From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Water Service Co. v. Beckley

Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia
Mar 20, 1934
114 W. Va. 720 (W. Va. 1934)

Opinion

No. 7815

Submitted March 7, 1934.

Decided March 20, 1934.

HATCHER, JUDGE, absent.

Original mandamus proceeding by the West Virginia Water Service Company against the City of Beckley and others.

Writ granted.

File, Goldsmith Scherer, for relator.

Grover C. Trail, Ned H. Ragland and W. A. Thornhill, Jr., for respondents.


Relator, West Virginia Water Service Company, owning and operating a power plant and distribution system for the generation and distribution of electricity in the city of Beckley, seeks a writ of mandamus compelling respondents, the mayor, recorder and common council of the municipality, to settle and sign "bill of exceptions No. 1," incorporating the evidence introduced before the council on an application of F. L. Conway for a franchise to construct, maintain and operate an electric power plant and distribution system for the generation and distribution of electric power in the city, and "bill of exceptions No. 2," incorporating the evidence introduced before the council upon the protest of relator to a written contract between Consumers Cooperative Power Company (assignee of Conway) and the city, in which the company agreed to sell to the city the power plant and distribution system which it proposes to construct under the franchise. The new set of municipal officers, elected and installed since the issuance of the rule, express their willingness to settle and sign the bills of exceptions if the Court be of opinion that they have authority so to do. As we have recognized the authority of a judge to settle and sign bills of exceptions in a case tried by his predecessor ( Ott v. McHenry, 2 W. Va. 73), we see no reason why the present officers of the city may not complete the unfinished business of the old by settling and signing the bills of exceptions in question. The writ may therefore issue against them.

Writ issued.


Summaries of

Water Service Co. v. Beckley

Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia
Mar 20, 1934
114 W. Va. 720 (W. Va. 1934)
Case details for

Water Service Co. v. Beckley

Case Details

Full title:WEST VIRGINIA WATER SERVICE COMPANY v . CITY OF BECKLEY et al

Court:Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia

Date published: Mar 20, 1934

Citations

114 W. Va. 720 (W. Va. 1934)
173 S.E. 785

Citing Cases

Koestler v. Dallas Tank Co.

I. A bill of exceptions to a decision of the municipal authorities of a city is valid when signed by the…