From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Jenkins

Supreme Court of Texas
Apr 18, 1917
194 S.W. 131 (Tex. 1917)

Summary

In Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Jenkins, 108 Tex. 374, 194 S.W. 131, the Supreme Court, without discussion of the point, affirmed a recovery to grandparents, the deceased being a grandchild.

Summary of this case from Western Union Tel. Co. v. Shaw

Opinion

No. 2500.

Decided April 18, 1917.

Case Followed.

The rulings in Western U. Tel. Co. v. Tucker, ante p. 371, are followed and held to control the disposition of this case.

Error to the Court of Civil Appeals for the Second District, in an appeal from Mitchell County.

Jenkins sued the telegraph company and obtained judgment. This was affirmed on appeal by defendant, who then obtained writ of error.

N.L. Lindsley, Ed J. Hamner, and George T. Wilson (George H. Fearons of counsel), for plaintiff in error. (See briefs in last preceding case.)

W.P. Leslie and Royall G. Smith, for defendant in error. (See briefs in last preceding case.)


This is a companion case to Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Tucker, this day decided, the suit having been instituted by J.E. Jenkins for damages suffered by himself and wife on account of the neglect of the telegraph company to deliver the telegram set out in the opinion in that case, announcing the death of their grandchild. The facts of the two cases are substantially the same. Our ruling in the Tucker case is conclusive of the material questions involved in the present case, and a further discussion of them is unnecessary.

The judgments of the District Court and Court of Civil Appeals are affirmed.

Affirmed.


Summaries of

Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Jenkins

Supreme Court of Texas
Apr 18, 1917
194 S.W. 131 (Tex. 1917)

In Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Jenkins, 108 Tex. 374, 194 S.W. 131, the Supreme Court, without discussion of the point, affirmed a recovery to grandparents, the deceased being a grandchild.

Summary of this case from Western Union Tel. Co. v. Shaw
Case details for

Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Jenkins

Case Details

Full title:WESTERN UNION TELEGRAPH COMPANY v. J.E. JENKINS

Court:Supreme Court of Texas

Date published: Apr 18, 1917

Citations

194 S.W. 131 (Tex. 1917)
194 S.W. 131

Citing Cases

Western U.T. Co. v. Shaw

" In further support of this theory are the cases of Western Union Tel. Co. v. McMillan, 174 S.W. 918, and…

Western Union Tel. Co. v. Shaw

It has in two cases in this state been decided, in effect, that the relation of grandparent and grandchild…