQL™OSLMNSPÔL]UQPNLTLS]L 4NQ4LSQ?Q]]N5LSQTLQPMSN̂LO?QPN̂NQWPSUW?Q]F9LS?POSFUP1sxžXNP?Q]I¹722yF DVU?QP?RROUS]XLPKUP›PKLI4NQPU?QOL5?WLQ4LOX]]LOP?Q]PKUPLRLQWUQPO™LSL/',(/.j$#,".$ '&.(|"+m$PKSNX]KG61vFœ9LS?POMMFUP26FNPONFLOM?PLUVL]?Q]PKUP rPKLIWNLOQNP?WLQP?RZUO?Q]VL OXMMNOLWVZ?TMSNMLS4KUPRSNTG61vF9NSLN5LSr?QPKLP™N?QOPUQ4LO™KLSLDVU?QP?RRO\4KUSPO MLST?PU4NTMUS?ONQrPKL?SUQUVZOLOWNQNPWLTNQOPSUPLUQZQNP?4LÛVL4KUQ]L?QOMSLUWOUSNXQW PKLL4LT̂LSG61v›LQWœWUPLRNSPKL›4NSL4NQOM?SU4ZMLS?NWFœi**$I¹¹vGurvGwFRU 4NQOM?SU4ZU4PXUVZ™UOSLOMNQO?̂VLRNSDVU?QP?RRO\SLOXVPO UONMMNOLWPNr"+,*n$/."/r4KUQ]?Q] TU4SNL4NQNT?44NQW?P?NQO OMSLUWOOKNXVWKU5LOKUSMVZWL4V?QLWURPLSL4LT̂LSG61vFXP DVU?QP?RRO\4KUSPOOKN™QNOX4KLRL4PF ¾¿ÀÁµ·ÁÂÃÅÆÀÁ¿Å·¶ÅË¶µ·×¶¿ÅÂ¶×ÅèÀÛ×¶ÈÛ¶µ¶áÁÛÅÆÀÛ·¶×ÃÜOLMVU?QLW?QLRLQWUQPO\ NMLQ?Q]̂S?LRx9LS?POSFUP1s3G6yrDVU?QP?RRO\RU?VXSLPN4NQPSNVRNSTU4SNL4NQNT?4RU4PNSOrV?šL PKLXSNMLUQWL̂P4S?OLOrTUšLODVU?QP?RRO\UQUVZOLO?Q4UMÛVLNRMVUXO?̂VZWLTNQOPSUP?Q]PKUP Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 20 of 46 1v UQZMXSMNSPLW4KUQ]LO?QOMSLUWOWXS?Q]PKLIVUOODLS?NW™LSL4UXOLŴZUVL]LW4NVXO?NQF1s DVU?QP?RRO\P™NUS]XTLQPO?QSLOMNQOLRU?VF €"n#,rUOLRLQWUQPOOKN™LWx9LS?POSFUP1wyrDVU?QP?RRO\UPLTMPOPN4NQPSNVRNS TU4SNL4NQNT?45US?ÛVLOXO?Q]PKLOMSLUWONQ4LSPU?QON5LSL?]Q̂NQWOUSLRU4?UVZWLR?4?LQP L̂4UXOLDVU?QP?RRORU?VPNV?T?PPKNOL4NQPSNVOPN̂NQWOWLQNT?QUPLW?QFFWNVUSO PKLNQVZ 4XSSLQ4ZSLVL5UQPPNDVU?QP?RRO\4VU?TOFDVU?QP?ROSLOMNQWPKUPPK?ORU?VXSLWNLOQNPTUPLS L̂4UXOLPKL?S›UQUVZOLO™LSLWNQL?QPLSTONR?QPLSLOPSUPLZ?LVWOFœ9LS?POMMFUP2uQFv6FXP 4NTTNQL4NQNT?4LMLS?LQ4LPLU4KLOPKUPZ?LVWONR̂NQWOWLQNT?QUPLW?QXSNONSNPKLS 4XSSLQ4?LOUSLQNPW?SL4PVZ4NTMUSÛVLPN̂NQWOWLQNT?QUPLW?QWNVUSÔL4UXOL?QRVUP?NQSUPLO 5USẐLP™LLQ4XSSLQ4?LOF1w i*'&+|rDVU?QP?RONRPLQRU?VPN?WLQP?RZ™K?4K?OOX?Q]4NXQPSZ\ÔNQWO™LSL?Q4VXWLW?Q UQZMXSMNSPLW›4NQPSNVœ]SNXMrUQWL5LQ™KLQPKLZWNrDVU?QP?ROOPUPLPKUPPKLZXOLWUO4NQPSNVO NQVẐNQWO›?OOXLŴZLSTUQZrHSUQ4LrUQWPKLQ?PLWJ?Q]WNTœNŜNQWO?OOXLŴZPKL Q?PLWPUPLOFi**9LS?POSFUP1wQF76xžXNP?Q]I¹¹v7vrvu8yFDVU?QP?RROWNQNPUWWSLOO KN™OX4K̂NQWO4UQ̂L4NQO?WLSLWLRL4P?5L4NQPSNVO™KLQPKNOL4NXQPS?LO™LSLRUSVLOOURL4PLW ẐPKLXSNMLUQWL̂P4S?OLOPKUQ4NXQPS?LOOX4KUOMU?QrPUVZrUQWSLL4LFG6 ¾¿ÀÁµ·ÁÂÃÅÔáÚ×¶ÚÈ×¿ÒÅàÈ¿ÒÅ¶µÅÑÙÙ×ÈÙÀ·ÈÉÅÊÀ·ÀÅÀµÉÅèÈÀµÁµÙ¿ÈÃÃÅÑéÈ×ÀÙÈÃ¢LRLQWUQPO 1sDVU?QP?RO4NQ4LWLPKUPNQLTU4SNL4NQNT?4RU4PNSrPKLXSNMLUQWL̂P4S?O?OrVLWPNOMSLUWÔL4NT?Q]›Š"|*#,?Q LUSVZG61Grœ̂XPOKSX]NRRLRLQWUQPO\US]XTLQPOÛNXPPKLRU?VXSLPN4NQPSNVRNSPKL4S?O?OUOTLSLVZ›M?4š?Q]UPNQL OPXWZFœ9LS?POMMFUP22FXPPKUPT?OOLOPKLMN?QPFDVU?QP?RRO\RU?VXSLPN4NQPSNVRNSTU4SNL4NQNT?4RU4PNSO ]LQLSUVZ?QRL4PO/.$NRPKL?SUQUVZOLOUQWSLQWLSOPKL?SOPUP?OP?4UVSLOXVPOXQSLV?ÛVLFi**$9LS?POSFUP1w3G6F 1wi**p$*gmgrIKS?OPNMKLS”FLLVZrk&)o/n"+m$q+,*n+/,"&+/.$&+|$‹"*.|#rHLWLSUVLOLS5LUQšNRPFNX?Or 4NQNT?4ZQNMOLOxG61uyxQNP?Q]PKUP›MUQ?OKUQWPUV?UQ]N5LSQTLQP̂NQWZ?LVWOUSLQNPW?SL4PVZ4NTMUSÛVLPN PKNOLNRFFSLUOXS?LÔL4UXOLPKL̂NQWOUSLMU?W?QW?RLSLQ4L4XSSLQ4?LOœyr/l/"./„.*$/,KPMOÝR?VLOFOPVNX?ORLWFNS] ÝR?VLOÝKPWN4OÝMX̂V?4UP?NQOÝLOÝ1uÝê1wêG61u36s36uFMWRFHXSPKLSr?Q5LOPNSO\MSLRLSLQ4LPNSL4L?5LMUZTLQP?QWNVUSO 4NTMUSLWPNXSNONSNPKLS4XSSLQ4?LOTUZ4KUQ]LN5LSP?TLrRNSLUTMVLUO?Q5LOPNSORVN4šPNPKLMLS4L?5LWOURLPZ NRFFWNVUSOWXS?Q]WL̂P4S?OLOURL4P?Q]XSNMLUQ4NXQPS?LOFi**$"|g G6DVU?QP?ROOXTTUS?VZUOOLSPPK?OUS]XTLQP?O›?QUMMSNMS?UPL£¤œx9LS?POMMFUP2uyr̂XPTUšLQNUPLTMPPNLMVU?Q ™KZPK?O?QRNSTUP?NQ?OQNPYXW?4?UVZQNP?4LÛVLRNSPKLSLUONQOLMVU?QLW?QLRLQWUQPO\NMLQ?Q]̂S?LRFi**$9LS?PO SFUP1wQF76F Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 21 of 46 12 UVONWLTNQOPSUPLW?QPKL?STN5?Q]MUMLSOPKUPDVU?QP?RO\UQUVZOLOUSLTLUQ?Q]VLOÔL4UXOLPKLZ USL̂UOLWNQU5LSU]LOr™K?4KUSL?Q4UMÛVLNROKN™?Q]PKUPUQZOML4?R?4DVU?QP?R™UO?QYXSLWF i**$9LS?POSFUPG13GGFQSLOMNQOLrDVU?QP?ROMN?QPPNPKLXOLNR›U5LSU]LOœ?QUQUVZOLOXMKLVW ẐPKL4NXSP?Qq+$n*$k&))&|",j$~†'!gp$q+'grG17HFXMMF7W271r2uvxFFFEFG612yx›{&.|œyr X̂PPKUP4UOL?OW?OP?Q]X?OKÛVLF{&.|$?Q5NV5LWPKLUVL]LWS?]]?Q]NRPKL›WU?VẐLQ4KTUSš MS?4LœNR]NVWr™K?4K™UO›º?QLPS?4ÛVZ?QPLSP™?QLW\™?PKPKLMS?4?Q]NR5US?NXO£]¤NVW £?¤Q5LOPTLQPOUQW?OÛX?VP3?Q4NTMNQLQPNRTUQZ4NQPSU4PO]N5LSQ?Q]]NVW3SLVUPLW ?Q5LOPTLQPOFœq|gUP2uGr2uuF{&.|PKXO?Q5NV5LWU)*/+"+mz(.U5LSU]L PKLTUQ?MXVUP?NQNR PKL̂LQ4KTUSšMS?4LW?SL4PVZ?TMU4PLWPKLMS?4LNRPKL?QOPSXTLQPO?Q™K?4KPKNOLMVU?QP?RO PSUQOU4PLWFG1Z4NQPSUOPrPKLU5LSU]LONQ™K?4KDVU?QP?RROSLVZKLSLUSL™NSPKVLOORNSMXSMNOLO NROKN™?Q]UQP?PSXOP?QYXSẐL4UXOLLU4K̂NQW?OMS?4LW?QWLMLQWLQPVZrUQWDVU?QP?ROKU5L QNPUVL]LWKN™PKLMS?4LNRNQL̂NQW?TMU4POPKLMS?4LNRUQNPKLSFi**$9LS?POSFUPG8QFu6F KXOrU5LSU]LO™?V?QL5?PÛVZ4NQ4LUVTLUQ?Q]RXVW?RLSLQ4LÔLP™LLQ̂NQWO W?RLSLQ4LOPKUP LQP?SLVZQL]UPLDVU?QP?RRO\UVL]UP?NQONR?QYXSZFGG ¾¿ÀÁµ·ÁÂÃÄÅÑµÀ¿ÒÃÈÃÅË¶µ·×ÀÉÁÛ·ÅÐÏÈÁ×ÅÐÏÈ¶×ÒÅ¶ÂÅ·ÏÈÅËÀÃÈÜDVU?QP?RRO\UQUVZOLOUSLUVON ?TMVUXO?̂VL̂L4UXOLPKLZ4NQPSUW?4PDVU?QP?RO\N™QPKLNSZNRPKL4UOLF9LS?POSFUPGGFHNS LUTMVLrPKL4KUSP?QMUSU]SUMKvGwNRPKLIOKN™OPKUP›L4LOO5NVUP?V?PZœOM?šLW„*z&n*PKL L̂]?QQ?Q]NRPKLUVL]LW4NQOM?SU4ZMLS?NWrUQWW?OMVUZLWQNQNP?4LÛVL4KUQ]LRSNT?POPSLQW V?QLUPPKLP?TLPKL4NQOM?SU4ZUVL]LWVZLQWLWFi**$I¹vGwFDVU?QP?RRO\SLOMNQOL?OO?TMVZPN G1DVU?QP?RO\SLV?UQ4LNQ0./#}/$~.*'g$*+#"&+$€(+|$lg/+}$&z$0)g$k&nogr18vHFXMMF7WuuxFFFEFG612y x›qi%0z"†œy?OT?OMVU4LWRNSPKLOUTLSLUONQF?šL{&.|rqi%0z"†?Q5NV5LWPKLUVL]LWTUQ?MXVUP?NQNRU ›̂LQ4KTUSšSUPLFFFPKUP?OPKLQXOLWUOU4NTMNQLQPNR£PKL¤MS?4LœNRPKL?QOPSXTLQPO?Q™K?4KPKLMVU?QP?ROPKLSL UVL]LWVZPSUQOU4PLWFq|gUPvwF GGDVU?QP?RO\UOOLSP?NQPKUPPKL?SUQUVZO?O™UOPKL›LU4PPZMLNRUQUVZO?O4UVLWRNSœ̂Zq+$n*$k&))&|",j$~†'!gp$q+'g$ i".l*n$€(,(n*#$ƒ$‡o,"&+#$ n/|"+m$‚","mgrG617t1166886rUP̧uQFuxFFFEF9USF1srG617yr?O™SNQ]F9LS?PO MMFUPv23v8FQPKUP4UOLr”XW]LDUPLSONQUWWSLOOLWKZMNPKLP?4UV4NTMUS?ONQONRPKLU5LSU]LMS?4LONR"+|"l"|(/. 4NTTNW?P?LON5LSP?TLrQNPPKLU5LSU]LMS?4LNR5US?NXOXQSLVUPLW?Q5LOPTLQPOr™?PKNXPU4NTTNQMS?4?Q] L̂Q4KTUSšF Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 22 of 46 18 US]XLPKUPPK?OWNLOQNPXQWLST?QLPKL?S&,!*n$UQUVZOLOFi**$9LS?POMMFUP2sFXPPKUP MUSP?4XVUSRVU™?ONQVZ5?O?̂VL™KLQPKLSLOXVPOUSLOXR?4?LQPVZWLPU?VLWx"g*gr™KLQPKLSLOXVPOUSL OKN™Q?QUV?QL]SUMKrSUPKLSPKUQÛUS4KUSPNSQNPW?OMVUZLWUPUVyFKUPDVU?QP?RRORU?VLWPN MSN5?WLOXR?4?LQPWLPU?VORNSPKL?SNPKLSUQUVZOLO PKXOWLQZ?Q]LRLQWUQPOUQWPKLINXSPPKL Û?V?PZPNWLPLST?QL™KUPRVU™O?QRL4PPKLT ?OSLUONQLQNX]KRNSPKLINXSPPNSLYL4PPKLTF ?šL™?OLrDVU?QP?RRO\4KUSPOOKN™PKUPrL5LQURPLSPKL4NQOM?SU4ZOXMMNOLWVZLQWLWr̂?W3 UOšOMSLUWO™LSLRUS4VNOLSWXS?Q]PKLMNOP34NQOM?SU4ZMLS?NWPNPKL?SVL5LVO?QPKLUVL]LW 4NQOM?SU4ZMLS?NWPKUQPKLZ™LSLPNPKL?SVL5LVO?QPKLMSL34NQOM?SU4ZMLS?NWFi**p$*gmgrI ¹¹v7737vFK?OUVON4UQQNP̂LOžXUSLW™?PKDVU?QP?RO\N™QUVL]UP?NQOrUQWWLTNQOPSUPLOPKUP DVU?QP?RRO\MXSMNSPLWLMLSPOUSL?Q4UMÛVLNRW?OP?Q]X?OK?Q]PKLOXMMNOLWLRL4PNR4NVXO?5L 4NQWX4PRSNTNPKLSSLUONQOPKUP̂?W3UOšOMSLUWO4KUQ]LN5LSP?TLFG7 @¢¥ ¦C§§̈d©ª©̈«̈«¬©®dª¦Aª;̄A©«ª©¬d C̈ª¬©ë©C«ª«¬̈ëCd¢ DVU?QP?RRORU?VPNLMVU?QKN™UQZNRPKLLR?4?LQPLQRNS4LSRU4PNSONRW?SL4P4UXOUP?NQr ÛOLQ4LNRTNSLW?SL4P5?4P?TOrNSQNQ3OML4XVUP?5LWUTU]LOOXMMNSPPKL?SUQP?PSXOPOPUQW?Q]F 1F́ DVU?QP?RRO\IVU?TOSLNNLTNPLUQWQW?SL4PF DVU?QP?RROUS]XLPKUPPKLZ™LSLKUSTLŴL4UXOLLRLQWUQPO\UVL]LW›U]SLLTLQPQNPPN 4NTMLPLœONTLKN™›SLWX4£LW¤4NTMLP?P?NQœPKSNX]KNXPPKLMXSMNSPLW›̂NQWTUSšLPœUQW PKLSLRNSL™?WLQLWOMSLUWONQPKL̂NQWODVU?QP?RROUVL]LWVZPSUWLW™?PKULRLQWUQPF9LS?PO MMFUP87F5LQ?RPK?OPKLNSZ™LSLOXR?4?LQPPNMVLUWUQP?PSXOP?QYXSZrDVU?QP?RO\UVL]LW G7DVU?QP?RO\US]XTLQPPKUPPKLZ›WNQNPUVL]LPKUPPKLMSL3”UQXUSZG66wOMSLUWOUSLPKLº4NSSL4P\™?WPKœT?OOLOPKL MN?QPFi**$9LS?POMMFUP2sFDVU?QP?RO4NQ4LWLPKUP›L4NQNT?4RU4PNSOœ4UXOLOMSLUWOPN4KUQ]LN5LSP?TLFq|g DVU?QP?ROS?]KPVZSLUV?ŸLPKUPPKLZTXOP4NQPSNVRNSPKNOLL4NQNT?4RU4PNSO?RPKL?SUQUVZOLOUSLPNWLTNQOPSUPLPKUP UQZSLTU?Q?Q]4KUQ]LOUSLPKLSLOXVPNRMXSMNSPLW4NVXO?NQFKUPOMSLUWO?QPKLUVL]LWMNOP34NQOM?SU4Z4NQPSNV MLS?NW™LSLTX4K4VNOLSPNOMSLUWO?QPKL4NQOM?SU4ZMLS?NWPKUQPKLZ™LSLPNOMSLUWO?QPKLMSL34NQOM?SU4Z4NQPSNV MLS?NW *l*+$/z,*n$./"+,"z#$'&+,n&.#$Š*n*$/oo."*| WLTNQOPSUPLOPKUPPKNOL4NQPSNVOUSL?QLRL4PXUVrUQWPKUP DVU?QP?RO\UQUVZOLOWNQNPr?QRU4PrOUZUQZPK?Q]ÛNXPPKLL?OPLQ4LNR4NVXO?NQFPTUšLOQNW?RLSLQ4L™KLPKLS DVU?QP?ROUVL]LPKLOMSLUWO?QNQLrNSQNQLrNRPKLOLMLS?NWO™LSL›4NSSL4PFœ Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 23 of 46 1s ?QYXS?LO™NXVŴLPNNSLTNPLPN4NQRLSOPUQW?Q]̂L4UXOLPKLZUSL›NQVZ?QW?SL4PVZSLVUPLWPNPKL MS?TUSZ5?NVUP?NQUOOLSPLWœ PKLUVL]LWTUQ?MXVUP?NQNR?QW?5?WXUVPSUQOU4P?NQOFGu DVU?QP?RRO\4VU?TLW?QYXSZQL4LOOUS?VZWLMLQWONQONTLXQOML4?R?LW4KU?QNRL5LQPO ™KLSL̂ZPKLUTNSMKNXOLRL4PONROXMMNOLW›W?T?Q?OKLW£¤WLUVLS4NTMLP?P?NQœxI¹uw2y ONTLKN™?TMU4PLŴ?WW?Q]̂LKU5?NSUQWQL]NP?UP?NQORNSPKNXOUQWONRW?OMUSUPLPSUQOU4P?NQO ?Q5NV5?Q]UKLPLSN]LQLNXOT?NR̂NQWO™?PKW?RRLSLQP4KUSU4PLS?OP?4OrPLSTOrUQWPLQNSOrPSUWLW UP?QW?5?WXUVZQL]NP?UPLWMS?4LOFi**9LS?POSFUP1G317FK?OXQWLQ?ÛVZ›UPLQXUPLW4UXOUP?NQ L̂P™LLQPKLUVL]LW4NQOM?SU4ZUQWPKLUOOLSPLW?QYXSZ?OPNN?QW?SL4PPNOXMMNSPUQP?PSXOP OPUQW?Q]Fœ‚/j|&+$lg$ˆ"“(!&$/+}p$‚,|grG61ut1Gs6u2urUP̧wxFFFEF9USFGsrG61uy¡ #**$/.#&e$fg$he,!$i,g$-*/.,j$k&g$lg$k","mn&(op$q+'grG61st1u1vG6wrUP̧11xFFFEF9USF G6rG61syxQNOPUQW?Q]™KLSL›PKL4KU?QNR4UXOUP?NQ̂LP™LLQDVU?QP?R\OUVL]LW?QYXSZUQW LRLQWUQPO\TUQ?MXVUP?NQœ?Q5NV5LW›U4NTMV?4UPLWOLS?LONRTUSšLP?QPLSU4P?NQOUQW UOOXTMP?NQOœyFGvDVU?QP?RO\4?PUP?NQOPN?QUMMNO?PL4UOLOWNQNPOKN™NPKLS™?OLFG2 UPKLSPKUQSLOMNQWPNLRLQWUQPO\US]XTLQPOrDVU?QP?RROPSZPN4KUQ]LPKLOX̂YL4P̂Z UOOLSP?Q]PKUPPKLZUSL›on*z*nn*|œUQP?PSXOP4VU?TUQPÔL4UXOL›DVU?QP?RROPSUWLŴNQWO GuDVU?QP?RO\UVL]UP?NQPKUP x#**$9LS?POMMFUPuv3u2ŷLUSOQN UVL]LWW?SL4PV?QšPN QWLLWrDVU?QP?RO 4NQ4LWLPKUP i**$QFGr#(on/¡#**$/.#&$/nnjrGuuHFXMMF7W UPuG7¡0##&'g${*+g$k&+,n/',&n#$lg$k/.g$i,/,*$k&(+'".$&z$k/no*+,*n#$x›0{kœyruvwFFv1wrv7ux1ws7yx™K?VLUQ ›UQP?PSXOP5?NVUP?NQTUẐLLML4PLWPN4UXOLS?MMVLONRKUSTrœPKLUQP?PSXOPVU™OWNQNP›MSN5?WLUSLTLWZ?Q WUTU]LORNSUV?QYXS?LOPKUPT?]KP4NQ4L?5ÛVẐLPSU4LWPNUQUQP?PSXOP5?NVUP?NQœyF GvDVU?QP?RO\QL™PKLNSZNRUQP?PSXOP?QYXSẐUOLWLQP?SLVZNQPKLXQLMVU?QLWS?MMVLLRL4PONRUVL]LWVZT?OMS?4LW PSUWLO?Q"+,*n|*/.*n$PSUW?Q]x9LS?POMMFUP8638Gy UPKLNSZ™K?4KR?QWOQNRU4PXUVOXMMNSP?QPKLIUQW™UO ?TMSNMLSVZSU?OLWRNSPKLR?SOPP?TL?QDVU?QP?RO\MMNO?P?NQ̂S?LRx#**#(on/UPv38y ?TMV?4UPLOUQL5LQTNSL ›4NTMV?4UPLWOLS?LONRTUSšLP?QPLSU4P?NQOUQWUOOXTMP?NQOrœe$fg$he,!$i,n**,rG61st1u1vG6wrUP̧11rUQWPKXO 4UQQNPMNOO?̂VZOXMMNSPDVU?QP?RO\OPUQW?Q]UOLR?4?LQPLQRNS4LSOF G2DVU?QP?RO\SLV?UQ4LNQq+$n*$q+,*n*#,$-/,*$iŠ/o#$0+,",n(#,$‚","mgrG21HFXMMF7Wu76ruw1xFFFEFG618y x›q-iœyrUQWq+$n*$kn*|",$%*z/(.,$iŠ/o#$0+,",n(#,$‚","mgrG61utu78w11GxFFFEFLMFurG61uyx›k%iœyr?O T?OMVU4LWFQ̂NPK4UOLOrMVU?QP?RO™LSLRNXQWPNKU5LUVL]LWU4VLUSV?Qš̂LP™LLQPKLUVL]LW5?NVUP?NQxUQ UQP?4NTMLP?P?5L̂NZ4NPNSL4VXO?NQUSZMSU4P?4LyUQWMVU?QP?RO\UVL]LW?QYXS?LOx̂L?Q]RNS4LWPNMUZ?QRVUPLW MS?4LOyFi**$q-irG21HFXMMF7WUPuw7¡k%irG61utu78w11GrUP̧wF[LSLr?Q4NQPSUOPrDVU?QP?RO5U]XLVZUVL]L XQWLR?QLWKUSTRVN™?Q]RSNTMXSMNSPLWVZ›W?T?Q?OKLW£¤WLUVLS4NTMLP?P?NQFœI¹uw2F Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 24 of 46 1w |"n*',.j™?PKLRLQWUQPOFœ9LS?POMMFUP8738uxLTMKUOLO?QNS?]?QUVyFG8?SL4PPSUQOU4P?NQO ™?PKULRLQWUQPrKN™L5LSrWNQNPTUšLDVU?QP?RRO\UVL]LW"+ì(n"*#W?SL4PRNSMXSMNOLONR UQP?PSXOPOPUQW?Q]FGsL4UXOLDVU?QP?RRO4UQQNPOKN™PKUP›LRLQWUQPO\UVL]LWUQP?4NTMLP?P?5L U4POW?SL4PVZSLOPSU?QLWPKLFFFPSUQOU4P?NQO?Q™K?4KDVU?QP?ROMUSP?4?MUPLWrœ‰jo.$lg$’ˆ&nm/+$ k!/#*$ƒ$k&g$x›‰jo.$qœyrG618t1177uu2rUP̧uxFFFEF9USFGurG618yrPKL?SOPUQW?Q] WLMLQWOLQP?SLVZNQ›5U]XLVZWLR?QLWV?QšOœ̂LP™LLQPKLUVL]LW5?NVUP?NQUQWPKL?SUOOLSPLW ?QYXSZr™K?4KUSL?QOXR?4?LQPFi**$0{kruvwFFUPv7u¡‚/j|&+rG61ut1Gs6u2urUP̧wF GF́ 9NSLR?4?LQPQRNS4LSO?OPF DVU?QP?RROMSLW?4PÛVZUOOLSPPKUP›£Q¤NTNSLLR?4?LQPLQRNS4LSOPKUQDVU?QP?ROL?OPFœ 9LS?POMMFUP8u38vFXPrPNPKLLPLQPUQZUQP?PSXOP5?NVUP?NQ?OMVUXO?̂VZUVL]LWxUQW?P?OQNPyr PKLSL™NXVŴLUQN̂5?NXO]SNXMNR›TNSLW?SL4P5?4P?TOœ™KNOL›OLVR3?QPLSLOP™NXVWQNSTUVZ TNP?5UPLPKLTPN5?QW?4UPLPKLMX̂V?4?QPLSLOP?QUQP?PSXOPLQRNS4LTLQPœ¼¼4NXQPLSMUSP?LO?Q5NV5LW ?QPKLUVL]LWVZMS?4L3R?LWPSUQOU4P?NQOW?O4XOOLW?QPKLIF0{kruvwFFUPvuGrvuv¡#**$ /.#&${/,r811HF7WUP8wFDVU?QP?RROKU5LRU?VLWPNUWLžXUPLVZMVLUWPKLZ™LSLNQPKLNPKLSO?WL NRPKNOLMXSMNSPLWPSUQOU4P?NQOx#**9LS?POSFUPFF1F¡#(on/$FF1yrUQWPKLZUSL?Q4UMÛVLNR LMVU?Q?Q]™KZPKL?S4VU?TO™NXVŴLTNSL›W?SL4PFœ 7F́ DVU?QP?RRO\DXSMNSPLWUTU]LOrRQZrSL[?]KVZML4XVUP?5LF QPKLMMNO?P?NQrDVU?QP?RROMSNT?OLPN›MXPRNSPKUQLMLSPSLMNSPœPKUP™?V›MSN5?WL ÛXQWUQP]SNXQWOXMNQ™K?4KPNLOP?TUPLWUTU]LOFœ9LS?POMMFUP82FXPDVU?QP?ROWNQNP W?OMXPLPKL?QPSU4PÛVLMSN̂VLTO?QKLSLQP?QUPLTMP?Q]PNSL4NQOPSX4PPKNXOUQWONRKZMNPKLP?4UV G8HNSPK?OMSNMNO?P?NQrDVU?QP?RO4?PLq."+&"#$n"'}$k&g$lg$q."+&"#ru71FF8G6r8u2x1w88yFXPq."+&"#$n"'}?O ?SSLVL5UQPKLSLFLRLQWUQPO4KUVLQ]LDVU?QP?RO\OPUQW?Q]QNP̂UOLWNQONTLRU?VXSLPNUVL]LW?SL4PMXS4KUOLOr̂XP L̂4UXOLDVU?QP?RO\UOOLSPLW"+ì(n"*#USLPNN?QW?SL4PPNOXMMNSPUQP?PSXOPOPUQW?Q]Fxi**9LS?POSFUPG73GuFy Gsi**$‚/()/++$lg$‰/,"&+/.$&'}*j$‚*/m(*rw68HFXMMFGWu2vrusuxFFFEFG61GyxW?SL4PMXS4KUOLSONR PLVL5?O?NQOLS5?4LOVU4šLWUQP?PSXOPOPUQW?Q]PNOXL›̂UOLWNQONTLXQ?WLQP?R?LW?Q4SLUOL£¤£?Q¤MS?4LNRPKL?SN5LSUV 4ÛVLMU4šU]LUVL]LWVZOPLTT?Q]RSNTPKLÛOLQ4LNR4NTMLP?P?NQœy¡$#**$/.#&$n*'"#"&+rG611t86v7s68rUP̧s xW?OT?OO?Q]UQP?PSXOP4VU?TOWLOM?PLW?SL4PMXS4KUOLOrO?Q4L›MVU?QP?ROWNQNPTUšLUQZ4NQQL4P?NQ̂LP™LLQPKL WLRLQWUQPO\UQP?4NTMLP?P?5L4NQWX4PUQWPKL?SUVL]LW?QYXS?LOœyF Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 25 of 46 G6 ?̂WOUQWNRLSORNSUTXVP?PXWLNRW?RRLSLQP̂NQWO?QU›̂XPRNSœ™NSVWÛOLQPPKL UVL]LW4NVXO?NQF9LS?POSFUPGuFNSWNPKLZSLRXPLLRLQWUQPO\US]XTLQPPKUP4UV4XVUP?Q] WUTU]LORNSUVPSUQOU4P?NQOOXMMNOLWVZUP?OOXL?OUV̂XP?TMNOO?̂VL™KLSL›PKLSL?OQNMNOP3 PSUWLMS?4LPSUQOMUSLQ4ZFœI¹17uFGwOP?TUP?Q]WUTU]LO™NXVWSLžX?SL]XLOO™NSšUOPN PKNXOUQWONR?QW?5?WXUVZQL]NP?UPLWPSUQOU4P?NQOr™K?4K4UQQNPVLUWPN›UYXOPUQWSLUONQÛVL LOP?TUPLœNRWUTU]LOF{*.„&")$lg$/+}$&z$0)*n"'/$k&noFrsG7HF7W8vwr88wxGWI?SFG612yF ¢ ; <<a@;< =;< @<¢ DVU?QP?RRO\4NQOM?SU4ZPKLNSZ PKUPLUVLSLRLQWUQPOrPKSNX]K MXSMNSPLW ›DS?TUSZDVUZLSOrœ76U]SLLWPNU4PUOU›O?Q]VLrXQ?PUSZºOXMLS3WLOš\œ4USSZ?Q]NXPUQ?V3WLR?QLW U]SLLTLQP›QNPPN4NTMLPLœRNŜNQWPSUWLORNSOL5LQZLUSOrURL4P?Q]PKLMS?4LONRUV N̂QWPSUWLOx*gmgrI¹¹17r1sy ?O?TMVUXO?̂VLNQ?PORU4LrUQWDVU?QP?RRORU?VPNMVLUWW?SL4PNS ?QW?SL4PL5?WLQ4LOXR?4?LQPPNOXMMNSP?PFDVU?QP?RRO4NQP?QXLPNUS]XLPKUPx1yPKLO™LLM?Q] 4NQOM?SU4ZUVL]LW4NXVWKU5LNMLSUPLWONVLVZPKSNX]K/|$!&'4NTTXQ?4UP?NQOUTNQ]OX̂OLPONR LRLQWUQPO¡xGyPKLTNOPVẐ?VUPLSUV4KUPOUVL]LW?QPKLIUSLW?SL4PL5?WLQ4LNRU4NQOM?SU4Z UTNQ]UVLRLQWUQPO¡UQWx7yL5LQ?RPKLZUSLQNPrPKNOLOUTL4KUPOUSLOXR?4?LQPPN?QRLSU 4NQOM?SU4ZUTNQ]UVLRLQWUQPOFNQLNRPKNOLUS]XTLQPOKUOTLS?PF GwHNSPK?OSLUONQrPKLWUTU]LO3SLVUPLW4UOLOPKUPDVU?QP?RO4?PLUSLW?OP?Q]X?OKÛVLFi**9LS?POMMFUP8v382FNPK €í$UQWqi%0z"†?Q5NV5LWUQUVL]LWVZTUQ?MXVUPLŴLQ4KTUSšSUPLFi**$q+$n*$€&n*"m+$~†'!g$*+'!)/n}$-/,*#$ 0+,",n(#,$‚","mgx›€íœyrG612tv16s171rUP̧sxFFFEFLMPFG6rG612y¡qi%0z"†r18vHFXMMF7WUP21F DVU?QP?RO\NPKLS4?PLWUQP?PSXOP4UOLO?Q5NV5LW4NTTNW?P?LO™?PKWLR?QLWMS?4LOOX̂YL4PPNSLV?ÛVLLOP?TUP?NQFi**$q+$ n*$%%0Ž$%"n*',$(n'!/#*n$0+,",n(#,$‚","mgrvsvHF7W288xGWI?SFG66wyxMSLO4S?MP?NQWSX]Oy¡’g$ n(*,$/j+*$k&gp$ q+'g$lg$k!nj#.*n$ˆ&,&n#$k&nogruv1FFvv8x1ws1yxUXPNTN̂?VLOy¡"m*.&Š$lg$-‡$-/|"&$"',(n*#r7G8FFGv1 x1wu2yxTNP?NQM?4PXSLOyFUOPVZr‚*†)/n}$q+,.p$q+'glg$i,/,"'$k&+,n&.$k&)o&+*+,#p$q+'gr17uFIPF1788xG61uy x4?PLW?Q9LS?POMMFUP8vyrUWWSLOOLWPSUWLTUSš4VU?TOXQWLSPKLUQKUT4PrSUPKLSPKUQUQP?PSXOP4VU?TOXQWLS PKLKLSTUQ4PrUQWW?WQNPMXSMNSPPNÛSN]UPLPKLOPUQW?Q]UQUVZO?OXQWLS0{kF 76INQPSUSZPNDVU?QP?RO\UOOLSP?NQrUPQNMN?QPW?WLRLQWUQPO›4NQ4LWLœPKUPDVU?QP?RO 9LS?POMMFUPGwQFG7FQRU4PrLRLQWUQPOUS]XLPKLLU4PNMMNO?PL™K?VL rPKLZRU?VPNUWLžXUPLVZUVL]LUQZ4NQQL4P?NQ̂LP™LLQ rVLPUVNQLPKL?SMUSP?4?MUP?NQ?QPKLUVL]LWO4KLTLFi**9LS?POSFUPGw376F Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 26 of 46 G1 ¢¥ ;̄A©«ª©¬¬d>̈«d§©Aë³¦C̈³©d̈«dC«d©ëĀ¢ DVU?QP?RRORU?VPNUVL]LU5?ÛVL4NQOM?SU4ZPKUPTUšLOL4NQNT?4OLQOLx#**$9LS?POSF L4P?NQyrUQWDVU?QP?RRO\MMNO?P?NQSL?QRNS4LOPKL4NQOM?SU4Z\O?TMVUXO?̂?V?PZF €"n#,rDVU?QP?RROT?O4NQOPSXLLRLQWUQPO\MVUXO?̂?V?PZUS]XTLQPFLRLQWUQPOWNQNPUS]XL PKUPPKL4UOLOKNXVŴLW?OT?OOLŴL4UXOLPKL›RXVUQWMSL4?OLO4NMLœNRPKL4NQOM?SU4Z?O XQ4VLUSx#**$9LS?POMMFUPsyr̂XPSUPKLŜL4UXOLDVU?QP?RRO\UVL]UP?NQOr?QW?5?WXUVZNS 4NVL4P?5LVZrRU?VPNMVUXO?̂VZMVLUWPKL4NQOM?SU4ZPKUP,!*jUVL]LFINXSPOSNXP?QLVZWLPLST?QL ™KLPKLSUMVU?QP?RKUOMSLOLQPLWRU4POOXR?4?LQPPNOXMMNSPPKLO4NMLNRPKLUVL]LW4NQOM?SU4Z NQTNP?NQOPNW?OT?OOFi**r*gmgr$q+$n*$˜"+'$0+,",n(#,$‚","mgr1vvHFXMMF7WF778r72wr787 xFFFEFG612yxW?OT?OO?Q]MVU?QP?RO\UVL]UP?NQONRU›̂SNUWrRUS3SLU4K?Q]R?5L3ZLUS 4NQOM?SU4Zœ̂L4UXOLPKLUVL]UP?NQOUP̂LOPUOOLSPLW›UPKLNSZNR4NQOM?SU4ZQUSSN™LS?QWXSUP?NQ UQWO4NMLœUQWPKUPW?WQNPMVUXO?̂VZ4UXOLPKL?S?QYXSZyF[LSLrDVU?QP?RROUVL]LPKUPPKL MXSMNSPLW4NQOM?SU4Z?OTUOO?5L UOMSU™V?Q]xUV̂L?POLVR3OLS5?Q]VZ5U]XLyU]SLLTLQPUTNQ]/. LRLQWUQPO›QNPPN4NTMLPLœNQ/+ĵNQWPSUWLRNSOL5LQZLUSO?QNSWLSPNTUQ?MXVUPLPKL *+,"n*̂NQW›TUSšLPFœ9LS?POMMFUPu3vF71DVU?QP?ROUSLrNR4NXSOLrRSLLPNUVL]L ™KUPL5LSPZMLNR4NQOM?SU4ZPKLẐLV?L5LPN̂L™USSUQPLWFXPDVU?QP?RRO4UQQNPrNQPKLNQL KUQWrSLMLUPLWVZ4KNNOLPNUVL]LURUS3SLU4K?Q]r™?WL3SUQ]?Q]rVNQ]3OPUQW?Q]4NQOM?SU4ZrUQW PKLQrNQPKLNPKLSKUQWrWLTUQWPKUPPKLINXSPSLV?L5LPKLTRSNTPKL4NQOLžXLQ4LONRPKUP 4KN?4LFDVU?QP?RRORU?VPNUVL]LKN™,!"#OXMMNOLWVZTUOO?5L4NQOM?SU4Z4NXVWKU5LNMLSUPLWrNS KN™PKLO4UPLSOKNP4KUPODVU?QP?RROUVL]LOXMMNSPPKLL?OPLQ4LNRUO4KLTLPKUP4NXVWURL4P *l*nĵNQWPSUWL̂ZUQZLRLQWUQPF i*'&+|r$DVU?QP?RO4NQ4LWLPKUP 71DVU?QP?RO4NQ5LQ?LQPVZM?4šUQW4KNNOLKN™PKLZMNSPSUZPKL?TMU4PNRPKLMXSMNSPLW4NQOM?SU4ZUO?POX?POPKL?S QLLWOrUS]X?Q]UPP?TLOPKUP?PLQ4NTMUOOLONQVZPSUQOU4P?NQOW?SL4PVẐLP™LLQFF3̂UOLW?Q5LOPNSOUQWLRLQWUQPO x9LS?POMMFUPurGwyrUQWUPNPKLSP?TLOPKUPPKL?TMU4P™UO›TUSšLP3™?WLœx"|gUP7vr7syF Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 27 of 46 GG 9LS?POMMFUP76FQUWW?P?NQrPKLZWNQNPW?OMXPLPKUPPK?OTL4KUQ?OT™NXVW SLžX?SLQLUS34NQOPUQP4NTTXQ?4UP?NQUQW4NNSW?QUP?NQNR4XSSLQPPSUW?Q]?QRNSTUP?NQL5LSZP?TL UOXMMNOLW4NQOM?SUPNSSL4L?5LWUSLžXLOPRNSUžXNPLRSNTU4XOPNTLSFi**$"|gKLOKLLS 5NVXTLNR?TTLW?UPL4NTTXQ?4UP?NQOPK?O™NXVWQL4LOO?PUPLSLQWLSOPKL4NQOM?SU4ZVN]?OP?4UVZ ?TMVUXO?̂VL̂L4UXOL?P™NXVWSLžX?SLUWL]SLLNR›NS]UQ?ŸUP?NQUQW4NNMLSUP?NQ£PKUP?O¤ MSU4P?4UVZ?TMNOO?̂VLFœi**$9LS?POSFUPG83Gsx4?P?Q]k!(„"n}&$lg$*,*n$(#g$(n*/($&z$ig$ "*|)&+,p$q+'gp827HFXMMFGW8vwr82vxtFFFIFG611yyF DVU?QP?RRO4VU?TPKUPPKLZKU5LUVL]LWPKLSLžX?O?PLVL5LVNR4NNSW?QUP?NQx9LS?POMMFUP Gw376yr̂L4UXOLPKLZUVL]LPKUPLRLQWUQPO F9LS?POMMFUP76FXPPK?O 4NQ4VXONSZ4VU?T?O4NQPSUW?4PLŴZUVL]UP?NQO?QPKLIr™K?4KrUP̂LOPrOKN™ONQVZOMNSUW?4r /|$!&'rTNOPVẐ?VUPLSUV4NTTXQ?4UP?NQUTNQ]OK?RP?Q]OX̂OLPONRLRLQWUQPOFi**$9LS?POSFUP G23GsFDVU?QP?RROUVONUOOLSPPKUPPKLZKU5LUVL]LWRU4POOKN™?Q] x9LS?POMMFUP76yr̂XPDVU?QP?ROU4šQN™VLW]LPKUP 7Gq|gDVU?QP?RROOP?VRU?VPNNRLSUPKLNSZ NRKN™OX4K4NTTXQ?4UP?NQ4NXVŴL4NNSW?QUPLWUTNQ]/.UVL]LW4NQOM?SUPNSOrNSL5LQKN™ NQLUVL]LW4NQOM?SUPNS4NXVWMNOO?̂VZšQN™™K?4K4N34NQOM?SUPNSOPN4NQPU4PXMNQSL4L?5?Q]U 4XOPNTLS?QžX?SZ?RPKUPUVL]LW4NQOM?SUPNS™UOUPLTMP?Q]PN4NVXWLFt?PKNXP4NQO?OPLQPUQW ?TTLW?UPLU44LOOPNOX4K?QRNSTUP?NQrWLUVLSO4NXVWQNPKU5L4NVXWLWFi**$9LS?POSFUPG23GsF DVU?QP?RROXVP?TUPLVZSLONSPPNUS]X?Q]PKUPLRLQWUQP3™?WL4NTTXQ?4UP?NQ?OXQQL4LOOUSZ x9LS?POMMFUP77ŷL4UXOL›£U¤Q?Q5LOPNS?QPLSLOPLW?Q̂XZ?Q]NSOLV?Q]UQ̂NQW]LQLSUVZ 7G ?OQNPUQUWLžXUPLOX̂OP?PXPLRNSDVU?QP?RO\RU?VXSLPNUVL]LPKL Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 28 of 46 G7 4NQPU4PLWQNTNSLPKUQURL™WLUVLSOFœq|g$UP77¡I¹177FXPWLUVLSOSL4L?5?Q]USLžXLOPRNS UžXNPLOP?V™NXVWQNPšQN™™K?4KNPKLSMXSMNSPLW4NQOM?SUPNSOKUŴLLQ?Q5?PLWPN̂?WrUQW ™NXVWPKLSLRNSLQLLWPN4NQPU4PUVPKLUVL]LW4NQOM?SUPNSOPNLQOXSLPKUPQNQL™LSL4NTMLP?Q] NQLU4KPSUQOU4P?NQFi**9LS?POSFUPGwr7v378FDVU?QP?RROUVL]LQNRU4POOKN™?Q]UQZOX4K 4NTTXQ?4UP?NQrUQW?P?OQNL4XOLPKUPDVU?QP?RRONQVZKU5L4NNMLSUP?NQTUPLS?UVORSNTP™N LRLQWUQPO¡?RLRLQWUQP3™?WL4NTTXQ?4UP?NQOL?OPLWrDVU?QP?RO™NXVWKU5LPKLTRSNT 4NNMLSUP?NQTUPLS?UVORSNT/+j$P™NLRLQWUQPOF DVU?QP?RROUVONLSSNQLNXOVZSLVZNQ€í$qqPNPSZPNOXMMNSPTUQZNRPKL?SMVUXO?̂?V?PZ US]XTLQPOr?Q4VXW?Q]PKL?S4VU?TOPKUPPKL4NQOM?SU4Z?OMVUXO?̂VLL5LQPKNX]Kx?y?P™UO UVL]LWVZ?TMVLTLQPLWXO?Q]NQVZW?SL4P4NTTXQ?4UP?NQx9LS?POMMFUP7137GyrUQWx?y DVU?QP?RROUVL]LWNQVẐ?VUPLSUVNSTXVP?VUPLSUV4NTTXQ?4UP?NQÔLP™LLQW?OP?Q4POX̂OLPONRPKL UVL]LW4NQOM?SUPNSOx"|gUP7737uyFXP€í$q?O™KNVZ?QUMMNO?PLFOUMSLV?T?QUSZTUPLSr?P ?Q5NV5LÔLQ4KTUSšSUPLOr™K?4KDVU?QP?RO4NQ4LWL?OQNPPKL4UOLKLSLF9LS?POMMFUPGv QF1vF77QUWW?P?NQrPKLINXSP4NQ4VXWLW?Q€í$qqPKUPPKLMVU?QP?RROKUWMVUXO?̂VZUVL]LWU ŜNUWLS4NQOM?SU4ZPNR?H½3SLVUPLWPSUQOU4P?NQO5?UW?SL4P4NTTXQ?4UP?NQNQVZ/z,*nKU5?Q] UVSLUWZRNXQWr?QUMS?NSWL4?O?NQrPKLNS?]?QUVrQUSSN™LSPKLNSZNR̂LQ4KTUSšSUPLTUQ?MXVUP?NQ ™UOMVUXO?̂VZUVL]LWFq+$n*$€&n*"m+$~†'!g$*+'!)/n}$-/,*#$0+,",n(#,$‚","mFr8uHFXMMF7W vs1rvw1xFFFEFG61vyx›€í$qœyFH?QUVZxUQWUVONXQV?šLKLSLyrPKL€íMVU?QP?RROUVL]LWPKUP WLRLQWUQPO4NVL4P?5LVZ4NQPSNVLWN5LSw6MLS4LQPNRPKLRNSL?]QL4KUQ]LN5LS3PKL34NXQPLS TUSšLPr™K?4KMXSMNSPLWVZ]U5LPKLTPKLÛ?V?PZPNSLV?ÛVZ4NNSW?QUPL4LSPU?QPSUQOU4P?NQOUPU 77i**q+$n*$€&n*"m+$~†'!/+m*$*+'!)/n}$-/,*#$0+,",n(#,$‚","mg$x›€í$qqœyr17I?5F88swxyrG612tv16s171r UP̧GŗvxFFFEFLMPFG6rG612yx4NTMVU?QPMVLW›PKLL?OPLQ4LNRU4NQOM?SU4ZPNR?̂LQ4KTUSšSUPLOUQW ?̂WÝUOšOMSLUWOœ̂UOLWNQ4?S4XTOPUQP?UVL5?WLQ4LNRU]SLLTLQPOPNR?MS?4LOUQWPKL›W?SL4PSLVUP?NQOK?Mœ̂LP™LLQ WLRLQWUQPO\U4P?5?P?LO?QPKLTUSšLPUQWPKLUSP?R?4?UVMS?4LTN5LTLQPOPKUPKUSTLWPKLMVU?QP?ROy¡i".l*nr77GHF XMMF7WUPw62xQNP?Q]PKUP›£U¤VPKNX]KPKLSL?ONRPLQUOPUP?OP?4UVZO?]Q?R?4UQPrNSRNSTXVU3̂UOLWr4NQQL4P?NQ L̂P™LLQUR?QUQ4?UV̂LQ4KTUSšUQWSLVUPLWWLS?5UP?5LOrPKL?TMU4PNRLM?ONW?44NNSW?QUPLWPSUW?Q]FFF?OXQ4VLUSœyF Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 29 of 46 Gu OML4?R?4P?TLNRWUZPNTUQ?MXVUPLPKL̂LQ4KTUSšSUPLF€í$qqrG612tv16s171rUP̧GGF KLSLTU?Q?Q]4UOLODVU?QP?RO4?PLRNSPKLMSNMNO?P?NQPKUPU4NQOM?SU4Z4UQ̂L ?TMVLTLQPLW5?UW?SL4P4NTTXQ?4UP?NQ4NQPU?QLWRU4PXUVUVL]UP?NQOOKN™?Q]U4NQ4SLPLMSN4LOO Ẑ™K?4KPKLUVL]LW4NQOM?SU4ZNMLSUPLWPN4NQO?OPLQPVZUQWSLV?ÛVẐLQLR?PLU4KWLRLQWUQPF 9LS?POMMFUP7GFNQLNRPKNOLNPKLSOXMMNOLW4NQOM?SU4?LOSLV?LWONVLVZNQ/|$!&' 4NTTXQ?4UP?NQOPNRXQ4P?NQF7u?T?VUSVZr?QPKL4UOLODVU?QP?RRO4?PL™KLSL4NXSPORNXQW UVL]UP?NQONR̂?VUPLSUV4NTTXQ?4UP?NQOOXR?4?LQPrLU4KUVL]LWU4NQOM?SU4Z?Q™K?4KPKL4N3 4NQOM?SUPNSO4NXVWMVUXO?̂VZNMLSUPL™?PKNXP4NQP?QXNXO4NTTXQ?4UP?NQrUQWLU4K4NQOM?SUPNS\O 4NQP?QXLWUWKLSLQ4LPNPKLUVL]LWU]SLLTLQP4NXVŴLSLUW?VZ5LS?R?LŴZPKLNPKLSUVL]LW 4NQOM?SUPNSOF7vNPONKLSLr™KLSLDVU?QP?RRO\UVL]LW4NQOM?SU4Z™NXVWSLžX?SL4NQOPUQP 4NTTXQ?4UP?NQ?Q5NV5?Q]PKLLQP?SL]SNXMNRMXSMNSPLW4N34NQOM?SUPNSOL5LSZP?TLNQLNRPKLT SL4L?5LWUSLžXLOPRNSUžXNPLxUQWDVU?QP?RROKU5LQNPMVUXO?̂VZUVL]LWUQZOX4K 7ui**$q+$n*$"m!$€n(',&#*$k&n+$ijn(o$0+,",n(#,$‚","mgrGwvHF7W2v1r2vu3226x8PKI?SFG66GyxSL5LSO?Q]U]SUQPNR OXTTUSZYXW]TLQPRNSWLRLQWUQPO™KLSLMVU?QP?ROOML4?R?4UVZUVL]LWUQWMSLOLQPLWL5?WLQ4LPKUPWLRLQWUQPO ?TMVLTLQPLWUQU]SLLTLQPPNR?MS?4LÔZUWNMP?Q]XQ?RNSTMS?4LOrSLRXO?Q]PNO?]QVNQ]PLSTMS?4?Q]U]SLLTLQPOr UQŴXZ?Q]4NSQOZSXMRSNTLU4KNPKLSPNUVL]LWVZOPÛ?V?ŸLTUSšLPOKUSLOy¡q+$n*$~.*'g$&&}#$0+,",n(#,$‚","mFrsvwHF XMMFGW281r28v38wxFFFEFG61GyxWLQZ?Q]TNP?NQPNW?OT?OÔUOLWNQMVU?QP?RO\UVL]UP?NQONRPKSLLWLR?QLW RNSTONR4NQWX4PPNLRL4PPKL4NQOM?SU4Zx1yO?TXVPUQLNXOVZWLVUZ?Q]PKLSLVLUOLNRPKL?SLNNšOXQP?VURPLS KUSW4N5LS4NM?LO™LSLSLVLUOLWrxGyO?]Q?Q]?WLQP?4UVOUVLO4NQPSU4PO™?PKMMVLPKUP]U5LPKLMX̂V?OKLSO?Q4SLUOLW MS?4?Q]UXPKNS?PZrUQWx7yPKSLUPLQ?Q]PN™?PKKNVWLNNšORSNTTUŸNQUQWNPKLSLNNšSLPU?VLSO?ROX4KSLPU?VLSO W?WQNPU]SLLPNPKL?SPLSTOyF 7vQi(."l/+$lg$/n'./j#$‚kr173453Gs11xDJIyrG618t2svv86rUP̧1xFFFEFHL̂FG1rG618yrO?T?VUSPNPKL €í4UOLrMVU?QP?ROMVLWPKUPWLRLQWUQPOTUQ?MXVUPLWPKL̂LQ4KTUSšSUPLNQUWU?VẐUO?ÔZOX̂T?P?Q]RUVOLWUPUPKUP ™UOPKLQXOLWPN4UV4XVUPLPKLSUPLrUQWPKUPPKLSUPL™UOUW?SL4PVZ?Q4NSMNSUPLWMS?4?Q]PLST?QUVNRMVU?QP?RO\ 4NQPSU4POFNPÛVZrPKL4NXSP?Qi(."l/+W?OT?OOLWPKL4NXQPOUOOLSP?Q]?QOPUQ4LONR?QW?5?WXUVPSUWLS3̂UOLW4NQWX4P SLVUP?Q]PNMXSMNSPLW›4NVX£O?NQ¤NQPKLMS?4?Q]NROML4?R?4WLS?5UP?5LPSUQOU4P?NQOœNS›4NNSW?QUP£?NQ¤PNS?]̂?WO?Q PKL?SPSUQOU4P?NQO™?PK4NXQPLSMUSP?LOœ PKLNQVZPZMLONRUVL]LWTUQ?MXVUP?NQKLSL QNP?Q]PKLSL™LSL?QOXR?4?LQP RU4PXUVUVL]UP?NQOOXSSNXQW?Q]PKUPMUSP?4XVUSPZMLNRT?O4NQWX4PFq|FUP̧Gu3GvFQq+$n*$‰0i%0•$ˆ/n}*,‘ˆ/}*n#$ 0+,",n(#,$‚","m/,"&+r12wHFFFuw7rv6GxFFFEF1ww2yrPKLMVU?QP?ROUVL]LWPKUPWLRLQWUQPO™LSLÛVLPN TLPKNW?4UVZR?OL4XS?P?LOOMSLUWÔZ4NVL4P?5LVZSLRXO?Q]PNžXNPLNWW3L?]KPKONRUWNVUS?QPKL?Ŝ?WOUQWUOšOFQ q+$n*$ € ‘‚k%$–€./,$/+*.—$0+,",n(#,$‚","m/,"&+rG28HFFFvs7rvssxFFIUVFG616yrPKLMVU?QP?ROUVL]LWUQW MSLOLQPLWL5?WLQ4LPKUPWLRLQWUQPTUQXRU4PXSLSOr™KNWNT?QUPLWPKLxUVSLUWZ4NQ4LQPSUPLWy?QWXOPSZWXS?Q]PKL MLS?NWNRPKLUVL]LW4NQOM?SU4ZrTLPSL]XVUSVZPNSLU4KU]SLLTLQPONQPUS]LPMS?4LOrRVNNSMS?4LOrUQWMS?4LSUQ]LO RNSH3IMUQLVOUQWSLVUPLWMSNWX4POFH?QUVZrq+$n*$"m!‘ *'!$~)o.&j**$0+,",n(#,$‚","m/,"&+rsv2HFXMMFGW 1167xFFIUVFG61Gyr?OU4UOLÛNXPQNQ3MNU4K?Q]U]SLLTLQPOPKUP?ORU4PXUVZ?SSLVL5UQPFKLSLr5US?NXO 4NTMUQ?LOPKUP™LSLUR?V?UPLW™?PKPL5L”N̂OU]SLLW™?PKNPKLSPL4KR?STOPNSLRSU?QRSNT4NVW34UV?Q]LU4KNPKLS\O OUVUS?LWLTMVNZLLOFKLO™LLM?Q]U]SLLTLQPOUVL]LWPKLSL™LSL›QNPV?T?PLŴZ]LN]SUMKZrYN̂RXQ4P?NQrMSNWX4P ]SNXMNSP?TLMLS?NWrœPKLSL̂ZN̂5?UP?Q]PKLQLLWPN4NTTXQ?4UPLÛNXPOML4?R?4LTMVNZLLO?QNSWLSPNU5N?W 4NTMLP?Q]RNSPUVLQPPKUPKUWUVSLUWẐLLQK?SLŴZNQLNRPKLUVL]LWVZ34NQOM?S?Q]R?STOFq|gUP1111r111v3G7F Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 30 of 46 Gv 4NTTXQ?4UP?NQyFi**9LS?POSFUPG23GsFQWDVU?QP?ROKU5LQNSLOMNQOLPNLRLQWUQPO\ US]XTLQPPKUPDVU?QP?RRORU?VPNUWLžXUPLVZMVLUWKN™UVL]LW4N34NQOM?SUPNSO4NXVWMNV?4LPKL 4NQOM?SU4ZFi**"|gUPGsF !"n|rDVU?QP?RRORU?VPNSLRXPLPKLUS]XTLQPPKUPPKL?QWXOPSZMSLOLQ4LNRQNQ3LRLQWUQP ̂NQWWLUVLSO ™KN4NXVWXQWLS4XP4NVXO?5LMS?4?Q] SLQWLSOPKLUVL]LW4NQOM?SU4Z ?TMVUXO?̂VLF9LS?POSFUP72378FDVU?QP?ROWNQNPMVLUWPKUP4XOPNTLSO4NXVWNSW?WONV?4?P žXNPLOrNSMXS4KUOL̂NQWOrONVLVZRSNTLUVLSLRLQWUQPO¡PNPKL4NQPSUSZrDVU?QP?RO U4šQN™VLW]LPKUP4XOPNTLSO4NXVWONV?4?PžXNPLORSNTQNQ3LRLQWUQPWLUVLSOFi**p$*gmgrI¹¹ 1Gwr F72DVU?QP?RRO\V?T?PUP?NQNRPKL?SMXPUP?5L4VUOOPNPKNOLPKUPW?SL4PVZPSUQOU4PLW™?PK LRLQWUQPOx9LS?POMMFUP72yWNLOQNP4XSLPK?OWLRL4PFKLRU4PPKUPU4XOPNTLSXVP?TUPLVZ MXS4KUOLŴNQWORSNTULRLQWUQPOUZOQNPK?Q]ÛNXPPKL?TMU4PPKUPQNQ3LRLQWUQPWLUVLSO ™NXVWKU5L?QXQWLST?Q?Q]PKLÛ?V?PZNRLRLQWUQPOPNMSN5?WLUQWMSNR?PRSNTUQP?4NTMLP?P?5L žXNPLOFH?QUVZrLRLQWUQPO\MN?QP?O+&,$xUODVU?QP?RO\OPSU™3TUQUS]XTLQP™NXVWKU5L?PyPKUP PKLMSLOLQ4LNRQNQ3LRLQWUQPWLUVLSOSLQWLSOPKLUVL]LW4NQOM?SU4Z?TMVUXO?̂VL̂L4UXOLPKLZ ™NXVWMSL5LQP?PRSNT™NSš?Q]›*l*njœO?Q]VLP?TLFq|gUP78FUPKLSr4XOPNTLSO\LUOZU44LOOPN QNQ3LRLQWUQPWLUVLSOSLQWLSOPKLUVL]LW4NQOM?SU4Z?TMVUXO?̂VL̂L4UXOLPKLMSLOLQ4LNRPKNOL QNQ34NVXW?Q]WLUVLSO™NXVWTLUQPKUPPKLUVL]LW4NQOM?SU4Z4NXVW+*l*nSLV?ÛVZRXQ4P?NQrUQW ™NXVW?QWLLWMNPLQP?UVZKUSTLRLQWUQPO?RPKLZ4KNOLPNRNSL]N4NTMLP?P?5L̂?WOF9LS?POSF UPGwF €"+/.jrDVU?QP?ROUWT?PPKUPPKLZWNQNPUVL]LRU4POPKUPOKN™LU4KLRLQWUQP MUSP?4?MUPLW?QPKLMXSMNSPLW4NQOM?SU4ZPKSNX]KNXPPKLLQP?SL4VUOOMLS?NWF9LS?POMMFUP7wF 72KXOrRUSRSNT4NQPSUW?4P?Q]PKLIx#**$9LS?POMMFUP72yrPK?OUS]XTLQP?OOXMMNSPLŴZ?PF?T?VUSVZr DVU?QP?RO4VU?TPKUPLRLQWUQPO›TUšLXMœPKLUOOXTMP?NQPKUPPKLZW?WQNPšQN™™K?4KWLUVLSO™LSLUMMSNU4KLW Ẑ4XOPNTLSORNSžXNPLOx9LS?POMMFUP78yr̂XPPK?OR?QWOO?]Q?R?4UQPOXMMNSP?QDVU?QP?RO\UVL]UP?NQOPKUP ̂NQWOUVLOUSLNMUžXLFq|gUP72x4?P?Q]I¹¹1Gw372yF Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 31 of 46 G2 INQPSUSZPNDVU?QP?RO\US]XTLQPPKUPPK?O›OUZOQNPK?Q]œÛNXPPKL4NQOM?SU4Z\OMVUXO?̂?V?PZx"|gyr ?P?OPLV?Q]PKUPDVU?QP?RRO4UQQNPTUšLOX4KUOKN™?Q]WLOM?PLPKLLPLQO?5L4NNMLSUP?NQ TUPLS?UVOPKLZSL4L?5LWRSNTOLPV?Q]WLRLQWUQPOFQUWW?P?NQrDVU?QP?RO\SLOMNQOLPNLRLQWUQPO\ US]XTLQPPKUPPKLZKU5LW?O?Q]LQXNXOVZMNSPSUZLWXQ4NQQL4PLWPSUWLSOUOMUSPNRPKL4NQOM?SU4Z PN?QRVUPL?PÔSLUWPKx9LS?POSFUP76y?OXQU5U?V?Q]rUOPKLZO?TMVZSLMLUPPKL?S4NQ4VXONSZ4VU?T PKUPPKLPSUWLSO›XQWLSOPNNWUQW?TMVLTLQPLWPKLU]SLLTLQPQNPPN4NTMLPLFœ9LS?POMMFUP7sr 7wQF7GF78 @¢¥ ;̄A©«ª©¬¬dA©̄ª̈ ̄ CBC©Cëªî©°C«ëC̈¬ª¦C ̄ CBC°̈«d§©Aë³̈ªª̈ ̈®§CªC¢ DVU?QP?RROUWT?PPKUP›W?SL4PL5?WLQ4LœNRU4NQOM?SU4ZTXOP›SLžX?SLQN?QRLSLQ4LœNRUQ UQP?4NTMLP?P?5LU]SLLTLQPF9LS?POMMFUPwx4?P?Q]q+$n*$q+#g$n&}*n/m*$0+,",n(#,$‚","mgr21s HF7W766r7G73Gux7WI?SFG616yyFDVU?QP?RROMSLOLQPQNOX4KL5?WLQ4L?QPKLIFUPKLSr DVU?QP?RROUVL]LUSUQWNTUOONSPTLQPNRXQSLVUPLWUQWMS?TUS?VẐ?VUPLSUV4NTTXQ?4UP?NQOUTNQ] W?OP?Q4POLPONRPSUWLSOSL]USW?Q]W?O4SLPLPSUW?Q]O?PXUP?NQORNŜNQWOPKUPWNQNP 4NQOP?PXPLW?SL4PL5?WLQ4LNRUQZ›U]SLLTLQPQNPPN4NTMLPLœUTNQ]UVLRLQWUQPOFi**$*gmgp$ 9LS?POSFUP71x4?P?Q]q+$n*$q&Š/$-*/|j‘ˆ"†$k&+'n*,*$0+,",n(#,$‚","mgr82sHFXMMFGWw21rw8v xFFN™UG611yxW?OT?OO?Q]4VU?T™KLSLMVU?QP?RRO\UVL]UP?NQO™LSLT?OO?Q]PKL›ºVUS]LS M?4PXSL\RSNT™K?4K?QRLSLQ4LONRU™?WLS4NQOM?SU4Z£4NXVW¤̂LWSU™QRSNT]X?VPZMVLUOPN OLMUSUPL̂?VUPLSUV4NQOM?SU4?LOœyyFQWLLWr̂L4UXOLPKLZVU4šW?SL4PL5?WLQ4LrDVU?QP?RROOMLQW TX4KNRPKL?S›W?SL4PL5?WLQ4LœUS]XTLQPžX?̂̂ V?Q]N5LS™KUP4UQ̂L"+z*nn*|RSNTPKLUVL]LW 4KUPOFi**p$*gmgr$9LS?POMMFUP1ux›K?O?OQNPUSLUONQÛVLÁµÂÈ×ÈµÛÈRSNTPKL4KUP¡̂XPL5LQ?R 78tK?VLDVU?QP?RO4NQPLQWPKUPPKLUVL]LW4NQOM?SU4Z™UO?QLRRL4PUONR”UQXUSZG66wrPKLZ4NQ4LWLPKUP F9LS?POMMFUPu1FDVU?QP?RO\NQVẐUO?O RNSUVL]?Q]U4NQOM?SU4ZMS?NSPN”XVZG66w?OOML4XVUP?NQÛNXP q|g UP7w3u1FK?O4NQYL4PXSL?OUQ?QOXR?4?LQP̂UO?ORSNT™K?4KPN?QRLSU4NQOM?SU4ZF9LS?POSFUP7ux4?P?Q]q+$n*$ ‚&+|&+$i".l*n$€"†"+mp$‚,|gp$0+,",n(#,$‚","mgrG17HFXMMF7Wv76rvvsQF1wxFFFEFG612yx›i".l*nœyyF Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 32 of 46 G8 ?P™LSLrPKLNMMNO?PL?QRLSLQ4L?OLžXUVZr?RQNPTNSLrMVUXO?̂VLFœyxLTMKUO?OUWWLWy¡"|g$UP17 x4?P?Q]4UOLVU™ÛNXP›'&+#,n(ï"+mð$/.$n*/#&+/„.*$ÁµÂÈ×ÈµÛÈÃœUOPNUVL]LWVZW?SL4PL5?WLQ4LyF QUQZL5LQPrPKL4KUPOPKUPDVU?QP?ROK?]KV?]KP?QPKL?SMMNO?P?NQUO›4NQ4SLPLrœW?SL4P L5?WLQ4LNRU4NQOM?SU4Z UVNR™K?4KUSL̂?VUPLSUVUQWXQ4NQQL4PLW NQVZWLTNQOPSUPLPKL RSU]TLQPLWQUPXSLNRPKL4NTTXQ?4UP?NQOUVL]LW?QPKLIFi**$9LS?POMMFUPw316 r16 r11 r1G FQU5U?QUPLTMP PNWLTNQOPSUPLPKLOL4NTTXQ?4UP?NQO™LSLMUSPNRPKLUVL]LWN5LSUS4K?Q]4NQOM?SU4ZrDVU?QP?RRO 4NQPLQWPKUPPKLUVL]LW4NQWX4PRUVO?QPN›RNXSPL4KQ?žXLOœUQWPKUPPKLZKU5LTUWLTXVP?MVL UVL]UP?NQOOKN™?Q]LU4KPL4KQ?žXLF7sq|gUPwFXPDVU?QP?RROOP?V4UQQNPMVUXO?̂VZ4NQQL4PUQZ 4KUPxNS4NVL4P?NQNR4KUPOy™?PKPKLUVL]LŴSNUWLSO4KLTLFKXOrL5LQU44LMP?Q]DVU?QP?RO\ 4KUSU4PLS?ŸUP?NQNR*l*nj4KUP?QPKLIrUP̂LOPrDVU?QP?RROKU5LUVL]LWOMNSUW?4r?ONVUPLW ?QOPUQ4LONRUT̂ ?]XNXO4NQWX4P̂Z4LSPU?QPSUWLSOPKUP?OQNPW?SL4PxNS?QW?SL4PyL5?WLQ4LNRUQ U]SLLTLQPUTNQ]UVLRLQWUQPOQNPPN4NTMLPL™?PKSLOML4PPNUVNRPKL?ŜNQW PSUQOU4P?NQORNSQLUSVZOL5LQZLUSOF DVU?QP?RROUVONUPLTMPPN4KUSU4PLS?ŸLPKLL4KUQ]LNRTUSšLP?QRNSTUP?NQUOMSNNRNRo*n$ #*XQVU™RXV4NQWX4PF7wi**$9LS?POMMFUP1v318FXPDVU?QP?ROU]U?QT?OOPUPLPKLVU™UQWPKL UVL]UP?NQO?QPKLIFP?O™LVOLPVLWPKUPPKLL4KUQ]LNRTUSšLP?QRNSTUP?NQr?Q4VXW?Q] MS?4?Q]?QRNSTUP?NQr?OQNPo*n$#*$XQVU™RXVFi**$9LS?POSFUP7137ux4?P?Q]0o*†$‡".$k&g$lg$ 7sDVU?QP?ROSLVZNQ"+|#$k&(+,jp$ˆ"##"##"oo"$lg$f/'!&l"/$/+}$‰g0gr866HFXMMFGW78sxFFFEFG616yrPN US]XLPKUP x9LS?POMMFUP1Gyr̂XPPKLZ N5LSOPUPLPKLKNVW?Q]NRPKUPWL4?O?NQFKL"+|#$4NXSPW?WQNPR?QWUO?Q]VLMNPLQP?UVZ4NVXO?5L4NQ5LSOUP?NQ UWLžXUPLPNMVUXO?̂VZUVL]LU4NQOM?SU4ZFQOPLUWrPKL4NXSP™UOL5UVXUP?Q]UWLRLQWUQP\OMUSP?4?MUP?NQ?QUQ UX4P?NQ3̂UOLŴ?W3S?]]?Q]4NQOM?SU4ZPKUPPKL4NXSPKUWUVSLUWZRNXQWPN̂LMVUXO?̂VLUOPNOL5LSUVNPKLSWLRLQWUQPO ÛOLWNQW?RLSLQPUVL]UP?NQO?QUon*l"&(#"+|#$k&(+,jWL4?O?NQNQLZLUSLUSV?LSF"+|#$k,jg866HFXMMFGWUP 7w73wvF 7wDVU?QP?RO4NQ4LWLPKUPPKLZUSLQNPUPLTMP?Q]PNUOOLSP4VU?TOXQWLSPKL›SXVLNRSLUONQFœ9LS?POMMFUP18QFsF Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 33 of 46 Gs %"ˆ/(n&rsGGHFGWGu2rGv83vsxGWI?SF1ws8y¡€"l*$i)",!#p$q+'g$lg$‰/,"&+/.$€&&,„/.$‚*/m(*$ ./j*n#$0##&'"/,"&+r8ssHFXMMF16uGr16v1xF9?QQF1wwGyyFu6DVU?QP?RRO4?PLPNPKLQP?PSXOP X?WLV?QLORNSINVÛNSUP?NQOTNQ]INTMLP?PNSO?QOXMMNSPNRPKL?SMNO?P?NQr̂XPPKL X?WLV?QLOWNQNPK?Q]PNOX]]LOPPKUP›PKLOKUS?Q]NR?QRNSTUP?NQºSLVUP?Q]PNMS?4LrNXPMXPr4NOPOr NSOPSUPL]?4MVUQQ?Q]FFF4XSSLQPNMLSUP?Q]UQWRXPXSL̂XO?QLOOMVUQOFFF£UQW¤?QW?5?WXUV 4NTMUQZWUPUr\UTNQ]4NTMLP?PNSOœMSN5?WLO›MN™LSRXVL5?WLQ4LNRUQ?VL]UV4NQOM?SU4ZFœ 9LS?POMMFUP1vFu1NPÛVZrDVU?QP?RRONT?PPKUPPKLX?WLV?QLOOML4?R?4UVZU4šQN™VLW]LPKUP ›PKLOKUS?Q]NR?QRNSTUP?NQUTNQ]4NTMLP?PNSOTUẐLMSN4NTMLP?P?5LUQW?ONRPLQSLUONQÛVZ QL4LOOUSZPNU4K?L5LPKLMSN4NTMLP?P?5L̂LQLR?PONR4LSPU?Q4NVÛNSUP?NQOFœq|g DVU?QP?RRO\SLV?UQ4LNQ…+",*|$i,/,*#$lg$k&+,/"+*n$k&nog$&z$0)*n"'/r7w7FF777x1w2wyr ?OO?T?VUSVZT?OMVU4LWFKLSLrPKLXMSLTLINXSP\OKNVW?Q]PKUPPKLWLRLQWUQPO\L4KUQ]LNR WLPU?VLWMS?4?Q]?QRNSTUP?NQ ?Q4VXW?Q]MS?4?Q]TUQXUVO™?PK™K?4KUWLRLQWUQP4NXVW4NTMXPL u6DVU?QP?RO\US]XTLQPPKUP›£P¤KLSL™UOQNUVL]UP?NQ?Q0o*†PKUPPKLWLRLQWUQPOL4KUQ]LW4NTTLS4?UVZOLQO?P?5L3 ?QRNSTUP?NQ?QPKLRXSPKLSUQ4LNRPKLUVL]LW4NQOM?SU4Zœx9LS?POMMFUP1syr?O?SSLVL5UQPPNPKLXQLžX?5N4UV MSNMNO?P?NQLOPÛV?OKLW?Q0o*†$PKUP›L5?WLQ4LNRTLSLL4KUQ]LNR?QRNSTUP?NQ̂Z4NTMLP?PNSO4UQQNPLOPÛV?OKU 4NQOM?SU4ZFœ9LS?POSFUP7137GFDVU?QP?ROUVONPSZPN4Û?Q€"l*$i)",!#UO?Q5NV5?Q]›YXOPNQL5U]XLRU4PXUV UVL]UP?NQNR4NQ4LSPLWU4P?NQœx9LS?POMMFUP1syr̂XPPKLZ?]QNSLPKUPPKL›NQLFFFUVL]UP?NQœ4NQ4LSQLWUMUPLSQ NRSL]XVUSL4KUQ]LONR?QRNSTUP?NQUTNQ]WLRLQWUQPOO?T?VUSPN™KUPDVU?QP?ROUVL]LKLSLF€"l*$i)",!#r8ssHF XMMFUP16u2xUVL]?Q]PKUPMVUZLS3U]LQPO›SL]XVUSVZL4KUQ]LW4NTMLQOUP?NQ?QRNSTUP?NQUQW?QRNSTUP?NQÛNXP 4XSSLQPNRRLSOUTNQ]PKLTOLV5LOœyFKL4NXSPRNXQWPKUPPK?OUVL]UP?NQ™UO?QOXR?4?LQPPNOXMMNSPUo*n$#*5?NVUP?NQ NRPKLKLSTUQ4P̂L4UXOL›£P¤KLL4KUQ]LNRMS?4LWUPUUQWNPKLS?QRNSTUP?NQUTNQ]4NTMLP?PNSOFFF4UQ?Q 4LSPU?Q4?S4XTOPUQ4LO?Q4SLUOLL4NQNT?4LRR?4?LQ4ZUQWSLQWLSTUSšLPOTNSLrSUPKLSPKUQVLOOr4NTMLP?P?5LFœq|F x?QPLSQUV4?PUP?NQNT?PLWyF u1DVU?QP?ROUVON4?PLPN0)*n"'/+$k&.()+$ƒ$‚()„*n$k&g$lg$…+",*|$i,/,*#rGv8FF788x1wG1yrUQLUSVZKXQWSLW ZLUSNVW4UOLxNQL̂LPLSSLTLT̂ LSLWRNS?POMN™LSRXVW?OOLQPORSNT”XOP?4LSUQWL?OUQW”XOP?4L[NVTLOyWL4?WLW NQOX̂OPUQP?UVZW?RLSLQPRU4PXUV]SNXQWOFKLSLrPKLWLRLQWUQPO™LSLTLT̂ LSONRUQUOON4?UP?NQPKUPWL5LVNMLWU OZOPLTUP?4MVUQRNSPKLWLRLQWUQPOPNOKUSL›WU?VZr™LLšVZUQWTNQPKVZSLMNSPONRPKLT?QXPLOPWLPU?VONRPKL?S X̂O?QLOOrœUQWPNTNQ?PNSLU4KNPKLS\ÔLKU5?NSPKSNX]KW?O4SLP?NQUSẐNNšUXW?POUQWOPN4š?QOML4P?NQOrUQŴZ SL]XVUSVZOX̂T?P?Q]WLPU?VONRPKL?ŜXO?QLOOLOPNUQLMLSPRNSUQUVZO?ONQKN™PN›KUSTNQ?ŸLœPKLTUSšLPFq|FUP u16FDVU?QP?ROTUšLQNOX4KUVL]UP?NQOKLSLrUODVU?QP?RO\UVL]LWO4KLTLLQPU?VOQN›OZOPLT?4MVUQœUQW?QOPLUW SLV?LONQPKLx?TMVUXO?̂VZUVL]LWyUW3KN4OKUS?Q]NR?QRNSTUP?NQPKUPDVU?QP?RO\N™QUVL]UP?NQOOKN™™UOQNP 4NTMLP?P?5LVZOLQO?P?5Lx9LS?POSFUP7137uyr™?PKNXPUQZUVL]LWTL4KUQ?OTRNSPKL̂SNUWLS]SNXMPN4NQO?OPLQPVZ L̂MS?5ZPNOX4KL4KUQ]LONSTNQ?PNSLU4KNPKLS\ÔLKU5?NS?QUQZ™UZx"|g$UPG2376yFDVU?QP?RO\SLV?UQ4LNQPKL TLS?4UQ”XS?OMSXWLQ4LPSLUP?OLMSN5?WLOQNUWW?P?NQUVOXMMNSP̂L4UXOLPKLOL4P?NQDVU?QP?ROžXNPLSLV?LO L4VXO?5LVZNQ0)*n"'/+$k&.()+Fi**$vuTF”XSFGWr9NQNMNV?LOUQWLOPSU?QPONRSUWLñuvxG61wyQF16FQUQZ L5LQPr?P?OQN™̂LZNQWW?OMXPLPKUP›£?¤QRNSTUP?NQL4KUQ]LOrNSU]SLLTLQPOPNOKUSL?QRNSTUP?NQrUSLYXW]LWXQWLS PKLSXVLNRSLUONQFœL4P?NQNRQP?PSXOPU™r0+,",n(#,$‚/Š$%*l*.&o)*+,#UPwsxsPKLWFG618yF Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 34 of 46 Gw PKLMS?4L4KUS]LŴZU4NTMLP?PNSNQUOML4?R?4NSWLSPNUOML4?R?44XOPNTLS SLOXVPLW?QMS?4L R??Q]™UÔUOLWNQPKLRU4PPKUPPKL?QWXOPSZ™UOWNT?QUPLŴZSLVUP?5LVZRL™OLVLSOUQWPKL MSNWX4P™UORXQ]?̂VLF7w7FFUP778FQ4NQPSUOPrDVU?QP?RROWNQNPW?OMXPLPKUPPKLSLUSLTUQZ ̂NQWWLUVLSOx#**9LS?POSFUPGwyrUQWPKLI\OUVL]UP?NQOSL]USW?Q]PKLMXSMNSPLW ›TUSšLPœRNŜNQWOx"g*grWLO4S?̂?Q]UTUSšLP4NQO?OP?Q]NROL5LSUV4UPL]NS?LONR̂NQWO NRLSLŴZÛSNUWUSSUZNR?OOXLSOyOKN™OPKUPPKL̂NQWOUSLQNPRXQ]?̂VLFi**"|gUPu13uG¡I ¹¹11v31sFuG [LSLrPKLL4KUQ]LNRTUSšLP?QRNSTUP?NQ̂ẐNQWWLUVLSO™UOMSN4NTMLP?P?5L?Q PKL?SSNVLOUOTUSšLPTUšLSOF9LS?POSFUP7G377FDVU?QP?RRO\4NQPLQP?NQPKUPPK?O›R?QWOQN OXMMNSP?QPKLIœx9LS?POMMFUP1vyr?OMVU?QVZ4NQPSUW?4PLŴZPKL?SUVL]UP?NQOÛNXPPKL QUPXSLNR̂NQWOUVLOFDVU?QP?RROUWT?PPKUP›WLUVLSOºMSN5?WLV?žX?W?PZNSTUšLTUSšLPÔZ L̂?Q]™?V?Q]PN̂XZUQWOLV̂NQWO\œx"|gx4?P?Q]I¹vuyy PKLOUTLOPSU?]KPRNS™USW MSN4NTMLP?P?5LYXOP?R?4UP?NQLRLQWUQPONRLSUOPN™KZ?P™UOONTLP?TLOQL4LOOUSZRNSPSUWLSOPN OKUSL?QRNSTUP?NQr?Q4VXW?Q]MS?4?Q]UQŴNQWU5U?VÛ?V?PZFi**$9LS?POSFUP7GF44NSW?Q]PN PKLIr̂NQWOUVLON44XS›N5LS3PKL34NXQPLSœxI¹1GwyrUSLTNSLNMUžXLPKUQTUQZ NPKLŜNQWOUVLOx"|g¹17uyrUQWUSLWLUVLS3WS?5LQx"|g¹1GwyFDVU?QP?RRORXSPKLSUVL]LPKUP›PKLSL ?OQNMNOP3PSUWLMS?4LPSUQOMUSLQ4ZœUQWPKUP›PKLSL?ONRPLQQNPSUQOMUSLQ4Z?QPNPSUW?Q]5NVXTLO NSMS?4LONPKLSPKUQ™?PKSLOML4PPNPKL£̂NQW\O¤?Q?P?UV?OOXUQ4LFœq|g¹17uFKXOrU44NSW?Q]PN DVU?QP?RRO\N™QUVL]UP?NQOrTUSšLP3TUš?Q]WLUVLSO™NXVWQLLWPN4NTTXQ?4UPL™?PKNPKLS WLUVLSOPNU44NXQPRNSPK?OVU4šNRPSUQOMUSLQ4Zr™K?4K™NXVWW?OP?Q]X?OKTUSšLP3TUš?Q]?Q N̂QWORSNTNPKLS?QWXOPS?LO™KLSLOX4K?QRNSTUP?NQL4KUQ]LOTUẐLXQQL4LOOUSZFu7 uGQUQZL5LQPrPKLL4NQWI?S4X?PKUOOX̂OLžXLQPVZLMVU?QLWPKUPk&+,/"+*n$k&no&n/,"&+\OUQUVZO?O?OSLVL5UQP NQVZPNUSXVLNRSLUONQ4UOLFi**$/,"o/m."/r8uvHFGWUP18v¡#(on/$UPQFuF u7HNSPK?OOUTLSLUONQrDVU?QP?RO\US]XTLQPPKUP UQWPKUPOX4K4NQWX4P?OU›MVXORU4PNSœPKUP™USSUQPOUQ?QRLSLQ4LNR4NQOM?SU4Zx9LS?POMMFUPG13 Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 35 of 46 76 ¢¥ ;̄A©«ª©¬¬dA©̄ª̈ ̄ CBC©ë±®dªA«ª©Āî©°C«ëC±¬©ë©C«ªª̈±§§̈ªA ;̄A±d©ò̄C«¬CC«ëC̈¬̈«d§©Aë³¢ DVU?QP?RRO\MMNO?P?NQ4NQR?STOPKUPPKLZKU5LRU?VLWPNUVL]LMUSUVLV4NQWX4PUQWPKL QL4LOOUSZ›MVXORU4PNSOœOXR?4?LQPPNOXMMNSPUMVUXO?̂VL?QRLSLQ4LNR4NQOM?SU4ZF 1F́ DVU?QP?RROHU?VPNVL]LDUSUVLVINQWX4P̂ZLRLQWUQPOF DVU?QP?RROUS]XLPKUPPKLI?O›SLMVLPL™?PK?QOPUQ4LOœNRLRLQWUQPO\MXSMNSPLWVZ MUSUVLV4NQWX4Px9LS?POMMFUP1w3G6yr™KLQ?QRU4PPKLUVL]UP?NQOOKN™QNPK?Q]NPKLSPKUQ OMNSUW?4UQWXQ4NQQL4PLW4NTTXQ?4UP?NQOUTNQ]W?OMUSUPLOX̂OLPONRPSUWLSON5LSTUQZZLUSOF 9LS?POSFUP7vFDVU?QP?RROUSLSLžX?SLWPNOKN™TNSLPKUQ›?ONVUPLWU4P?NQœPN›MSN5LPKL L?OPLQ4LNRUKX]LUQP?PSXOP4NQOM?SU4Z™?PKTXVP?MVLN̂YL4P?5LOUQW]NUVOrœ™K?4KPKLZRU?VPN WNFi**$9LS?POSFUP7vx4?P?Q]n")*$*/.,!'/n*$i*nl#gp$q+'g$lg$i*nlg$~)o#g$q+,.$…+"&+rNF113 453G2vG3DI3rG617t7s8768urUP̧wxFFIUVF”XVZGvrG617yr/z|r2uGHFMM\22v xwPKI?SFG612yyFuuN™KLSL?QPKLIUSLPKLSLQNQ34NQ4VXONSZUVL]UP?NQOPKUPUVLRLQWUQPO O?TXVPUQLNXOVZLQ]U]LW?Q/+jMUSUVLV4NQWX4PrVLPUVNQL4NQWX4POXR?4?LQPPNOXMMNSPUQ ?QRLSLQ4LNR4NQOM?SU4ZFDVU?QP?ROUSLPKXOVLRPZLPU]U?QPNUS]XL 4?P?Q]PKLOUTL4UOLVU™ W?OP?Q]X?OKLWÛN5Lx#**$#(on/MFvQF2y PKUPÛ?VUPLSUV4KUP?OOXR?4?LQPPNOKN™MUSUVLV 4NQWX4PUTNQ]UV71LRLQWUQPOr™K?4K?P?OQNPFi**$9LS?POMMFUP1wF Guy RU?VOFHUSRSNT FDVU?QP?RO\US]XLPKUP…+",*|$i,/,*#$lg$…gig${jo#()$k&gru7sFF uGGx1w8syr?OW?OP?Q]X?OKÛVL̂L4UXOLPKLZUVL]LPKUPLRLQWUQPOOKUSLWWLPU?VLW?QRNSTUP?NQ›/,$,!*$*†o*+#*$&z$ '(#,&)*n#Fœ9LS?POMMFUP1sFNPONFQ{jo#()rPKLLMUSPTLQPNR”XOP?4LO?T?VUSVZUVL]LWPKUPPKLOKUS?Q]NR 4NTMLP?P?5LVZOLQO?P?5L?QRNSTUP?NQUTNQ]4NTMLP?PNSO™UOUPPKLLMLQOLNR4NQOXTLSOFq|g$UPuG23GsFQUQZ L5LQPrPKLUVL]LW4KUPONQ™K?4KDVU?QP?ROSLVZ Fi**r$*gmgrI¹¹7uv3u8 uuDVU?QP?RO?Q4NSSL4PVZ4KUSU4PLS?ŸLn")*$*/.,!'/n*$UOKNVW?Q]PKUP›MVU?QP?RO4NXVWQNPMSN5LPKLL?OPLQ4LNRU 4NQOM?SU4ẐUOLWNQMUSUVLV4NQWX4PPKUP4NQO?OPLWNRNQLº?ONVUPLWU4P?NQWXS?Q]UQUVL]LWR?RPLLQZLUS 4NQOM?SU4ZF\œ9LS?POMMFUPG6QF16FQSLUV?PZrPKLn")*$*/.,!'/n*$MVU?QP?ROUVL]LWOL5LSUVPZMLONRL5?WLQ4L ™S?PLQUQW5LŜUVU]SLLTLQPOr4?S4XTOPUQP?UVL5?WLQ4LrUQWMUSUVLV4NQWX4PFG617t7s8768urUP̧v3wF VP?TUPLVZrPKL4NXSP4NQ4VXWLWPKUPrV?šLKLSLrPKLVLQ]PKZUVL]UP?NQOMSLOLQPLŴZMVU?QP?RO™LSLPNN5U]XLUQW UT̂ ?]XNXOPNMVUXO?̂VZUVL]LU4NQOM?SU4ZFq|g$UP̧wF Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 36 of 46 71 GF́ DVU?QP?RROHU?VPNVL]LUDVUXO?̂VLINTTNQ9NP?5LPNINQOM?SLF DVU?QP?RRONRLSQNTLUQ?Q]RXVSLOMNQOLPNLRLQWUQPO\US]XTLQPPKUPPKLI?OWL5N?W NRUVL]UP?NQOOKN™?Q]KN™LRLQWUQPO4NXVWSLV?ÛVZMSNR?PRSNTPKL4NQOM?SU4ZrUQWPKLSLRNSL KN™PKLZ4NXVWMNOOLOOUQZTNP?5LPN4NQOM?SLF9LS?POSFUP7v372FuvDVU?QP?RROPKLTOLV5LO UVL]LPKUPUO›TUSšLP3TUšLSOrœLRLQWUQPÔNPK›̂XZUQWOLV̂NQWOœxI¹¹1Gwr172yr UQWPKXOPKLRU4PPKUPLRLQWUQPORSLžXLQPVZKNVW4KUQ]?Q]MNO?P?NQO?QPKL5US?NXOPZMLONR ̂NQWOPKSNX]KNXPU]?5LQPSUW?Q]WUZ?ORUSRSNT›XQOXMMNSPLWrœUODVU?QP?RROUS]XLFi**$ 9LS?POMMFUP7vFK?OTUšLO?P›KUSWLSPN?QRLSU4NQOM?SU4ZRSNT?QW?5?WXUVU4PONRPSUWLS3 ÛOLWTUQ?MXVUP?NQœ̂L4UXOL›UQZ4KUQ]LOTUZ™LVNROLPLU4KNPKLSFœk€$‚q‡-G88HF XMMFUPvvv¡#**$/.#&9LS?POSFUP72F 44NSW?Q]PNDVU?QP?RROr 9LS?POMMFUP7vx4?P?Q]I¹¹128rG7wyFXP?QPKLLUTMVLODVU?QP?RO4?PLr Fu2?T?VUSVZrDVU?QP?RRO\4NQPLQP?NQPKUPLRLQWUQPO\MXSMNSPLW ›U]SLLTLQPQNPPN4NTMLPLr™K?4KVLWPNK?]KLSOMSLUWOœRNSUV̂NQWOUQWONTLKN™ ]XUSUQPLLWPKUPLRLQWUQPO›™NQœNS›LPSU4P£LW¤œUW5UQPU]LOœNQL5LSZPSUQOU4P?NQSL]USWVLOO NRPKL?S5USZ?Q]̂NQWMNO?P?NQOx"|gyr?OXQOXMMNSPLWUQWXQPLQÛVLFH?QUVZrDVU?QP?ROMVLUWQN RU4POPNOXMMNSPPKL?SUOOLSP?NQPKUPLRLQWUQPO™KNT?]KPKU5L̂LLQKUSTLŴZUQZMUSP?4XVUS uvi**$/.#&$k€$‚q‡-rG88HFXMMF7WUPvv2x›t?PKQN4NQO?OPLQPMSLRLSLQ4L̂LP™LLQUK?]KLSUQWUVN™LSI[H SUPLrMVU?QP?RORU?VPNLMVU?Q™KZ?P?OMVUXO?̂VLPNPK?QšPKUPWLRLQWUQPO™NXVW4NQO?OPLQPVZOKUSLU MSLRLSLQ4LUPUQZ]?5LQP?TLrMUSP?4XVUSVZN5LSPKL4NXSOLNRUWL4UWLrUQW™KZNQLWLRLQWUQP\O?QPLSLOPOT?]KPQNP L̂UW5LSOLPNUQNPKLS\OFœyF u2i**…+"l*n#/.${n/|"+m$i*nlg$lg$*/jp$q+'FrG61Gt862uurUP̧vxFFIUVF”UQFwrG61GyxSLYL4P?Q]4NQOM?SU4Z PKLNSZ?Q™K?4KMSNOML4PNRMSNR?PPN4N34NQOM?SUPNSO™UOXQV?šLVZyr/z|$#(„$+&)Fr…+"l*n#/.${n/|"+m$i*nlgp$‚‚k$lg$ */jp$q+'grv27HFMM\v81xwPKI?SFG61uyF Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 37 of 46 7G PSUWLXQWLSOPNNWPKLZ›™NXVŴLTUWL™KNVL?QWXL4NXSOLFœi**$"|FUP72Fu8 7F́ DVU?QP?RRO\VL]UP?NQONRN4?UV?LOUQWINTTXQ?4UP?NQOUSLTTUPLS?UVF DVU?QP?RROWNQNPW?OMXPLPKUPTLSLUOON4?UP?NQUQW4NTTXQ?4UP?NQUTNQ]WLRLQWUQPOr ™KLPKLSMSNRLOO?NQUVZNSON4?UVZrWNLOQNPOX]]LOPUQ?VL]UVU]SLLTLQPF9LS?POSFUP7837sF QOPLUWrDVU?QP?RO4NQPLQWPKUP›PKLIMVU?QVZUVL]LOPKUPUV£LRLQWUQPO¤KUWRSLžXLQP NMMNSPXQ?P?LOPN4NTTXQ?4UPLrUQWU4PXUVZW?W4NTTXQ?4UPL™?PKLU4KNPKLSœx9LS?POMMg$UP GGyr™K?4KO?TMVZT?OSLMSLOLQPOPKLVL5LVNR4NTTXQ?4UP?NQUTNQ]UVLRLQWUQPOFDVU?QP?RO KU5LUVL]LW4KUPOPKUPOKN™UO4UPLS?Q]NRMS?TUS?VẐ?VUPLSUV4NTTXQ?4UP?NQOUTNQ]OX̂OLPONR PSUWLSOr™?PKNXPLOPÛV?OK?Q]UQZ4NQQL4P?NQUTNQ]TNOPNRPKLPSUWLSOUVL]LWVZUPPKLKLUSPNR PKL4NQOM?SU4ZFi**p$*gmgr9LS?POSFUP7837sFKLOLUVL]UP?NQO4NQPSUW?4PDVU?QP?RO\4VU?TOPKUP UVNRPKLLRLQWUQPO™LSL›RS?LQWOœ™KN4NTTXQ?4UPLW›QLUSVZL5LSZWUZUQWPKSNX]KNXPPKL WUZFœ9LS?POMMFUPGG3G7FQUQZL5LQPrL5LQUK?]K5NVXTLNR4NTTXQ?4UP?NQOUTNQ]PSUWLSO ™NXVŴL4NQO?OPLQP™?PKPKL?SVL]?P?TUPLU4P?5?P?LOUOTUSšLPTUšLSOPN4NTTXQ?4UPLUQWPSUWL ™?PKNQLUQNPKLSPNMSN5?WLrUTNQ]NPKLSPK?Q]OrV?žX?W?PZPN̂NQWPSUW?Q]FI¹1GwF X4K›SUP?NQUV̂XO?QLOÔLKU5?NSœWNLOQNP4SLUPL›U4NQPLPPKUPSU?OLOUOX]]LOP?NQNRU MSL4LW?Q]U]SLLTLQPFœˆ/j&n$ƒ$k",j$k&(+'".$&z$/.,")&n*p$ˆ|g$lg$k","mn&(op$q+'gr86wHF7W 1Gwr178xGWI?SFG617y¡#**$/.#&9LS?POSFUP7137G¡q+$n*$q+#g$n&}*n/m*$0+,",n(#,$‚","mgr21s HF7W766r7v6x7WI?SFG616yxW?OSL]USW?Q]MVXORU4PNSO™KLSLPKLSL™UOUQ›ºN̂5?NXOUVPLSQUP?5L LMVUQUP?NQ\RNSOX4KUQ?QWXOPSZMSU4P?4LœyF žXUVZXQU5U?V?Q]?ODVU?QP?RO\4VU?TPKUP›LRLQWUQPOLQ]U]L?QT?OW?SL4P?NQœ?Q US]X?Q]PKUPPKLIRU?VOPN u8Q4VU?T?Q]PKLIUVL]LO›TXVP?MVL4KUPOœL5?WLQ4?Q]PK?OXQWLSOPUQW?Q]UTNQ]PKLLRLQWUQPOrDVU?QP?RO4?PL PNU#"+m.*?Q4?WLQP?Q™K?4K 9LS?POMMFUP72rQFGsF Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 38 of 46 77 x9LS?POMMFUPGG3G7yFQSLUV?PZrDVU?QP?ROKU5L?WLQP?R?LWUVL]LW4KUPOMXSMNSP?Q]PNOKN™U SLVUP?NQOK?MNQVẐLP™LLQ NQPKLNQLKUQWrusUQW NQPKLNPKLSr™?PKQNRU4PXUVUVL]UP?NQO4NQQL4P?Q]PKLP™N]SNXMOFuw uF́ DVU?QP?RRO\PUP?OP?4UVQUVZO?OHU?VOPNXMMNSPUQQRLSLQ4LNRINQOM?SU4ZF DVU?QP?RRO4NQ4LWLPKUPPKLZWNQNPNRLSUQZL4NQNT?4L5?WLQ4LPKUPP?LOLRLQWUQPOPN PKL›TUSšLP3™?WLœMUPLSQOPKLZUVL]LWF9LS?POMMFUPGu3GvFK?OOPUQWO?QOPUSš4NQPSUOPPN PKL4UOLODVU?QP?RO4?PLr?Q™K?4K4NXSPORNXQWOPUP?OP?4UVUQUVZO?OMSN̂UP?5LNR4NQOM?SU4Z L̂4UXOL?P™UÔUOLWNQWLRLQWUQP3OML4?R?4WUPUFv6DVU?QP?RRO\NQVZSLOMNQOL?OPKUPPKLUVL]LW 4KUPOMSN5?WLQNQ3L4NQNT?4L5?WLQ4LPZ?Q]LRLQWUQPOPNPKLUVL]LWOPUP?OP?4UVUQUVZOLOF9LS?PO MMFUPGv3G2FXPDVU?QP?ROTUWLQNUPLTMP?QPKLIPN4NQQL4PPKL4KUPOPNPKLOPUP?OP?4UV UQUVZO?OrUQWPKL?SKUVR3KLUSPLWUS]XTLQP?QPKLMMNO?P?NQSLOPONQPKLRUXVPZMSLT?OLPKUP TLSLVẐL4UXOLPKL4KUPOUQWUQUVZO?OUSLUVL]LWVZRSNT›PKLOUTL£O?3ZLUS¤MLS?NWrœPKLZTXOP L̂4NQQL4PLWFv1 usDVU?QP?RO4?PLNQVZUO?Q]VL4KUP?Q5NV5?Q] PNOXMMNSPPKL?S4VU?TPKUP F9LS?POMMFUPGGFQWLLWrDVU?QP?ROO?WLOPLMPKL4VLUS ?QW?4UP?NQRSNTPKL4?PLW4KUPPKUP k&)o/n*$9LS?POMMFUPG7x yŠ",!$I¹7u8x yF uwOPN xI¹¹12sr 1w7rGs73svrGs8yrUQWPKLI?Q4VXWLOQNUVL]UP?NQOPKUP4NQQL4PPKLOLPSUWLSOPNNPKLSUVL]LWVZ4NQOM?S?Q] PSUWLSO QNPL5LQPKNOL™NSš?Q]RNSW?RLSLQP4NSMNSUPLLQP?P?LOUR?V?UPLW™?PKPKLOUTLLRLQWUQPFDVU?QP?RORU?VPN MVLUWUQZRU4POOX]]LOP?Q]PKUPPKLNPKLSO?UVL]LW4N34NQOM?SUPNSOTU?QPU?QLW4VNOLP?LO™?PKL?PKLSLU4KNPKLSNS PKLUVL]LW4N34NQOM?SUPNSO?WLQP?R?LWÛN5LF v6i**$i".l*nrG17HFXMMF7WUPvuvrvvs321xMVU?QP?RO›̂USLVZœ4VLUSLWPKLMVUXO?̂?V?PZKXSWVLWLOM?PLNRRLS?Q] OPUP?OP?4UVUQUVZO?OOKN™?Q]UQNTUVNXOMS?4?Q]MUPLSQOWXS?Q]PKLWU?VZrT?QXPLO3VNQ]O?V5LSSUPL3OLP?Q]MSN4LOONQ 1w66W?RLSLQPWUZÔUOLWNQUSL5?L™NR*/'!WLRLQWUQP\OPSUW?Q]U4P?5?PZy¡{&.|rG17HFXMMF7WUP2u2x›Q OXMMNSPNRPKL?SUVL]UP?NQOFFFDVU?QP?RO4NVL4PLWUMMSN?TUPLVZ766r666MS?4LžXNPLORSNTPKLLRLQWUQPOUSNXQW PKLD9H??Q]RSNTG6613G617UQWRNXQWPKUPLRLQWUQPO\]NVWMS?4LO™LSL4NQO?OPLQPVZ4VXOPLSLWPN]LPKLSœy¡ qi%0z"†r18vHFXMMF7WUPuux›44NSW?Q]PNPKLTLQWLWINTMVU?QPrPKLLRLQWUQPUQšOº4VU?TLWPNKU5LPKL LU4POUTL̂?WÝUOšOMSLUW\RNSºQLUSVZL5LSZWUZRNSTXVP?MVLZLUSO\FFFUQW4NNSW?QUPLWNMLQ3TUSšLPPSUWLÔLRNSL 11UFTFPNº̂UQ]PKL4VNOLF\œyF v1DVU?QP?RO\UPLTMPPNL4XOLPKLTOLV5LORSNT™LV3LOPÛV?OKLWMVLUW?Q]OPUQWUSWÔL4UXOLPKLZVU4šLRLQWUQP3 OML4?R?4WUPU?OTLS?PVLOOF9LS?POMMFUPG2FDVU?QP?ROKU5L̂LLQWLQ?LWU44LOOPNQNPK?Q]PN™K?4KPKLZUSLLQP?PVLW UPPKLTNP?NQPNW?OT?OOOPU]LrUQW?RLRLQWUQP3OML4?R?4WUPU?OXQU5U?VÛVLPNPKLTrPKLZ4UQQNPU5U?VPKLTOLV5LONR Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 39 of 46 7u vF́ DVU?QP?RRO\VL]UP?NQONRN5LSQTLQPQ5LOP?]UP?NQOUQWDLSONQQLV L4?O?NQOSLQOXR?4?LQPPNXMMNSPUQQRLSLQ4LNRINQOM?SU4ZF KLTLSLL?OPLQ4LNRU]N5LSQTLQP?Q5LOP?]UP?NQ?O?QOXR?4?LQPPNOXMMNSPUQ?QRLSLQ4L NR4NQOM?SU4ZF9LS?POSFUP7s37wFKXOrDVU?QP?RROUSLT?OPUšLQPKUP›NQ]N?Q]SL]XVUPNSZ ?Q5LOP?]UP?NQÔZPKL”UQWXSNMLUQINTT?OO?NQFFF4NQOP?PXPLUMVXORU4PNSFœvG$DVU?QP?RRO WNQNPW?OMXPLPKUPPKLIWNLOQNP?Q4VXWLUVL]UP?NQOPKUP/+j$LRLQWUQPKUOMVLW]X?VPZNS L̂LQMLQUV?ŸLWUOUSLOXVPNRUQZ?Q5LOP?]UP?NQSLVUPLWPNPSUW?Q]?Q̂NQWOF QOPLUWrDVU?QP?ROOLLšPNO?WLOPLMRXQWUTLQPUVMVLUW?Q]SLžX?SLTLQPÔZ?QPSNWX4?Q] QL™RU4PO?QPKL?SMMNO?P?NQSL]USW?Q]USL4LQPVZ3SLVLUOLWPUPLTLQPNR̂YL4P?NQÔZPKL XSNMLUQINTT?OO?NQFP?O›U?NTUP?4PKUP£U¤INTMVU?QP4UQQNP̂LUTLQWLŴZPKL̂S?LRO?Q NMMNO?P?NQPNUTNP?NQPNW?OT?OOFœi**p$*gmgp$&)o/+&‘f"+|j$k",j$/n,+*n#p$‚,|g$lg$*/n$ i,*/n+#$ƒ$k&gp$q+'gr8wuHFXMMF1G2vr1GsvxFFFEF1wwGyFDVU?QP?RRO?]QNSLPK?O™LV3OLPVLW MS?Q4?MVLUQWUS]XLr™?PKNXP4?P?Q]UO?Q]VL4UOLrPKUPPKLINXSPTUZPUšLYXW?4?UVQNP?4LNRPKL UQQNXQ4LTLQPUQWU44NTMUQZ?Q]MSLOOSLMNSPOF9LS?POMMFUPG23G8Fv7DVU?QP?RRO\?TMSNMLS UPLTMPPNUTLQWPKL?S4NTMVU?QPPKSNX]K̂S?LR?Q]OKNXVŴLSLYL4PLWF L]USWVLOOrPKLOPUPLTLQPODVU?QP?ROOLLšPN?QPSNWX4LWNQNPKLVMPKL?SMVUXO?̂?V?PZ US]XTLQPÔL4UXOLPKLZOP?VWNQNP?QW?4UPLPKUPUQZLRLQWUQPKUOMVLW]X?VPZr̂LLQMLQUV?ŸLWr NŜLLQRNXQWPNKU5LLQ]U]LW?QT?O4NQWX4PFINQPSUSZPNDVU?QP?RRO\T?OSLMSLOLQPUP?NQOrPKL I\OMSLOOSLVLUOLSL]USW?Q]?POPUPLTLQPNR̂YL4P?NQOQL?PKLS?WLQP?R?LOPKLRNXŜUQšO SLMNSPLWVZOX̂YL4PPN?PO?Q5LOP?]UP?NQrQNSSLMSLOLQPOUQZ›4NQ4VX£O?NQ¤PKUPPKLSL?OOXRR?4?LQP US]XTLQPOPKUPSLžX?SL?PFQRU4PrDVU?QP?RO|&KU5LU44LOOPNWUPURSNTOLPV?Q]WLRLQWUQPOxI¹vyrUQWZLPOP?V RU?VPNP?LLRLQWUQPOPNPKLMXSMNSPLW›TUSšLP3™?WLœMUPLSQOPKLZUVL]LF vGDVU?QP?RO\SLV?UQ4LNQi,/nn$lg$i&+j$ˆ{$ˆ(#"'$~+,*n,/"+)*+,rvwGHF7W71uxGWI?SFG616yr?OT?OMVU4LWFQ i,/nnrPKLL4NQWI?S4X?PSLYL4PLWWLRLQWUQPO\US]XTLQPPKUPU4NQOM?SU4Z4NXVWQNP̂L?QRLSSLŴL4UXOLUMSL5?NXO ?Q5LOP?]UP?NQKUWLQWLWFq|gUP7GvFKL4NXSPW?WQNPNPKLS™?OLMVU4LO?]Q?R?4UQP™L?]KPNQUVL]UP?NQONR ]N5LSQTLQP?Q5LOP?]UP?NQO?QWL4?W?Q]™KLPKLSU4NQOM?SU4Z™UOMVUXO?̂VZUVL]LWF$ v7QPKL5LSZQLPMU]LrDVU?QP?ROTUšLPKLLU4PNMMNO?PLUS]XTLQP PKUPOX4KUTUQLX5LS?O4NQPSUSZPNVU™Fi**$ 9LS?POMMFUPGsQFGGxUS]X?Q]PKUP›PUš?Q]YXW?4?UVQNP?4LNROX4KLPS?QO?4L5?WLQ4L?O?TMSNMLSœyF Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 40 of 46 7v L5?WLQ4LNRUQ?QRS?Q]LTLQP¡œvu?PTLSLVZSLMSLOLQPOPKLI\OXQ4NQR?STLWon*.")"+/nj5?L™r ™K?4K?OOX̂YL4PPN4KUVLQ]LUQWWLRLQOL̂ZPKLPUS]LPONRPKL?QžX?SZFSN4šLPL4VFrF1 x›KLOLQW?Q]NRUOPUPLTLQPNRN̂YL4P?NQOWNLOQNPMSLYXW]LPKLNXP4NTLNRUQ ?Q5LOP?]UP?NQFFFF£URPLSSL4L?5?Q]PKLOPUPLTLQP¤£P¤KLMUSP?LO4UQPKLQLUT?QLPKLWN4XTLQPO?Q PKLINTT?OO?NQ\O?Q5LOP?]UP?NQR?VLrSLMVZ?Q™S?P?Q]UQWSLžXLOPUQNSUVKLUS?Q]PNMSLOLQPPKL?S 4NTTLQPOFœyF9NSLN5LSrPKLPUPLTLQPNR̂YL4P?NQO4NQPSUW?4POPKL4NQOM?SU4ZPKUPDVU?QP?RRO MXPRNS™USWKLSL?QPKUP?PUVL]LOPKUPNQVZRNXŜUQšOUSLOX̂YL4PPNPKLI\O?Q5LOP?]UP?NQ¡vvPKUP UQZOXMMNOLWT?O4NQWX4P?OUVL]LŴZPKLIPNKU5LN44XSSLW›UPW?RLSLQPMLS?NWÔLP™LLQ G66wUQWG61vœSUPKLSPKUQPKLRXVWXSUP?NQDVU?QP?ROUVL]L¡UQWPKUPPKLSL™UOQN̂SNUW 4NQOM?SU4ZQNPPN4NTMLPLFi**$SN4šLPL4VFF1x›KLINTT?OO?NQ\O?Q5LOP?]UP?NQSLVUPLO PN4NQWX4P̂Z4LSPU?QPSUWLSOUPPKLRNXŜUQšOUQWWNLOQNP?TMVZPKUPPKLUVL]LWUQP?3 4NTMLP?P?5L4NQWX4P™UOU]LQLSUVMSU4P?4LUTNQ]̂NQWPSUWLSOFœyF DVU?QP?RRO\SLTU?Q?Q]US]XTLQPPKUP4LSPU?QLRLQWUQPO\›UW5LSOLœMLSONQQLVWL4?O?NQOUSL U›MVXORU4PNSœVU4šÔNPKVL]UVUQWRU4PXUVOXMMNSPF9LS?POMMFUPG83GsFDVU?QP?ROSLVZNQMXSL OML4XVUP?NQrUVL]?Q]QNRU4POPNOX]]LOPPKUPPKL4?PLWMLSONQQLVWL4?O?NQOUQW4KUQ]LO?QHI SL]?OPSUP?NQOPUPXO™LSLPKLSLOXVPNRUQZUVL]LW4NQOM?SU4ZFv29LS?POSFUP7wFQUWW?P?NQrPKL 4UOLPKLZ4?PLRNSPKLMSNMNO?P?NQPKUPUW5LSOLMLSONQQLVWL4?O?NQO4NQOP?PXPLU›MVXORU4PNSœ vu5LQ?RPKL4NXSPPUšLOYXW?4?UVQNP?4LNRPKLQL™OUSP?4VLODVU?QP?ROOX̂T?PLWrPKNOLUSP?4VLO4UQQNP̂LQNP?4LWRNS PKLPSXPKNRPKLOPUPLTLQPOUOOLSPLWPKLSL?QFq+$n*$ˆ*nn".$‚j+'!$ j'&$-*#*/n'!$i*'g$‚","mgrNF67Ióu6s6x9Dyr G66ut76vs6wrUP̧uQF7xFFFEFHL̂F1srG66uyx›tK?VLQL™OUSP?4VLOTUẐLYXW?4?UVZQNP?4LWRNSPKLRU4PNR PKL?SMX̂V?4UP?NQrPKLZTUZQNP̂LYXW?4?UVZQNP?4LWRNSPKLPSXPKNRPKLTUPLSUOOLSPLW¼PKUP?OrUOºUWYXW?4UP?5L RU4POF\œi**$/.#&$i,/*!n$lg$/n,z&n|$€"+g$i*nl#g${nogp$q+'grvu8HF7Wu62ruGv3G2xGWI?SFG66syx›£¤P?OMSNMLSPN PUšLYXW?4?UVQNP?4LNRPKLRU4PPKUPMSLOO4N5LSU]LrMS?NSVU™OX?PONSSL]XVUPNSZR?V?Q]O4NQPU?QLW4LSPU?Q?QRNSTUP?NQr ™?PKNXPSL]USWPNPKLPSXPKNRPKL?S4NQPLQPOFœyF vvKLIRU?VOPNUVL]LPKUPR?5LNRPKLLUVLSLRLQWUQPOxUS4VUZOrDDUS?̂UOr[IrIUQWyKU5L L̂LQOX̂YL4PPN/+j]N5LSQTLQP?Q5LOP?]UP?NQF v2DVU?QP?RORU?VPNUVL]LPKUPTNOPLUVLSLRLQWUQPOL5LSOXOMLQWLWNSPLST?QUPLWPSUWLSO?Q4NQQL4P?NQ™?PK T?O4NQWX4PSLVUPLWPN̂NQWPSUW?Q]F9LS?POSFUP7wQFvvF5LQ?RDVU?QP?ROKUWUWLžXUPLVZUVL]LWPKUPPKL 4KUQ]LO?QLTMVNZTLQPUQWÝNSSL]?OPSUP?NQOPUPXO™LSLPKLSLOXVPNR̂NQW3SLVUPLWT?O4NQWX4P ™K?4KPKLZWN QNP OX4KUVL]UP?NQOWNQNPOXMMNSPPKLUVL]LW4NQOM?SU4ZUTNQ]UVLRLQWUQPÔL4UXOLDVU?QP?RORU?VPNUVL]L UQZO?T?VUS4NQOLžXLQ4LORNSPKLTUYNS?PZNRPKLMXSMNSPLWMS?TUSZMVUZLSOF Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 41 of 46 72 €n&+,&"+,$0#"/+$~l*+,$%n"l*+$€(+|p$‚gg$lg$k","„/+}p$‰g0FrNF12IóFvG27xJ[yrG61s tus766s8xFFFEF4PFurG61syx›iq‡-$qqœy ?O?QUMMNO?PLFKLSLrPKLINXSPKLVWPKUPU SLMNSP?OOXLŴZU?Q]UMNSLUQ̂UQš?Q]SL]XVUPNSRNVN™?Q]?PO?Q5LOP?]UP?NQ?QPNUVL]LW L̂Q4KTUSšSUPLTUQ?MXVUP?NQ ™K?4KRNXQWPKUP177?QW?5?WXUVPSUWLSOTUQ?MXVUPLWPKLSUPL OLP?Q]MSN4LOOUQW™LSLOX̂OLžXLQPVZL?PKLSPLST?QUPLWNSW?O4?MV?QLŴZPKL?SLTMVNZLSO OXMMNSPLWUQ?QRLSLQ4LNRU'&))&+$)&,"l*$,&$'&+#o"n*Fiq‡-$qqrG61stus766s8rUP̧7F DVU?QP?RROKU5LQNPUWLžXUPLVZUVL]LWUQZO?T?VUSTNP?5LKLSLr#**$#(on/$FIFGrQNSUQZO?T?VUS ]N5LSQTLQPR?QW?Q]ONRT?O4NQWX4PF ¢ ;< a a=; ; a ;;< a¢ DVU?QP?RROUS]XLPKLINXSPOKNXVWL4XOLPKL?SRU?VXSLPNW?RLSLQP?UPLUTNQ]UQŴLP™LLQ PKLPK?SPZ3NQLLQP?PZLRLQWUQPOrUOOLSP?Q]TLSLVZPKUP›PKLPNX4KOPNQLXQWLSXVLs?O+&,"'*Fœ i**9LS?POMMFUP8sxLTMKUO?O?QNS?]?QUVyFELPDVU?QP?RRORU?VPNMSN5?WLL5LQPKLTNOP̂UO?4 QNP?4LPNLU4KLRLQWUQPFQOPLUWrDVU?QP?RROSL]XVUSVZVXTMPN]LPKLSUVLRLQWUQPOrNSUPP?TLO LVL5LQMXSMNSPLW›̂UQš]SNXMOFœq|g$UPGw¡#**p$*gmgrI¹¹vrs311r1731vr1s31wrGGô723u1r uwrv8r2Gr81rs6rsvrw6rwvr161r162FKUPRUVORUSOKNSPNR™KUPPKLVU™SLžX?SLO QNP?4LPN LU4KWLRLQWUQPNRKN™?PrOML4?R?4UVZrUVL]LWVZ4NQOM?SLWr™?PK™KNTrUQWRNS™KUPMXSMNOLFq+ n*$˜"+'$0+,",n(#,$‚","mgr1vvHFXMMF7W778r7suxFFFEFG612y¡#**$/.#&$k!/n.*#$i'!Š/„ k&nog$lg$/+}$&z$0)g$k&nogrss7HF7W2srsurw6xGWI?SFG61syxSLYL4P?Q]UVL]UP?NQOU]U?QOP MUSLQP4NSMNSUP?NQOUQWPKL?SOX̂O?W?US?LOPKUP›4NVUMOL£W¤œPKNOLOLMUSUPLLQP?P?LO›?QPNNQLœUQW PSLUPLWPKLTUO›]SNXMLWLQP?P?LOœyFDVU?QP?RO\MUOO?Q]UPLTMPPNW?OP?Q]X?OKLRLQWUQPO\ UXPKNS?PZx9LS?POMMFUP8sQF27yNQVZK?]KV?]KPOPKLOKNSP4NT?Q]ONRPKL?SMNO?P?NQFO DVU?QP?RRO\WLO4S?MP?NQNRPKL4UOLOOKN™OrPKLI\O]SNXM?Q]NRLRLQWUQPO5?NVUPLOPKLTNOP ÛO?4MVLUW?Q]SLžX?SLTLQPOF9LS?POMMFUP8s¡#**$/.#&9LS?POSFUPu73uvFQWLLWrOX4K]SNXM MVLUW?Q]?OMUSP?4XVUSVZ?QUMMSNMS?UPLKLSLr̂L4UXOLDVU?QP?RÔX?VWPKL?S4UOL4K?LRVZNQ Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 42 of 46 78 MXSMNSPLW4KUPÔLP™LLQUQWUTNQ]P™NNSPKSLLPSUWLSOx™K?4KPKLSLRNSLW?WQNP?Q5NV5LTNOPNR PKLLRLQWUQPOyFi**p$*gmgrI¹¹126r127F NS4UQDVU?QP?RROYXOP?RZPKL?S]SNXMMVLUW?Q]™?PKSLOML4PPN4NSMNSUPLLQP?P?LOPKUPUSL UR?V?UPLW™?PKLU4KNPKLSFDVU?QP?RO4?PLPKLI\OT?Q?TUV?QPSNWX4PNSZWLO4S?MP?NQONRLU4K LQP?PZx#**p$*gmgr9LS?POMMFUPDUSPóxy3x[yyr̂XPURPLŜS?LRVZ?QPSNWX4?Q]PKLOLLRLQWUQPOr PKLI4NTMVLPLVZ?]QNSLO4NSMNSUPLOLMUSUPLQLOOUQW]SNXMOUVUR?V?UPLOPN]LPKLS™?PKNXP W?RLSLQP?UP?NQFi**p$*gmgrI¹s6x›LRLQWUQPOIrIrIrUQWIUSL SLRLSLQ4LW4NVL4P?5LVZ?QPK?OINTMVU?QPUOºISLW?PX?OOLF\œyFINXSPOSNXP?QLVZW?OT?OO 4NTMVU?QPO™?PKOX4K]LQLS?4UVL]UP?NQOU]U?QOP]SNXMONRUR?V?UPLW4NSMNSUPLLQP?P?LOF9LS?PO SFUPu73uvFK?O?ÔL4UXOLDVU?QP?RO4UQQNP›?TMNOLV?Û?V?PZNQWNŸLQONRWLRLQWUQPÔUOLW NQ4NSMNSUPLUR?V?UP?NQUVNQLFœn*'"#"&+$0##&'#grG611t86v7s68rUP̧12FKLINXSPOKNXVW SXVLPKLOUTLKLSLr™KLSLDVU?QP?RO\]SNXMMVLUW?Q]WLQ?LOUWLžXUPLQNP?4LPNLU4KNRPKLPK?SPZ3 NQLLQP?PZLRLQWUQPOFi**$q+$n*$%"m",/.$ˆ(#"'$0+,",n(#,$‚","mgrs1GHFXMMFGW7w6ru18 xFFFEFG611yF < HNSPKLRNSL]N?Q]SLUONQOrPKLIOKNXVŴLW?OT?OOLW™?PKMSLYXW?4LF Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 43 of 46 7s UPLW9US4K17rG61w L™ENSšrL™ENSš ÝOÝIUST?QLFN44XŸŸ?”SF IUST?QLFN44XŸŸ?”SF 9USPKUFóL]U3NQŸUVLŸ ?TNPKZKNTUOLL4K IE»[9 D QL?̂LSPZDVUŸU L™ENSšrE16662 LVLMKNQLxG1GyGGv3Gv6s HUxG1GyGGv37www 4̂N44XŸŸ?õ4]OKF4NT T5L]U3]NQŸUVLŸõ4]OKF4NT PVLL4Kõ4]OKF4NT 0,&n+*j#$z&n$%*z*+|/+,$‰$/n"„/#$/+|$‰$ /n"„/#$i*'(n","*#$k&nog ÝOÝ”UZFJUOQLS ”UZFJUOQLS JUSLQ9FLQP JrDrr9[» H9D HNXS?TLOžXUSL L™ENSšrL™ENSš16672 LVLMKNQLxG1Gy87v37666 HUxG1Gy87v3G666 YUZFšUOQLSõOšUWWLQF4NT šUSLQFVLQPõOšUWWLQF4NT$ $ 0,&n+*j#$z&n$%*z*+|/+,#$k","mn&(o$q+'gp$ k","„/+}$‰g0gp$k","mn&(o${.&„/.$ˆ/n}*,#$q+'gp$ /+|$k","mn&(o${.&„/.$ˆ/n}*,#$‚")",*| $ $ ÝOÝ?OU”FHS?LW ?OU”FHS?LW LQYUT?QFHVLT?Q] [óD s8vK?SW5LQXL L™ENSšrL™ENSš166GG LVLMKNQLxG1Gyw1s37666 HUxG1Gyw1s37166 V?OUFRS?LWõKN]UQVN5LVOF4NT L̂QYUT?QFRVLT?Q]õKN]UQVN5LVOF4NT LQYUT?QHF[NVP vvvK?SPLLQPKPSLLPrt tUOK?Q]PNQrIG666u LVLMKNQLxG6Gy2783ssuv HUxG6Gy2783vw16 L̂QYUT?QFKNVPõKN]UQVN5LVOF4NT 0,&n+*j#$z&n$%*z*+|/+,$knö|",$0mn"'&.*$ k&no&n/,*$ƒ$q+l*#,)*+,$/+}$ ÝOÝ[LŜLSPFtUOKLS [LŜLSPFtUOKLS U5?WF”UQXOŸL™Oš? VU?JUPŸ KL?VUIFUTLOK WUTF9?QPŸ I[»D s6D?QLPSLLP L™ENSšrL™ENSš1666v LVLMKNQLxG1Gy86137666 HUxG1GyG2w3vuG6 K™UOKLSõ4UK?VF4NT WYUQXOŸL™Oš?õ4UK?VF4NT LšUPŸõ4UK?VF4NT OSUTLOKõ4UK?VF4NT UT?QPŸõ4UK?VF4NT $ 0,&n+*j#$z&n$%*z*+|/+,#$kn*|",$i("##*$0{p$ kn*|",$i("##*$i*'(n","*#$–…i0—$‚‚kp$kn*|",$ i("##*$i*'(n","*#$–~(n&o*—$‚,|gp$/+|$kn*|",$ i("##*$q+,*n+/,"&+/.$ $ Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 44 of 46 7w ÝOÝ”NKQFXSLPU ”NKQFXSLPU Ió[rt»9D sGv?]KPK5LQXL L™ENSšrE1661w LVLMKNQLxG1Gyu8u31666 HUxG1Gyu8u37866 ŶXSLPUõ4SU5UPKF4NT 0,&n+*j#$z&n$%*z*+|/+,$‰&)(n/$ q+,*n+/,"&+/.$o.'$ ÝOÝ?WUQZQQNP ?WUQZQQNP UXSU9FJ?Q] DrtrHJrt[» D 1Gsv5LQXLNRPKLTLS?4UO L™ENSšrE1661w LVLMKNQLxG1Gy78737G17 HUxG1GyuwG36G17 UOZQQNPõMUXV™L?OOF4NT Vš?Q]õMUXV™L?OOF4NT $ 0,&n+*j#$z&n$%*z*+|/+,$‰&)(n/$i*'(n","*#$ q+,*n+/,"&+/.p$q+'g$ ÝOÝVLUQWLS”Ft?VO4KLS VLUQWLS”Ft?VO4KLS 9UPKL™”FDNSMNSU PLMKLQ[FFIVUSšL ó»I9tD 1GvSNUWPSLLP L™ENSšrE1666u LVLMKNQLxG1Gyvvs3u666 HUxG1Gyvvs37vss ™?VO4KLSUõOXV4SNTF4NT MNSMNSUTõOXV4SNTF4NT 4VUSšLOPõOXV4SNTF4NT 0,&n+*j#$z&n$%*z*+|/+,#$-&j/.$/+}$&z$ k/+/|/p$-k$k/o",/.$ˆ/n}*,#p$‚‚k$/+|$-k$ ~(n&o*$‚")",*|$ Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 45 of 46 u6 ÝOÝ”UTLO[FFt?QWLVO ”UTLO[FFt?QWLVO SL]NSZF9NSS?ONQ óDJ»ttD uv6L?Q]PNQ5LQXL L™ENSšrE16618 LVLMKNQLxG1Gyuv63u666 HUxG1Gy8613vs66 YUTLOF™?QWLVOõWU5?OMNVšF4NT ]SL]NSZFTNSS?ONQõWU5?OMNVšF4NT 0,&n+*j#$z&n$%*z*+|/+,#$ !*$ &n&+,&‘%&)"+"&+$ /+}$/+|$ %$i*'(n","*#$–…i0—$‚‚k$ $ $ $ $ ÝOÝUSSZFKLS USSZFKLS QPKNQZQPNQLV? D[D G66DUSš5LQXL L™ENSšrE16122 LVLMKNQLxG1Gy71s32666 HUxG1GyG7638812 ÛSSZOKLSõMUXVKUOP?Q]OF4NT UQPKNQZUQPNQLV?õMUXVKUOP?Q]OF4NT 0,&n+*j#$z&n$%*z*+|/+,#$/n'./j#$/+}$ ‚kp$/n'./j#$k/o",/.$q+'gp$/n'./j#$ i*nl"'*#$‚")",*|p$/+|$/n'./j#$k/o",/.$ i*'(n","*#$‚")",*|$ Case 1:16-cv-03711-ER Document 591 Filed 03/13/19 Page 46 of 46