From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Vanden Bosch v. Consumers Power

Supreme Court of Michigan. Reported Below: 56 Mich. App. 543
Jun 27, 1975
394 Mich. 428 (Mich. 1975)

Summary

In Vanden Bosch, the owner of a building agreed to indemnify the power company as the result of any injury from the location of a building under the transmission lines of the power company.

Summary of this case from Kole v. Amfac, Inc.

Opinion

Docket Nos. 56528, 56523.

June 27, 1975.

Rhoades, McKee Boer (by F. William McKee), for plaintiffs. Warner, Norcross Judd (by William K. Holmes), for defendant Consumers Power Company. Cholette, Perkins Buchanan (by Edward D. Wells), for defendant Ferro-Cast Corporation. (Docket Nos. 56528, 56523.) Reported below: 56 Mich. App. 543.

SWAINSON, J., not participating.


ORDERS

Entered June 27, 1975. — REPORTER.

On order of the Court, Consumers Power Company's application for leave to appeal is considered, and the same is hereby granted. The Court, sua sponte, pursuant to GCR 1963, 865.1(7), hereby reverses the decision of the Court of Appeals on the issue of the indemnification agreement.

Ferro-Cast agreed to indemnify Consumers Power against loss "arising in connection with or as a direct or indirect result of a location of such building under the transmission and/or distribution line wires of said second party." The agreement was an accommodation by Consumers Power allowing Ferro-Cast to build and maintain a structure in a location where it otherwise did not have a right to do so and the indemnification does not appear to have been improperly exacted by virtue of any monopoly position of the utility. Although not "expressly" stated in the agreement, we are persuaded from our reading of that agreement, in light of the surrounding circumstances, that the parties intended that Consumers Power be indemnified against liability for its own negligence of the type precipitating this litigation.

On order of the Court, the application of Ferro-Cast Corporation for leave to appeal is considered, and the same is hereby denied, because the appellant has failed to persuade the Court that the questions presented should be reviewed by this Court.


Summaries of

Vanden Bosch v. Consumers Power

Supreme Court of Michigan. Reported Below: 56 Mich. App. 543
Jun 27, 1975
394 Mich. 428 (Mich. 1975)

In Vanden Bosch, the owner of a building agreed to indemnify the power company as the result of any injury from the location of a building under the transmission lines of the power company.

Summary of this case from Kole v. Amfac, Inc.

In Vanden Bosch, Ferro-Cast had agreed to indemnify Consumers Power against loss "arising in connection with or as a direct or indirect result of a location of such building under the transmission and/or distribution line wires of said second party".

Summary of this case from Pritts v. J I Case Co.
Case details for

Vanden Bosch v. Consumers Power

Case Details

Full title:VANDEN BOSCH v CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY

Court:Supreme Court of Michigan. Reported Below: 56 Mich. App. 543

Date published: Jun 27, 1975

Citations

394 Mich. 428 (Mich. 1975)
230 N.W.2d 271

Citing Cases

Paquin v. Harnischfeger Corp.

We need only note that in the context of a claim that the indemnity agreement was intended to apply to one's…

Pritts v. J I Case Co.

In Michigan, the rule appears to be that broad, all-inclusive indemnification language may be interpreted to…