Opinion
May, 1923.
Judgment and order reversed, with costs. The judgment as rendered was contrary to law within the ruling laid down in the following cases: Demarest v. Flack ( 128 N.Y. 205); Van Antwerp v. Linton (89 Hun, 417, 419; affd., 157 N.Y. 716); Murray v. Usher (117 id. 542); Burns v. Pethcal (75 Hun, 437, 442); Mauer v. Egan (182 N.Y. Supp. 180); Potter v. Gilbert ( 130 App. Div. 632; affd., 196 N.Y. 576). The complaint against the defendant Colson is dismissed, with costs. Kelly, P.J., Rich, Jaycox, Manning and Kelby, JJ., concur.