From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Swanger v. Rice

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Mar 1, 1957
96 S.E.2d 836 (N.C. 1957)

Opinion

Filed 6 March, 1957.

Negligence 4f — Nonsuit held proper in this action by an electrician employed in the repair of a burned building, who was injured in doing his work when a board broke under his foot as he was walking, in the progress of his work, near to a ragged burned-out hole in the floor, which he had seen and passed several times before.

APPEAL by plaintiff from Huskins, J. November Civil Term 1956 of BUNCOMBE.

Don C. Young and Narvel Crawford for Plaintiff, Appellant.

Meekins, Packer Roberts for Defendants, Appellees.


Action for damages for personal injuries.

At the close of plaintiff's evidence, the court entered a judgment of involuntary nonsuit, and plaintiff appeals.


Defendants, who were general contractors for the repair of a burned building, employed plaintiff, who had been engaged in the electrical business 36 years, to do temporary electrical work in the burned building to supply light so the repair work could begin. Plaintiff, in doing his work, was walking a foot or so to the right of a ragged edged burned-out hole in the floor six or eight feet square, that he had seen and passed several times before, when a board broke under his left foot, and he fell into the basement, receiving injuries.

A careful consideration of the evidence in the Record constrains us to hold that the court below correctly entered the judgment of nonsuit, if not upon the ground of plaintiff's failure to make out a case of actionable negligence against the defendants, then upon the ground of contributory negligence.

Affirmed.


Summaries of

Swanger v. Rice

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Mar 1, 1957
96 S.E.2d 836 (N.C. 1957)
Case details for

Swanger v. Rice

Case Details

Full title:J. W. SWANGER v. H. M. RICE AND RONALD A. RICE, TRADING AND DOING BUSINESS…

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Mar 1, 1957

Citations

96 S.E.2d 836 (N.C. 1957)
245 N.C. 612

Citing Cases

Bain v. Phillips

(emphasis supplied) See Gaut, supra, 212 Va. at 42, 181 S.E.2d at 647; Clinchfield Coal Corp. v. Redd, 123…