From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

State v. Saunders

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Feb 1, 1884
90 N.C. 651 (N.C. 1884)

Opinion

(February Term, 1884.)

Appeal.

Appeals in criminal actions will be dismissed where the record fails to show there was a final judgment.

( State v. Bailey, 65 N.C. 426; State v. Keeter, 80 N.C. 472; State v. Wiseman, 68 N.C. 203, cited and approved).

INDICTMENT for fornication and adultery, tried at Fall Term, 1883, of WATAUGA Superior Court, before Graves, J.

Attorney-General, for the State.

No counsel for the defendant.


The defendants Edith Saunders and Columbus Anderson were indicted for fornication and adultery, and the defendant Edith was alone on trial. There was a verdict of guilty, and the defendant appealed. Motion by the state to dismiss the appeal upon the ground that the record does not show that judgment was pronounced.


In looking into the record, we find there was no judgment rendered in the court below upon the finding of the jury. The appeal therefore cannot be sustained. It has been repeatedly decided by this court that no appeal lies in a criminal action at the instance of either party, where there is no final judgment. State v. Bailey, 65 N.C. 426; State v. Keeter, 80 N.C. 472; State v. Wiseman, 68 N.C. 203.

Lest, however, the case may be brought up again to this court upon the exception taken on the trial, we take occasion to say that upon a careful perusal of the record and statement of the case, even if there had been a judgment in the court below, there is no ground for a new trial.

Appeal dismissed.


Summaries of

State v. Saunders

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Feb 1, 1884
90 N.C. 651 (N.C. 1884)
Case details for

State v. Saunders

Case Details

Full title:STATE v. EDITH SAUNDERS

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Feb 1, 1884

Citations

90 N.C. 651 (N.C. 1884)

Citing Cases

State v. Hazell

Mr. Jas. E. Boyd, for the defendant. (State v. Saunders, 90 N.C. 651; State v. Bailey, 65 N.C. 426; State v.…

Barbour v. Scheidt, Comr. of Motor Vehicles

The appellant takes the position that a conviction in a criminal case is not final within the meaning of the…