From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Toles v. Hair

Court of Appeals of Georgia
Jan 9, 1951
63 S.E.2d 3 (Ga. Ct. App. 1951)

Opinion

33300.

DECIDED JANUARY 9, 1951.

Action for damages; from Chattooga Superior Court — Judge Nichols. August 18, 1950.

T. J. Espy, Maddox Maddox, for plaintiff.

Brinson Davis, for defendants.


1. Where the plaintiff was a passenger in an automobile that collided with a truck being driven by one of the defendants, and the evidence did not disclose that the plaintiff was in any way negligent and did not show that the driver of the automobile was the agent of or under the control of the plaintiff, it was error for the court to charge that a duty was upon the plaintiff to exercise ordinary care to avoid the consequence of the defendants' negligence, if any, and that if she failed to do so there could be no recovery. Bellamy v. Georgia Power Co., 67 Ga. App. 569 ( 21 S.E.2d 294); Kuttner v. Swanson, 59 Ga. App. 818, 821 (3) ( 2 S.E.2d, 230).

2. Where the evidence plainly shows that the injuries of the plaintiff were due exclusively to the negligence of the defendant truck driver, or of the driver of the automobile, or of both, it was error for the court to charge the law of accident. Morrow v. Southeastern Stages, 68 Ga. App. 142, 146 ( 22 S.E.2d 336).

3. The assignment of error complaining of the failure of the court to charge, in charging Code § 38-107, that the jury might consider the witnesses' personal credibility so far as the same might legitimately appear from the trial will not be passed on, as the omission to so charge will not likely occur on a new trial.

4. The assignment of error complaining of insufficiency of the verdict will not be passed on as a new trial is granted on other grounds.

The court erred in overruling the amended motion for a new trial.

Judgment reversed. Sutton, C. J., and Worrill, J., concur.

DECIDED JANUARY 9, 1951.


Summaries of

Toles v. Hair

Court of Appeals of Georgia
Jan 9, 1951
63 S.E.2d 3 (Ga. Ct. App. 1951)
Case details for

Toles v. Hair

Case Details

Full title:TOLES v. HAIR et al

Court:Court of Appeals of Georgia

Date published: Jan 9, 1951

Citations

63 S.E.2d 3 (Ga. Ct. App. 1951)
63 S.E.2d 3

Citing Cases

Chadwick v. Miller

Thus, Morrow stands for the proposition that, under a strict definition, the defense of accident is not…

Durden v. Collins

DEEN, Presiding Judge, concurring specially. In Chadwick v. Miller, 169 Ga. App. 338 (___ S.E.2d ___) (1983),…