From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Zimmerman v. Kitzan

Supreme Court of North Dakota
Nov 21, 1952
56 N.W.2d 208 (N.D. 1952)

Opinion

File No. 7257

Opinion filed November 21, 1952. Rehearing denied January 8, 1953

Appeal from the District Court of Morton County, Honorable J. O. Wigen, Judge.

J. K. Murray, for appellants.

Milton K. Higgins, for respondents.


Upon a former appeal in this case, 77 N.D. 477, 43 N.W.2d 822, we affirmed an order of the district court granting a new trial. In proceedings in district court after remand, the attorney for defendants moved the court to vacate the order which this court had affirmed. The district court granted the motion and entered an order vacating the order granting a new trial. This appeal is from that order.

There is no question but that the order appealed from was beyond the power of the district court. In effect the vacation of an order affirmed by this court is a vacation of an order of this court. Unless the decisions of this court are clothed with finality "litigation would never be ended, and the supreme tribunal of the state would be shorn of authority over inferior tribunals." 3 Am Jur (Appeal and Error Sec 1236) 732, see also, 5 CJS (Appeal and Error Sec 1964) 1501, 1502; Walker v. Young, et al., 93 Fla. 29, 111 So. 516; Jacobson v. Mutual Benefit Health and Accident Assn., 71 N.D. 542, 3 N.W.2d 239; Colter v. Dill, 49 N.D. 902, 193 N.W. 662; Weigel v. Powers Elevator Co., 50 N.D. 776, 198 N.W. 121.

The order appealed from is reversed.

MORRIS, C. J. and BURKE, SATHRE, CHRISTIANSON and GRIMSON, JJ., concur.


Summaries of

Zimmerman v. Kitzan

Supreme Court of North Dakota
Nov 21, 1952
56 N.W.2d 208 (N.D. 1952)
Case details for

Zimmerman v. Kitzan

Case Details

Full title:SOLOMENA ZIMMERMAN, and John F. Schneider as Administrator of the Estate…

Court:Supreme Court of North Dakota

Date published: Nov 21, 1952

Citations

56 N.W.2d 208 (N.D. 1952)
56 N.W.2d 208

Citing Cases

Zimmerman v. Kitzan

Thereupon plaintiffs appealed. This court reversed that order, Zimmerman v. Kitzan, N.D., 56 N.W.2d 208. The…