From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Tanner v. Bioust

Supreme Court of Georgia
Jan 6, 1966
221 Ga. 632 (Ga. 1966)

Opinion

23275.

SUBMITTED DECEMBER 15, 1965.

DECIDED JANUARY 6, 1966.

Probate of will. DeKalb Superior Court. Before Judge Dean.

Miles B. Sams, for appellant.

Weekes Candler, John Wesley Weekes, for appellee.


This case involves the probate of a will. On appeal in the Superior Court of DeKalb County the judge directed a verdict in favor of the propounder. The caveatrix appealed the case to this court. Here the appellant insists the direction of the verdict was error for the sole reason that, as she contends, there was some evidence to support the grounds of the caveat that the testator did not possess testamentary capacity and that the sole beneficiary of the will induced the testator to make the same through the exercise of undue influence over him. Held:

1. There was evidence, undisputed, that the testator was of sound and disposing mind, and the only evidence relied upon by the caveatrix to prove his mental incapacity was disputed testimony that he could not read. Proof of illiteracy standing alone is no evidence of insanity or mental weakness. 94 CJS 706, Wills, § 16. The evidence demanded a verdict in favor of the propounder on the issue of mental competency of the testator.

2. The record contains no evidence that the beneficiary or any other person influenced or used any influence over the testator to induce him to make the will.

3. The proof of the testator's mental capacity, the voluntariness of his action in making the will and of the requisite formalities in its execution were established through the undisputed testimony of the witnesses to the will.

Judgment affirmed. All the Justices concur.

SUBMITTED DECEMBER 15, 1965 — DECIDED JANUARY 6, 1966.


Summaries of

Tanner v. Bioust

Supreme Court of Georgia
Jan 6, 1966
221 Ga. 632 (Ga. 1966)
Case details for

Tanner v. Bioust

Case Details

Full title:TANNER v. BIOUST, Executrix

Court:Supreme Court of Georgia

Date published: Jan 6, 1966

Citations

221 Ga. 632 (Ga. 1966)
146 S.E.2d 721

Citing Cases

Haddad v. Haddad

A testator may have the capacity to execute estate documents in a language he neither speaks, reads, nor…