From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Walton v. Frost

Supreme Court of Rhode Island. PROVIDENCE
Jun 9, 1900
46 A. 680 (R.I. 1900)

Opinion

June 9, 1900.

PRESENT: Stiness, C.J., Tillinghast, and Rogers, JJ.

(1) Slander. Words Actionable per se. In an action for slander, the statement "I will go tell the superintendent and overseer about your taking that sleeve-lining out of the mill" is not actionable per se, it not necessarily implying larceny. To make the words a foundation for an action of slander, facts must be set forth, in a colloquium, which would show that the words could only have been understood to apply to a felonious taking.

TRESPASS ON THE CASE for slander. The declaration charged the defendant with uttering the words concerning the plaintiff: "I will go tell the superintendent and overseer about your taking that sleeve-lining out of the mill," meaning and intending that the plaintiff stole certain sleeve-lining out of the mill where he was employed. Heard on demurrer to declaration, and demurrer sustained.

Thomas F. Vance, for plaintiff.

Lellan J. Tuck, for defendant.


The declaration in this case, which is an action for slander, does not set out words which are actionable per se. They were, in substance, that the defendant would tell the superintendent about the plaintiff's taking sleeve-lining out of the mill. These words might only refer to a violation of the rules of the mill. They do not necessarily imply larceny. To make the words a foundation for an action of slander, facts must be forth, in a colloquium, which would show that the words spoken could only have been understood to apply to a felonious taking. Richmond v. Loeb, 19 R.I. 120; Blake v. Smith, 19 R.I. 476, 481.

The cases relied on by the plaintiff are those where the words were actionable per se, or where they were explained by a colloquium.

Demurrer sustained, and case remitted.


Summaries of

Walton v. Frost

Supreme Court of Rhode Island. PROVIDENCE
Jun 9, 1900
46 A. 680 (R.I. 1900)
Case details for

Walton v. Frost

Case Details

Full title:ALBERT WALTON vs. JOSEPH FROST

Court:Supreme Court of Rhode Island. PROVIDENCE

Date published: Jun 9, 1900

Citations

46 A. 680 (R.I. 1900)
46 A. 680

Citing Cases

Ogrodnick v. Providence Journal Co.

In the case at bar the language in question is not explicit and the declaration obviously fails to show by…