From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

State v. Lake

Supreme Court of Rhode Island
Apr 13, 1889
17 A. 552 (R.I. 1889)

Opinion

April 13, 1889.

Art. 9, § 1, of the Constitution of Rhode Island, which provides, "No person shall be eligible to any civil office . . . unless he be a qualified elector for such office," requires the qualification as elector to exist at the time of election to office, not at the time of exercising the functions of the office. A complaint charged the defendant at Tiverton, in the County of Newport, with wantonly injuring a building. Held, that the complaint by necessary inference located the building in the town of Tiverton.

EXCEPTIONS to the Court of Common Pleas.

Criminal complaint appealed by the defendant to the Court of Common Pleas, and brought into this court by the defendant's exceptions.

William P. Sheffield, Jun., for plaintiff.

J.C. Blaisdell, for defendant.


The complaint is that, on the 24th day of July, A.D. 1887, at Tiverton, in the county of Newport, the defendant did wantonly and maliciously injure and deface a building not his own, etc. The defendant contends that the complaint is bad, because, for anything therein alleged, the building may have been in Massachusetts, and the defendant, standing in Tiverton, may have injured and defaced it by throwing stones across the boundary. We do not think so. The act complained of is the act of injuring and defacing the building, which act is alleged to have been committed at Tiverton, in the county of Newport, and clearly, if the building had not been at Tiverton, the defendant could not have injured and defaced it there.

The complaint was made July 25, A.D. 1887. The defendant produces a certificate from the town clerk of the town of Tiverton to the effect that the magistrate who received the complaint had sold all his real estate some months previously, and that his name was left off the voting list by the canvassers in the following spring, and he contends that the magistrate was not qualified to act as such, not being a qualified elector, referring to the Constitution of the State, art. 9, section 1. The section simply provides that "no person shall be eligible to any civil office (except the office of school committee) unless he be a qualified elector for such office." The town clerk's certificate, even if it shows that the magistrate was not a qualified elector when he received the complaint, which we do not think it does, does not disprove that he was a qualified elector when he was elected to his office, which is all that the section referred to requires.

Exceptions overruled.


Summaries of

State v. Lake

Supreme Court of Rhode Island
Apr 13, 1889
17 A. 552 (R.I. 1889)
Case details for

State v. Lake

Case Details

Full title:STATE vs. RODMAN LAKE

Court:Supreme Court of Rhode Island

Date published: Apr 13, 1889

Citations

17 A. 552 (R.I. 1889)
17 A. 552

Citing Cases

Williamson v. Killough

A late case on the subject is that of Olsen v. Merrill, 5 P.2d 226, where, after an extensive review of the…

Smith v. Hooper

Income signifies that which comes in. It is as large a word as can be used to denote receipts. It is the gain…